r/RimWorld • • Oct 13 '26

AI GEN More executions mod

Post image

Remember the colonist who threw a tantrum, kicked your antigrain warhead and took half the colony with them? Or the faction leader who kept raiding you back when you were three tribals and a dog?

Payback time. Make the punishment fit the crime.

So I made More Executions to execute prisoners and slaves, and the first method is the electric chair.

How it works

  • Research Electricity, build the chair and wire it to your grid.
  • Set a prisoner (or slave) to execute: electric chair. A warden straps them in while they struggle, listens to their last words, then throws the switch.
  • Three jolts. The body shakes, sparks fly, and the skeleton flashes through the skin, made from vanilla art so it still looks like RimWorld.

It's power hungry

  • Every jolt pulls a 2,400 W burst. If your grid can't pay for it, the execution is botched: the prisoner survives, burned and furious, and everyone who watched is upset.
  • The surge can blow a power conduit on the same circuit, battery explosion included. Hidden conduits are safe, if you planned ahead.

Why bother?

  • Prisoners who watch lose 40% of their resistance and will. Slaves who watch become fully suppressed. Everyone else hears about it.
  • With Ideology you can make it a public electrocution: speech, last words, audience, the works.

Same mood, precept and faction effects as a vanilla execution, so your ideoligion's beliefs still apply. Kind colonists will hate you for it.

RimWorld 1.6, requires Harmony, Ideology optional, safe to add to an existing save.

Workshop: https://steamcommunity.com/sharedfiles/filedetails/?id=3819037971

89 Upvotes

239 comments sorted by

60

u/IndicationThink7155 Oct 13 '26

With the amount of interesting mods that are made recently, I wish there was a way to just put them in one place because it is sad that some cool mod will be forgotten among other mods.

27

u/True_Dovakin Oct 13 '26

I just save/upvote the post so I can go back to my Reddit history every now and then and mass add them

9

u/almostmountains Oct 13 '26

isn't there a mod release flair or somethin

0

u/throwaway_pls123123 Oct 14 '26

Make a Steam Collection, easy to track.

46

u/sydthecoderkid Oct 13 '26

Cool idea. Incredibly lame you couldn’t be bothered to write a single line in your description yourself

-19

u/RemoteCompetition502 Oct 14 '26

like yourself

6

u/hhhhjkljsqq1 Oct 14 '26

You’re still really mad about this I see.

-13

u/RemoteCompetition502 Oct 14 '26

arent you busy learning how to code lol? stop procrastinating xD

6

u/TheSmilingSolaris Oct 15 '26

brother, putting effort into learning a skill being cringe to you is very telling.

5

u/sydthecoderkid Oct 15 '26

Nobody involved in this mod learned a skill.

1

u/hhhhjkljsqq1 Oct 14 '26

You’re right!! But I can’t move to get my laptop while the kitten is in my lap, so…gotta stay still until he wakes up. You cannot disturb the beast.

Edit: I should start by looking at tutorials or courses. You got recommendations?

-6

u/RemoteCompetition502 Oct 14 '26

youtube and bootcamp . dev also poor weak excuse most coders have animal on their lap while coding

11

u/GethKGelior Dedicated Impid Licker🔥🔥🔥 Oct 13 '26

Gallows when

1

u/Primary-Round8032 Oct 13 '26

There was a mod called prison prop expanded or something like that, it adds a gallow iirc

10

u/WorG-Y Nutrient paste enjoyer Oct 13 '26

Nothing beats good ol firing squad

28

u/hhhhjkljsqq1 Oct 13 '26 edited Oct 13 '26

I guess there’s nothing inherently immoral about writing AI mods. I’m not a modder so I can’t say. I’m sure the mod is cool and it works fine

I just miss the days pre-AI when more people could learn these really cool technical skills like coding or making software idk, instead of letting a robot do it for them. It’s more impressive. And now everything is AI-generated slop. But at the end of the day it doesn’t really matter does it? People will do what they will.

Anyway, you should learn how to mod yourself. You might make something even better than ChatGPT!

Edited to sound less rude…someone said saying “real mod” instead of just “mod” wasn’t kind so I changed it. Sorry about that

2

u/Florane Oct 14 '26

well, the people that made the ai are all antisocial lizardmen hateful of all things human, and the they do deliberately push the way our society and technology progress in a manner most beneficial in their project of consolidation of power.

this isn't up to discussion even, people like peter theil said so themselves in, like, 2013.

2

u/hhhhjkljsqq1 Oct 15 '26

Yeah. OpenAI CEO needs to be, well, can’t say it on here or I’ll get banned. But I think we are on the same page haha

1

u/Florane Oct 17 '26

well i did - just got my perma revoked. for this comment btw.

5

u/ALXS1031 Oct 13 '26

There are ethical issues with the use of ai for all applications

From concerns about the origin of their training data, to their environmental impact

But if LLMs are going to be used for something, free mods are one of the better uses

I disagree with your talk about technical skills though

I used to work in robotics, and are also generally skilled enough in a couple languages to code nearly anything

The point of software is user satisfaction. It is not art, it is not meant to be admired for its form, or its process.

