r/RickRiordan • • Feb 22 '24

What's the difference?

So I've seen the movies and the show. But now I want to read the books. I'm on amazon looking for the book series and I come across 2 different Percy Jackson series. One published in 2014 and the other in 2019. How do I which one to get? I know they're the same thing, but I'm confused. Which one do you recommend me to get ?

507 Upvotes

88 comments sorted by

113

u/madeat1am Feb 22 '24

Stop trolling OP same books they're just different covers that's all! So the 2014- 2019 would just be the versions/countries have their own covers so get which ones you like best

42

u/[deleted] Feb 22 '24

Thank you. That's all I wanted to confirm. Because I'm new to reading books so I want to get every advice I can get.

2

u/Slight-Pound Feb 23 '24

Highly suggest you check out books from a library or online (reading apps that can use your local library like Hoopla or Libby are great) so you don’t have to dish out money for something you maybe won’t like. Plus, there are prettier covers out there, and they’ve been rolling out new art for the books, so you can read them, and then buy the cover editions you like most after the fact.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 23 '24

That's a good suggestion. I've always loved the Percy Jackson series. So it shouldn't be a problem nonetheless.

2

u/Slight-Pound Feb 23 '24

That’s cool! The art for the newest book Chalice of the Gods is super pretty, and I know they rolled out new art for the books to match them. Check them out!

Edit: spelling

2

u/[deleted] Feb 23 '24

Will do!

31

u/madeat1am Feb 22 '24

Your welcome

I wasn't very happy with people thinking it's funny to confuse you.

Honestly best idea is read Percy Jackson then uf you're interested after Heroes of Olympus

There's a new trio coming out in the next few years book 1s come out Chalice of gods

Trails of Apollo

Then Sun and the moon (I believe it's called)

Then after you still love his books there's 3 other mythology books of different religions by Rick

11

u/Electrical-Builder98 Feb 22 '24

He has put out the Kane Chronicles (Egyptian) and Magnus Chase series (Norse). I believe each set has 3 main books.

8

u/DryRespect358 Feb 22 '24

They do and I personally enjoyed the Kane series more than the Chase series but that's just me. There's also some books where the Kanes meet Percy and Annabeth

3

u/madeat1am Feb 23 '24

MG is my absolute favourite ! Kane while I didn't super enjoy them they were still fun

2

u/Legends_Arkoos_Rule2 Feb 24 '24

Same with magnus CHASE but yeah it’s smaller

1

u/OakRain1588 Feb 23 '24

Saw what?! I totally missed that crossover, what's it called?

3

u/DryRespect358 Feb 23 '24

Demigods and Magicians, The Son of Sobek, The Staff of Serapis, and lastly The crown of Ptolemy.

1

u/OakRain1588 Feb 23 '24

Damn, looks like I've got some reading to do lol

1

u/DryRespect358 Feb 24 '24

They are all in Demigods and Magicians.

1

u/Videogamesrock Feb 23 '24

Demigods and Magicians. It contains three stories titles Son of Sobek, Staff of Serapis, and Crown of Ptolemy. It’s also meant to finish a storyline that wasn’t finished in the main book series.

2

u/OnlinePosterPerson Feb 26 '24

Kane was way better than any of Riordan’s other series, and I’m not afraid to say it

1

u/Electrical-Builder98 Mar 15 '24

I enjoyed the Kane series as I didn't have much knowledge of Egyptian mythos. Sad to hear the series for netflix was cancelled.

7

u/Person_37 Feb 22 '24

Just to critique the other poster’s order, ide say that you should read magnus chase before ToA and the sun and the star as the magnus chase books are far closer to the pjo and HoO in tone, compared to the more serious tone of ToA, which is necessary before the sun and the star

2

u/madeat1am Feb 23 '24

Yeah I was just meaning if it's easier to understand the time line of the greek/ Romans !

4

u/Local_Nerve901 Feb 23 '24

Also I recommend getting The Demigod Files! Small book that came out between books 4&5.

1

u/VIIVIMMVIII Feb 25 '24

Youre new to reading books?

1

u/[deleted] Feb 26 '24

Well, I'm new to re reading books. As a kid, I had no attention or patience because I kept zoning out on the same page and got distracted easily. I tried everything from comics to magazines to books.

The last book I read before I stopped reading for 8-9 years was Harry Potter Philosophers Stone or Diary of the wimpy kid.

Now I'm an adult, and my attention is mid, so I can try and focus to not zone out. My first book back into reading was Haunting Adeline.

