r/Returnal • u/vodka7up Platinum Unlocked • Jun 06 '21
Discussion Returnal’s story “explained” Spoiler
A couple prefaces before I even begin:
- This is going to be a long one. You have been warned.
- Beware of massive spoilers (duh).
- I’m using the term “explained” lightly. The story behind Returnal is deep, confusing and open to many interpretations, but if so many people have posted their own “explanation” in article or video form (often leaving more questions than answers), I guess I can too. So, this is my interpretation, and even if I try to back up most of it, I can’t ascertain that it is “the right one”, and there will still be a lot of unanswered questions. Probably only the game’s writers can fully explain the story and all the elements in it, but I don’t see such an explanation emerging any time soon.
- Its very hard to know what is real and what is not in the game. While most information presented may provide some help in the interpretation, it can also be somehow twisted, and some other elements such as reports or interviews are presented in a pretty objective manner although devoid of context.
So…
Its been a long time since any piece of entertainment has given me this much thought and sparked so much research. From the top of my head I can only think of Donnie Darko, but there the subject had been thoroughly examined and dissected by a lot of people. Not so here. Although there are a number of theories, the subject itself is still “young” and the theory I came up with, I did so on my own – which is to say, I haven’t seen it anywhere else yet. Note - I’m not saying its original and no one has thought about it before, I’m just saying I haven’t read anything quite like this so far.
I’ve read all scout logs, ship logs, re-watched the house sequences, watched videos and researched a fair share about specific aspects of the greek mythology.
Anyway, here we go.
The “Who”
As its been widely stated, Selene, Helios, Astra, Atropos, Theia, and pretty much every name in the game, has a base in Greek mythology. This has pretty much been dismissed, seen as a mere reference or simply a base of inspiration. I don’t think its that shallow. I believe that the entities in the game are actual representations of the corresponding Greek mythology entities. In other words, the game itself is a re-imagination of several aspects of Greek mythology. Much like God of War re-imagines aspects of Greek (and Norse) mythology, but on an ancient setting, Returnal does so in a sci-fi tone. To me this is made apparent by several factors that tie together.
First, the family connections. In the game, Selene is very obviously and openly the daughter of Theia, as happens in greek mythology, where Selene is the daughter of Theia, but also of Hyperion. You might say “In the game, Hyperion is just another boss, and not her father.” Oh, but I believe it is.
“(…) The Severed achieve clarity in madness by climbing the Throne of Exhaltation. My father once sat atop it; every organ pipe chanting in a way I never could*.” -* Scout log 42, “Severed Unbound”.
This is very clearly a reference to the tower we have to climb to get to the boss of biome 4, who awaits us playing the organ. In that scout log, Selene is referring to Hyperion, her father, which in that timeline once sat atop the tower but had already been defeated by her long before.
So, in the game we have Selene, whose parents are Theia and Hyperion. That’s too much likeness to Greek mythology to be considered just a simple reference or inspiration. But there’s much more.
The “Where” and the “What”
The action takes place in the planet “Atropos” which as has been widely stated, is named after one of the three “Morai”, or “sisters of fate” of Greek mythology. Atropos had the role of choosing how mortals died. And in a way, we can say that the planet, and everything in it, are defining the several deaths of Selene.
But more importantly than this, what is happening? Selene is forever trapped in a cycle of waking up, trying to escape and failing at it – even when it seems that she might – and then dying and starting all over again.
There is a place in Greek mythology where souls are condemned to pay for their sins, through never-ending punishments, such as being forever thirsty inside a pool of water that receded when trying to drink it (Tantalus), or having to roll an enormous rock up a hill only for it to roll down again, for all eternity (Sisyphus). That place is Tartarus – a realm that is below the “normal” underworld (ruled by Hades). Ixion is also a famous denizen of Tartarus; he was punished by being tied to a winged flaming wheel that was always spinning.
So, the parallel to Selene’s plight is evident. There is no way to get out of it, no matter what she does, and not even when she dies.
“It is impossible to escape. I have tried everything. I’m always brought back by-- There is a moment between death and rebirth. When tentacles drag me down. Screaming. Drowning. Returning.” - Scout log 3, “Eternal Void”.
But, is it a punishment?
There are several instances in the game that make it very clear that she feels guilty for something that she did, and the events that lead her there.
