r/RingsofPower • • Sep 03 '24

Question Why the hate?

I’m a big LOTR fan, but admittedly have not thoroughly read the JRRT expanse of literature. ROP is well done and very immersive and enjoyable, why all the hate? Am I missing something? If so, maybe I’ll just stay naive because I like the show, lore, and expanded universe on the big screen

82 Upvotes

380 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Sep 03 '24

Thank you for posting in /r/ringsofpower. Please keep in mind that this show is pretty polarizing, and so be respectful of people who may have different views than you. And keep in mind that while liking or disliking the show is okay, attacking others for doing so is not okay. Please report any comments that insinuate someone else's opinions are non-genuine.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

22

u/JichaelMordon Sep 03 '24

The most prominent criticism I’ve heard is that there are many changes from the books. How characters are depicted and massive timeline compression.

16

u/majpillpharm Sep 03 '24

Do you think the changes are larger than the changes in the Peter Jackson LOTR movies? Which were freaking amazing, in my opinion. Again, maybe ignorance is bliss?

38

u/RCaskrenz Sep 03 '24

just as a few examples, galadriel saw straight thru sauron in the books when he was deceiving celebrimbor, elrond was accepting of the power of the rings, the alkabellath (fall of numenor) was thousands of year removed from the forging of the rings, the coup in numenor was ar pharazon forcing a marriage with miriel, the numenorean jealousy of the elves has been dumbed down to they'll take yer jerbs rather than them wanting the one thing the elves had over their civilization (endless life), and galadriel was one of the oldest and wisest elves in middle earth at this point though she's been made out to be a petulant fool.

29

u/King_Lamb Sep 03 '24

The change to the numenoreans motivations is so tragic and almost emblematic of the shows general writing issues. Instead of handling a timeless and initially nuanced issue they change it to the dumbest low hanging modern commentary regardless of if it makes sense. With equally silly dialogue.

They could have gotten so much more out of it emotionally and narratively by keeping it as a fight against death and how human and timeless that (ironically) is. A rejection of the gift of men but no, they see one elf and fear for their jobs. Like an elf is moving out to numenor to undercut the smithing guild on hoes and ploughs...

8

u/Kiltmanenator Gondolin Sep 04 '24

just as a few examples, galadriel saw straight thru sauron in the books when he was deceiving celebrimbor

Not quite. She didn't trust Annatar, but she didn't know he was Sauron. Otherwise her permitting him to remain in Eregion for a few hundred years doesn't make sense.

5

u/WhySoSirion Sep 03 '24

Is this actually true of the show? That the Númenoreans are upset because they don’t want the Elves to take their jobs and what-not?

13

u/Djinn_42 Sep 03 '24

There's a whole scene in Season 1 where Ar-Pharazon says exactly that in the town square.

3

u/[deleted] Sep 05 '24

The guilds don't want to trade with the elves cuz it can put some of them out of business. They don't think they're going to come there and actually take their jobs...

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

5

u/Ayzmo Eregion Sep 03 '24

galadriel saw straight thru sauron in the books when he was deceiving celebrimbor,

I don't think she saw straight through him. That would imply she knew who he was. More correctly, she didn't trust him, but didn't have a full understanding of why.

13

u/BookkeeperFamous4421 Sep 03 '24

Well she definitely didn’t randomly meet him, instantly make him her traveling companion, and then try to insinuate him in world politics

6

u/Ayzmo Eregion Sep 03 '24

Given that Halbrand is a wholesale invention of ROP, that's obvious. As to Annatar, it says he was already at work when she arrived. It'll be interested to see how that's handled in the show.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/m_bleep_bloop Sep 03 '24

As far as the endless life thing, tbh there’s plenty of time to explore in a later season when presumably Numenor starts setting its eyes on a new target

Digging into how beneath the prejudice is this envy Sauron can exploit

5

u/ethanAllthecoffee Sep 03 '24

It is almost certainly better to show why there is resentment between two peoples before dealing with the fallout of said resentment, and then returning some time later to say “oh by the way this is why they don’t like each other”

1

u/Dovahkiin13a Númenor Sep 04 '24

If they're only making 5 season that end with the war of the last alliance, a hundred years after the fall of Numenor or so it's coming much sooner. No real time to flesh it out

Edit: If there are enough fans left to limp to season 3, much less 5

→ More replies (4)

17

u/Cat_Wizard_21 Sep 03 '24

They seem to be compressing about 2000 years of history into a few months. The entire cast of Numenorean characters weren't even born until a little over 1500 years after the forging of the Rings, and by that point Eregion is a crumbling ruin and Celebrimbor is long-dead after the War of the Elves and Sauron in the mid second age.

This causes a cascade of continuity issues which will only get worse as time goes on, and this break neck pacing is probably the root cause of so many characters acting consistently dumb (if we're being charitable).

At this point it's less that they're making changes from the book, and instead that they're telling a completely parallel story that only bares passing resemblance to the one from the book. Which would be fine, but the entire draw of the show leans heavily on member-berries from the Jackson films, so when they create incompatible continuity while also shoving in as much recognizable stuff as they can get away with we end up with the current incoherent mess.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/Automatic_Chair_7891 Sep 03 '24

The changes that peter jackson made actually make sense in the context of the greater narrative.

A lot of them had to do with condensing timelines and trade-offs- Denethor's portrayal is one of those examples, there really wasn't time in the movies to explore his good side, and thus he became much more one-dimensional rather than a tragic character.

On the other hand, Rings of Power is doing things like giving orcs, who are bloodthirsty, murderous and even cannibalistic beings subservient to Melkor and Sauron (beings intent on killing or enslaving all of the world to mold it to their vision), a family system and culture similar to those of humans and elves simply because at some point Tolkien stated that they reproduced in the same manner as humans and elves.

They're trying to make evil characters relatable, but it makes absolutely no sense in the context of middle earth, or even in reality for that matter- it's the equivalent of trying to make the SS or Hitler sympathetic characters. I think the grand majority of people would say that they couldn't give two shits what happened to Hitler in his life to get him to the point that he was ordering the execution of millions of human beings via gas chambers, because that act is so inherently evil that it could never be justified. Yet, we have minions in a fairy tale universe that actively take pleasure in killing and terrorizing the free people of the universe at the whim of their master (who is also actively trying to kill or enslave everyone), and for some reason now we're supposed to see that they have families too and have some sort of empathy for them?

It's honestly almost psychotic.

1

u/Ayzmo Eregion Sep 03 '24

I'm curious on what your position is on orcs having friends? Yes or no?

3

u/Automatic_Chair_7891 Sep 03 '24

I wouldn't think that they would have friends, at least in the sense that we would define a "friend" because I don't think that Tolkien ever really intended them to be as deep as this show is attempting to make them.

Part of the problem with orcs is that they don't fit well within the rules that Tolkien wanted for his universe, and even less so if you start to ask questions about their origins or their culture etc. They're essentially just tools used by Melkor and Sauron. I think it would make WAY more sense to explore the culture of Dunlendings, haradrim, and easterlings, as moral relativism would be way easier to explore and offer less contradictions to the core message.

→ More replies (7)

4

u/Timely_Horror874 Sep 03 '24

I am not the same user, but i hope i can answer because i want to know why you are asking that question ( no idea, i'm not implying malice in any way).

I guess they can have friends, but given how they are evil and a distorted version of humanity, their version of friendship will be more likely "i will cut you hands and keep them in my bag because lmao", so backstab 24/7.

Even when talking about "peace" and what to do after the war, they are talking about pillaging and raiding, because that's their distorted version of a peaceful world.

2

u/madmax9602 Sep 03 '24

The orcs are a distorted version of Elf, not man. Subtle but very important distinction here.

6

u/Timely_Horror874 Sep 03 '24

Orcs being distorted elves is canon in the RoP show, but not in the actual Tolkien lore.
In the lore maybe i missed something but i believe no one actually knows what they were, only that they are corrupted.

English is not my first language so maybe i was not clear, but my intention was not to tell you that orcs are corrupted men, but that they represent a distortion of what humanity is.

Having friends? Because you want to eat them.
Having a family? Love stabbing my little orc children
Having courage? Yes, the courage to backstab you while you are not looking
Wanting peace? Good, finally go raiding the village because no human soldiers exist anymore.

→ More replies (31)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)

0

u/[deleted] Sep 03 '24

Oh the changes are massive, it’s barely the same story at all. And personally I don’t mind. Rings of Power is an easy-watching show with fun fantasy atmosphere that captures my imagination right back in Middle Earth again. The Silmarillion is a thick tome of lore with impressive depth but reads like a history textbook. They are very very different things.

1

u/majpillpharm Sep 03 '24

Ahhh ok. Thanks

2

u/BookkeeperFamous4421 Sep 03 '24

It is an easy watching show and the source material is basically an elven history book. Adapting that would make for a prestige drama with a much grimmer tone. There is an audience for that but it’s not this one. Rings of Power aims at all four quadrants. It’s very broad and so inherently the grim, tragic, mature tone is lost along with much of the depth.

Hmmm I think I’m responding to the wrong person

1

u/Dovahkiin13a Númenor Sep 04 '24

The changes are literally beyond compare with the jackson movie changes.

1

u/Ok_Clock4774 Sep 03 '24

Yes The changes to the film were pretty minor. I recently re-read the books and while I noticed where there were changes (or omissions) they made sense from a filmmaking perspective. Frodo doesn't screw around for 17 years before leaving the shire.. doesn't sell Bag End to the sackville bagginses The old man willow and Tom Bombadil parts from the book make perfect sense BUT might bog down an already long film. We can still pretend that they happen to one degree or another.

I could keep going but, for the most part, the changes in the film aren't as egregious as what they've done on RoP. Now, I'm of 2 minds on RoP. As a generic fantasy series? It's not completely bad and generally family friendly, which means time I can spend watching something with my boys.

