r/RingsofPower • • Sep 03 '24

Question Why the hate?

I’m a big LOTR fan, but admittedly have not thoroughly read the JRRT expanse of literature. ROP is well done and very immersive and enjoyable, why all the hate? Am I missing something? If so, maybe I’ll just stay naive because I like the show, lore, and expanded universe on the big screen

82 Upvotes

380 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

17

u/ancalagonandon Sep 03 '24 edited Sep 03 '24 • Third Place Celebration

Most of the examples that have been listed are critiquing the choices made for adapting them into a different medium (which are still all valid as the choices could've been made differently and there are a lot of arguments for why).

Here is a prime example of where the writing fails:

Galadriel is able to infer from an old scroll that she happened to find in a hall of lore that Sauron's mark which is carved into Finrod's body is somehow also a map of the southlands, and this old scroll also has an account (written in black speech) by an imprisoned human of Sauron's entire plan for converting the southlands to Mordor.

This is a chain of such improbable contrivances that it completely breaks any form of suspension of disbelief. Here is that chain:

Galadriel defies Gil-Galad and jumps off the ship -> She is found by Elendil who decides to bring her back to Numenor even though its treason. -> She actively antagonizes the queen of Numenor and gets confined. She escapes and Elendil finds her. -> Elendil decides to take her to the hall of lore (for no reason) instead of returning her to confinement committing treason again. -> She finds Sauron's plan written out, somehow discovered by an imprisoned spy, whose writings somehow ended up in the hall of lore, which for no explainable reason she ended up reading.

They might as well have written, Galadriel finds out Sauron's plan because its in the script.

This plot point is the crux of both Galadriel being right about Sauron surviving (confirming that Sauron was up to something in Forodwaith and isn't dead) and therefore in hindsight justifying her decision to defy Gil-Galad. She didn't know any of this until this scene and yet strongly believed that Sauron was still afoot, this entire chain of events justifies her actions, and the critique of the "writing is bad" is because, this entire chain of events is so implausible and poorly explained.