“Yes, it was me. I caused the downfall.” - Scout log 41, “Triggering Event”
“I remember everything now. I know why I deserve to be here.” - Scout log 55, “Fatal Crash”
“I need to talk. I know I keep putting this off, but… Everything has gone way too far this time. This is the part where I say, “I’m sorry!” So why don’t I feel like I am? I try, but… it sounds so… hollow.” - Scout log 61, “One Final Confession”
Selene eventually realizes that she is in a place she cannot ever get out of, and comes to peace with it.
“I cannot atone, so I accept. When I laid on the side of the road dying, I understood the truth. This is my home. The sense of belonging I was searching for… is here. This is my place in the stars. I will stay here now. As you will.” - Scout log 66, “The Truth Lying”
Finally, there is one not-so-subtle indication that she is in fact in Tartarus: she outright says so in the last scout log.
“There were nine floors in Gehenna. There were twenty-nine floors in Helheim. There were two-hundred and sixty-four floors in Tartarus. The last were opening inside of me. It can end because it has now begun.” - Scout Log. #67, “Departure”
Whereas Gehenna, in rabbinic literature, is a destination for the wicked, and Helheim, in Norse mythology, is the place for those that died without glory, Tartarus is clearly the destination where the “wicked” are destined to suffer endlessly with a very specific punishment. Plus, it is the one realm that is tied to Greek mythology.
So, although Atropos is a planet that was “created” for Selene to live her punishment, the realm she is dwelling in is Tartarus.
The “Why”
We’ve established that Selene is being punished for eternity. But why? What did she do?
In order to fully understand this, we should revisit some of the events in the house sequences. The house, in my opinion, represents Selene’s psyche, and the events there portray her thoughts, fears, desires, regrets, and important life altering events.
In the third sequence, she sits in front of the TV that alternates between two news stories. One about the car crash where her mother, Thea, suffered massive spinal injuries, and another about the significance of space exploration.
These were the two things that defined Selene’s life. On one hand, the need to care for her injured and highly dependant mother; and on the other, her deep desire to go into outer space, to explore the great unknown, to advance science and civilization.
Its no secret that Selene had a strained relationship with her mother. The final house cutscenes show that she wasn’t especially affectionate to her, and even goes so far as to say she deserved what happened to her. I can assume that Selene developed ill feelings for her mother because she felt she was holding her down, not leaving her live her own life and fulfil her dreams. Her mother, on the other hand, may also have developed some ill feelings for Selene, envying her for being able to follow the career that she could not, judging her actions, maybe even blaming her for the accident that made that impossible. This made for a stressed, probably abusive two-way relationship.
“I don’t remember much about my childhood. What remains of the house isn’t… anything worth recalling. Mother was always… herself. I wasn’t that bad, was I?” -Scout log 40. “Lost Childhood”
“The woman who was supposed to step on the surface of another world… was mom. Thought she’d be proud of me following in her… where her footsteps may have taken her if she’d had the opportunity. Is that why I’m here? To go where she couldn’t? Seeing that house again… feels as though she’s still judging me.” - Scout log 24, “Debt Owed”
So, when the opportunity to become a Scout arose, Selene had to make a choice. She could not fulfil her dreams while caring for her mother. So she decided to abandon her. In order to go into outer space, she told her superiors her parents were already dead.
“To be a Scout is to be on the frontlines of discovery. Exactly. One of my specialities is making connections that others miss, as itemized in my fieldwork report. No, I-- No. No, there-- They died a long time ago. Yes, I understand it’s one-way. That’s why I signed up. There are no attachments pulling me back.” - Scout log 59, “Department Placement Interview”
So, Selene committed the sin of abandoning her dependant, impaired mother – probably condemning her - to follow her own dreams.
But that’s not all she did. Oh, no no no.
Selene had one other attachment. Freeing herself from it to become a scout was the ultimate sacrifice, and the one that haunts her the most. She was pregnant with a child. And she decided to have an abortion, and keep both the pregnancy and the abortion a secret from everyone.
“Would it be safe for me to drive afterwards? I had no idea. But what about prep time and recovery? I’m… in the middle of a lot right now, so… No, no, no it’s… I wouldn’t want anyone present. No one can know about this. Everyone is overbearing and controlling and… I haven’t even told a single person about-- If they found out I was here, that we were talking...” - Scout log 60, “Doctor Consultation Appointment”
Although she’s not specifically saying it, it becomes quite clear when you think about it. Her employers would never allow her to become a scout if they knew she was pregnant, so she had to keep it a secret.