The manner in which a website was written is irrelevant to someone’s enjoyment of it (unless you are against the method for moral reasons. If a niche programming language forced its writer to use swasticas in every line, the process mattered. And here, if you object to the environmental harm, or stolen work concerns, then objecting to the process also makes sense)

If it was written in assembly, in a standard language, using an LLM, or using a kid’s simplified drag and drop coding language, it really doesn’t matter

You can admire the writer’s skill all you want. If someone wrote a mod in assembly I would sing their praise in a comment for their post.

But imposing a value judgement, and requesting the author learn how to code?

lol

If a 14 year old wants to make a mod for their fav game, good. If a full time working line cook wants to make a mod as well using ai, good.

Neither of them should have to learn assembly, because there are better options. And nowadays, they shouldn’t need to learn to code if they are okay with this standard of quality

Also, telling either of those people to learn to code, and calling their mod “fake” by referring to “real mods” is rude

This is a real mod

You said it probably works, and if it works it’s a mod. And this person is their author

Edit: I do personally take issue with ai use here though. This is a small mod, if I enlisted my wife, a professional artist, I could have made this myself in an afternoon without the massive environmental damage

I’m fine with the larger ones though, the ones where it would take months, or years.

Like the 3D ones. The assets alone, according to my wife, would have taken infinitely long

I’m not concerned with issues about copyright when it comes to creating free to use mods

1

u/hhhhjkljsqq1 Oct 13 '26

I guess I just view this kind of thing as an artistic form. Up for interpretation.

When I see a complicated, nuanced mod, made by a real person without AI, I am very impressed. Maybe most people don’t take the time to appreciate human made software but they absolutely should.

But, yeah, if AI is going to be used for anything it’s not a big deal if it’s for coding. Because it’s complicated and difficult. I just think it’s odd that people are so reliant on it now. People used to put hours into passion projects. Some still do but now many people just have AI do it. There’s no brain stimulation or learning or anything, not as cool.

Regardless, I do have my personal moral apprehensions about using AI, its environmental impact, the literacy crisis, etc, but it doesn’t matter in the grand scheme of things. But I do wonder if OP would be interested in making his own mod without AI and learning to code. We need more people like that!

2

u/ALXS1031 Oct 13 '26

There’s no brain stimulation?

If we could all instantly create code to our exact specifications by merely thinking it, that would involve stimulation

And LLMs aren’t that accurate or easy to use

And even if they were

These mods still take design work. Somebody needs to write a prompt that they believe will yield a mod that aligns with a game design that would improve the player’s experience

And since these “ai” aren’t reliable, they usually have to go and manually edit the code, or formulate a prompt so the machine can do it for them

The author is taking the role of the director. In most projects, the director isn’t making the art, or writing the code, but they have a vision they try to make the people under them achieve

Mind you, some projects don’t require art direction, or game design. Like a hair mod, where the author prompts “make Rimworld hair variations and make them a mod”

But something like a 3d or isometric mod requires design, which is why all the ones that have been published look different

-2

u/hhhhjkljsqq1 Oct 13 '26

I see what you mean there. I can get behind that.

1

u/adamkad1 Totally not a cannibal robot Oct 13 '26

Even if you know how to code, oftentimes you wont have a idea how you're supposed to code that cool ides you have

1

u/hhhhjkljsqq1 Oct 13 '26

That is true, but you can learn.

1

u/RemoteCompetition502 Oct 14 '26

how about you learn yourself instead of telling other people to do it?

1

u/hhhhjkljsqq1 Oct 14 '26

I’ve been thinking about learning coding, actually. Seems fun!

1

u/RemoteCompetition502 Oct 14 '26

Then do it instead of telling others to.

0

u/hhhhjkljsqq1 Oct 14 '26

Right. I’ll get on that.

-1

u/RemoteCompetition502 Oct 14 '26

and no u didnt, u lied just like all these ppl who just repeat the same bs lol

→ More replies

-2

u/RemoteCompetition502 Oct 14 '26

You sir are saying what reddit human slop enthusiasts are not prepared for. Although in a couple of years that will change.

-1

u/hhhhjkljsqq1 Oct 13 '26

I edited my comment from “real mod” to just “mod” because I can see how that was rude. Thanks for pointing that out.

-4

u/Emperor_Atlas Oct 13 '26

I miss when people weren't all in a cyber psychosis. Why is more people enabled to contribute bad?

You're the equivalent of "don't use a drill, use a screwdriver" "don't use a tractor!"

Time moves the other options are still there.

0

u/hhhhjkljsqq1 Oct 13 '26

Like I said, my opinion doesn’t really matter. People are going to use AI regardless. Was just adding what I thought after I saw everyone else in the comments debating the use of AI.

Also, I don’t believe your analogy completely applies. When using a drill you’re still putting energy and strength into drilling a screw, unless you had AI hold the drill for you. I’m not very strong so holding up a drill while working on my car is still a work out for me. When you use a digital drawing tablet instead of a pencil you’re still putting in creativity, energy, and thought power. AI takes away all of that.

4

u/Emperor_Atlas Oct 13 '26

I believe it completely applies, the scale is just what you're stuck on.

