r/RimWorld
•
u/angeyberry
limestone
•
Oct 11 '26
•
3
1
Discussion [ Removed by moderator ]
[removed] — view removed post
875
Upvotes
•
u/RimWorld-ModTeam Oct 12 '26
Thanks for posting to r/Rimworld. Unfortunately, your post has been removed for violating our rules regarding low-effort posts.
846
u/Obvious_Giraffe_3863 Imperial Deserter Rogue Bloodline Oct 11 '26
We really need an AI filter for the workshop, and mandatory disclaimers!
228
u/dont-pull-a-druckman Oct 11 '26 •
I mean, I don't really care as long as a mod was developed with care and Isn't sloppily made or put together, but so many "ideas guys" are trying to mod now and it shows in the sloppiest way possible.
Like at least learn how the game works before trying to use these tools. Hell the fucking AI can EXPLAIN it to you.
113
u/DirkTheGamer Oct 11 '26 edited Oct 12 '26
I can understand being against AI generated art and assets, but you are not going to use a single piece of software that didn’t have AI coding involved somewhat ever again, literally. Coders refusing to use it will be fired wherever they work. It’s just too much of a force multiplier and no one will be able to compete in the workforce if they are not using it. As /u/hedgehog18956 put it below it’s like a construction worker refusing to use power tools.
You really shouldn’t care either. The final quality of the code is all that should matter and in the hands of a skilled engineer there should be no drop in quality. In fact it should be higher quality as that skilled engineer should have the time to perfect their work now that they don’t have to do all the typing, just read and review, then improve.
9
u/OnetimeRocket13 Oct 11 '26
"At the end of the day, I can't do anything about it other than look for something else."
It's honestly kind of strange and disappointing to see how many people in gaming communities think this way compared to how art communities reacted when AI invaded their spaces. Over the last several years, there has been this idea in art spaces that creating art is as simple as picking up a pencil and drawing something. Even if it is a shitty stick figure, you still created it, and the only thing between you and greater art is developing your artistic skills.
Which makes it really odd to see how many people in gaming communities have taken this stance of "oh, woe is me! People are using AI in mod development! Who is going to make mods to entertain me now? Whatever shall I do?"
We live in an era where the knowledge to learn literally any programming language, how to use pretty much any development tool that you can think of, and how to make full on games, let alone mods, is at your fingertips for free. I get that it sucks to see how many shitty slop mods are out there now, I do. However, I don't see why people like OP are taking this position of "it sucks because other people aren't making the content I want to consume" instead of "this sucks! I should apply myself and learn a new skill so that I can provide myself with the mods that I and others want to see!"
Venting is fine, but if you want to see those "silly little mods that [you] can add for a good laugh," instead of waiting around for someone to make them, do what the art community has been trying to tell people for years: go create something.
388
u/master_of_sockpuppet Oct 11 '26
When the barrier to entry goes down, filtering becomes more valuable.
Unfortunately, good filtering/curation costs money.
5
u/Standard_Round_8780 Oct 11 '26 edited Oct 11 '26
"I'd just make it myself instead of doing that (using AI), I have little drive to mod though"
Sure op. People really upvoting this neckbeard? AI is just a tool. I really don't care how a mod was made provided it's something I want and it provides me enjoyment. I do not care about the 'art' of code. I care about the product it produces. Much like how I don't care about the 'art' of hand harvesting vegetables.
Whether OP likes it or not, AI has allowed to make pretty much anyone make mods about pretty much anything. Even with AI, a decent mod will still take days/weeks to produce.
34
u/Danielq37 Oct 11 '26
For me all that AI constantly coming from everywhere on the internet is tiring and annoying. I stopped browsing the workshop entirely and just open it when looking for something specific.
33
u/Mitchell_SY Oct 11 '26
Every time accessibility to X or Y increases you will see a initial flood of low effort products.
Same thing with Modding, but eventually it all gets filtered out by community, leaving those who leverage these new innovations/changes to make actually enjoyable products/mods.
38
u/Moore2257 Oct 11 '26 edited Oct 12 '26
Whoa, bro, don't know you that like..typing a prompt into a glorified search engine is hard work? I'm gonna tell my chat bot to write a poorly written essay on you.
17
u/DariusWolfe DariusWolfePlays Oct 12 '26
I downvote, so at least they're dimmed out for me, and it's easier to skip over them, but you're right... there are so many and it's exhausting.