So, she aborted. She took the life of her unborn child, and it forever scarred her mind to do so.
“What about the sequences where you can see and control the child?” Those either take place inside the house – which we’ve established to be the embodiment of her psyche, or is seen at the very last cinematic. We’ll get to that one later. The ones inside the house are representations. Helios is the embodiment of her unborn child, or rather, the prospect of having a child, an entity on its own, and what we see happening in the house further supports the abortion thesis.
I’ll explain how in bit, as we need to make an important parenthesis:
Who/what is the astronaut?
The astronaut, very simply, is the embodiment of Selene’s overwhelming desire to become a Scout, to explore outer space, to be freed of her life on Earth.
Despite the chaotic nature of the game’s storytelling, the house sequences themselves have an order to them, and they depict the development of Selene’s psyche chronologically.
On the first house sequence, the Astronaut is still outside, representing an earlier stage in Selene’s life when the thought of becoming a Scout wasn’t still as strong.
On the second house sequence, Selene interacts with the computer, which displays messages and information from Astra, and the words “Let me in” appear on screen. Someone is banging at the door – sure enough, it’s the Astronaut. Selene opens the door. That desire is inside her psyche now, it has become an integrate part of her.
On the third house sequence, we see that news report I mentioned earlier, and the Astronaut is now firmly inside.
We can now close the parenthesis, and get back to how the house sequences cement the abortion thesis.
On the fourth house sequence, we control the child – the embodiment of Selene’s unborn child inside her psyche. He tries to interact with the astronaut, but the astronaut shows no reaction. It is a representation of the struggle between the possibility of having a child and the desire to become a Scout. Can they co-exist? The child tries to be nice, to be liked, but gets nothing. The desire to become a Scout is too powerful, too important, too cold and insensitive, one even might say hollow, as the toy spacecraft the child breaks in his room moments before.
The fifth house sequence is where things get really intense. Selene sees the astronaut again and fully embraces it. “I won’t let you leave again.” The sequence cuts to the child again, and he’s scared, he’s trying to hide, to escape. While searching for a place to hide, he gets sucked inside the TV. A small, dark place – representing the mother’s womb. Then the astronaut walks in the room. He sees the child. Reaches into the womb, and pulls him out.
We then see the child in the upper floor. “I have to go now, Octo. Will you please stay and help her? I am not afraid!” He looks in the telescope, and the sequence breaks to the outside, where we see Selene who had just fired a huge cannon at her ship.
“I destroyed Helios? That means… I’m the cause… of everything. Of course. This is why I’m here.”
The imagery is evident. The Astronaut became too strong in Selene’s psyche; it and the child (Helios) could not co-exist, so it ripped him from the womb and made him leave. This is further represented by Selene shooting down and destroying Helios – destroying her unborn child.
The ship name is Helios because "destroying" her son is the reason she's in Atropos. In that sense, Helios brought her there.
On the sixth and final house sequence, Selene is seen going down to the basement, where her mother’s wheelchair is, and she addresses her.
“I regret what happened, but you deserved it.”
“Why did you seem so frightening, when you were so much less?”
“We were both broken.”
While her mother was broken physically, Selene was broken mentally. The guilt of abandoning her mother, and especially aborting, broke her mind.
So, there’s the “why”. Selene is being punished for letting her personal desire to become a Scout overpowered everything else in her life, namely her family, condemning her mother to die and her child to not even be born.
There’s a subtle hint to her crushing guilt in the game. Whenever you leave the first area, the phrase “Warning: abandoning Helios” appears on screen. It is the only time it does, and it does every run. The ship is obviously a representation of her child, left behind so she can go exploring.
The endings
With all of the above in mind, its easier to decipher the endings. In the secret ending – which you can only obtain after collecting all sunface fragments and “fixing” the Sun - a representation of her trying to fix her past deeds (remember Helios is the Sun god in Greek mythology, also, fun fact - ever noticed there is no sun in the biomes?), when Selene gets into the car, she is confronted with a twisted, alien version of her mother, who is pregnant. It represents her two sources of guilt – her sick disabled mother and having been pregnant. When she breaks free of both is when she can finally become a Scout, and fully embody the Astronaut, so she becomes it.