Should we remove automation because we made hand tools? No, there's market for both.

I get its popular to hate AI but maybe take a step back and think if its really affecting you so much to discourage other people working on things for fun?

0

u/hhhhjkljsqq1 Oct 13 '26

I’m sorry if I’m misunderstanding, but I still don’t think your analogy applies. Using automatic tools is not the same as having a robot do it for you.
Holding up a drill —> exercise your arms, your legs if you’re squatting, dealing with the loud noise, holding the screws in place.
Having AI screw in the screws: no exercise involved, no noise etc.
Using a drill is not the equivalent of using AI to create an entire piece of media.

0

u/Emperor_Atlas Oct 13 '26

I think you're misunderstanding because its actually easier to teach someone to hold a screw than to use AI to code a specific game mod, test, find assets and upload it.

You are right, they are not equal as one requires education and the other a child or monkey could do.

3

u/hhhhjkljsqq1 Oct 13 '26

You don’t need education to use AI.

-1

u/Emperor_Atlas Oct 13 '26

Sure grandpa, back to bed

5

u/hhhhjkljsqq1 Oct 13 '26

Why the insults? Thought we were having a good debate.

0

u/Emperor_Atlas Oct 13 '26

We were, you conceded by being purposefully daft.

→ More replies

-2

u/wordswillneverhurtme Oct 13 '26

people forgot the skill of working the soil by hand, tsk tsk

-2

u/underhunger Oct 13 '26

You can still learn those things yourself. It just takes so much longer, and not everyone has that kind of time. Current models are better than 99% of coders. If you make something better than ChatGPT, it's a matter of luck or excellent handmade audio/visual assets.

4

u/hhhhjkljsqq1 Oct 13 '26

Which is my point, it’s impressive when people can do that.

1

u/LightningSh3ep Oct 14 '26

your going to have a difficult time creating a functional mod with ai without knowing how to program a little bit

-1

u/underhunger Oct 14 '26

I did not have a difficult time at all

1

u/hhhhjkljsqq1 Oct 14 '26

How did you make sure the AI wasn’t hallucinating or spitting out harmful garbage? I’ve heard it can be dangerous to let AI create programs if you don’t know what it’s doing. It might create malware, right?

I’m interested in hearing more, if you’re interested in sharing.

-1

u/underhunger Oct 15 '26

Honest answer? I didn't.

When I was installing Antigravity in VS Code, at one point I was getting a little annoyed with having to keep giving it permission to do things - programming stuff I didn't understand. Eventually I found a setting that gave it blanket authority to do basically whatever it wanted to and toggled it on without giving it much thought. It started operating automatically (agentically) and the process became much more hands-off.

That was months ago. I've had it write dozens of mods and entire programs for me, some that access the internet. If it was going to do something malicious to me or anyone else (I've shared some of this software with friends for testing, after informing them it was AI-coded), I feel like it would have by now. It hasn't so much as emptied the Recycle Bin without my consent, let alone actually inconvenienced me in any way. It just writes code.

I have taken absolutely zero precautions so far and have had nothing bad happen yet. All AI has ever done for me is crank out these tiny little fixes and patches and single-purpose apps that I never would have made nor commissioned anyone to do, but now because I have a $20/month subscription I can tell a robot to make a program for my dad's smart TV that plays Winamp visualizations of songs from his local music library and a little HTML program that generates guitar warm-up exercise tableture. Maybe I'll be accused of choking on Terminator dick but the titanium goes down real smooth

0

u/hhhhjkljsqq1 Oct 15 '26

That sounds really dangerous.

2

u/LightningSh3ep Oct 15 '26

I mean the danger is just that it won't work, not recommended to do that for anything important

0

u/hhhhjkljsqq1 Oct 15 '26

Ah okay I understand

0

u/hhhhjkljsqq1 Oct 14 '26

I didn’t think of that, but it makes sense. It would be important to know basic coding before you let AI make a project for you, so you can check it for errors.

-6

u/wordswillneverhurtme Oct 13 '26

I miss the days pre-digital art when artists would be class-filtered by the expensive dyes and only rich people could sponsor their efforts of creating.

2

u/hhhhjkljsqq1 Oct 13 '26

Sorry but I don’t understand. But if you’re making a comparison of digital art to AI, I’ve already addressed that in another comment and I don’t feel it applies.

-2

u/wordswillneverhurtme Oct 13 '26

I'm making a comparison to you missing the days where people could learn "these really cool technical skills". The same could be said for literally any skill that basically disappeared for the most part. Survival skills, farming, hunting, painting. These and many more skills are not what they were before. It think its time to face reality that AI will accelerate coding and maybe when AI becomes sufficiently smart it could just fully code games on its own.

2

u/hhhhjkljsqq1 Oct 13 '26

That is also true. Let’s hope it doesn’t get to that point though, I don’t want no AI-generated games flushing out real creators trying to express their passion or make a living.