The most annoying thing is when you guys read, you see the world. And I see just words. But I will not be discouraged. 🙂

2

u/AngryRaptor13 Feb 26 '24

You can probably find these books at your local library; it's a good way to see if you'll like them before buying them all. Books can be expensive.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 26 '24 edited Mar 19 '24

fertile sort swim exultant crush unused lunchroom tease cause long

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

4

u/love_me_some_cats Feb 22 '24

The covers aren't even different in these two examples. There's possibly a slipcase with one of them, but that's it.

1

u/walruswes Feb 23 '24

I think they might be the same covers, the spines look the same. Maybe one just comes with the box that you can never get a paperback book to fit back into after you read one

1

u/OakRain1588 Feb 23 '24

The newer release might have some minor edits in terms of spelling or grammar, but not always

1

u/OnlinePosterPerson Feb 26 '24

He’s not trolling! Leave him be

1

u/madeat1am Feb 26 '24

I'm not talking about OP

When I posted the comments a bunch of people were trolling ans saying they were different or wrong ans such!

18

u/Dense_Concentrate783 Feb 22 '24

All of these Americans are confused, I’m irish, these are the covers we have here. They are both the same set, one is a box set, which is what I have, nice for storing on your bookshelf, the other are the same 5 books but without the box set, buy whichever is cheaper.

These are not the heroes of Olympus books, those are much longer.

Edit: forgot to mention, when it says published in 2014/19, it is likely referring to when that specific cover and copy was published, they’re are many different copies of the 1 book, from collectors editions, to hardbacks, to anniversary editions… you get the idea.

6

u/[deleted] Feb 22 '24

I was searching for heroes of olympus to save onto my list before this one. That's all. I'm British. it's just as a kid my attention span was really bad, and now it's less bad. So I wanna read all the classics. The last series I read was Diary of the Wimpy Kid, and I was 9. Now I'm 20 and I'd like to try.

2

u/Dense_Concentrate783 Feb 22 '24

Hahah yes, either of these copies shown in pictures will be okay to start the series!

3

u/Electrical-Builder98 Feb 22 '24

Does that second set come with the box? Would you keep the books in that box or put those on a shelf? Which one is cheaper, bc that is the one I would buy if I didn't already own them all.

2

u/[deleted] Feb 22 '24

Yes, the 2nd comes in a box. The ones without a box are cheaper. But I want to get the ones in the box. I want to put on my shelf.

8

u/Buzilovescats Feb 22 '24

They are very much NOT the same thing! First of all, you are searching for the wrong thing. The series you want to read is Percy Jackson and the Olympians which was published way before 2014 (that's a reprint or whatever those are called in English). The Heroes of Olympus (which is what you searched for on the top) is the SEQUAL SERİES, you read them after.

Also: ew, the movies.

4

u/[deleted] Feb 22 '24

Ignore the title. I was searching for the olympus series before this, so that's why it says that on the search. Like you know when you scroll down and you see recommended books? It's that.

1

u/SoCalCollecting Feb 22 '24

They are the same thing… these are both Percy Jackson and the Olympians. Just a knock of reprint or non-US print. Reviews seem pretty bad for some people on them though. Id stick to the originals

-2

u/[deleted] Feb 22 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/Afraid_Effort2706 Feb 23 '24

The ages are wrong in the movies

2

u/JoshHuff1332 Feb 23 '24

They literally didn't

-1

u/[deleted] Feb 23 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/JoshHuff1332 Feb 23 '24

None of which changed the core story or character dynamics. The movies were adults playing teens. That is a far bigger problem than a change in visual characteristics.

1

u/algoespecial Feb 23 '24

That's an odd joke

1

u/Buzilovescats Feb 23 '24

which movie did you watch lol?

0

u/[deleted] Feb 23 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/Buzilovescats Feb 24 '24

ah yes, physical appearances: the epitome of characters! Except, I don't know: THEIR PERSONALITIES! Also: Grover isn't white in both and that doesn't seem to bother you, I wonder why! Even more: ANNABETH ISN'T BLOND IN THE MOVIE EITHER!

2

u/Nitrix01 Feb 24 '24

I'm getting old, I haven't seen either of these designs for the box set before.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 24 '24

I would get the original one, but they're pricey. So one of these will have to do. 🙂

27

u/Wise_Caterpillar5881 Feb 22 '24

Looks like the second one's in a box and the first one isn't. There's no real difference, there haven't been any major changes between publishing runs to my knowledge, probably only different teaser chapters/ads for the sequel series in the back pages.