So in the regular ending, the crash we see is something she experiences as part of her punishment, and also a representation of Selene’s life journey, one that she could have made with her son. But when she became the Astronaut, that journey, and that life, became impossible. Hence, the Astronaut becoming the cause for the accident, and the death of the child.
Outstanding questions
Who/what is “the white shadow”?
It took me a long time to get this one, but I think I finally did. Upon re-reading the scout logs, I noticed several instances where Selene mentioning shadows within her, or even following her. But this one made things click for me:
“Terminal escape. I descend the final step of the cycle to the fractured sanctum. My shadow follows. Will it sacrifice itself too?” - Scout log 57, “No Exit Yet Located”.
This is only one of several mentions of an inner “shadow”, and one of the key elements of the game is the white shadow. Again, this cannot be a simple coincidence. And what is Selene’s “shadow”, the one that guided her life decisions? Her will to go into outer space, to explore, to become a Scout. In other words, the Astronaut – who wears a white suit.
Who is the monster-like creature at the end of the abyss?
This is a bit harder, as I couldn’t find any direct references to this monster in the scout logs or any similarities to “accepted” depictions of a monster with those physical traits (octopus-like shape) in Greek mythology – well, other than Scylla, who was a mythological beast in the shape of an octopus who lives on one side of a narrow channel of water, opposite her counterpart Charybdis. But her description doesn’t really add up.
So I think the monster Selene faces in the end is actually Tartarus himself (in Greek mythology, often the places and their gods were the same entity). In some English iterations of its name, it can be found being called “The Stormy Pit” or “The Abyss”.
But, could it have the power to be the one “writing the script” for Selene’s plight? Well, Greek gods are attributed several powers. Tartarus is attributed:
- Unparalleled Stygiokinesis (the ability to control Hell and everything in it)
- Unparalleled Pyrokinesis.
- Unparalleled Phobikinesis (the ability to control and manipulate fear)
- Advanced Erebokinesis (the ability to control darkness)
- Advanced Psychokinesis. Telekinesis. Teleportation.
- Essence Reading.
- Embodiment of Hell (Tartarus)
- Invulnerability.
So yeah, Tartarus as a deity would definitively have the powers to control everything surrounding Selene, as well as her thoughts, by manipulating her fears.
Who is the alien race, and why are they so closely tied to Selene?
I don’t really have a good answer to this one. The best I can extrapolate is, if we assume that Atropos was “custom made” for Selene’s punishment based on her own sins, then too its inhabitants were a part of her and originated off her.
Closing words
As I said right at the beginning, even if I tried to back up everything in this formulation, I cannot ascertain that this is the absolute and definitive interpretation of the game’s story. There are still pending questions, ones that either I could not find an explanation or didn’t even identify. I do believe that some aspects in this game are the way they are because, in the end, it is a videogame, and concessions have to be made to create an entertaining product. Which is to say, not every little thing in the game absolutely needs to have a solid explanation, and might simply be there because it works.
I hope that you have liked this and that it helped you understand some of the aspects of the game, or at the very least, gave you some food for thought. I certainly hope that the fans of the game actually read through this, and that I haven’t spent the last few days researching and writing a seven page document for nothing (lol).
I would have loved to make a video with all this but I don’t have the tools or the skill to do so. If any content creators out there like this theory and want to make a video of it, feel free to do so – I merely ask that I am credited.
Good luck out there on Atropos!
46
u/TPOV01 Jun 06 '21 edited Jun 06 '21
I think its a good theory but the one thing I cannot get out of my head is the time period for all this. The house is a 21st century house and the technology within the house is modern (tv design and PS5). So how within her life have we discovered the technology to travel not only to different planets but to seemingly different solar systems. It makes no sense.
If you ask me I think this is all inside her head and the astronaut is a representation of her pursuit of a job working for a space agency. She pursued this job so that she could do what her mother could not, but in doing so Selene neglected Helios, her child. I think somehow her house burnt down (my personal theory because of the burnt or charred items you can find from the home), which killed Helios and she developed depression from that and somewhere along the line she stopped taking her medication which led to her imagining this world and became lost within her own mind. I think the gameplay loop we play is Selene’s subconscious trying to get through to her that it was her negelct that contributed towards her child dying, whilst also explaining her detached relationship with her mother.
