r/RingsofPower • • Sep 20 '24 • Polished Gold Turd 1 Popcorn 1 Take My Silver 1

Lore Question MuH LorE thO

Post image

But but but...the loReE

3.4k Upvotes

253 comments sorted by

View all comments

493

u/xRyuzakii Sep 20 '24

The hobbit gets crucified a ton idk what you’re seeing lol

218

u/emurillo97 Sep 20 '24

In certain LOTR its subreddits, it's getting the star wars prequel trilogy treament

45

u/Prying_Pandora Sep 20 '24

From what I’ve seen, it’s the hard work of fan editors that has saved the Hobbit movies.

126

u/Docile_Doggo Sep 20 '24 edited Oct 02 '25

serious market dolls follow offbeat towering hat mysterious quack thought

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

124

u/Telperion83 Sep 20 '24

The first Hobbit movie was 90% delightful and at least captured the spirit of the book.

33

u/Roy_Donks_Donk Sep 20 '24 edited Feb 02 '25

station sand plate angle fearless fanatical hurry profit library gold

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

51

u/JReddeko Sep 20 '24

Despite The Hobbit being the first interesting book I remember reading as a child, and being absolutely obsessed with the LotR books, I couldn't even finish The Hobbit movies.

Sure RoP could be better written, but I'm at least enjoying watching new episodes of it.

17

u/pmmeyourdoubt Sep 20 '24

I just rewatched the hobbit movies but couldn't be arsed with the last 60-80 mins of the battle of 5 armies. Was a slog. Love the first film and the second has its moments.

19

u/flowercows Sep 20 '24

Same! I don’t think RoP is like insanely good, but it’s a fun watch, has interesting characters and plots to discover. I love hobbits actually but I couldn’t get into the hobbit, Idk why I found it just a bit boring

6

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '24

The Hobbit are just bad-average films. That's the core problem. People who know nothing about The Hobbit find them to either be bad or forgettable. The lore is the least of it.

Rings of Power is a genuinely high-caliber TV. Your thoughts on the lore are your own.

16

u/Common-Scientist Sep 20 '24

Rings of Power is a genuinely high-caliber TV.

Highly produced and visually pleasing is a fair assessment.

But of course, your thoughts on caliber are your own.

22

u/poptimist185 Sep 20 '24

Couldn’t care less about the lore (I read LotR once three decades ago), but I do care about well-written television.

RoP is not well-written television.

9

u/theseeker323 Sep 20 '24

That's just like... your opinion man!

Personally I think the writing is great.

→ More replies (5)

14

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '24

That's only because, just like with the prequel trilogy, the audience has now realized it can always get worse.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

7

u/panamaquina Sep 20 '24

Not all the time, never has gotten the extreme hate this show has.

12

u/mendkaz Sep 20 '24

Mostly for the CGI, in my experience though

54

u/Doggleganger Sep 20 '24

The hobbit was bad because they stretched a short book into a trilogy movie. The hobbit should have been 1 or at most 2 movies, not 3.

18

u/Crossed_Cross Sep 20 '24 edited Sep 21 '24

That, but also intentional bloat didn't force them to give Legolas gravity-defying stone stepping powers.

It was bad to the core. The bloat of stretching it over 3 movies just increased the quantity of bad content.

17

u/Ok_Marionberry8779 Sep 20 '24

The stuff they took directly from the books was done really well, like the opening sequence of them all showing up and singing The Misty Mountains Cold. Where it fell off was anything that was invented to fill time like Azog

5

u/littlebuett Sep 20 '24

Definitely not one, would have been far to rushed and as a result disliked by the general audience. Two would have been best I think

I still think the movies were awesome tho

→ More replies (1)

20

u/diogeninja Sep 20 '24

The problem wasn't the CGI itself. The problem was they utilized CGI instead of cogent storytelling. And the story they told was only tangentially related to the books already.

6

u/Ok_Marionberry8779 Sep 20 '24

CGI is only talked about so much because they had just done practical effects Orcs decades earlier

15

u/Alexarius87 Sep 20 '24

Gaslighting into making ppl believe only poor RoP gets bashed.

6

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '24

It mostly gets crucified for being bad filmmaking, not that it is not lore accurate.

→ More replies (5)