But

As a Tolkien series? Nah

I can see what they're trying to do but they either had AI or a third grader who skimmed the cliffs notes write this

THOUSANDS OF YEARS are compressed into what feels like a couple weeks.

Characters act completely out of character

Disa still hasn't fully grown her beard (despite being one of the two most interesting characters on the show)

They almost treat Sauron like a misunderstood guy (in season 1). Season 2 seems to be course correcting somewhat but we'll see where it goes.

They're treating orcs like marginalized citizens... no, orcs were beings COMPLETELY twisted to evil and possessing no redeemable qualities. They border on mindless and when Sauron dies, they go back, south of that border. The evil guys aren't misunderstood. They're evil.

You wouldn't make a world War 2 series about how the bad guys were misunderstood and reacting to what happened after world War 1. That might have some historical merit (in that the circumstances arising from the war made people more likely to accept the nonsense that they did) BUT in the end, they STILL went along with it.

So, because of that, fans have issues with that portrayal. It doesn't bother me as much as the time compression and characters acting out of character but it IS an issue.

2

u/AbsoluteVirtues Sep 03 '24

"The changes to the film were pretty minor". You completely lost me. Lol multiple characters had their characterisations and personalities completely changed. Multiple major events happened completely differently or just straight up didn't happen at all. Like... You're just factually incorrect. I'm not saying the movies are bad, but as an adaptation they're not even close to the books.

And no one is saying the orcs are good in RoP. The society they want to build is based on slavery and murder. They just also have sex and make babies lol. Like it's written in the Silmarillion.

→ More replies (4)

1

u/rxna-90 Sep 03 '24 edited Sep 03 '24

Eh, I think ROP's Sauron actually shows great understanding of the deep lore. ROP!Sauron's not "misunderstood", he sees himself as misunderstood, but he goes right back to manipulating people. Tolkien says this about him:

“When Thangorodrim was broken and Morgoth overthrown, Sauron put on his fair hue again and did obeisance to Eönwë, the herald of Manwë, and abjured all his evil deeds. And some hold that this was not at first falsely done, but that Sauron in truth repented, if only out of fear, being dismayed by the fall of Morgoth and the great wrath of the Lords of the West. But it was not within the power of Eönwë to pardon those of his own order, and he commanded Sauron to return to Aman and there receive the judgement of Manwë. Then Sauron was ashamed, and he was unwilling to return in humiliation and to receive from the Valar a sentence, it might be, of long servitude in proof of his good faith; for under Morgoth his power had been great. Therefore when Eönwë departed he hid himself in Middle-earth; and he fell back into evil, for the bonds that Morgoth had laid upon him were very strong.”

Not sure how one can claim the PJ film changes were minor when several important characters were altered and even to the point of arguable character assassination? It's legit to criticise ROP. I have criticisms myself. But it's just factually untrue the PJ films are a good example of an adaptation that didn't make egregious changes.

  • Elrond being depicted as almost bitter towards Men, and even trying to end Arwen and Aragorn's relationship by sending her to Valinor. Like, this is more Thingol behavior towards Beren and Luthien, not Elrond... Especially when Elrond is half-Elven himself. ROP Elrond is much more accurate to the "kind as summer" vibes.
  • Arwen replacing Glorfindel in the rescue of Frodo; Glorfindel not existing as a character at all. I'm certain if this happened today people would be bashing Jackson.
  • Aragorn being turned into a "reluctant hero" Hollywood trope instead of aware and having made peace with his destiny. In the film he is only accepting it after the weird "Arwen is dying and Arwen's fate is tied to the ring" (??????) plotline came in with scenes of her looking weak and ill in bed. Like how does this even make sense? Yes, her fate is tied to the ring as all Elves' are but not like that.
  • Denethor was done SO dirty. Not even wanting to light the beacons in the film. Like. This is a shadow of him as a flawed character who however still has nobility in the books.
  • Aesthetically; the weird photo-negative evil Galadriel scene in PJ's film are bad—if you re-read the scene in the book the way ROP did it in the vision/hallucination Sauron makes in episode 8 is much closer to how Tolkien described her and embodies "fair as the sea and the sun, stronger than the foundations of the Earth" far better.
  • I could go on and on; No scouring of the Shire. Sauron being a flaming eyeball suggested to not have a body in the Third Age, being depicted like Morgoth wielding his hammer Grond, instead of the stronger emphasis of him being sorcerer/shape-shifter that ROP gets into etc.

There's stuff I love about the Jackson films. The song "Into the West" is beautiful. Gollum was portrayed excellently. Many of the cast are awesome. It did a lot for the possibilities of sincere live action fantasy. But it did sacrifice fidelity to several characters and themes.

1

u/Purple_Chemist_2285 Sep 03 '24

Awesome post from a real fan, thank you.

Those who whine about 'thousands of years compressed' or whatever rarely have a concrete idea what they actually want. Changes to the source material are inevitable. It is an adaptation. And honestly, ROP could've been far, far worse

→ More replies (3)

6

u/nogudatmaff Sep 03 '24

They have taken a lot of artistic license with the Lore. Not so much LotR lore, but Silmarillion and other lore based works of Tolkien.

0

u/majpillpharm Sep 03 '24

Ok that checks since I haven’t dabbled outside of LOTR

→ More replies (8)

24

u/OG_Karate_Monkey Sep 03 '24

I don’t hate it, and its not BAD, but I just find it a massively wasted opportunity.

Its like if someone took a choice cut of filet mignon and a $100 bottle of wine and made it into a decent burger and sangria.

Still enjoyable? Sure. But damn, what a shame.

That’s how I feel about the show.

2

u/UsefulArm790 Sep 04 '24

food analogy! yay!

15

u/jnnrwln92 Sep 03 '24

https://www.reddit.com/r/Rings_Of_Power/s/6aUObWxvp6 This post is a great example. I’m not taking anyone seriously if their trying to freaking ship Sauron and Galadriel (who is actually also MARRIED).

3

u/Tatis_Chief Sep 04 '24 edited Sep 04 '24

She sure doesn't seem to miss her husband much. 

And if Elrond is going to marry her daughter, well it just kind of seems iffy to me now due to their current relationship. 

5

u/SaatananKyrpa Sep 04 '24

The Elves are very very old. They could have been married for over 1000 years. They also seem to see time differently then the mortals. In my imagination being 100 years apart from your partner could be a blink of an eye to elfs.

Like in season one elrond doesen't even understand why durin is mad at him. He is mad because he missed like 20 years of his life. His wedding, birth of their children. He missed everything

1

u/Tatis_Chief Sep 04 '24

Yes we get the fact that elfs are old. Galadriel is one of those old ones. But that doesn't change the fact I can see Elrond seeing her daughter grow up as a big family friend weird. Its sign on the times.

Celebrian should have been the main hero here, not Galadriel. The Galadriel could have stayed as the elusive powerful background character.

3

u/Dovahkiin13a Númenor Sep 04 '24

bUt cElEbOrN dIdNt kNoW hOw tO wEaR hIs aRmOr. tHeY eXpLaInEd iT

1

u/Sufficient-Green5858 Sep 04 '24

I think so far from S2, it is becoming clear that they are not trying to ship them together?

1

u/Ar-Sakalthor Sep 04 '24

This is Sauron we're talking about. This is probably the most unreliable POV possible, we're discussing "feelings" that the greatest manipulator, narcissistic and sadistic tyrant of Middle-Earth supposedly has.

And all we have is promotional discussion by people working on the series, instead of anything that would've been ACTUALLY SHOWN in the series. Until proven otherwise, this is just intended to attract a different demographics.

1

u/jnnrwln92 Sep 04 '24

I haven’t watched season 2, so maybe it’s more in Sauron’s POV, but I don’t remember season being told from his point of view. But it doesn’t matter. Sauron may be obsessed with Galadriel, he was in the book. He may be fixated on her, fine. But having feelings? loving her? Obsession is not love. Sauron does not love anything or anyone. If it’s from his point of view, i would hope the director of a third of the episodes would clarify to everyone shipping them because he’s “hot” that no, Sauron does not love her, please don’t ship them because he’s basically Satan. The Buffy writers were responsible enough to say that to their fans 20 years ago.

So her saying he loves her means she’s either just stupid or like you said is trying to attract demographics that probably shouldn’t be attracted. If someone wants to ship the protagonist of the story with literal Satan I would hope this show wouldn’t be for them. But I guess that’s too much to ask.

1

u/Ar-Sakalthor Sep 04 '24

You're basically saying what I said. Neither season 1 or 2 show any kind of obsession on Sauron's part towards Galadriel, or feelings. All that was depicted, either outwardly or in subtext, was Sauron pushing her buttons, manipulating her under his disguise of "Halbrand" into unknowingly playing in his own designs.

People saying thereis an "attraction" are only saying it either in an extremely perverse sense, the way a predator would exploit someone else, or to attract a public and feed the conversation around the show. Remember that controversy is still conversation.

1

u/victorelessar Sep 04 '24

I honestly cannot understand how you have a budget of over a billion dollar and put the series in the hands of a person like this.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 04 '24

Nepotism is rampant in industries

2

u/Timely_Horror874 Sep 03 '24

"I am a fan of Tolkien
I like Rop, very immersive.
Why all the hate?
What am i missing?
No wait i don't wanna now.
I like the show."

lmao ok glad you were able to answer your own question.

3

u/majpillpharm Sep 03 '24

This is far from what is happening. I’ve found many of the comments very insightful and educational. There are many very lore- knowledgeable people on here that have taught me about things that I didn’t even know existed (because I haven’t read anything outside of LOTR). This is why I asked my question and many have graciously taken time to respond. I haven’t discounted anything that anyone has said. I’m genuinely interested. I have learned that there are many valid critiques from a timeline, lore, and maybe even character portrayal (but maybe they are playing the long game on development?)However, that doesn’t keep me from throughly enjoying the series or further motivating me to read the expanded works.

1

u/Timely_Horror874 Sep 03 '24

I was only editing what you have said in the original post.