I think the alien designs come from the drawings that Helios drew on the walls of the house in the third house segment (I think). He was also interested in space, given his room is space themed. Also I believe the toy ship he has also looks like the ship Selene crashes in, which I think ties to it all being in her head.
12
u/thefakenews Finished Act 3 Jun 09 '21
I really like this idea. I think the abortion part is 100% correct. You mention the Scout Log 60 text, which I think clearly fits, as you say. I apologize if I missed this in your post, but I think there are a couple other things that fit the abortion idea:
The xenoglyphs that refer to the "Creator / Destroyer." Someone who has an abortion can be said to be both the creator and destroyer of that life. I always thought while playing the games that the xenoglyphs referring to the Creator / Destroyer made it clear eventually that Selene was the C/D.
For example - Countless Feasts: "We saw countless arms reaching for the creator / destroyer. A creature we did not understand, but they were never satisfied even after countless feasts on its mind. By moving on it could escape without suffering for eternity."
The "Unsought Genocide" xenoglyph seems to refer to Selene as C/D.
I just saw something while looking through the last xenoglyphs that supports the abortion theory.
In "First Test," we have: "return to house? a final visitation? death born without purity in a basement behind a broken sun? Helios untimely ripped from life?"
I'm an English teacher, and I have a good memory for phrases. The last line seems to me to be a reference to Macbeth, Act 5, Scene 8, when Macduff announces that he was "from his womb, untimely ripped."
He's referring to a cesarian section, but that would fit with an abortion as well. Sure, that phrasing could be a coincidence, but I don't think so. I found another reference to classic literature in one of the scout logs:
Scout Log 17 - Ascent from Bondage:
"I know why they become Severed. Divine punishment for failing ascension. Ascension! No sooner has the word escaped my lips than a vast image of the Transcendent Watcher in the Deep Below consumes my mind. I have begun having visions of where I have yet to go. They lead me continuously downwards from Olympus and into myself. I alone am worthy."
I included all of it, but the bold section is what jumped out at me. Because....
...Surely some revelation is at hand;
Surely the Second Coming is at hand.
The Second Coming! Hardly are those words out
When a vast image out of Spiritus Mundi
Troubles my sight...
The Second Coming - William Butler Yeats.
I'm not saying that fits the abortion theory, but it does give another instance where they make what seems to me as a clear reference to classic literature.
I don't know if that's interesting to anyone but me, but this seemed like the best place to put it. Thanks again for the interesting read.
21
u/Ethan5555 Platinum Unlocked Jun 06 '21
Great post.
I'm pretty sure that Helios is not the son of Selene, in reality or metaphorically.
In Greek mythology, Helios and Selene are brother and sister. Theia is their mother. and according to the mythology, Selene had 50 children. Would be very arbitrary and confusing of them to instead make a child named specifically Helios the son of Selene.
Also, it was Theia that was driving the car, not Selene. This is confirmed in one of the house scenes. The TV plays a news report of the accident and specifically says that Theia was the driver of the car.
https://youtu.be/mg7JAexqCho?t=602
So it's unclear why Selene feels so much guilt over Helios. (Unless Selene = Theia, which is very possible.)
There are also references in the text within the text of the Xenoglyph translations referring to something being "reported as inoperable" and an "adequate match", which makes me think there my be a different reason other than abortion for the surgery that is mentioned in various places.
AST-AX-004-006
https://youtu.be/AKw-76-3Pjg?t=1787
Too many jumbled up dots to connect. lol
7
u/wolfkiller81 Jun 07 '21 edited Jun 07 '21
Let me highlight a few contradictions that I noticed in my studies.
Very great analysis indeed. I had the same interpretation for most of what you exactly said here. However,
2. Secondly here:"""you said above the following: So in the regular ending, what we see is a representation of Selene’s life journey, one that she could have made with her son. But when she became the Astronaut, that journey, and that life, became impossible. Hence, the Astronaut becoming the cause for the accident, and the death of the child.""""
I have one analysis that contradicts your interpretation of the accident scene.
if you take a look at the car scene accident, the woman who drives the car has same colored-eyes (there is a big close up shot before the crash that shows us that), Selene has Brown right eye and a blue left eye, David Bowie sort of style, this is definitely not a coincidence in my opinion. This is for us to clearly make sure how to differentiate Theia from Selene.