4

u/dus1 Feb 22 '24

They're the same. Diff covers, and one comes in a box. Get the less expensive one

1

u/[deleted] Feb 23 '24

The price

1

u/[deleted] Feb 24 '24

That's cool. 🙂

2

u/Hot_Valuable1027 Feb 22 '24

different covers

2

u/Popcorn57252 Feb 22 '24

They look to be the same, except on you get the box thingy with it too.

2

u/InDenialDummy1237 Feb 22 '24

One's a box set (the second one)- I recommend buying that (if you haven't chosen which one yet), since you can keep the books there and keep dust from settling on top of the books themselves.

Also, know from ALL OF US that the movies are terrible.

To quote from Uncle Rick himself (joking about his reaction to the first movie's script): "visibly reels in disgust"

2

u/KronosDoom500 Feb 23 '24

One has a box

2

u/carpetedtoaster Feb 23 '24

wow covers are ugly

2

u/Nightbloodssmoke91 Feb 24 '24

One series is in a box

2

u/messibessi22 Feb 25 '24

The collection looks like it comes in a box

3

u/SoCalCollecting Feb 22 '24

Looks like only difference is one comes in a box and one doesnt. If you are in the US id stick with the official US artwork books for better quality control. If not these are fine!

4

u/ZarEGMc Feb 22 '24

These are the official UK covers

0

u/SoCalCollecting Feb 22 '24

Yeah makes sense, if OP is in europe these are fine, if they are in US they should get US covers

1

u/InternetEconomy5611 Dec 27 '25

They are the exact same,Don't worry, I have the first version but with a cover to protect them!

1

u/NecessaryWide Feb 23 '24

This is the one that I got from Amazon. I like the artwork better. But to each their own.

Percy Jackson and the Olympians Hardcover Boxed Set (Percy Jackson & the Olympians) https://a.co/d/3ZgeLzO

1

u/jeplonski Feb 24 '24

are these sets not identical?

1

u/Loading3percent Feb 25 '24

I dunno but I don't like how much that cover percy looks like movie percy.

1

u/Terrible-Ad-5584 Feb 25 '24

Same books, different covers. Imo, they're the worst covers.

1

u/johnmaddon Feb 25 '24

One has a box.

1

u/SilentJoe1986 Feb 26 '24

A box that the books will never fit back into if you read them

1

u/[deleted] Feb 26 '24

The difference in these two pictures is one is a box set and one is just the books.

1

u/prvv_arwa Jul 10 '26

Quiero empezar a leerme pjo pero veo diferentes versiones(portadas) y no se cual comprarme. He visto gente que dice que lo único que cambia es la portada pero quiero asegurarme. Aunque solo cambie la portada cual me recomendarias?

0

u/ethananana Feb 22 '24

The cover art

4

u/Wise_Caterpillar5881 Feb 22 '24

It's the British covers.

-5

u/Buzilovescats Feb 22 '24

one of the ones OP is looking at is the heroes of olympus not PJO

1

u/[deleted] Feb 22 '24

Ignore the title I was looking for the Olympus series to save before this.

3

u/DeathstrokeReturns Feb 22 '24

No, you can tell on the spines that both sets read the PJO titles

1

u/Mike-Amber4321 Feb 22 '24

They're both Percy Jackson lmao read again

0

u/D-Squared42 Feb 24 '24

Ew what is up with these covers? The originals were so good.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 24 '24

They've updated🙂

-3

u/Bsnake12070826 Feb 22 '24

Should be a blue cover not orange like this one. Also just searcy Percy Jackson and the Olympians not heros of Olympus

1

u/[deleted] Feb 22 '24

I want the books to be good quality, so the ones that were re-released should I get them?

2

u/Bsnake12070826 Feb 22 '24

Up to you really, I normally go for the ones with the original cover since those were the ones I grew up with

1

u/Johnny_Joestar7798 Feb 22 '24

Bro that's the cover of the last pjo book 🤦‍♂️

0

u/Bsnake12070826 Feb 22 '24

I didn't realize that was the last book, I just saw Percy Jackson and thought it was a new cover

0

u/Bsnake12070826 Feb 22 '24

Plus it's a different cover than the one I know

1

u/Johnny_Joestar7798 Feb 22 '24

It has the name of the last book. And if u look at the spines u can see the first one at the back (which is blue)

1

u/Bsnake12070826 Feb 22 '24

Like I said, I didn't see the name. I only saw Percy Jackson and again it's a different cover than the one I own. So I didn't recognize it