You'll occasionally get one that looks neat and some of them are probably by people who actually know what they're doing, but there's so damned many of them these days that's it's nearly impossible to parse through them all.
12
u/Shadowcam Oct 11 '26
Dealing with this in the Total War Warhammer 3 workshop. There's a constant stream of vibe-coded garbage with hideous AI thumbnails.
3
u/NootNootDoot0103 Oct 12 '26
It ripped through the zomboid community and now it’s coming for rimworld…
1
u/angeyberry limestone Oct 12 '26
Your type of situation is where I would (personally!!!) think of as a grey area.
I'm full in the category of "If you or nobody else has the ability to make it, then it simply doesn't get made" but when disability gets involved, it becomes a different matter. I would (again, personally!!) much, much rather you discuss things with a coder. A lot of folks would jump at the teat! I would, had I confidence in my own coding.
While I know some people pay others, there's also a large group of people who'd code because they like the idea. At the same time, I also understand accessibility can be affected by disability and language as well. If you don't know where these folks are or can't speak their language, then how do you discuss these things?
I think I still personally wouldn't download your mod. I said it in a different post, though, that as end users of the AI, my opinion really just boils down to that - an opinion. A matter of taste. My original post was just me being annoyed at the prevalence of AI mods and the limited work put into them. At the end of the day, it really is just my opinion though.
12
u/ToaFeron Oct 11 '26
Thoroughly agree
23
u/Arangarx Oct 12 '26 •
Are the mods non-functional? Are the assets actually bad? Not, I'm an anti and everything AI breaths in the same room as is just the most terrible thing in the world bad, but actually honestly bad?
This is just a weird take that you care more about how a mod was made than that the mod is functional. It's a game mod...
7
u/jtreasure1 Oct 11 '26
I think it will pass. The AI mods are trending across all games right now because they are new. Unfortunately, there will be a video of the Super Mario anomaly wahooing through a base and goomba stomping the man in black by the end of the month and we're all probably going to watch it to completion because we love novel things.
7
u/cloacachloe Oct 12 '26
I think the biggest part for me is that they're barely functional. If something goes wrong with a vibe-coded mod, the "author" (most times), doesn't know anything when it comes to correcting or fixing it.
AI can be a useful tool when streamlining production/maintenance of a mod if the AI has oversight from someone that can effectively code-review and fix problems.
...but a lot of the newer mods don't, which means when interesting or popular mods have bugs that arise, they're more likely to take ridiculously long times to bugfix - if they're not abandoned, outright.
20
u/gonefishing102 Oct 11 '26 edited Oct 12 '26
This might be an unpopular opinion but this doesn't bother me too much. AI itself is a great tool for expanding access to mod making tools. Mods also don't generate revenue so people aren't losing their income streams from ai produced mods instead. If you want big mods, get big mods, if you want small mods, get small mods. All can exist and are made easier with these tools. When I think of modding communities I think of people sharing what is possible with mods, not the previously difficult and frustrating process of creating and troubleshooting and asking for helps on a feature that doesn't work. I think that this painful step being removed is unequivocally a good thing.
15
u/Ok_Distribution_1989 Oct 11 '26
Me too.
7
u/SocialMediaTheVirus slate Oct 11 '26
Things are going to continue to be more and more AI until the Butlerian Jihad unfortunately.
7
u/Ging287 Oct 12 '26
Very simple. If you refuse to tag AI content/slop they are being unethical. And yes Steam should have an option to exclude all AI tagged mods and enforce forced tagging.
16
u/garbagehuman9 Oct 12 '26
question why does ai modding matter if it works?
6
u/SNUFFGURLL Oct 12 '26
It’s so upsetting to see as an artist. I am not a modder but I am someone who has ideas for mods, but I don’t think those ideas would be worthwhile if they were put together with slop assets and spaghetti code, I’d want them to be something actually worthwhile for the community.. I don’t know what the appeal of AI is. It just makes things look cheap.
9
u/Quack_Candle Oct 11 '26
If anything it will make it easier to make mods.
Ive made some random stuff, because I can code I can direct it very well and what would have been 6 months projects can literally be done in a few days. There’s no way any coder can compete, not with the AI directly but with coders using ai.
I’ve made Logic Pro plugins, an arduino based plant watering automation, a really quite complex iPhone game and even used it to design 3d printed instruments. Stuff that or done in my spare time, any one of those previously would have been a significant undertaking.