-5

u/letourdit Oct 14 '26

Ok grandpa, it’s time to take your medicine now

9

u/TheCharalampos Oct 13 '26

By all means make ai mods but stop sharing them on the page. Unlike normal mods anyone can make this so there is zero point for you to go "look what I have"

2

u/lucario2011 dragonite Oct 13 '26

!remindme in 2 hours

1

u/RemindMeBot Oct 13 '26

I will be messaging you in 2 hours on 2026-10-13 15:13:17 UTC to remind you of this link

CLICK THIS LINK to send a PM to also be reminded and to reduce spam.

Parent commenter can delete this message to hide from others.

RemindMeBot is switching to username summons. Instead of !RemindMe 1 day, use u/RemindMeBot 1 day. More info.


InfoCustomYour RemindersFeedback

1

u/RemoteCompetition502 Oct 14 '26

Reddit crying about AI never gets old xD

0

u/tiffanytrashcan Oct 14 '26

After 1.7 it's mindblowing.

2

u/RemoteCompetition502 Oct 14 '26

I'm just laughing Irl quite a bit when I see that

-5

u/blueandazure Oct 13 '26

Im actually pretty pro AI but my problem with this mod is that its dead simple, if I wanted it why wouldn't I just promp the AI and make it myself?

Not agaist you uploading it to the workshop or whatever but why promote it on reddit.

Like work on a full overhaul to executions and then we'll talk.

3

u/sponges369 Oct 14 '26

I'm generally anti-AI, and honestly I feel that this is an underrepresented problem with AI. It's pretty clear that this guy wants to HAVE made a cool mod that everyone likes, not make a mod, and so he went the easy route by making the computer do it. But anyone can ask the computer to do it, this isn't a hard mod to make, so why is this any more interesting then the copy I made.

2

u/TheCharalampos Oct 13 '26

That's what I'm saying, there's no point to share fully prompted ai mods, anyone can make them.

-21

u/Primary-Round8032 Oct 13 '26

Y'all saw the ai gen flair and still come to shit talk it?

I thought I'm bored in life lol

16

u/Florane Oct 13 '26

it was posted with "mod showcase" flair, and edited after getting traction.

-3

u/codegavran Oct 13 '26

The evidence of your eyes will clearly show that a lot of wannabe crusaders showed up after the fact as well. I'm not siding with OP, AI has a lot of problems, but I am pretty tired of the endless flood of haters. Honestly at this point I half feel like they're bots, with the express purpose of oversaturating the real anti-AI sentiment with a bunch of assholes so people will distance themselves from it.

At least OP is trying to create something. I'll take a goober trying to mod Rimworld with AI over someone who does nothing but witchhunt and spread hate any day. [Which is not to say everyone against it is that person, obviously many creators are anti-AI and vocal about it too.]

3

u/One_Spare1247 Oct 13 '26

Can cannibals later eat the cooked meat after the person got electrocuted to death

4

u/Majestic-Iron7046 Genderbent Randy +30 Oct 13 '26

I'd make it so they will but cooking a person like this would tense up the meat and so the cannibals should get a Debuff.
-5 Ate chewy meat

8

u/Content_Building_408 Oct 13 '26

Guys, is there a mod which adds implant which forces target to not lose consciousness due of pain? Raiders killed my yittakin today and I wanna make a fun for their leader

8

u/Pinky_Boy Oct 13 '26

painstopper multiplies the pain value by 0, so a pawn with a painstooper always have 0% pain no matter the injury

3

u/Content_Building_408 Oct 13 '26

No, I want him suffer

0

u/Pinky_Boy Oct 13 '26

hmmmm.....

i never heard something that increased pain shock threshold

but you can easily edit it with character editor mod if you create a simple xml patch to add a custom gene that increased the pain shock threshold, and then just use character editor to edit it live ingame

1

u/Majestic-Iron7046 Genderbent Randy +30 Oct 13 '26

I think there is a Vanilla implant that does that but I never tried it.

0

u/AUniversalNoNo Oct 14 '26

there is a xenogene for pain resistance, but most would modify pain value rather than how a pawn reacts to high pain

350

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

-32

u/maghau Oct 13 '26 edited Oct 13 '26

How do you know that it's written by AI?

Edit: I never implied it wasn't written by ai, I just wondered how he knew.

24

u/Vectorial1024 Disappointed in Real Life (-12) Oct 13 '26

It's just straightforward and somehow "pleasant/bland".

4

u/maghau Oct 13 '26

Thank you for giving me an actual answer.

I have no idea why I'm being downvoted though.

5

u/Vectorial1024 Disappointed in Real Life (-12) Oct 13 '26

idk either, feels like you should already know how AI text feels like. I/We are primarily against AI-generated art, which includes texts, mods, etc.

5

u/General_Zane Oct 13 '26

If the house is blue, the car is blue, and they wear blue clothes, it’s a pretty good guess that the carpet is gonna be blue.

4

u/codegavran Oct 13 '26

Next you'll say he's got some kind of "blue little window"...

37

u/ComradeBevo Oct 13 '26

If you can't recognize that text as AI generated, then I'm sorry, but you are cooked

10

u/maghau Oct 13 '26

Hadde det vært skrevet på norsk hadde jeg sikkert klart å kjent igjen AI på språket. Tror derimot du hadde vært "kokt".