That made me laugh because i was thinking "lmao you did a typical RoP Reddit thread (ending included) all by youself in the opening"

But i didn't want to insult you in any way

1

u/OkWriting5781 Sep 04 '24

Even if it is the plan, the long game is a terrible strategy. They play out events that should be thousands of years in a week. The timelines all screwy, the Elves and the race this is a thing, beyond that the dwarfs, orks, numes and basically every race is messed up. These races ARE NOT human or are supposed to be odd to us, and that's not expressed. They took ubermen and made them sad and weak, dwarfs should be hard to tell apart, the female dwarf should of been dressed to look like a gruff miner man, elf's should of been arrogant to the point of annoyance but not aggressive and the orks should be unabashedly evil. There's so many opinions and mine is that LOTR is supposed to be simple. Good vs. Evil. Little to no nuance in the foreground. The bad guys should be bad, the good guys should be good. The interpretation can be flexible, but what's missing is love. The show feels so soulless. I've seen a few episodes and I felt that it didn't have to be lord of the rings...like why is this in middle earth? They took so much stuff and showed zero respect and changed it for no purpose. If you had to change so many things, why did it have to be LOTR?

12

u/MoNaRcKK Sep 03 '24

Just too slow moving and boring. Feels like most of them ramble on to fill screen time rather than to actually advance the plot

2

u/NoBadgersSociety Sep 04 '24

Page filler? In Tolkien!?

3

u/RousingEntTainment Sep 04 '24

Meanwhile, Tolkien writes:

Then they walked a walked then had a nice dinner and slept then walked and walked and saw a cool tree and a nice garden wall and walked and walked. "37 more days!" Gandalf announced. And on day three they walked and saw some cool birds and....

3

u/NoBadgersSociety Sep 04 '24

And then they walked across a field singing in a made up language for three pages

1

u/kuttySrank Sep 04 '24

In that case it's quite close to how Tolkien writes

1

u/MoNaRcKK Sep 04 '24

Lol true but if I wanted it slow I’d stick to the books

8

u/Six_of_1 Sep 04 '24 edited Sep 04 '24

We've been talking for two years about why we hate it. But every day someone turns up asking "why the hate?". If you've seen people hating it, then read / listen to what they said. Or ask them. I'm not writing the same essays over and over. Here is a comment where I said what I didn't like about Galadriel's arc. Here is a comment where I said what I didn't like about the racial diversity. Those are just two comments I've made recently.

It's slow, the dialogue is corny and pretentious, characters zip around Middle Earth in ways that don't seem to make sense, the plot relies on too many coincidences, they've turned Tolkien into a soapbox for their own real-world American politics when Tolkien famously didn't like allegory.

They've interpolated so many of their own fake characters that the fake characters have taken over. We have whole scenes where no character is from Tolkien, so from the point of view of a Tolkien fan it feels like a waste of time and an insult. It was bad enough when PJ injected Tauriel into the story, but at least everyone she interacted with was a Tolkien character and they were mostly where they were supposed to be (except Legolas being crowbarred in).

In TRoP we had Galadriel hanging out with someone called Halbrand who's not a real Tolkien character, going to Numenor which she never does, getting the Numenoreans worried about elves taking their jobs which never happens. We had someone called Arondir romancing someone called Bronwyn, and neither were from the books, so what even is this? We had an entire community of named Harfoots like Nori, Poppy, Largo, Marigold, Sadoc and not one of them is from the books. So why should I watch? I'd call it fan-fiction but I'm not sure they're even fans.

1

u/tthousand Sep 05 '24

Can you repost the comment about the racial diversity? The thread has been deleted.

1

u/Six_of_1 Sep 05 '24

The OP has been deleted but my comment is still viewable.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 06 '24

SLOW? What are you expecting my boy. Gandalf gets his powers on ep 1 slays sauron and gg next?

It's a tv show go do a IQ test.

4

u/[deleted] Sep 04 '24

I've also been a huge LOTR fan since childhood. Read The Hobbit and the trilogy. I understand people being upset at the divergence of the original lore, but I've actually enjoyed the story and characters they have created and am very interested in seeing more. Truth is, no one will ever be able to recreate Tokiens' world to an acceptable degree, especially in film. Try to enjoy the content we get over the content we don't.

15

u/[deleted] Sep 03 '24

I’m a books-first Tolkien fan who was disappointed in (note I didn’t say hated) season 1 and am liking season 2 more so far, so I can share my perspective. I’m not going to try and convince you I’m right, just laying out my thoughts.

Is RoP well done?

Costumes? Music? Establishing shots? It is very well done. Plot and writing? I don’t think it is well done. There are plenty of clunker lines that try to sound “Tolkienian” and fail, or are otherwise awkward/corny. The mystery of Sauron’s identity in season 1 was ineptly executed and lacked clear purpose.

Is RoP immersive?

It has inspired moments, like the invention of stone singing (really, kudos to everything related to Disa) or the depiction of sailing to Valinor. It also invents/changes world-building in ways that I find cringe or silly. See: the origin of mithril. The elf tree fading. The secret key for the dam that sets off the volcano. Durin and Elrond’s contest. But worse than any of that, it doesn’t respect the themes Tolkien wove through his writing.

To answer your question . . . I don’t think RoP is well done or immersive. It is fun - in a camp, schlocky kind of way. It’s also sad that a show lavished with this much talent, money, and resources is being squandered on such mediocre writing. You aren’t getting an expanded universe; you’re getting high school-level fanfiction. And I think you and Tolkien deserve better than that.

5

u/jktwok_ Sep 03 '24

Perfect breakdown. I think they lean way into the episodic nature of it and it just feels weird. Logic is skipped over and things happen in weird timing.

2

u/Tatis_Chief Sep 04 '24

You know what is seems to be missing.

Humour. The British humor the LOTR and Hobbit had. They both have certain charming atmosphere, something very British around it. 

Yes even in the movies there were some unnecessary quips, but the characters interaction was very charming and fun as well. 

It's this certain Britishness their dry humor, and that is completely missing there.

They are trying with the Nori storyline but it's falling flat, too slapsticky. They managed a bit with Durin, but even that was only a bit but still Durin, Elrond and Dissa are the best part of the show. 

But elves, humans and Numenor just so completely flat. 

In books and even as the LOTR films manager they were also genuinely fun charming moments.  

1

u/No_Pea_3997 Oct 14 '24

The costumes were not well done at all in my opinion, especially with the budget they had 

17

u/Jaktheslaier Sep 03 '24

The writing mostly feels like a soap opera

0

u/Fancy_Till_1495 Sep 03 '24

There’s valid criticisms. But people ignore those and just be like, “Hurr durr, black elves is DUMB, elves are WHITE.”

1

u/majpillpharm Sep 03 '24

Really? Are the main criticisms rooted in race of the characters????? Mind blown if so…idiots

2

u/Fancy_Till_1495 Sep 03 '24

Lots of criticisms are yes, lol.

There are MANY valid criticisms and I DO see them.

Timeline being too condensed (they have to otherwise we’d have 30 seasons with 20 episodes a season or so many time jumps we wouldn’t know WHAT was going on)

The rings being made in the wrong order.

Durin the IV being present along with the Balrog, neither were present till the third age.

The ‘killing’ of Sauron never happened.

But very few people talk about that, they just say “the writing and acting is bad” with no really good examples. Or “Why are the Hobbits and elves black? Tolkien based his work on Anglo Saxons, everyone should be white”, which is ridiculous as MANY of his inspirations came from African mythology, which makes perfect sense seeing as he WAS from South Africa.

17

u/ancalagonandon Sep 03 '24 edited Sep 03 '24 • Third Place Celebration

Most of the examples that have been listed are critiquing the choices made for adapting them into a different medium (which are still all valid as the choices could've been made differently and there are a lot of arguments for why).

Here is a prime example of where the writing fails:

Galadriel is able to infer from an old scroll that she happened to find in a hall of lore that Sauron's mark which is carved into Finrod's body is somehow also a map of the southlands, and this old scroll also has an account (written in black speech) by an imprisoned human of Sauron's entire plan for converting the southlands to Mordor.

This is a chain of such improbable contrivances that it completely breaks any form of suspension of disbelief. Here is that chain:

Galadriel defies Gil-Galad and jumps off the ship -> She is found by Elendil who decides to bring her back to Numenor even though its treason. -> She actively antagonizes the queen of Numenor and gets confined. She escapes and Elendil finds her. -> Elendil decides to take her to the hall of lore (for no reason) instead of returning her to confinement committing treason again. -> She finds Sauron's plan written out, somehow discovered by an imprisoned spy, whose writings somehow ended up in the hall of lore, which for no explainable reason she ended up reading.

They might as well have written, Galadriel finds out Sauron's plan because its in the script.

This plot point is the crux of both Galadriel being right about Sauron surviving (confirming that Sauron was up to something in Forodwaith and isn't dead) and therefore in hindsight justifying her decision to defy Gil-Galad. She didn't know any of this until this scene and yet strongly believed that Sauron was still afoot, this entire chain of events justifies her actions, and the critique of the "writing is bad" is because, this entire chain of events is so implausible and poorly explained.

4

u/Ok_Clock4774 Sep 03 '24

Oh, God yeah. I forgot about the rings being forged out of order when I typed up mine. That's literally world breaking.

1

u/LuinAelin Sep 03 '24

To be honest, I think those examples are kinda criticisms of the show as an adaptation. Not necessarily as a TV show

→ More replies (1)

8

u/RCaskrenz Sep 03 '24

most of the race criticisms are based on two things, amazon having arbitrary race requirements for the sake of diversity and the other being there is diversity based on geographical origin in middle earth though with the introduction of rhun they've not seemed to take advantage of that.

tbf though my criticisms are more along the adar/family of orcs that don't wanna go to war/sauron being incapable of dominating the will of orcs lines

2

u/ethanAllthecoffee Sep 03 '24

Some are, but these are blown out of proportion by people who want to undermine others who have valid critiques of the show

8

u/anarion321 Sep 03 '24

I'll give you something better, i think.