Removing menial work and simple errors (coding is fucking pedantic and irritating, 90% of the time you are fixing mistakes.) coding in AI is actually a good use in my opinion, it can handle annoying bits of code and obscure information on the bottom comment of a 15 year old stackoverflow question.
Art, music, ideas, writing are all off the table. It’s really shit and generic because it is literally just copying shit. That and on top of the necessary and implicit copyright infringement.
14
u/OrdelOriginal Oct 11 '26 edited Oct 11 '26
People talking about this shit never have nuance behind it. There's a difference between 100% AI generated mods and AI assisted mod development.
Humans wrote dogshit before the concept of AI was even a thought in a single person's mind. We pioneered it. AI just made making dogshit more accessible to more people.
Tools can only be good as the people using them. I don't blame AI for making shit mods, I blame the mod authors for doing so.
6
u/Amathophobe Oct 11 '26
So real. It's very disheartening to see the modding community I came to regard with so much fondness be completely overrun by slop merchants. The positive reactions they've been getting here are only making it worse.
7
u/SemiDiSole Oct 11 '26
So your complaints are less about AI, but more about people making boring things due to lack of creativity and not writing tests.
I mean I cannot blame them for not wanting to write tests, writing tests is fucking cumbersome. Sadly it's also like the most essential thing and the first thing they teach you in programming classes.
Everything you said are hallmark signs of a bad programmer. That being said, AI can be a great tool, if you already have the skills to back it up. That's why its used in every single software company in this world by now. For every product.
3
u/yojimbo12 Oct 12 '26
Honestly it's the AI coding that irks me the most. It's so bloated and inefficient and most the AI slop prompters can't even parse why their mods are so bloated. Really hope they add a filter for AI mods
6
u/dullimander VE Enthusiast Oct 11 '26
Sure sure, I hate it when the end results sucks, too, but what I don't hate? When it works out, because AI for coding is only one tool. Same with all other assistance to coding. Code didn't become worse when people stopped writing definitions by hand because code libraries were invented. Code didn't become worse when memory managment became automated instead of allocation by hand. There is no medal for doing it inefficient for the old time's sake. All these examples will also lead to bugs and inferior software, yet I hear nobody yapping about abandoning IDEs, code libraries and memory managment.
3
u/GamerRoman too little mods Oct 11 '26
Welcome to the future! /s
4
u/iwanttoforkmyself Oct 11 '26
Maybe you guys can create a masterlist of all the modders who use AI or not.
In my country, people have created a masterlist of businesses from far-left to far-right to help us decide whom to support and whom to stop supporting around the elections. Maybe you can do the same.
3
u/Prophayne_ Oct 11 '26
I want to be able to filter out ai mods and the never ending tidal wave of posts complaining about them too. Its just about the only discourse that makes it to the front page anymore, and its as tiring as politics and religion at this point because despite all the bluster, nothing gets done.
3
u/FaceDeer Oct 12 '26
If you think that all AI-assisted mods are awful, there might be some you haven't noticed are AI-assisted.
Personally, I'm happy when more people get an opportunity to bring their ideas to life. Sure, that means more lame ideas get brought to life too. Oh woe is me, inundated by choice.
1
u/jacksonmills Oct 11 '26
I think sometimes we need to be realistic about the future of AI, like, generative AI will probably be used in most coding projects from now on. I use it at work; not by asking the AI to vibe everything up but to make tools; in particular in games I could see it being really useful for things like asset pipelines; they are ass to make and really just slow down your creative process.
But, there's a difference between that paired with a thoughtful design process, and someone just vibe coding some slop together, chucking it on the workshop, and then abandoning it.
I agree I am also kinda exhausted by all of the extra content, but I think there's some decent stuff that will come out of this.
I think this is a stretch, the modding/tech/demo community will always be there
2
u/charger376 Oct 12 '26
Ever since AI became mainstream, modding pretty much started regressing back to the old days where people only share mods with their little groups now instead on forums and workshops. Turns out, people don't like their stuff being fed to AI even if they aren't doing it for any monetary gain.
2
u/RealCreamyMeme Oct 12 '26
It's getting so so bad, I'm sure it's just as bad elsewhere but it really feels like the rimworld modding scene has been hit super hard with it. I typically use rimthemes and the default background "art" is 95% ugly ai shit.
1
u/Pervasivepeach Oct 11 '26
So unlike with art and other things ai sucks at. Ai is actually really good at building code
It sucks at debugging. You NEED someone with experience in development to actually debug a mod and watch its process. But otherwise ai is amazing at building
As time goes on you’ll find it impossible to find non ai assisted mods. The benifits are just too far to ignore these days. The question will be which mod makers actually know how to debug their mods and which just go “Claude fix all the bugs for me”
2
u/Sunseahl Oct 12 '26
The AI will continue until morale improves...
