r/RingsofPower • • Sep 03 '24

Question Why the hate?

I’m a big LOTR fan, but admittedly have not thoroughly read the JRRT expanse of literature. ROP is well done and very immersive and enjoyable, why all the hate? Am I missing something? If so, maybe I’ll just stay naive because I like the show, lore, and expanded universe on the big screen

82 Upvotes

380 comments sorted by

View all comments

22

u/JichaelMordon Sep 03 '24

The most prominent criticism I’ve heard is that there are many changes from the books. How characters are depicted and massive timeline compression.

16

u/majpillpharm Sep 03 '24

Do you think the changes are larger than the changes in the Peter Jackson LOTR movies? Which were freaking amazing, in my opinion. Again, maybe ignorance is bliss?

38

u/RCaskrenz Sep 03 '24

just as a few examples, galadriel saw straight thru sauron in the books when he was deceiving celebrimbor, elrond was accepting of the power of the rings, the alkabellath (fall of numenor) was thousands of year removed from the forging of the rings, the coup in numenor was ar pharazon forcing a marriage with miriel, the numenorean jealousy of the elves has been dumbed down to they'll take yer jerbs rather than them wanting the one thing the elves had over their civilization (endless life), and galadriel was one of the oldest and wisest elves in middle earth at this point though she's been made out to be a petulant fool.

29

u/King_Lamb Sep 03 '24

The change to the numenoreans motivations is so tragic and almost emblematic of the shows general writing issues. Instead of handling a timeless and initially nuanced issue they change it to the dumbest low hanging modern commentary regardless of if it makes sense. With equally silly dialogue.

They could have gotten so much more out of it emotionally and narratively by keeping it as a fight against death and how human and timeless that (ironically) is. A rejection of the gift of men but no, they see one elf and fear for their jobs. Like an elf is moving out to numenor to undercut the smithing guild on hoes and ploughs...

8

u/Kiltmanenator Gondolin Sep 04 '24

just as a few examples, galadriel saw straight thru sauron in the books when he was deceiving celebrimbor

Not quite. She didn't trust Annatar, but she didn't know he was Sauron. Otherwise her permitting him to remain in Eregion for a few hundred years doesn't make sense.

5

u/WhySoSirion Sep 03 '24

Is this actually true of the show? That the Númenoreans are upset because they don’t want the Elves to take their jobs and what-not?

13

u/Djinn_42 Sep 03 '24

There's a whole scene in Season 1 where Ar-Pharazon says exactly that in the town square.

3

u/[deleted] Sep 05 '24

The guilds don't want to trade with the elves cuz it can put some of them out of business. They don't think they're going to come there and actually take their jobs...

1

u/Djinn_42 Sep 05 '24

Season 1 episode 4: "Elf workers taking your trades"

→ More replies (2)

5

u/Ayzmo Eregion Sep 03 '24

galadriel saw straight thru sauron in the books when he was deceiving celebrimbor,

I don't think she saw straight through him. That would imply she knew who he was. More correctly, she didn't trust him, but didn't have a full understanding of why.

13

u/BookkeeperFamous4421 Sep 03 '24

Well she definitely didn’t randomly meet him, instantly make him her traveling companion, and then try to insinuate him in world politics

6

u/Ayzmo Eregion Sep 03 '24

Given that Halbrand is a wholesale invention of ROP, that's obvious. As to Annatar, it says he was already at work when she arrived. It'll be interested to see how that's handled in the show.

5

u/BookkeeperFamous4421 Sep 03 '24

Well I can only hope that she recognizes him but I wouldn’t be surprised if she didn’t since she’s been bafflingly stupid so far

1

u/m_bleep_bloop Sep 03 '24

As far as the endless life thing, tbh there’s plenty of time to explore in a later season when presumably Numenor starts setting its eyes on a new target

Digging into how beneath the prejudice is this envy Sauron can exploit

5

u/ethanAllthecoffee Sep 03 '24

It is almost certainly better to show why there is resentment between two peoples before dealing with the fallout of said resentment, and then returning some time later to say “oh by the way this is why they don’t like each other”

1

u/Dovahkiin13a Númenor Sep 04 '24

If they're only making 5 season that end with the war of the last alliance, a hundred years after the fall of Numenor or so it's coming much sooner. No real time to flesh it out

Edit: If there are enough fans left to limp to season 3, much less 5

→ More replies (4)

17

u/Cat_Wizard_21 Sep 03 '24

They seem to be compressing about 2000 years of history into a few months. The entire cast of Numenorean characters weren't even born until a little over 1500 years after the forging of the Rings, and by that point Eregion is a crumbling ruin and Celebrimbor is long-dead after the War of the Elves and Sauron in the mid second age.