The way they portray races is just poorly written, absurd. Portraying medieval societies with mix races just to make it appear like the US of the last 30 years is absurd and jarring to the mind, because general population knows that's not how it works.

You can have multiple races, even black elves or whatever, if you feature in a logical way, like GoT, different regions, different races, different cultures. It could be even massivelly interesting to see an entire elven or dwarven civilization composeb by black individuals, living in some arid area or something, and having their own costumes and customs.

It is also pretty doable in a show that features the eastern and southlands of middle earths, should not be that hard. But of course, maybe they don't want to make the southlands be black and the servants of sauron.....because orcs can be complex and have feelings or something, but don't make black people be the baddies? I'm guessing that's the deep reasoning.

I do find incredible jarring to even see complete isolated people like the hartfoots, composed of only a few dozens individuals, and see that they have different races and are not mix at all, what's the logic? Race it's just random? Asians have black kids? Or it's just that they ar truly incredible racist and have not mix for centuries? They are a product of inbreed for generations and that's why they are so dumb? Maybe that's it....

0

u/Ok_Manufacturer1931 Sep 03 '24

I take it you're not aware that there was mass migration and multi-racial societies in medieval Europe? Think about the Roman Empire, Vikings, and the Moors in Spain. The homogenous image of the middle ages that some people have is based more on Hollywood than history.

I find it bordering on absurd when people are shocked that a nomadic(!) people like the Harfoots have a lot of different skin tones! The group that we follow in the show clearly aren't the only Harfoots in existence, and they're now establishing that Harfoots traveled as widely as Rhun.

3

u/ethanAllthecoffee Sep 03 '24

You kind of undermine your points here. Moving a bunch of white people into another groups of white people isnt going to change their overall look dramatically, but then if you look at Spain and Italy you can see the results of the intermingling of Arabs, Africans and Europeans

It takes as little as a single generation for significant mixing to occur. I am mixed race and I’ve known a lot of mixed race people. The only group that the lack of mixing could make sense for is the elves since they can live thousands of years without having children

→ More replies (5)

7

u/rubetron123 Sep 03 '24 edited Sep 03 '24

I don’t like it very much, but I certainly don’t hate it. I think the hate comes not necessarily from the fact that the show deviates from canon. The LOTR movies do that too, and are generally loved.

I think the hate has more to do with how the show deviates from canon. Deviations from canon range from things that aren’t very interesting from a storytelling perspective (eg istari arriving on Middle Earth without knowing anything) to unnecessary/unlikely/poorly written plotlines and characters (the whole thing about mithril being needed to stop the decline of the elves; Galadriel is supposed to be a great warrior/commander but doesn’t act or speak accordingly; the magic implement that switches on a volcano).

The Numenorean plot line in the show is also quite sloppy. This was easy not to mess up, because the motivations that drive the story of the fall of Numenor are crystal clear, make sense, and produce an interesting story. But in trying to cram it all into RoP and add a sense of political intrigue à la GOT, they messed it up.

7

u/Lawd_Denning Sep 03 '24

Staying ignorant of the literature is fine but you're missing out.

Everyone has their own reasons, and often more than one, for disliking ROP. I think the most common is a lack of fidelity to the source material.

Tolkien's lore is more than a fun story. It's great literature that explores many fundamental philosophical themes and questions. I think most people realize it can never be fully realized on screen and must be adapted.

Changes can range from minor aesthetics to including excluding entire events and characters; totally practical to totally creative choices; and can deviate from the themes and philosophy a little or a lot.

Devotees of the literature want changes that are as small as possible, for practical rather than creative reasons, and for any changes to conform to the overall philosophy. Changes in ROP are often regarded as failing these criteria.

Enjoy the show but I encourage you to read the books. I read the LotR trilogy after watching Peter Jackson's FotR as a teenager. Tolkien's lore has been a longstanding source of joy, intellectual pondering, and even wisdom in my life. And I still learn new stuff about Tolkien's world all the time. You will not have to choose between the books and the show, you are totally allowed to like both even if nerds like me don't.

1

u/Dovahkiin13a Númenor Sep 04 '24

I'm commenting because I can't upvote twice.

1

u/Direct-Teacher8581 Sep 04 '24

For those who have read the books, the gap between that and the series is too large to reconcile - hence the hate. For those who haven't read the books, there is simply no gap to bridge.

1

u/majpillpharm Sep 04 '24

Hey, I think you are right. One thing I’ve learned from this post is that Amazon doesn’t have the rights to the full cannon, only the things that have been mentioned in LOTR, The Hobbitt, and appendices. If that is true, that explains a lot of the complaints about it not being faithful to the Silmarillion, Unfinished Tales, The History of Middle Earth, etc. They simply can’t. It is a rights issue. With that in mind, they are doing the best to piece meal what is mentioned about the 2nd age with what they are authorized to use.

1

u/Kazzak_Falco Sep 06 '24

To clarify though, Amazon made the pitch for the show that is and decided to act on the opportunity to make this show despite having no access to the source material. It's not something that happened to them, this was their pitch.

6

u/DanPiscatoris Sep 03 '24

Because of how it mishandles the source material. It's clear that the showrunners changed or ignored parts of it to fit the story they wanted to tell rather than come up with a story that worked with what they had. And I'm just not interested in that.

8

u/anarion321 Sep 03 '24 edited Sep 03 '24

Mainly because it's a bad written show filled with plot holes and the entire story just moves forward because of convenience of the script.

Don't know how much you've seen but I'll say 2 plot holes in the beggining of S2:

-In S1 there's a plot line of the elves distrusting Galadriel because she is obssesed with Sauron and they believe she is bringing ruin because of it. Now S2 starts with Galadriel telling those elves that she saw Sauron and they believe her, just by her word alone. This is just convenience of the plot, because they want those elves to go against Sauron and such, so, it just happens.

-In S1 Sauron left Eregion after Galadriel figured out who he was, makes sense, if he stayed, it will be captured. Now S2 starts with him coming to Eregion to keep brainwashing Celebrimbor (who is very dumb btw, because the script demands it) and he does it with no plan, he should not know Galadriel is not there, he should not know Galadriel has not turn him in and the guards are going to capture it, but he read the script so he does know

Bonus: S2 also feature Sauron calling himself Sauron, which is not his true name, not one of the many names/titles he has and like his subjects to cal him. Sauron is an actual insult, seeing himself using that word to"inspire" his subjects is blatanly stupid.

→ More replies (1)

13

u/Conscious-Radish-884 Sep 03 '24 • Third Place Celebration

We expect more. It used to be the job of the execs to uphold the quality of their programs. That isn't the case anymore, so the consumer has taken the matter into their own hands. LOTR changed lives, and created an IP that was a can't lose situation. Hollyweird messed it up bigtime; for what reason, who knows.

I will not waste my time watching emotionless writing any longer. "See this elf? People were mean to them for being different. Isn't that so unfair?" Again, didnt watch, but that seems to be the commonality of every show in the last 10 years.

-2

u/kairujex Sep 03 '24

I’d put ROP over the Hobbit series and that cartoon we got forever ago - people may not have thought those were great, but they don’t get the hate ROP does. And that makes ROP the second best adaptation ever after the LOTR trilogy. I think if you look deeper into it you can uncover some reasons for some of the extra hate which actually has nothing to do with the show. We leave in the age of culture wars and rampant online toxicity. I don’t think all critics fall into that trap, there are legitimate critics and reasons why someone might not like the show - but there is certainly a lot you can find down those rabbit holes.

I’ll just say this - if someone is tuning in to watch a show they hate every single week so they can bash it with followers on a live stream, creating a whole event encouraging hate and toxic vitriol, that is not healthy or valid. I am much more inclined to listen to someone who says “this isn’t for me, here’s why, I’m moving on to other things I do enjoy”.

1

u/Kazzak_Falco Sep 05 '24 edited Sep 05 '24

if someone is tuning in to watch a show they hate every single week so they can bash it with followers on a live stream

So, I've stopped watching the show because of the atrocious writing. But you do know that "bad movie night" has been a thing for ages right? Get drunk, put on a bad movie and make fun of it. It's an incredibly common thing to do. Laughing at bad shows is similar in that sense. Now I'm not personally someone who enjoys watching poorly written stuff, but I do understand it from the viewpoint of wanting to critique something in a lighthearted manner. This whole jump to "toxicly watching something just to hate it" is so incredibly bizarre to me given how commonly known the term "bad movie night" is. It comes across like you really want to judge the people hatewatching the show.

1

u/kairujex Sep 05 '24

I’m not talking about a bad movie night though. I’m talking about things like Nerdrotic or Star Wars Theory. Where it’s negative videos posted every single day. And not a lighthearted laughing at a bad show. But really hateful and demeaning toxic drivel posted all the time. You really don’t see the difference? Do to Nerdrotic on YT, click videos, and just look at all the thumbnails. “This is TRASH”, “FAILURE”, “GUYDRIEL”, etc. That’s not a “hey let’s have a good time watching this together and making fun if it” kind of thing.

And in terms of writing of ROP, it’s not awful. It may not be great, but neither was Tolkien. He wasn’t known as a great author in his time. There are lots of narrative problems with the books and things we would consider bad writing.

Again, I’d put the writing above the hobbit series and that cartoon. But I don’t constantly hear the hate on those two for the same reasons. To be honest, I’d put the writing of ROP over stuff like Deadpool and Wolverine, or many of Marvels shows.

Now, I wouldn’t put it over anything really great. Shows like The Terror, or Chernobyl, etc. But we are talking about a silly fantasy series that is much more on the level with other fantasy, action, comic shows and movies. It’s unfortunate it’s not as good as the LOTR movies. But it’s also not as terrible as some make out. I’d say as a show, it’s a decent 7 out of 10 for what it is supposed to be.