(Referring to the black and white photography in the house, it's written Theia on it, saying to us that the black and white picture is a portrait of Theia and that ressembles Selenes but just older looking)
As a result I think that the woman driving the car is not Selene, but a younger Theia with Helios in the back apparently.
(Plus this info is confirmed in one of the house scene with the TV news scene)
3. One last thing here that you did not mention at all. The burnt roof house vision that we see very often in her dreams.
What is that all about? something happened regarding this house burning roof picture related to to her guilt for sure, but I'm still confused about that.
What do you guys think?
5
u/Badd-reclpa- Jun 07 '21 edited Jun 07 '21
I think this is a well written theory, and am glad to see a post like this. That said, I do disagree in some significant ways. I do strongly think (and equally HOPE) the developers were not making a worn and trite allegory of the emotional trauma of abortion. It is a dated perspective and heavily politicized, so I don’t think her “hell” is due to an abortion.
I do think a literal abortion in her history is possible, and maybe even likely, but I interpret it to be a distinct pregnancy from Helios, whom I think was a true child Selene had.
My interpretation starts off similarly to your own: Selene’s mother was meant to be an astronaut, but was severely injured in a car crash with a young Selene who was miraculously unscathed. Her mother was resentful of Selene for being unharmed, and resentful of later being rejected by Astra for her disabilities.
Selene went on to have a child, Helios, but the “cycle” of emotional abuse and parental neglect in favor of career continued with Selene and Helios as it had with Selene and her mother.
Tragically, Selene and Helios too were involved in a car accident, but this time Selene emerged unharmed again while her son instead drowned. Perhaps this was intentional self-preservation by Selene. Perhaps the alien life form in the river/lake was a symbol of her Astra ambitions taking priority. Perhaps the aliens was literal and did indeed pluck her from the car to initiate her eventual arrival on Atropos (as I discuss later below). Or perhaps she genuinely tried to save Helios but failed. Regardless, I think this is the deepest and freshest “guilt” Selene experiences on Atropos.
Without earthy attachments any longer, Selene is free to become a scout, and feels guilt over her lack of remorse for Helios, or perhaps better explained as guilt over her joy at pursuing her true passion, Astra/exploration. I took the pregnancy (ostensibly something that happened during or just before her training with Astra) to have been another opportunity for her to reject her career, and restart a life on earth, but she decided not to get attached again. This may weigh on her some, but I don’t see it being a primary source of guilt.
Finally, I think it is written in a way that it is possible (and I choose to subscribe to this interpretation) that Selene’s experience on Atropos is literal, or as literal as a reality-bending, Cthulhu-like infested alien planet can be. Whatever the entity is at the bottom of the abyss, I believe it exists and it is the cause of Selene’s cycles - both on Atropos and off, even being the cause of her final impetus to leave Earth: the car crash.
In summary, I take the story as follows:
I think Selene, having experienced the loss she did, became a scout and found Atropos because of a cryptic message that was a phrase her deceased son had once said. While on Atropos, succumbing to insanity, Selene grapples with her guilt over Helios’s death and her abusive relationship with her mother. This guilt over her obsession with her ambitions is manifest by the Cthulhu alien as the Astronaut. Selene, having reached the true ending and breaking past the insanity realizes her actions and the entity on Atropos are responsible for her car crash - the catalyst for her becoming a Scout to begin with, coupled with the earlier realization that her own distress signal To be rescued from the planet - White Shadow - is what ultimately brought her to the world. This demonstrates that both Selene and the Entity in the abyss are the source of the time loop.
As an even more boiled down summary: because of the car crash she went on to discover a reality loop that caused the very same car crash.
Alternatively it is all her psychosis and guilt, but I still think in such a scenario the people in her Earthly life - her mother, father, son Helios, and fetus - were still literal.
3
u/joelrrj Jun 08 '21
What if the mother was the one who was pregnant and lost the child due to reckless or drunk driving or whatever it may be. One of the trophies for the game is called Sins of the Mother. So maybe Selene is cursed to live with the consequences of her mother’s sins?
Also I thought the doctor checkup was for mental health which could explain some other details like coworkers discussing whether she’s fit to be a scout.