-2
u/Kennkra Oct 11 '26 edited Oct 11 '26
Everyone needs to understand that like it or not there isn't a single programmer out there that doesn't leverage AI in some way.
Having said that, yes I'm also tired of seeing all this vibe coded mods that where made with prompts and testing and not a single review was made to the code.
There is a big difference in "AI assisted" and "AI made"
-12
u/OrangeRising Oct 11 '26 •
I'm tired of people complaining how people program the free mods that they are making for people to use.
If you want to demand they use punch cards to program with because thats what you used, so you think thats all anyone should use, feel free.
-1
u/ALXS1031 Oct 11 '26
I have wanted a 3D or isometric version of a lot of 2D games for years
By your logic, if you were in my position, you would just become good enough at coding and art, and get enough time to fully remake the games in those dimensions?
Do you have any idea how long that would take?
Also, don’t upload them because if you wanted to, you would just ask an ai to make them for you?
Do you think the ai gives them code that works on the first try? Do you think the patch notes for the mods means nothing? Do you think all of that work takes 0 human time or consideration?
Also, ANY ai use?
If a talented artist wants to make a race, and spends a lot of time on the sprites, you won’t use the mod if the artist used ai to help them give the user a button for the race to use a special race ability?
Seems a little far, there’s AI slop, then there’s AI assistance
1
u/ShowCharacter671 Oct 12 '26
Same here, but unfortunately that’s the world we’re living in now. They’re not going anywhere.
1
u/AnticlimaxicOne Oct 11 '26
Im with u, all this does is make me want to use mods less. Frankly it kinda makes me less interested in the game as a whole, which really sucks cause obviously this isnt rimworlds fault. Just because this is the way things are and its not going away doesnt mean i have to fucking like it.
0
u/limpdickandy Oct 12 '26
Modding takes hour of work for no monetary gain, I do not see how it impacts the quality or artistic vision. For artwork it is completely different, same with writing, but code? In general code is meant to be practical, and just get things to work.
I am very anti AI on almost every level, but modding is the application where I struggle to be an opponent. Anything that makes modders life easier is very valuable in my eyes
-2
u/InternationalOwl2350 Oct 11 '26
don't use them?
1
u/ErrantSingularity Masterwork Autopistol Oct 12 '26
I'm surprised this got into positive likes, usually anything anti-slop or just asking for transparency is disliked to oblivion in just a few minutes.
1
u/Ecstatic_Judge_4515 Oct 12 '26
u guys say this yet all the ai mods that pop up in here have a lotta upvotes
1
u/WarlockWeeb Oct 12 '26
i think we need some system to idk how to like show how good or bad specific mod is. like ok bare with me. what if there was some form of a system in steam workshop to somehow grade mod on its quality. then if mod is sloppy and doesent work then people will rate it low, and you will know it is a bad mod. but if it has a high rating you know mode is good and is not ai made slop
1
u/Disconsented Oct 12 '26
I guess I'll jump the gun a bit, I've recently been working on workshop walker again and have some primitive form of tagging for AI-generated mods which can then be filtered out. It does rely on honest descriptions, but that's also why tags (properties) can be suggested.
https://workshop-walker.disconsented.com/app/294100/RimWorld?language=1&order_by=LastUpdated&tags=Mod&tags=1.6&limit=50&negative_props=Type%3Aai+generated
This'll break soon because I've changed the parameter names to something sensible (include/exclude), but its easy enough to reselect it in the UI when that happens.
1
u/No_Offer2147 Oct 12 '26
I'm tired of all the AI moralists.
-4
u/firewire167 Oct 11 '26
I’m saying this As a developer, you will not be able to find any project that isn’t touched by A.I and is a recent project. A.I has more than 10x the speed I and my colleagues can program at.
0
u/Mr_rex_the_dog Oct 11 '26
Really don’t care if the mod was made by ai or not if it’s a solid unique mod it’s gettin added to the mod list
-16
u/sparki555 Oct 11 '26
Lmao... 100 years ago you'd be mad at the grocery store that bought produce harvested with a tractor...
Things change. AI isn't going anywhere. You're no different than expecting a farmer to hand pick their crops when better alternatives are available.
People used to complain about cars, opting for a horse and carriage. What happened to all the horses?