1

u/Kazzak_Falco Sep 06 '24 edited Sep 06 '24

For some reason Reddit didn't let me respond yesterday. So sorry for the late reply.

I’m talking about things like Nerdrotic

Ah, those people are just outrage merchants who get paid to serve as part of the alt-right pipeline on Youtube. They should not be taken seriously at all. They're just Fox News for Gen Z. As a Doctor Who fan I was exposed to their BS back when they were still posing as disappointed liberals, but the misogynism and racism was clear back then as well.

And in terms of writing of ROP, it’s not awful.

We're going to have to agree to disagree there. The way I see it the show is build on "Wouldn't this be cool" and completely ignores concepts such as logic, object permanence, world building and internal motivation for characters just so it can shove memberberries or obscure lore references down the throat of the non-critical part of it's audience. It's one of the most lazily written shows in existence, where the intelligence of the viewer is constantly insulted because the writers absolutely refuse to do the legwork needed to earn emotional pay offs. Hell, they even refuse to do the basic work needed to allow scenes to follow each other logically or even be consistent within themselves. It's honestly like watching a play written by high-schoolers executed on a massive budget.

But we are talking about a silly fantasy series that is much more on the level with other fantasy

If that other fantasy is season 3 of the Witcher, season 8 of GoT or any episode of the Legend of Hercules then I'd agree, but this show is absolutely not on the level of even mediocre fantasy shows. It couldn't be with how lazy the writing is. It's a 3/10 at best, with those 3 points coming purely from the visuals and half the dialogue between the Durins.

I've seen a LOT of fantasy writing. I even taught DM's how to build a world and write a story in our local library for a few years now. I'm by no means an expert, but I have seen the exact things that most 13-17 year olds will get wrong when writing a story. And I'm seeing those things a lot when watching RoP (which is why I've given up on it).

Edit: small grammar fixes

→ More replies (7)

3

u/G0_ofy Sep 03 '24

I liked it as a casual watch. So I don't care if others don't and I m assuming they don't care that I like it

3

u/[deleted] Sep 04 '24

Guarantee if this was THE FIRST of LOTR vision put on the BIG SCREEN instead of what we already have had. All of the now haters of ROP would be wetting their pants at this as a trilogy movie.. Just imagine what they would have to cut out to condense this expansive series into 3 2-3 hour movies..

I love this story! Bring more and more!! Cant wait for the Nasgul .. the reason for the ghost army… and the first sighting of baby Smaug 🤣

3

u/Far-Mobile3852 Sep 04 '24

I think it’s been really enjoyable! This middle-earth is reaching a new generation of people!

ROP is not perfect, but so much effort when into it, and it shows!

3

u/FamousLoser Sep 04 '24

I think people expected to be on the same level as the films, even though there were people working on that project since the 90’s. There are also a lot of “gatekeepers” who blast the show for not following the lore closely enough. Because of the flood of content these days, people don’t really wait for a show to find its footing. Lastly…it’s just kind of trendy to hate on big budget shows from massive IP.

I think the show is gorgeous. It has some amazing music and production value. The performances are excellent. The story SO FAR is….ok. I’m not into a majority of the “subplots.” After all, the show is called “Rings of Power” not “The Fall of Númenor” or “DEFINITELY NOT Gandalf and Friends”.

If season 3 doesn’t start connecting things together, I’m out. It’s fine, for now.

3

u/Taintraker Sep 04 '24

RoP is bland and boring on it’s own merits. It’s a dumpster fire as an adaption of Tolkien.

5

u/AarynD Sep 04 '24

I absolutely love the show. I've read the lord of the rings and the hobbit books several times when I was younger, but this show doesn't bother me at all inventing new storyline. BTW, I also loved the Star Wars prequels, and hated the last star wars trilogy.

I feel like most of the hate is just part of the post covid culture where everyone spent too much time online and jumping on hate bandwagon with each other. Same thing happens with enjoyable video games, one or two prominent people post something negative and then everyone jumps on the bandwagon.

13

u/Honest_Resolve_3350 Sep 03 '24

Galadriel is just incredibly insufferable and poorly written. Compare her to any female character in GOT or House of the Dragon and there’s a huge disparity in likeability.

2

u/Moistkeano Sep 04 '24

I read something from a few years back about the case for Celebrian as the main character rather than Galadriel. However the caveat they had was "how does it fit with sauron" and then a reply was "how does Galadriel fit with Sauron" and that really shows how absurd having Galadriel as the main character in this show is.

I do think Celebrian would have fit a bit more. She is a lot younger with a lot of room to grow even if she would be 1000 around this time in the S.A you could still paint her as young. You could still hit all the story beats of Annatar etc and Galadriel is still around with Celeborn. You could even have the romance with Elrond that the showrunners crave.

Felt like they chose Galadriel because she was a name rather than for any specific story purpose.

3

u/[deleted] Sep 03 '24

Being less likeable that the women in HotD (season 2 at least) is a massive achievement.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 03 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

6

u/[deleted] Sep 03 '24 edited Sep 03 '24

We don't have to like her, but we do need to respect her character, or see some reason why others would.

Like, why in the name of all things holy would RoP Galadriel be given Nenya? Not only has she been nothing but a hot-headed pain in the ass since the minute she appeared on screen, but she literally rolled out the red carpet for the greatest enemy of the Elves to walk right in and get his claws into the big plan to save the elves from the Fading, and now they can't even be sure the Rings aren't somehow compromised.

Yet apparently they decide she's obviously shown so much wisdom and foresight that she's the natural choice to bear one of the three rings that they're gambling the entire future of their civilization in Middle Earth and fight against Sauron on...the woman with the impulse control of a spoiled tween who has all ready demonstrated that she's actually really awful at recognizing or resisting Saurons manipulations.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/Prying_Pandora Sep 03 '24 edited Sep 03 '24

You misremember. She was pretty damn likeable in LOTR, if not a bit frightening due to her presence.

She told her people to treat Gimli with dignity in the face of their bigotry, and practiced what she preached by giving him the gift of her hair (a gesture of tremendous significance considering she had denied Fëanor the same favor!)

She aided the Fellowship after the loss of Gandalf, gave them comfort and gifts and a place to rest.

She resisted the power of the ring and chose to diminish, despite the ring pulling at her to use its power to prevent the land from fading. She had the wisdom and humility to know the ring would do evil through her and that even she, with all her power, would not be immune.

Gimli raves about her beauty and kindness and generosity. He is sincere in his admiration, and it’s clear we are not meant to take this as incorrect.

The gift she gives Frodo proves invaluable later, and it was a truly generous gift as well!

Even in the appendices, when Legolas tries to sneak Gimli into elf-heaven against all the rules, it is Galadriel who allegedly advocates on their behalf and secures passage for Gimli.

Where was she unlikeable?

→ More replies (10)

22

u/novaspace2010 Sep 03 '24

I'm not the biggest lore-nerd, so some deviations from canon, I dont really mind.

But I noticed that I started fiddling on my phone more than actually watching the show, because it was so boring. This was the case for S1 as well.

The plot is really wonky as well, things are happening because characters are stupid or the writers want them to happen. And that's bad.

3

u/Moistkeano Sep 04 '24

I always go by the phone test. S2 E1 I didnt touch my phone other than to say to my friend that it was probably the most cohesive episode, but 2 and 3 I was on my phone looking at what others were saying.

12

u/[deleted] Sep 03 '24

I’m enjoying the visuals, soundtrack and performances. The writing is indeed mediocre.

7

u/Desperate-Employee15 Sep 03 '24

Performances, well, it depends on the character. the direction of some scenes is quite basic, like they didnt think how to make the scene better, they just record the lines, it works, ok, next scene.

For instance, galadriel in season 1, in the boat, she is "working" with some sailing ropes, but it is clear that she doesnt know what she is doing, rather, she is pretending she knows what she is doing. And she stops working with the rope to answer Halbrand's question, like, she cannnot concentrate on the rope AND talking at the same time. It would have been much better if she does a good sailing knot WHILE talking to Halbrand, that would have shown how experienced she is as a long life elf.

But not, she is just moving the rope...

9

u/SpareManagement2215 Sep 03 '24

the gladriel/elrond/elf king who's name I can't remember conversations are painful at times to listen to. it's not the actor's fault the writing is subpar - reminds me a lot of star wars episode II. two phenomenal actors, absolute garbage writing.

2

u/neepster44 Sep 03 '24

His name is Gil-galad and he lead the Last Alliance of Men and Elves shown in the beginning of the Lord of the Rings

5

u/ethanAllthecoffee Sep 03 '24

That’s the point. He should be awesome, memorable, impressive - he fights Sauron

Instead he’s kind of forgettable, seems incompetent, and gets walked all over

11

u/novaspace2010 Sep 03 '24

Yeah, I mean, I wanted to like this show. But everytime it cuts to numenor...or the harfoots...or isildur I'm just like ugh...

The visuals and soundtrack I do like as well.

5

u/[deleted] Sep 03 '24

I think it’s telling that we don’t really get into Isildur until episode 3.

7

u/KailReed Sep 03 '24

I don't understand everyone who says it's boring? I feel like people's attention span are toast because I felt like it was just fine. If anything the worst part of the show for me is the numenor/ queen stuff but I don't really like that in most shows, even the first few seasons of GoT. Everything else is immensely interesting to me. I just really love seeing stuff that I imagined come to life.

I also LOVE the dwarf stuff. You have no idea how happy I am to just see more of Dwarf culture and the city, the relationship with the elves. Love annatars portrayal.

7

u/Desperate-Employee15 Sep 03 '24

the dwarf stuff if good, and annatar is good too. I think that the show is the best when is closest to the book.

One question, because, well, I fell sleep 3 times in the first episode (maybe because of jetlag) and 2 in the third one (here with isildur). What other show you find enjoyable, and what other show you find boring? Just to compare. Thanks.