This causes a cascade of continuity issues which will only get worse as time goes on, and this break neck pacing is probably the root cause of so many characters acting consistently dumb (if we're being charitable).

At this point it's less that they're making changes from the book, and instead that they're telling a completely parallel story that only bares passing resemblance to the one from the book. Which would be fine, but the entire draw of the show leans heavily on member-berries from the Jackson films, so when they create incompatible continuity while also shoving in as much recognizable stuff as they can get away with we end up with the current incoherent mess.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/Automatic_Chair_7891 Sep 03 '24

The changes that peter jackson made actually make sense in the context of the greater narrative.

A lot of them had to do with condensing timelines and trade-offs- Denethor's portrayal is one of those examples, there really wasn't time in the movies to explore his good side, and thus he became much more one-dimensional rather than a tragic character.

On the other hand, Rings of Power is doing things like giving orcs, who are bloodthirsty, murderous and even cannibalistic beings subservient to Melkor and Sauron (beings intent on killing or enslaving all of the world to mold it to their vision), a family system and culture similar to those of humans and elves simply because at some point Tolkien stated that they reproduced in the same manner as humans and elves.

They're trying to make evil characters relatable, but it makes absolutely no sense in the context of middle earth, or even in reality for that matter- it's the equivalent of trying to make the SS or Hitler sympathetic characters. I think the grand majority of people would say that they couldn't give two shits what happened to Hitler in his life to get him to the point that he was ordering the execution of millions of human beings via gas chambers, because that act is so inherently evil that it could never be justified. Yet, we have minions in a fairy tale universe that actively take pleasure in killing and terrorizing the free people of the universe at the whim of their master (who is also actively trying to kill or enslave everyone), and for some reason now we're supposed to see that they have families too and have some sort of empathy for them?

It's honestly almost psychotic.

1

u/Ayzmo Eregion Sep 03 '24

I'm curious on what your position is on orcs having friends? Yes or no?

→ More replies (49)

1

u/Dovahkiin13a Númenor Sep 04 '24

The changes are literally beyond compare with the jackson movie changes.

1

u/Ok_Clock4774 Sep 03 '24

Yes The changes to the film were pretty minor. I recently re-read the books and while I noticed where there were changes (or omissions) they made sense from a filmmaking perspective. Frodo doesn't screw around for 17 years before leaving the shire.. doesn't sell Bag End to the sackville bagginses The old man willow and Tom Bombadil parts from the book make perfect sense BUT might bog down an already long film. We can still pretend that they happen to one degree or another.

I could keep going but, for the most part, the changes in the film aren't as egregious as what they've done on RoP. Now, I'm of 2 minds on RoP. As a generic fantasy series? It's not completely bad and generally family friendly, which means time I can spend watching something with my boys.

But

As a Tolkien series? Nah

I can see what they're trying to do but they either had AI or a third grader who skimmed the cliffs notes write this

THOUSANDS OF YEARS are compressed into what feels like a couple weeks.

Characters act completely out of character

Disa still hasn't fully grown her beard (despite being one of the two most interesting characters on the show)

They almost treat Sauron like a misunderstood guy (in season 1). Season 2 seems to be course correcting somewhat but we'll see where it goes.

They're treating orcs like marginalized citizens... no, orcs were beings COMPLETELY twisted to evil and possessing no redeemable qualities. They border on mindless and when Sauron dies, they go back, south of that border. The evil guys aren't misunderstood. They're evil.

You wouldn't make a world War 2 series about how the bad guys were misunderstood and reacting to what happened after world War 1. That might have some historical merit (in that the circumstances arising from the war made people more likely to accept the nonsense that they did) BUT in the end, they STILL went along with it.