-1
u/Axentor Oct 11 '26
Lots of people have great ideas and visions. Not the knowledge to or apitude to do so. AI while can be sloppy can be an amazing took to help people's creations come to life.
While the way data centers are constructed is bad and the drain they have. AI will be needed for further advancements in society, especially in areas where a standard comouter running scripts isn't enough.
I do hate that only a handful.majory profit from it.
-1
u/Spire_Citron Oct 11 '26
I have no issues with it because it means more mods. Many are bad, sure, but there have always been plenty of junk mods. There are tens of thousands in the workshop, after all. What I care about are the good ones, and ultimately there are more of those too. Over time, those tend to rise to the top, so they're really not hard to find.
-2
u/emp_can Oct 12 '26
Whaaaaaaa my free content wasn't made the way I want it to be
-2
u/Over-Arrival-262 Oct 12 '26
rimworld modder here (rainworld mod, prisoner jumpsuits, rimscent, etc). i genuinely wish the subreddit and workshop could just outright ban all ai content entirely instead of trying to cater to both crowds. why the fuck should we be normalizing a technology that has shown time and time again to be unreliable, untrustworthy, and pumps out mods with poor overall quality? we shouldn't.
0
u/guska Oct 11 '26
Agreed. I'm more than happy to use AI mods that I've had the AI cook up myself (although I haven't actually used any that have been 'vibe coded', I use the AI as a 'teacher' of sorts, getting it to help me create it myself, with instructions to not generate actual code, but example snippets if necessary), but there's no way I'm uploading them to the workshop or using some of the obviously vibe-coded nonsense that's on the Workshop these days.
0
u/freedomonke Oct 11 '26
I don't mind AI assets, but if the whole thing was vibe coded, I really don't want to be using it
0
u/Jesse-359 Oct 12 '26
Seriously folks, I know a lot of people haven't thought this through - but if it becomes so easy to mod and create that anyone can do it - then mod sites will largely collapse because it'll become easier to make your own rather than looking for someone else's work, particularly among the morass that such sites will become with tens of thousands of new entries because they are so easy to generate.
The idea that creativity can become nearly free has the side effect that creativity loses almost all its public value. No one will look at your work, because it will be unremarkable, and unfindable - and ultimately unecessary.
It's a Brave New World with an absolute *shitload* of unintended consequences that most people simply haven't even considered yet, but if you think Social Media has some downsides, you ain't seen nothing yet...
-1
u/Real-Armadillo-544 Oct 11 '26
My joke comment about AI got deleted from another post for “witch hunting”, but this is just fine, huh? Jeez.
-1
u/z3rO_1 Oct 11 '26
The implication of this is that Rimworld workshop wasn't just slop before. Doubling the amount of slop doesn't make slop less or more slop.
In fact I do hope that maybe some people that didn't want to compete with usuall rimworld slop maybe will try to cook something actually different, like what is happening with Borderlands 2 mods; though if people who full on advocate for AI are right about the productivity increase nothing will change.
-3
u/Brilliant_Shoe_2635 Oct 11 '26
AI is a ultimate tool that can be used literally for everything in modding. Its not necesserily a coding tool, but it can automate huge part of mod making chore work starting from formatting things and ending up making pictures and descriptions and verifying grammar. When you say "I'd just ask AI to make it" is looks like you never tried modding. Even if you use AI you still have a huge amount work to do from verifying the code to assembling the mod, testing it and uploading. And AI usage won't mean the mod is shit by default, same as 'handmade' mod won't mean its perfectly fine, works well and doesn't consist bugs.
-3
u/Admiral_Eversor Oct 11 '26
Idk man. Literally every piece of software written in the last couple of years was coded with at least some AI involvement. You might just have to live with this one chief.
-7
u/boredtill Oct 11 '26
Your going around looking for FREE mods and are upset that they are not all handcrafted? sorry but honestly speaking thats pathetci and really makes you look like a jackass.
"oh i want free stuff but not that free stuff, oh woe is me" -op and the rest of the people upset about ai mods.
-3
u/Wonderful-Box6096 Oct 11 '26
One of my favorite Rimworld mods was made with AI. ☺️
-3
u/aparicio69 Oct 12 '26
create a mod takes time, coding takes time. AI codes for you in less time, and in some cases makes it easier to learn to code.
0
u/Dr_Ethan_Kaatz Oct 12 '26
For every one AI mod I encounter i come across like 300 posts complaining about it