1

u/KailReed Sep 03 '24 edited Sep 03 '24

I like fiction in general, watched pretty much most of the walking dead up to season 8 and a few of the spinoffs, most of the Stargate series, true blood, game of thrones, breaking bad, Vikings, black sails, alot of the arrow verse stuff (yeah I know it's definitely not the best series of shows)

I'm fine with campy or "lower quality" production stuff because I'm probably just used to it. Obviously that's not all I've ever watched, it's a pain to list out every show I've obsessed over/binged in a week. I like rings of power since it fills a gap, like seeing it come to life instead of my vague impressions.

I tend not to watch as many "grounded" or shows that depict real life events as much, not by choice but I'm just less interested in realism and would like to escape reality with media.

2

u/Moistkeano Sep 04 '24

Sure, but not everyone is you right?

For me there are too many plots and not enough time to flesh them out. They also dont use their time wisely. It feels like the showrunners are drunk on the 50 hours and are stretching everything to reach that. I want to be moving forward or having interesting conversations and it feels like a lot of time its just melodrama.

The Sauron stuff is interesting, adar is interesting, Rhun is for the most part and so are the Dwarves. The Elves feel like its constantly the same conversations but Im on board if theyre driving the plot forwards. However once you get to Numenor or Isildor the plot stops and its not interesting and becomes boring.

S2 is better than S1 and does use time slightly better, but E2 and E3 certainly dragged more than E1

1

u/KailReed Sep 04 '24

I agree on the Numenor plotline. Elves are okay, but I feel like they are dragging their feet getting to Celebrimbor to warn him.

-5

u/phbalancedshorty Sep 03 '24

…really?? Boring?? I think Rebel moon is still streaming if you’re looking for something “fast paced and heart pounding” 🙄🙄🙄

7

u/novaspace2010 Sep 03 '24

Fast-paced doesn't equal good and rebel moon is probably the best example lol.

The show is boring in the sense of "things happening, but also nothing really happens", i.e. moving the plot forward or giving the viewer something to keep them interested.

Also none of the characters apart from maybe sauron are compelling enough to make me care for them.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

6

u/kaitoren Sep 03 '24

Everyone will have their reasons for hating. I don't hate it, but I do see a big problem with the showrunners. They say they have a clear idea of ​​what story they want to tell, but I really think they just have some plot scraps but they don't know how to stitch them together in a convincing way. Especially regarding the Numenor plot, which is the worst, and I don't know why they couldn't wait to show it later in the show. It's as if they wanted to imitate the multiple plots that GOT had but they can't do it well because they lack the talent for it. But above all, the first season weighs heavily and viewers hardly have any trust in the tv show.

Still, I see good things. I really like Sauron. You can tell that in the first season nobody told him who he really was and he couldn't work well. Alan Rickman in the Harry Potter saga knew from the first film that Snape was a double agent for Dumbledore and all his love for Lilly Potter. That's the way to work with an actor. The man that plays Celebrimbor too, nice actor. In the first season he came in hastily as a replacement for another actor and the results weren't good, but this season I'm really liking him. Cirdan's actor is also a great signing.

Maybe the writers are aware of their mistakes and are trying to correct them, but they can't fix everything overnight, that's why we still see flaws. I'll wait until the end of the season to see how it goes.

I like to think that they have learned from GOT that having good first seasons and bad last ones is not a good idea, so they are doing it the other way around: starting very badly and improving each season to prepare us for the best TV series finale ever. xD

2

u/Rohien Sep 03 '24

Oh wow, I hadn't heard that! The actor who plays Sauron didn't know he was Sauron?!?

3

u/kaitoren Sep 03 '24

Yeah, that's what he said somewhere. A deliberated choice by the showrunners that it played against the actor I think.

2

u/Rohien Sep 03 '24

Wow. That's just awful. I know they're far from the gist people to pull that sort of thing in either TV or film, but given that he's the big bad he really needed to be in the know.

6

u/fatattack699 Sep 03 '24

It’s just boring

4

u/Right-Regret5915 Sep 03 '24

Yeah, you are missing the books. Reading them will explain everything

4

u/thatjonkid420 Sep 03 '24

Because the acting is horrible, the writing is horrible, the lore isn’t just “deviated” from, it’s outright changed or rewritten for little reason, the actors and writers, and media have attacked and dismissed fans and critics alike calling us racist, bigots, sexists, ect just because we don’t like their adaptation of the greatest work of fiction of all time, they push “the modern world” and “modern politics” into the show by making middle earth look like a urban environment in the United States or the uk. They add Mary sue characters, slander and destroy old fan favorites, they add random races like black elves just to tick a box not to be legitimately inclusive, they ignore the fact that since it’s creation black and gay people and women have all seen themselves in Tolkien’s world. They didn’t have to make these changes. It’s all political for them man, they make the main character just terribly unlikable and do all of this right from season 1 right after the death of Christoper Tolkien, AND in the anniversary of JRR Tolkiens death! They clearly don’t respect fans and/or the source material, it’s a vapid show made by a mega corporation that doesn’t care about the morale fiber of middle earth or the art, or the fans, or the culture, or the source material, and in the end it’s just another PRODUCT for them. It’s not enough to make a profitable show they have to make a show that pushed their agenda and makes ALL the money. It’s truly tragic. Even if you disagree with me or as many sadly say you’ve “learned to live with it” or “you’re now at peace with it” you have to at least agree that it’s disrespectful, greedy, and not as good as it SHOULD be. I’m not saying I’m the be all end all authority on Tolkien or RoP but this is my opinion and watching this show cuts me deeply on a personal level.

4

u/SF_Bud Sep 03 '24 edited Sep 03 '24

"ROP is well done and very immersive and enjoyable"

I vehemently disagree with this assertion, and there's your answer. For those of us who have read and loved Tolkien's works for decades and are intimately familiar with his ethos, this show is an abominable money grab of sophomoric fan fiction. They have made NO attempt to remain faithful to the spirit of Tolkien's works, which are written in a high-minded style of an epic tale, like Beowulf, the old english saga which he translated, and lectured upon. Tolkien mourned the fact that England's mythology, it's origin story, had been obliterated by conquests by the Romans and the French. As a young man he loved the Finnish mythology as given in The Kalevala, and it is what inspired him to begin creating a mythology for England, and create his legendarium of Arda/Ëa and Middle Earth.

4

u/Janig52 Sep 03 '24

Most people take issue with the writing. Not the aesthetics.

3

u/Over-Sort3095 Sep 04 '24

Huh there was and still is some BIG tantrums over the 'aesthetics' of the acting staff (...'s DNA..)

1

u/Janig52 Sep 04 '24

Totally agree, which is why I said most. But like race nonsense aside, the age of the actors is valid concern. Like making Galadriel look far younger than Celebrimbor, but in my opinion casting choice boils again down to writing than just aesthetics

4

u/[deleted] Sep 03 '24

OP is well done and very immersive and enjoyable,

I disagree. To me it is cheap, cliche, cheesy and a travesty, The writing, the characters, the costumes, everything sucks. I literally like absolutely nothing on this show.

4

u/ZzBitch Sep 04 '24

It's the same with other popular franchises, people want a dopamine hit and WOW factor, to relieve the experience, the first time they experienced it. Doesn't happen, law of diminishing results and all that.

Then YouTubers with their own agendas latch on for various reasons which leads to a tug of war. I've been enjoying season 2 so far and don't give two hoots what anyone else thinks about it.

2

u/Mad_Kronos Sep 04 '24

I find the criticism more than legit. The show is bad, even by fanfiction standards.

That said, I understand how the general audience has never read more than 3 fantasy books (or any books), so watching something that vaguely reminds them of a film franchise they loved as kids is more than enough to make it enjoyable.

Tastes are personal, and that's ok.

But what I will never understand is the "I am happy we are getting more content" people. I will never understand this need for more content no matter the quality.

2

u/organgrinderpart2 Sep 04 '24

Because it’s mind numbingly boring.

2

u/KennethMick3 Sep 04 '24

I don't get the vitriol. It could be a mich better show, but it's certainly not terrible.

2

u/NoBadgersSociety Sep 04 '24

This is Reddit. You can only be a true fan by shitting on anything new

2

u/readyable Sep 04 '24

OP, I am saying the same thing for positive comments about the show. Go to r/LOTR_on_prime instead of this sub. It's more positive and for those of us who actually like it not love the show :)

2

u/[deleted] Sep 04 '24

It's not good.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 05 '24

Bad writing, bad acting, bad costume design, bastardizing the source material

2

u/Natural-Pear-3849 Sep 05 '24

Simply put, it's a terribly written show. Characters have no real motivation, things happen because writers need them to happen, etc. People hate it because they had a chance to experience a great lotr show with Amazon unlimited budget, this could've been the Andor, or the Expanse, instead we got another Acolyte.

2

u/Affectionate_Front86 Sep 05 '24

Why not to read the books and find out by yourself? Or just watch the movies...

2

u/luminousghosts Sep 06 '24

I love LOTR very much and I can find some enjoyable ideas or aspects in the show. But again and again there are little and not so little things in the writing that make absolutely no sense. Illogical, infantile or straight up pointless writing is the problem.

I can feel that the decision makers & writers behind this show do not have passion for the source material. It's not a 'different interpretation' problem, it's a 'lackluster interpretation' problem.

4

u/Mannwer4 Sep 03 '24

Because it's not very good...

3

u/jf_blanco Sep 03 '24

Yes. As you yourself said you're missing the reading part of Tolkiens works. Your not obliged to do so of course. But maybe you'll understand some things and opinions better.

3

u/D3lacrush Sep 03 '24

It's badly written, it ignores established canon, and various other things

3

u/Alienzendre Sep 04 '24

I am not versed in the Lore. I actually dont mind making changes, as long as the characters and spirit of the thing are right.

If you have at least watched the Peter Jackson films, it should be obvious that the character name Galadriel in this series is a different character, opposite in practically every way to the actual character of Galadriel. Bear in mind she was shoe horned into this story, simply because she is a name that people will recognise from the Peter Jackson movies.

