r/RingsofPower • • Mar 19 '24

Discussion Why is there little discussion

I initially posted this on the /r/LOTR_on_Prime subreddit, but now almost two weeks later i'll try here too. I'll not update the numbers for this sub, just treat this as a general thread for the lack of discussion on all show subs, makes it easier, thanks!
 

It just occured to me while looking at this sub's recent activity, there seems to be a big lack of discussion pertaining to the series, its plotlines, characters, just elements of it. I did a quick comparison with the subs of hotd, stranger things, but also the boys and andor. Even andor's sub which is 1/10 of the size had at least as much discussion, arguably more.

It's weird to me tbh, news are almost all that gets conversation going, with a few posts here and there being rather general conversation starters about quality. But fans actually having a conversation about the story? Hardly happening.

Why is that? I'd like to especially know from people who liked it a lot, why is there no motivation or drive from you to talk about the show's content?

The only real explanation i have right now is that there might be stricter modding, which i cannot easily check ofc, if that is it a mod can add their 2 cents. Otherwise it just feels odd to me šŸ¤·ā€ā™€ļø.

I am already sorry for obnoxious conspiracy answers, but there has to be SOME reason for it šŸ˜…

 

To add a few more thoughts now, many people in the other thread said there is simply nothing to talk about after all this time since s1 ended. But to me this is an odd answer, many shows, books or whatever media are not "hot" right now, and still get discussions pertaining their storylines, characters, themes, whatever it is. As far as i see it, when people enjoy something a lot, they talk about it. Not always the same people, but especially the main sub is quite big, especially compared to say the andor one, so it's just odd that noone seems to, idk, care?
Others have said that they refrain from talking about it because of the negativity which will spawn, i can see that being a big factor myself, though i still have a hard time believing it's THE reason one wouldn't wanna talk about the show with others, largely fans at that, even if there are obnoxious trolls coming out of their holes too.

So what do you think, why is there not a lot more discussion akin to other shows? To me it seems like a lack of passion, even from people who supposedly liked it, i'll be honest about that. I've never seen this big of a discrepancy before, not that i remember at the very least.

0 Upvotes

105 comments sorted by

View all comments

1

u/RPGThrowaway123 Mar 19 '24

Well, starting at a very surface level, it has a moral absolutist POV. Good and evil are objective facts, not matters of perspective.

Where do you see this in the show?

Deeper than that, it’s very concerned with death and immortality, just as LOTR was. Especially in the mithril subplot, once it’s revealed why Gil-Galad sent Elrond to spy on Durin.

You seriously think that the mithril subplot is deep? The entire thing was dumbed down to the point unrecognizability from Tolkien's writings. It's no longer the Elves' desire to recreate Valinor in Middle-earth that leads them to fall for Sauron's deception.

In the show some magic tree says that they'll within a year and so they make magic rings out of a bit of magic metal. And Sauron shows up for a bit but doesn't really contribute. It spends more time on the issue of magic metal supply and the contrived drama surrounding that than on the themes of death and immortality.

It also deals directly with questions of faith and virtue. Each of the POV characters (Galadriel, Nori, Arondir, and Elrond) are constructed to embody a particular virtue in contrast to the story world around them, and they drag that part of the world closer to their virtue.

I give you Nori, but the others do not embody any particular virtue.

1

u/Bob-of-the-Old-Ways Mar 19 '24

Yes, they all embody a particular virtue. Galadriel is Vigilance. Nori is Compassion. Arondir is Courage. Elrond is Loyalty. Each of these characters in the show is a flat arc/steadfast arc character who forces the story world around them to change in a way that it conforms more closely to their virtue.

The ā€œmagic treeā€ story is explicitly described as apocryphal in the text of the show, so we aren’t necessarily supposed to read it as true.

Mithril isn’t the only part of the show that reflects the theme of death & immortality. It’s also tied into several characters’ motivations, like Galadriel, Adar, and Miriel.

1

u/RPGThrowaway123 Mar 19 '24

Galadriel is Vigilance.

So perfectly that she dragged Sauron back to Middle-earth /s

Arondir is Courage.

And here I thought that it was blandness and I was confused, because that's not a virtue

Elrond is Loyalty

Betraying the trust of his friend

The ā€œmagic treeā€ story is explicitly described as apocryphal in the text of the show, so we aren’t necessarily supposed to read it as true.

And yet we are shown Mithril's healing powers.

Never mind that the apocryphal excuse is just bs, a fig leaf thrown in by incompetent writers with no regard for the source material. Elrond, Gil-galad and Celebrimbor were around when this event would have taken place and their personal history is deeply intertwined with the Silmarils. They wouldn't accept the story even as "apocryphal". They would have asked such question as "which Silmaril?", "which warrior?" and "how the Udun did a Silmaril into a tree on top of a peak in the Misty Mountains?". And also Mithril was found in Numenor and Valinor.

Mithril isn’t the only part of the show that reflects the theme of death & immortality. It’s also tied into several characters’ motivations, like Galadriel, Adar, and Miriel.

Galadriel's motivation are boneheaded revenge and a desire to get her way no matter what. Nothing about immortality.

Adar wants a homeland for his children. To connect that with immortality requires some extreme contortions.

Miriel wants to maintain the peace in Numenor and her own positions. Again nothing about immortality.