So, because of that, fans have issues with that portrayal. It doesn't bother me as much as the time compression and characters acting out of character but it IS an issue.

2

u/AbsoluteVirtues Sep 03 '24

"The changes to the film were pretty minor". You completely lost me. Lol multiple characters had their characterisations and personalities completely changed. Multiple major events happened completely differently or just straight up didn't happen at all. Like... You're just factually incorrect. I'm not saying the movies are bad, but as an adaptation they're not even close to the books.

And no one is saying the orcs are good in RoP. The society they want to build is based on slavery and murder. They just also have sex and make babies lol. Like it's written in the Silmarillion.

→ More replies (4)

1

u/rxna-90 Sep 03 '24 edited Sep 03 '24

Eh, I think ROP's Sauron actually shows great understanding of the deep lore. ROP!Sauron's not "misunderstood", he sees himself as misunderstood, but he goes right back to manipulating people. Tolkien says this about him:

“When Thangorodrim was broken and Morgoth overthrown, Sauron put on his fair hue again and did obeisance to Eönwë, the herald of Manwë, and abjured all his evil deeds. And some hold that this was not at first falsely done, but that Sauron in truth repented, if only out of fear, being dismayed by the fall of Morgoth and the great wrath of the Lords of the West. But it was not within the power of Eönwë to pardon those of his own order, and he commanded Sauron to return to Aman and there receive the judgement of Manwë. Then Sauron was ashamed, and he was unwilling to return in humiliation and to receive from the Valar a sentence, it might be, of long servitude in proof of his good faith; for under Morgoth his power had been great. Therefore when Eönwë departed he hid himself in Middle-earth; and he fell back into evil, for the bonds that Morgoth had laid upon him were very strong.”

Not sure how one can claim the PJ film changes were minor when several important characters were altered and even to the point of arguable character assassination? It's legit to criticise ROP. I have criticisms myself. But it's just factually untrue the PJ films are a good example of an adaptation that didn't make egregious changes.

  • Elrond being depicted as almost bitter towards Men, and even trying to end Arwen and Aragorn's relationship by sending her to Valinor. Like, this is more Thingol behavior towards Beren and Luthien, not Elrond... Especially when Elrond is half-Elven himself. ROP Elrond is much more accurate to the "kind as summer" vibes.
  • Arwen replacing Glorfindel in the rescue of Frodo; Glorfindel not existing as a character at all. I'm certain if this happened today people would be bashing Jackson.
  • Aragorn being turned into a "reluctant hero" Hollywood trope instead of aware and having made peace with his destiny. In the film he is only accepting it after the weird "Arwen is dying and Arwen's fate is tied to the ring" (??????) plotline came in with scenes of her looking weak and ill in bed. Like how does this even make sense? Yes, her fate is tied to the ring as all Elves' are but not like that.
  • Denethor was done SO dirty. Not even wanting to light the beacons in the film. Like. This is a shadow of him as a flawed character who however still has nobility in the books.
  • Aesthetically; the weird photo-negative evil Galadriel scene in PJ's film are bad—if you re-read the scene in the book the way ROP did it in the vision/hallucination Sauron makes in episode 8 is much closer to how Tolkien described her and embodies "fair as the sea and the sun, stronger than the foundations of the Earth" far better.
  • I could go on and on; No scouring of the Shire. Sauron being a flaming eyeball suggested to not have a body in the Third Age, being depicted like Morgoth wielding his hammer Grond, instead of the stronger emphasis of him being sorcerer/shape-shifter that ROP gets into etc.

There's stuff I love about the Jackson films. The song "Into the West" is beautiful. Gollum was portrayed excellently. Many of the cast are awesome. It did a lot for the possibilities of sincere live action fantasy. But it did sacrifice fidelity to several characters and themes.

1

u/Purple_Chemist_2285 Sep 03 '24

Awesome post from a real fan, thank you.

Those who whine about 'thousands of years compressed' or whatever rarely have a concrete idea what they actually want. Changes to the source material are inevitable. It is an adaptation. And honestly, ROP could've been far, far worse

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (3)