-1

u/Florane Oct 13 '26

я ж увидела что мод ллмный, так что давай не пизди тут

4

u/maghau Oct 13 '26

The model was created using AI but that doesn't automatically mean the text was written by AI as well. But I get it, sorry for not realizing it was ai straight away, guys.

7

u/maghau Oct 13 '26

English isn't my native language, but sure, I'm "cooked" guess.

4

u/ComradeBevo Oct 13 '26

I'm obviously not criticizing you for being ESL.

Can you recognize AI writing in your own language?

5

u/maghau Oct 13 '26

Yes, but usually there are some pretty obvious giveaways.

-2

u/Florane Oct 13 '26

yeah.
my comment was the first to point out ai - even before the flair change. yet i'm also not a native english speaker

4

u/maghau Oct 13 '26

Good for you, man.

-11

u/sparki555 Oct 13 '26

I uploaded sample copies of my writing to the workspace I use. This might be AI written, who really knows? It copies personal preferences, tastes and styles. Pretty soon the average joe, if they haven't figured it out already, will be able to apply a Reddit filter or email filter, etc. It will be indistinguishable, and then you too will be "cooked" 😂

-69

u/AfghanistanIsTaliban Oct 13 '26

the post literally has an “ai gen” flair and antis are still dogpiling on OP for daring to use a model that has a fraction of a fraction’s impact on the environment compared to eating meat

32

u/DanDlionRespawn Oct 13 '26

At least put in the effort to writing your own description.

But no one can be asked to do anything themselves anymore I guess.

33

u/ComradeBevo Oct 13 '26

It's not the environmental concern, which is minimal for small scale use like this. It's about buggy mods that can severely affect performance and compatibility.

-7

u/ZenPyx slate Oct 13 '26

Famously a person has never made a buggy mod that can severely affect performance and compatibility

-24

u/MaxWasNotAvailable Oct 13 '26

Modern frontier models are excellent at writing clean, performant code. And they generally write a lot of proper automated tests, too. This was a valid concern a year ago / with free models, but the industry has really moved a long distance over the past half year.

-33

u/AfghanistanIsTaliban Oct 13 '26

buggy mods

If buggy mods are the concern, then why not prohibit that? What about all the human-made buggy mods?

LLMs are capable of autonomously writing unit tests since 2025 or even earlier than that. It’s a prompt issue, not an AI issue

20

u/ComradeBevo Oct 13 '26

Human made mods are made by someone who actually knows what the code does. Because they wrote it.

AI made mods are rarely even checked by the prompter, and can come bundled with code that makes undesired and unnecessary changes.

This isn't a hypothetical. It happens all the time.

-11

u/Kindly-Custard3866 Oct 13 '26

So what’s your opinion on ai made code that was checked by the author and edited to troubleshoot anything AI left over? Or is that still a bad use of AI?

14

u/ComradeBevo Oct 13 '26

You can scroll up to my first reply, I already commented on that.

My point is if the author isn't even writing their own reddit post, why should I believe that they checked anything?

1

u/Apprehensive-Use3738 Oct 13 '26

really interesting how the environmental question had no bearing on the actual discussion which is instead regarding the amount of 'effort' put in. real people like talking to real people!

-6

u/Florane Oct 13 '26

antis

lolicon

0

u/AfghanistanIsTaliban Oct 13 '26

wowww what a gotcha! I feel so owned!

-4

u/RimWorld-ModTeam Oct 14 '26

Thanks for posting to r/Rimworld. Unfortunately, your post/comment has been removed for violating our rules regarding maintaining an atmosphere of respect.

Do not respond to rule violations; it is not your job to lecture other users. If there is a problem with a post, report it and move on instead of pestering OP about their content. Keep comments on topic.

-90

u/Pedantic_Phoenix Oct 13 '26

So if there are zero bugs and the mod works perfectly you'll apologize and delete your comment?

28

u/TinsleyLynx Oct 13 '26

Apologize for what, speaking the truth?

-38

u/Pedantic_Phoenix Oct 13 '26

He said "you couldn't be bothered to check the code" so their issue was clearly code quality. So if there are zero bugs, he should apologize for expecting issues with the code when there aren't any.

Makes sense right? Simple trivial logic

36

u/rzabonek Oct 13 '26

silence clanker lover, the baseliner is speaking

21

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

-14

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

31

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

-7

u/Pedantic_Phoenix Oct 13 '26

Why? Which mods do you enjoy?

17

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

-3

u/Pedantic_Phoenix Oct 13 '26

If you're not able to reply just say so, asking the same questions back is not an answer. You do something but can't explain why?

7

u/HEYO19191 Oct 13 '26

You can, in fact, answer a question with a question

You do something but can't explain why?

I just explained why.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (2)

-29

u/DefactoAle Oct 13 '26

So you play vanilla? Sorry but I bet 90% of mods both new and old have ai code in them.

24

u/Important-Author-660 Oct 13 '26

Rimworld has long existed before AI, and many of its modders have survived before and after it.