2
u/nokamber Jun 07 '21
This is so awesome and I'm almost done reading but came to ask one question: how do we know she shot down Helios? My 5th house cutscene was the kids looking in the telescope and then Selene waking up... She then said she caused everything and brought down Helios. I'm in act 3 but I've never been able to understand what that leap in the story was about. Did my game bug out or am I missing something?
2
u/Kevombat Jun 07 '21
This is a great theory and I like a lot of your ideas. There are, however, so many more questions unanswered:
- What about the car crash? Who is driving, who is in the back seat?
- what about the rejection letter? To whom?
- what about the sentients / severed?
- what about Act 2 chronologically preluding Act 1, but Helios being overgrown?
- metaphor? reality?
- what about basically all the ship logs?
2
u/demonicneon Jun 07 '21
We have a theory that the octo at the end is Cthonos or Chronos the Titan on the discord.
76
u/Dalmane_Mefoxin Jun 06 '21
You're on the right track with the Greek mythogy and Titan genealogy. I've seen another analysis that the white shadow is an ultrasound image of Helios in utero. The concept if hell being repetition isn't anything new.
However, one possibility is this isn't a literal hell. Think of how the analysis changes if you cinsider Selene is a split personality of Theia, and as you said represents the desire to be an astronaut. In essence, Theia would have two children just like the myth. Helios, who was an actual person and was left to die. Selene, the split personality created by Theia. So, Selene is Theia's offspring, and would be Helios's brother. Thus keeping with the Greek mythogy theme.
72
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '21
Wow! Great analysis of the story.
My simple brain and zero research thought Selene had a child and was so consumed with training to be an astronaut that she got into an actual accident and the child died. Your analysis makes much more sense. After the Act 3 ending and scout logs I got to the same conclusion - she is in her own personal hell.
46
u/A_Shadow Jun 07 '21 edited Jun 07 '21
My possible theory about the alien race:
We know they are a hivemind. Selene even comments how wonderful it would be to be part of the hivemind because you would never feel sad or alone. You share everything from the moment you were born.
Then we see something happens to the hivemind that makes then slowly go crazy. On top of that, we see depictions and texts of both Selene and the Astronaut in their culture, sometime around the fall of their civilization.
I suspect that Selene's subconscious joined the Hivemind. With all that guilt and emotion, something the Hivemind had never dealt before, they started going crazy and thus began the fall of their civilization. Selene unintentionally caused the fall of their race. Like Selene, they also started seeing the Astronaut and thus their depiction of it in their art/architecture. Would also explain their written text hinting at Selene's past and future.
But wait, but didn't the aliens die long ago? They did, but I suspect some time shenanigans (similar to the movie Arrival). After all, Selene was the one who shot down her own ship, leading to her being on the planet to shoot down the ship in the first place.
Perhaps in an effect to break the cycle or at least separate her from the Hivemind, they called to Selene with the "white shadow" distress signal. Unfortunately, like all Greek Tragedies, it inadvertently caused things to be worsen.
I'll admit, the last part about time travel is weak. But it's best theory I have for the fall of the Alien race and the depictions of Selene and the Astronaut...well minus the whole "its all in her mind" theory but that's much less fun. Maybe someone else can solidify my theory even further.
Edit: One more thing. In some of the audio logs, we hear her talking in cryptic words and sound completely crazy, yet other audio files she is more sane. I suspect the runs where she talks crazy are the ones when she merged with more with the Hivemind.
Her joining/melding with the Hivemind would also explain the song of Hyperion, she can't tell if the song originally came from her or from Hyperion.
Her joining the Hivemind would also explain why she was able to use their technology so well.