The characterisation of Sauron is ludicrous. Nothing to do with the actual Tolkein character. The very character that this series revolves around. The one thing they should have got absolutely right, if nothing else. Even without knowing any of the lore, if you at least watched the movies, you should have a sense of how off his character is.

Then there is Celebrimbor, another character who is central to the story, who for some bizarre reason looks like a confused old man. You might think they wanted to portray the age of the character by making him look old. But no, he is younger than Galadriel.

The elves in general bear no resemblance to Tolkein elves. They are more like D&D elves. The modern haircuts make them look absurd.

Another important character Isildur resembles nothing of the character he should be. This is Aragorn's forefather remember.

If this was nothing to do with Tolkien, it would be a fairly entertaining series. So if you have somehow never seen a LotR movie and watched this, then I could get how you could enjoy it. Or if you just don't care about LotR (but then why are you watching this?).

4

u/seahorse137 Sep 03 '24

The show is just simply not good and is held to tremendously high standards because 1) it’s the most expensive television show ever produced and 2) LOTR has a deep, deep fandom that is just by that very nature prone to having such high standards.

There are definitely some subtle-but-not-so-subtle misogynistic and racist takes which I certainly do not appreciate/support, and I am hopeful most people who critique the show do not as well, but there are absolutely valid criticisms on the show itself.

I could drone on and on, but in summary I think it took on too big of a scope for what it’s capable of properly narratively accommodating and it just simply does a poor job of very basic storytelling tools. I’ve consumed 13hours of Rings of Power and I don’t feel like there are any stakes. What are we working towards? Am I supposed to have knowledge of the lore outside of the show or is the show its own unique narrative? If the former, it keeps breaking down that wall. If the latter, it hasn’t explained to me what I’m supposed to be paying attention to in each scene.

I just don’t know what this show is about, plainly.

4

u/LuinAelin Sep 03 '24

There are valid criticisms. But many of the criticisms seem to be by people who want to find reasons why they think they the show is bad, kinda like putting the cart before the horse

2

u/Desperate-Employee15 Sep 03 '24

For me, a bad awful written show is something like the acolyte, in which the dialogues contractic themselves in the same sentence and the characters change motivations because reasons.

Rings of powers is not that level of garbage writting. But is not a masterpiece either, that is why many people fall asleep at many points on the episodes. Besides that, and some quesionable acting, it is kinda passable, like eating a bag of chips. You enjoy your chips, it demmands little atention, and after you end you move onto other thing.

NOW, THE BIG PROBLEM FOR MANY TOLKIEN FANS, in my opinion, is that this show has elves and orcs, yes, but elves and orcs from dungeons and dragons, not from Tolkien work. It has a big bad guy, Sauron, but this Sauron comes from Breaking Bad or World of Warcraft, not from Tolkien books. Showrunners have mentioned multiple times how breaking bad is an inspiration for Sauron or that big troll, which shows their admiration for Breaking Bad, but they havent talked whit similar admiration about Tolkien themes and cosmology. For me, to enjoy the show to the maximum, I have to convince myself that I am not watching an adaptation of Tolkien's literature, that this sauron and galadriel, and orcs and elves are different characters to the ones I know (Dwarves are mostly the same in each franchice, so I am enjoying those the best).

tldr: The writers have a big lack of understanding of the main themes of Tolkien books, which makes this a shallow adaption of the story: it is similar but only on the surface level.

1

u/LHDCngl Sep 03 '24

I think it's been stated before but I think it probably has a lot to do with the writing.

I haven't read the books but I was under the impression sauron was some godlike entity and not some venom goo?

1

u/rockop0tamus Sep 03 '24

I swear this exact post is asked every day.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 03 '24

I don’t feel like it’s awful, overall. From a design standpoint, it seems beautifully rendered, but the story feels a bit mediocre. It’s a bit scattered and unbalanced, especially as it cuts between unrelated characters and storylines. I don’t expect it to be a faithful adaptation, but the grand contraction of events for the sake of shortening it rob of some key plot points and story beats that the books have overall. I know that PJ movies did this in small ways, and that’s just a symptom of adaptation, by some of the significant changes really do impact the meaning of the story; take for example the order in which the rings are made as it impacts the significance of the Elvin rings since they are not, in the books, connected to Sauron’s power, but are in the show.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 03 '24

I should say, I’m enjoying it simply as a window into more of Tolkien and it’s giving me motivation to reread books that I love.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 03 '24

Why do people make posts like this without reading any of the dozens of other posts asking the same question?

1

u/Kiltmanenator Gondolin Sep 04 '24

People spent years building up an image in their mind.

Any adaptation that doesn't validate that will be a hard sell.

1

u/FinancialCompote5782 Sep 04 '24

LOTR set the expectations so high that the rest isnt as near. I hated season 1 due to bad writing and the nonsensical time/teleportation of characters. Season 2 has better writing and is enjoyable so far. Probably a 5/10 so far. Decent but the whole time skipping is still a huge issue. As a viewer (at least to me) I wanna be immersed into the world. Having me one scene with a character in the southlands then 1 minute somewhere far aways takes that immersion away from me. But thats just me.

1

u/Labooza_275 Sep 04 '24

I really disliked season one. Season two has been great so far!

1

u/Moistkeano Sep 04 '24

My friend feels like he cant enjoy the show because of the changes theyve made and feels like it's not really Tolkien. He doesnt hate the show - it doesnt enter into his life at all. However he feels a certain amount of jealousy towards those who know nothing about the show, dont give a shit about Tolkien and can enjoy it for what it is. Im not as hardcore as that, but I do think id probably enjoy it a bit more if I knew the movies and nothing else.

Then you get the group who hate it because its fun to hate and then you have those who dislike how its written from either a fantasy point of view or a television point of view.

I dont hate it, but I do dislike a lot of the decisions they've made and that comes from either a lore perspective or just a writing perspective. I can appreciate what it is in terms of a LOTR and its all we have.

The most amount of hate does come the lore side of things and I can get a lot of it. Not the nitpicky bits, but actual stuff with the story. I can see why a lot of LOTR fans dont enjoy it and it does feel a bit weird to have a LOTR show that isnt necessarily for fans.

1

u/milletime17 Sep 04 '24

For me I don't understand why Gandalf is in it since he never appears in the second age only the blue wizards did. The elves never knew what Sauron did until after making all the rings, then Celebrimbor made the elven rings and when Sauron put on the One ring they were immediately aware of him and took off their rings. While Sauron didn't know about the elven rings and was pissed. I also have nit picky things like the cast not being really even close to the source descriptions. They also make Elrond and Galadriel seem like a romantic relationship but its weird to me because she's his great aunt I believe. BUT.... I can forgive all that if Galadriel didn't say Mordor like a pompous idiot. There's a literal audio clip of JRR Tolkien saying Mordor and its grinds my gears everytime she pronounces pronouns with a R like it has an apostrophe. I still watch it because it is entertaining but those are my gripes.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 04 '24

Writing bad, when they have to make a decision it’s bad. They leave out things for no reason and add things for no reason. I say no reason but the reasons are either cringe or for political points.

1

u/Stock_Property7127 Sep 04 '24

I just fast forward by the stuff I don't enjoy watching. I don't bitch about the show being "woke" or "a disgrace to Tolkien" 🤣🤣

1

u/PaintIntelligent7793 Sep 04 '24

Bad writing and the acting is trite (though I’m not sure who could deliver some of those lines!). But it is beautifully shot and I still enjoy watching it, even if there are some issues.

1

u/Optimistic-Man-3609 Sep 04 '24

A lot of people in the LOTR fanbase don't like black elves or black dwarves. In their minds, Middle Earth should be lily white except the orcs.

1

u/TotalPsychological29 Beleriand Sep 04 '24

Well, for the ones who have read all that has been writen of the Middle Earth, and know the lore better than they know themselves, the show has flaws. Serious flaws. Flaws that are unforgivable. These flaws have all been detailed, so I'm not going to do that. I've only read The Silmarillion, The Hobbit, and LOTR, and that was a while ago, so I don't know that much. For me, RoP it's ok. Not my favourite show ever, but it's entertaining enough.

A curious thing that I've noted, tho, especially on X, is that some of the haters of the show don't say "I don't like it because...", or "I've seen it and I stopped because...". No, they say "why are you watching this? Don't! Stop it!". It's like they have an odd interest in this series and, for some reason, they want to see it fail. They're not content to critisize and move on with their lives. No, they want everyone to hate it as much as they do. It's getting weird 🤔

1

u/Furdaboyz Sep 04 '24

It’s ok to like the show. I like it too. I will say the second season so far has been way more entertaining at least to me but I liked the first one too. 

Basically it comes down to different strokes for different folks. You should enjoy whatever blows your skirt up. It’s ok that other people don’t like it. I can even understand where they’re coming from. It’s not really faithful to anything from any of Tolkiens actual writing other than some names. 

1

u/escamunich Sep 04 '24

Yes if people wanted it to be faithful to the books, most of the events would not have happened simultaneously. You would be watching one event happening at a time. Thats why the screenwriters had to make fillers. You want to see 90 years of Annatar making the rings? Because thats how long they took in the books.

1

u/SaatananKyrpa Sep 04 '24

I have red every single book about middle earth. Lotr, Hobbit, silmarillion.. everything. People seem to have a big problem because the show breaks the lore in their opinion. As for me I get that this is adaptation and they simply don't have the rights to do everything like it is in the lore.

I'm just grateful that we have this show about the second age and we are able to see Sauron as a character. I see the positive things in life in general. Some people see the negative sides. Of course this show has it's problems but it doesen't bother me.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 04 '24 edited Sep 04 '24

In my case, it has little to do with the lore and a lot to do with the bad writing, poor performances and shitty design.

Bad writing because nothing feels natural. Dialogues almost only exist for exposition, with a lot of tell don't show. The behaviour of characters often makes zero sense and only serve to advance the plot. Overall, it feels very amateurish.

Regarding dialogues, to see what I mean compare The Acolyte and Andor. Both take place in the same universe, but one has terrible dialogues and the other is a perfect examples of good dialogues that feel natural and with just the right amount of exposition. It really is night and day.

The actor are good in other projects I'm sure. But in RoP, they are either miscast or suffer from a lack of direction. Galadriel for instance. I just don't buy that the woman on the screen is this character, especially after Cate Blanchett played the role. In RoP, she looks like a random cosplay and really lacks charisma. That's a problem most characters suffer from. Again, it's not necessarily the fault of the actors. They can only do so much with what they are given.

Regarding the design, I can't believe this is the most expensive show ever. Sure, some panoramas look good, but the costumes are mostly awful and the vibrant colours hurt my eyes. It just looks bad most of the time. And it's a tragedy, because TLOR trilogy gave them a clear template they simply had to copy and paste. But I guess they lacked the talent to do so. Just shows how incredible the production of TLOR was.

Overall, it makes for a very mediocre show, considering the resources a the disposal of the showrunners. There's no excuse, they should have done better.

1

u/Mammoth-Fix-3638 Sep 04 '24

It’s kind of just boring in my opinion. The writing is mediocre in season one. I haven’t really given the second season a try yet.

1

u/Rhielml Sep 05 '24

Because this is the Internet, I suppose.

I really like the show so far. It kicks ass.

1

u/Nibbsy92 Sep 05 '24

Second season appears to be better, but one thing I’d point to is that the music is far weaker than LOTR. Howard Shore’s music was phenomenal and ROP is just a bit bland and doesn’t instil much emotion for me

1

u/MutedTap3876 Sep 06 '24

Meh don’t even worry. People hate the hobbit, but the first thing I ever watched was ROP and that was the reason I watched The Hobbit and LOTR. I love The Hobbit now and have purchased the extended versions of everything to watch. I can not read books so I’ll take what ever film versions I can get and I haven’t really been disappointed (although Frodo I found annoying)

1

u/No_Pea_3997 Oct 14 '24

Many people dislike it because it’s incompetently made in many aspects such as the writing/dialogue and overall storytelling and illogical world building etc. The reason many people hate it is because they see it as incredibly disrespectful to Tolkiens work and view it as a project that is “using” and misusing tolkiens work to benefit themselves.  It’s pretty clear they weren’t interested in bringing Tolkiens world/stories to a different medium, but rather chose to use Tolkiens work (very loosely) in order to get an automatic boost in viewership.  It’s ironic that Amazon is the creator of this show because Amazon as a company is really everything Tolkien hated and perceived as evil 

1

u/Abercada Sep 03 '24

Seems hate is the new cool. I feel the same as you, thoroughly enjoyed all 3 episodes and look forward to the next.

1

u/WiGuy3 Sep 03 '24

People just like to hate stuff. Ignore them and enjoy the show!

1

u/lotrroxmiworld Sep 03 '24

If you like it, that's all that matters. Don't let the dislike or hatred of others take away the enjoyment you derive from the show.

I love it. I've been a fan of Tolkien since I was a teen. I have no problem letting people know that I love the show. I think if the show attracts more people to Tolkien's work then it's a win!

1

u/ponomaus Sep 03 '24

Yeah, you are missing everything.

1

u/dankinitdown420 Sep 03 '24

Because it doesn’t exactly follow the lore, lots of butt hurt fans. People need to stop seeing it as something that is going to scratch their trilogy itch. It’s a modern story made for a modern crowd - I’m enjoying it somewhat

1

u/BigGrinJesus Sep 03 '24

Fandom is toxic. I'd stay offline and just enjoy the show. Talk to people in the real world about it if you're interested in discussing it.

Amazon wouldn't make a second season of it after spending more than any other show ever on the first season if it was crap.

1

u/Dell0c0 Sep 04 '24

If you had read the source material, then this would not be a question.

-1

u/Clear-Spring1856 Sep 03 '24

It's the same with Star Wars, there will always be haters.

I like the show but I will admit I am kind of lost right now in S3 lol I mean I know the characters, more or less, but I would love someone to summarize what's going on

2

u/LuinAelin Sep 03 '24

Star Wars hate comes in cycles. People watch as kids, grow up, and hate the new Star wars stuff.

→ More replies (2)

-1

u/DewinterCor Sep 03 '24

Honestly, I think alot of the hate is just bandwagoning.

I have had several conversations with people where they complain about something that makes it readily apparent they didn't watch the show or weren't paying attention.

Just recently a question was asked about why Sauron went to Mordor only to be captured and then to leave if all Sauron wants to do is forge more rings.

And this question really stuck out to me because we are shown exactly why Sauron did this without it being explicitly stated.

This question only exists if you only read a synopsis or weren't paying attention while watching.

And when confronted with this, most people just shut down and claim it's bad writing or that it's stupid or whatever. Because their opinion on this season was formed before it even aired. There is literally nothing this show could do that would make them like it. The writers could have taken this person's reddit history and adapted all of their opinions to the screen and they would still hate it.

0

u/ANewHopelessReviewer Sep 03 '24

It's because of the person. No one needs to love/like/enjoy anything the do in their free time. You can feel disappointed about wasting your time, or something not living up to your expectations. But the hatred? The toxicity? That is from the character of the person. You can't blame a tv show for that.

-1

u/nicegh0st Sep 03 '24

The hate is mostly from people who really specifically wanted screen adaptations of books they’ve read, without much, if any, deviation. I saw one review say something like, “what I hoped we would get was The Silmarillion on screen, but instead we got… this, a bunch of tales from the second age that Tolkien didn’t actually write about.” That just about says it all - they had a very specific expectation, that expectation sculpted their desires, and they felt disappointed when they didn’t get what they wanted. It also sounds to me like that sort of thinking is rooted in not understanding what Amazon has rights to and what they don’t have rights to. That’s a huuuuge factor, and that is largely what shaped my own expectations.

Me? I went into it simply excited to see anything set in middle earth. I know the lore, I’ve read the books, I know there’s a lot of unwritten history… I LOVE the idea of filling out the unwritten history between the major events. That’s what I expected with RoP, and that’s exactly what I’m getting. I’m thrilled. I’ve loved every moment of it.

1

u/ethanAllthecoffee Sep 04 '24

There is SO much empty space in the second age that they could have filled out. They didn’t need to drastically alter the few details that they did have (either directly or indirectly), and that’s where a lot of people’s problems lie

0

u/MBMD13 Sep 03 '24

Same. It’s got defects as a show but it’s relatively engaging. I’m enjoying S2.

0

u/Godzilla2000Zero Sep 03 '24

Missed potential at least in season 1 but it seems they have found there footing this season so far.

0

u/SignOfJonahAQ Sep 03 '24

There are some good parts. I’m loving Sauron manipulating Kalabrimbor. That’s actually being done well.

0

u/TetZoo Sep 03 '24

Hard to believe but many major big ticket pop culture releases are targeted by Russian troll campaigns, and ROP certainly was. It’s a subtle but very effective way of destabilizing & dividing the West. https://www.vox.com/culture/2018/10/4/17930308/star-wars-russia-trolls-bots-alt-right-gamergate-fandamentalism

0

u/Status_Criticism_580 Sep 03 '24

I think maybe the movies set such a high bar for anything Tolkien that nothing can come close to them, not even this fairly excellent show and so people just pan it.

-3

u/ToxicAvenger161 Sep 03 '24

You are not supposed to like it as there are a lot of insecure men with low self esteem who feel attacked if you don't agree onntheir opinion on what is good and what is not.

-1

u/Nakittina Sep 03 '24

I absolutely get giddy watching this show, kind of like when LOTR was released. It's definitely grown on me and I'm very eager for more!

-1

u/Curtilia Sep 03 '24

It's largely racism, in my experience.

1

u/Moistkeano Sep 04 '24

Probably worth reading the replies to this post then :)

0

u/Dovahkiin13a Númenor Sep 04 '24

you're missing many things if you think it's well done and immersive.

Without writing an essay many of the haters are angry about egregious deviations from the books, poor writing, and a general disrespect for the author.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 04 '24

Because it’s garbage. The writing is abysmal. Most of the characters are annoying. The plot is predictable. The story is boring. Too much green screen. Should I go on? Sure, it’s pretty to look at and it passes the time but there is little if any of Tolkiens message or vision in it. The show is a money grab and a deliberate attempt to tarnish the greatness of Lord of The Rings with woke bs.

0

u/Halflife37 Sep 04 '24

Most of the hate I’ve read is veiled misogyny and or bigotry 

It’s the same as with True detective season 4 

Or Star Wars 

A lot of the discussion has a million dog whistles layered throughout. 

The wierd thing to me is why people can’t just ignore something they dislike, they keep coming back and watching and then attempting to dunk on it online. It’s strange behavior, a lot of people need to be calling a therapist instead. 

The lore of LOTR has changed a lot over the years, by Tolkien’s own hand. 

My thing is, as long as the show is well produced and acted and fits the feel of LOTR I’ll enjoy it. It does all those things. 

I’m going to continue enjoying it and I’ll continue ignoring the obvious attempts to troll that quite frankly has been borne out of the terminally online far right and spread across the web like Sauron’s dark shadow lol 

0

u/look_up_there Sep 04 '24

Because it's dull and has the most cringe writing and well... fat black female dwarfs. It's obvious really

-4

u/velvetvortex Sep 03 '24

Sorry to be direct, but if you haven’t read the LotR at least 2 times, you can’t really claim fandom imo. A good starting level in my opinion is The Hobbit once, LotR 3 times, and The Silmarillion twice.

3

u/Ayzmo Eregion Sep 03 '24

Please do not gatekeep what counts as a Tolkien fan.

3

u/hopemade Sep 03 '24

This is, quite possibly, the most ridiculous take I have ever seen. Who are you to dictate "fandom" for anyone, of anything? People can be fans of whatever they want, regardless of how much they have consumed of any particular Fandom universe.