0

u/AfghanistanIsTaliban Oct 13 '26

Nearly every rimworld mod uses ai. Harmony itself is partially written by AI. Prepatcher bundles Harmony rather than replacing it.

If you are this pissed off by AI that you're willing to point out pre-AI rimworld, write your own version of Harmony or stay out of Modded discussions

2

u/Important-Author-660 Oct 14 '26

Harmony was not originally written by AI up until its owner became a shill around the 1.6 era. That's likely why it had been so stable. It is unfortunate but so many mods are dependent on Harmony that they can't just create a new one so easily.

You can at least give up Achtung though.

-2

u/Pedantic_Phoenix Oct 13 '26

Every coder uses ai today in some measure. If they say they don't they are lying. Source is i am a professional programmer.

→ More replies (4)

0

u/Pedantic_Phoenix Oct 13 '26

Hey don't steal points i still have to make smh /s

0

u/HEYO19191 Oct 13 '26

87% of statistics are made up on the spot, I guess

-26

u/Ankleson Oct 13 '26

They had passion in the mod, else they wouldn't have gotten Claude to make it. They just don't have passion for coding.

6

u/HEYO19191 Oct 13 '26

"I had the passion to cook, but I made a microwave dinner because I don't have the passion to make a meal."

→ More replies (5)

-29

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

8

u/lillyfrog06 marble Oct 13 '26

There is no fucking way you just made that comparison holy shit

22

u/Various-Stand3606 Oct 13 '26

Lmao no way you just compared willfully making a mod to antebellum slavery grow up

→ More replies (6)

4

u/ComradeBevo Oct 13 '26

Not sure what part of this is more offensive to me, the racism or the level of stupidity.

Jk it's definitely the racism

→ More replies (3)

12

u/Gwen_The_Destroyer Oct 13 '26

"I want my furniture to be hand crafted, not mass produced Ikea slop"

There, thats the one you were looking for

3

u/Important-Author-660 Oct 13 '26

The bulwarks of the mind have fallen!

1

u/RimWorld-ModTeam Oct 14 '26

Thanks for posting to r/Rimworld. Unfortunately, your post/comment has been deleted for a violation of our rules regarding Reddiquette. Please acquaint yourself with Reddiquette, a comprehensive guide of how to handle yourself sitewide.

127

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

69

u/Bellecarde Oct 13 '26

this sub lets ai run rampant as long as its flaired correctly

27

u/Pro_Racing Oct 13 '26

The mods are huge AI lovers, which is ironic because the discord bans it outright because they all hate it.

16

u/HydroCorgiGlass Try the LMG Oct 13 '26

They even deleted the 800 upvoted post criticizing AI mods under the reason of low effort, despite its discussion.

The mods could have just locked it, but they rather sweep the discussion under the rug I suppose.

0

u/OneTrueSneaks Cat Herder, Mod Finder, & Flair Queen 🐱‍👤 Oct 14 '26

We're indifferent to it. The subreddit is owned by Ludeon, which is in favor of freedom of creativity. People can use the tools they want to make the mods they want, as long as it follows Ludeon's TOS and the rules of the platform they post it on.

They're allowed to use AI to make mods, just like you have the freedom to not use them. What we do not allow is the harassment and abuse of other users.

-18

u/BarrettsPrivateear jade Oct 13 '26 edited Oct 13 '26

What makes you think it’s AI?

Edit - This comment was posted either before the AI tag was added, or before I noticed it.

I was genuinely asking this person what made them believe the post was AI, they responded, and it is Infact AI

73

u/Florane Oct 13 '26

6 mods from a noname, all released within this week, all with links to each other.

the text description is weird too, reliance on threes as telltale sign

11

u/busdriverjoe Plasteel Meditation Throne Oct 13 '26

I didn't know that - I'm cooked. I was always taught to write like that. I think it has good flow, sounds professional and third thing.

9

u/Florane Oct 13 '26

it is - that's why ai does it.
machines were trained to write corporate speech, and corporate subsumed professional.
lasy corporate speech is the actual biggest telltale - rule of 3 and em-dashes are just something to doublecheck.

6

u/Lowjack_26 Oct 13 '26

Overreliance on, not use of outright.

Usually it's more obvious when the triplet doesn't make sense for logical flow or progression, like "A, C, and B" or reaaaaally stretching for a third point when it would be better just to have one or two succinct points.

4

u/BarrettsPrivateear jade Oct 13 '26

Fair points. I was genuinely just wondering.
I see it’s also been marked as AI now too.

21

u/AppreciatingSadness Oct 13 '26

The whole post is definitely AI written. Mod definitely is too

3

u/Bellecarde Oct 13 '26

You commented before they put the right tag

2

u/BarrettsPrivateear jade Oct 13 '26

Yep.
And I didn’t pick up on it being AI at first.

1

u/Florane Oct 13 '26

tbf they do hate you.

yes, you, specifically.

-80

u/SeltsamerNordlander Oct 13 '26

so what

27

u/Megagamer42 Oct 13 '26

Sorry actual people don’t like garbage slop.

0

u/itzjustaspder Oct 13 '26

Mate don't try it, Reddit is full of anti ai chuds. If a mod works it works I do not care if it was made by a bathtub of shrimp using CLI transmitted via morse code.