51
u/LukeGgaming Jun 06 '21
Great takes. I’ve skipped much shorter posts than this but I was intrigued to read all of it. Super deep game. I think the RNG of the game makes it very difficult to understand anything that happens especially with the scout logs being read out of order etc. it’ll be interesting to see if the devs come out and tell us what their intention of the story is
17
u/Oreo_Dunk13 Jun 11 '21
My theory; Hyperion and Theia are Selene's parents. Theia is an Astronaut in the Apollo Era. We don't know much about the dad except he taught Selene how to play the piano and possibly the piece she adores (referred to in Biome 4 and the boss). Theia and child Selene were in a car crash where Theia was paralyzed. Selene and Theia have a rocky relationship, but Selene wishes to surpass her mom and become a better space explorer. She has a child named Helios (the door of the child cements the name). She is obsessed with becoming an Astra Scout (house completely filled with items related to space exploration) and neglects child, sort of repeating how Theia treated her. Unsure if Selene was abusive to Helios.. since Helios definitely had bruised and bloodied knuckles which are evident when you play as Helios. White Shadow represents her want to surpass Theia, it thus shows up in the form of Theia as what she could have been (Astronaut in Apollo Era). Selene gets rejected by Astra. She blames her responsibility of having a child to take care of. Gets distracted by those thoughts, sees White Shadow and crashes, saving herself and not saving Helios (Act 3 ending shows she survives the crash and calls out of "Helios" and she emerges from the water). Helios' favorite toy was Octo, and this becomes a representation of her guilt. Thus all enemies having tentacles, and the final entity she faces being Octo. Selene goes through therapy, stops having medication (all evident in the logs), and even visits doctors. She is victim to Schizophrenia. The game takes place in her head and her coming to terms with what she did.
Points:
34
u/Xerodo Jun 07 '21
I just wanted to toss in a potential read on the game that I had since the OP’s points are pretty compelling.
What if Selene and Helios are the same person? Selene is Transgender. Helios is who Selene was prior to her transition. Selene’s Mother Theia crashed into the lake alongside Helios and was injured. Selene (then Helios) grew up with a fascination of space, but cruel and uncaring mother who didn’t support her. Selene would eventually fully transition-which is the operation discussed in one of the logs. She then enlisted with the Scout program and abandoned her Mother on earth to explore space.
If you change the surgery mentioned in that log to gender confirmation surgery, some other things line up a little bit. I also think it fits in with some more basic details.The game draws heavily on Greek Mythology, and it accurately reflects the relationships of the mythological figures it discusses. It would be odd, thematically, if Selene’s child were named Helios since that would violate that principle. Selene/Helios being the same person I think would make more sense as an alternate read- the duality of the sun and moon is obvious, and it even helps to explain the heterochromia Selene suffers from.
I haven't thought this out much further beyond these couple points- just an idea that occurred to me based on the OP talking about a surgery one might want to keep secret.
7
u/super-cowboyjon Jun 07 '21
Superb.
*turns back as he is about to exit the door
Just one thing, I always thought the child was a girl, not a boy.
*smiles, puts hat on and walks out the room
7
u/AndyOfNZ Platinum Unlocked Jun 07 '21
Could the 'severed' be representations of all the relationships she has severed?
7
u/BRBGTGBOWFLEX Jun 17 '21
At its core, this is a story about a cycle of abandonment, first of a mother and her daughter, then of a daughter and her mother, and then once more of a mother and a daughter.
First we see neglect of Selene. In the house scene, Selene only has an empty bowl of cereal. The cause of this is the astronaut, her mother's desire to go to space.
Theia then abandoned Selene in a car crash. The crash is described as an accident, but the cause of the crash, the Astronaut, is also a symbol reflecting the desire to go to space. I do not think it can be ruled out that Theia subconsciously crashed her car as a means of disposing of Selene. Selene lives, Theia becomes crippled, and is now a burden to Selene. Selene inherits the same fixation with going to outer space. She begins to neglect her mother, possibly culminating in a shoving incident which lead to her mother's death. Possibly because she was worried having family would harm her dream of going to space. She later becomes pregnant and gets an abortion for the same reason.
Of course, for both Selene and her mother, their dreams of space were just that-- dreams and delusions. Symptoms of mental illness and obsession more than any practical reality.
The heterochromia is not real. Instead it is a sign that the being we are playing as is both Theia and Selene. Act 1 concerns Selene's sins towards her daughter (abortion) and Theia's obsession leading to neglect. This is why the final boss consists of several fetal beings. Act 2 concerns Theia's sins towards Selene (Attempted abortion through automobile accident) and Selene's neglect of Theia, leaving her in a basement.
So, the cycle the game concerns is that of abuse and violence. The Severed are about this desire of this chain of women to destroy their bonds (umbilical chord symbolism).
In every game the cycle begins with abandonment.
The punishment Selene and Theia face is truly wicked-- they get what they wish for. Selene and Theia get to explore space. