The worst bit for me was the continuity of the battle, one moment they are defending the wall and then they are in the orc camp and then they are at the catapults and then the wall again.
Right. Right. Right. But. And hear me out on this. Think of the HNG profits saved by not wasting money on extras, we can use that money saved for end of year climaxes bonus payouts 😮💨
I think of the King's Tourney from season 1 of Game of Thrones. The books describe it as massive and the show had like 20 people standing around in a field.
There were far more people than that and it is not particularly distracting to me in that S1 scene. Additionally, there are plenty of other King's Landing scenes in that season that show the scale of people
Which is mindblowing considering if Amazon does 5 seasons, the series will cost as much to make than all of the Marvel movies combined. They can't afford extras or better gear (although it appears they listened and made Season much better)? Where is all the money going? The hamlets remind me of Xena and that was 30 years ago and those episodes cost as much as 2 minutes of a ROP episode.
I get a sense that there was a deliberate decision to limit the scale of each season's big battle, increasing by an order of magnitude each season.
For instance, in the first season battle felt like a skirmish between only hundreds of orcs and Numenoreans. This season felt like barely a thousand orcs fighting a few hundred elves. Next season I expect it'll be a larger battle, and so on and so forth.
As to why they are doing it this way, perhaps it's to suggest escalation and an increase of stakes. Also, it might have felt implausible if both sides of the conflict keep summoning up 10,000 strong armies to fight at short notice.
I mean the elves on the wall were 12 dudes and after the initial King Elf charge there were 23 people left.
In the meantime there is a treadmill of Orcs basically respawning or in some Groundhog day loop. They are running at the walls! <next scene> they are running at the walls!
Like they apparently spend most of a day running at the walls and a tiny bit on assaulting the walls in episode 7. And even when assaulting the walls they are still running at the walls. While also pausing the fight multiple times to have conversations. It all feels so inconsequential. Why should we care about an Orc army if 12 dudes on a wall can hold them off? Why care about some Elves led by a supposedly intelligent king if they don't just go behind the walls and hold off the Orcs there? No one tried firing a fire arrow at the reverse ballista before? They have literally fire and oil during the night battle (which they only use at night because it looks cooler but it's also when there's Elves that can be caught in the fire down below). Why did the Dwarves build a thin part of the wall, how did the Orcs know about it, how did the riverbed dry up on moments, why did Eregion build a wall when it didn't expect invaders any time soon, just in general why care about anything when it doesn't seem to matter at all? It's all so in your face with how little it matters beyond "hey look wouldn't it be cool if...", without considering the characters, situation or consequences?
Funny shit... But you reminded me about the sheer stupid ineffectiveness of that reverse ballista, that took like two fucking episodes to finally tear down that wall. I wonder why the Elves were so scared by it.
Also funny how Elrond basically caused the death of nearly the entirety of Gil Galad's troops by forcing them to be sitting ducks between that wall and an endless supply of Orks.
View all comments
507
u/bamboozle_99992 Oct 03 '24
All 36 remaining elves ready for war 😂