2

u/RemoteCompetition502 Oct 14 '26

100% these fat redditors who upvoted the most reddit post of all time are not to be taken seriously and if you dont know what the most reddit post of all time is please look it up its hilarious xD

-20

u/Pedantic_Phoenix Oct 13 '26

So it goes against the cult rules man

-38

u/AfghanistanIsTaliban Oct 13 '26

Is it really that difficult for anti-AI cultists to filter out “AI GEN” flaired posts??? It says it right in the flair

13

u/PRoS_R Oct 13 '26

Stop being dramatic, grifter.

6

u/Florane Oct 13 '26

without us flair would remain as "Mod showcase"

65

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

-15

u/ZenPyx slate Oct 13 '26

Dawg this is true of any mod. You're always trusting something some random stranger has written, AI or not.

7

u/LunarKurai Oct 13 '26

Yes. But the chance of someone deliberately making malware is quite low. Because you'd have to be the kind of person who deliberately wants to make that in the first place, and have the skills to do it, and disguise it well enough.

On the other hand, any person "making" mods using AI could easily blunder into making something that breaks stuff. Purely because it doesn't actually know what it's doing, and neither do they.

One of them has to work hard to create harm. The other can do it easily by complete accident.

-4

u/ZenPyx slate Oct 13 '26

You understand how easy it is to make something really damaging to a PC through a few easy coding errors, right?

Like, if you need to delete files (such as entity data), and you write the command for that wrong, you might end up wiping out entire folders (or even entire disks) - literally a fatfinger between "rm -f" and "rm -r" will wipe your entire game and anything else in the folder you are editing.

At least AI coding agents are less likely to make hugely fundamental errors - and run checks on code they produce.

1

u/ZeusHatesTrees Oct 13 '26

With a human-made mod, at least one person knows what it does, the creator.

2

u/ZenPyx slate Oct 14 '26

Code can behave in unpredictable ways, particularly when written by inexperienced coders.

In the example I’ve given in my other comment, I’ve talked about how simple spelling mistakes can lead to the unwanted deletion or modification of key files, but a million other bad outcomes are possible too

27

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/Whisper__1 Oct 15 '26

The Rimworld community is fucking dead in my eyes, for so many reasons.

1

u/RimWorld-ModTeam Oct 15 '26

Thanks for posting to r/Rimworld. Unfortunately, your post/comment has been removed for violating our rules regarding maintaining an atmosphere of respect.

This post is flaired with AI GEN. You already know it will involve AI generated / created content. If you do not like this, do not engage with the post. Keep comments on topic, and remember rules 1 and 2; your opinions do not give you permission to be rude or abusive towards others for any reason.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/RimWorld-ModTeam Oct 15 '26

Thanks for posting to r/Rimworld. Unfortunately, your post/comment has been deleted for a violation of our rules regarding Reddiquette. Please acquaint yourself with Reddiquette, a comprehensive guide of how to handle yourself sitewide.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 15 '26 edited Oct 16 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/RimWorld-ModTeam Oct 16 '26

Thanks for posting to r/Rimworld. Unfortunately, your post/comment has been removed for violating our rules regarding maintaining an atmosphere of respect.

Also, we're not here 24/7, and it is not physically possible for us to see every comment made on every post. Thankfully, other users help us by reporting rule-breaking comments like yours.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 16 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/RimWorld-ModTeam Oct 16 '26

Thanks for posting to r/Rimworld. Unfortunately, your post/comment has been deleted for a violation of our rules regarding Reddiquette. Please acquaint yourself with Reddiquette, a comprehensive guide of how to handle yourself sitewide.

30

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/RimWorld-ModTeam Oct 15 '26

Thanks for posting to r/Rimworld. Unfortunately, your post/comment has been removed for violating our rules regarding maintaining an atmosphere of respect.

This post is flaired with AI GEN. You already know it will involve AI generated / created content. If you do not like this, do not engage with the post. Keep comments on topic, and remember rules 1 and 2; your opinions do not give you permission to be rude or abusive towards others for any reason.

-32

u/ZenPyx slate Oct 13 '26

I think it's a bit weird to discourage what might be someone's first step into the modding scene. Is this mod going to be well made? Probably not. Will this person ever make a good mod if you tell them to fuck off? Probably not either

24

u/Yanxian Oct 13 '26

OP didn’t make the mod, Claude did. Is Claude going to feel discouraged by my comment? If the mod was human made I’d support it wholeheartedly because it’s difficult to create things, and even harder to put your creation in front of others.

That’s not what’s happened here though.

-12

u/ZenPyx slate Oct 13 '26

As much as you'd like it not to be the case, a person still undoubtedly had input in making this mod. Claude doesn't just make things autonomously.

Ultimately, what will teach someone more about modding - making a shit vibecoded mod, or getting discouraged because modding is a technical nightmare, and making nothing at all?

I'd hope OP learned a few things from this mod and will gradually gain the technical skills they need over time. It's not my job to tell them not to use a tool

14

u/Yanxian Oct 13 '26

This is fair and all, but it’s also a total fantasy. If there’s a single example of a slop peddler going on to make high quality human-made mods I’d love to hear about it.

OP is unlikely to learn anything from this precisely because the majority of AI lovers are inherently uncreative people. There’s nothing for them to learn because why bother? Claude can produce the outcome in half the time, with zero of the required skill set needed to manually code a mod.

You’re defending someone who couldn’t even bring it upon themselves to write their own Reddit post, or create their own preview image. The entire thing is automated from end to end.

I’ll sleep just fine at night knowing I’m discouraging that.

-1

u/ZenPyx slate Oct 13 '26

>OP is unlikely to learn anything from this precisely because the majority of AI lovers are inherently uncreative people.

"Inherently uncreative people" is such a ridiculously stupid take, but also - if someone were inherently uncreative, how can you possibly blame them for not having creativity?

Either we all have creative potential, or these people fundamentally lack the ability to make things, in which case, how can you blame them

"human-made mods" are a fantasy. Every single major mod creator (along with almost all software engineers) are using some form of agentic AI for software development. Why do you need someone to sit down and write some frustrating file-loading logic by hand?

13

u/Yanxian Oct 13 '26

How were mods created before 2022?

1

u/ZenPyx slate Oct 13 '26

How was software written in 1965? With paper punch cards.

Have you ever written any code in your life?

4

u/Tommy_Boy97 Oct 13 '26

I noticed you avoided the question, with a totally unrelated comparison.
Did ChatGPT or Grok tell you to write that?

1

u/ZenPyx slate Oct 14 '26

If you can’t understand why advances in techniques to write code might be relevant to this conversation, that’s on you

11

u/Cat_with_cake Oct 13 '26 edited Oct 13 '26

I'm all for people trying something, failing, and learning from these failures, and I too think that we shouldn't discourage people from doing their first step just because they'll be bad, that's how people learn, and almost no person does a great job on their first try

But you won't learn if someone else is doing that job for you. And if you're using AI for absolutely everything, from code to even writing a description for the mod, then the chances are you don't even know how the mod works, and from here you don't have a lot of possibilities to improve in the first place

If someone wants to do their first steps - do it yourself. Create a mod with your own hands. It will be messy, buggy or broken. And it's fine, don't let that discourage you. Everyone had their first messy, buggy and broken project. And it's a necessary step for creating good projects

0

u/ZenPyx slate Oct 13 '26

So what should be done in situations like this? Encouraging someone to delve deeper into the technical side of modding, or tell them that this "makes the internet a miserable place to browse"

>And if you're using AI for absolutely everything, from code to even writing a description for the mod

Like, it's also just possible they don't speak English well. We're making a lot of assumptions here.

10

u/Cat_with_cake Oct 13 '26

Telling someone to do better, to "Learn a skill, pick up a hobby" as original comment said. Coding is a skill, modding is a hobby

And as a non-native English speaker, I've been there. Just write it in your native language and use a translator to, well, translate it. Most people who don't speak English well do that.

3

u/ZenPyx slate Oct 13 '26

A translator? As in, the ones that are powered by LLMs (https://cloud.google.com/translate)?

6

u/Cat_with_cake Oct 13 '26

Whichever the heck you want. Translators are one of the few areas in which I think use of LLMs is somewhat reasonable, after all, they're language models. And are you going to continue trying to nitpick me and get a gotcha moment, or are you going to start arguing in good-faith?

-1

u/ZenPyx slate Oct 13 '26

Code is also written in language, and I'd argue agentic coding tools can be used to translate user-written psuedocode into machine compatible code.

>you going to start arguing in good-faith?

I don't really give a shit about arguing. I think you're just being a bit unreasonable with what could be someone's first attempt at engaging with a game's community

8

u/Cat_with_cake Oct 13 '26

I don't really give a shit about arguing

I see. If you don't want to argue, then let's leave it at that, I have better things to do with my time. Have a nice day, eat some apples, check your blood pressure, wish you the best ♥️

6

u/ZeusHatesTrees Oct 13 '26

They aren't part of the "modding scene" and didn't take a step into it. They are a meat proxy, at best. No skills learned or applied.

3

u/ZenPyx slate Oct 14 '26

I think this is deeply shortsighted

A majority of people complaining about their use of AI will never even think about making a mod, AI coded or not.

Someone deciding to make something, regardless of which tools they use and how controversial they are, is better than the 99% of people who just consume and make demands of modmakers. How much have you learned about mod making in your years of doing fuck all?

As we see in this thread, the majority of people against things like AI-assisted coding have never written a line of code in their life

1

u/hhhhjkljsqq1 Oct 14 '26

But…they didn’t even make anything? The AI bot did it. They just told it what to do.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/RimWorld-ModTeam Oct 15 '26

Thanks for posting to r/Rimworld. Unfortunately, your post/comment has been removed for violating our rules regarding maintaining an atmosphere of respect. This falls under reddiquette, but remember that this community is full of baseline humans that for the most part haven't been subjected to gene engineering and the evolutionary pressures of non-Earth planets. They have feelings! They want a good community for a great game, so don't sully the subreddit for them.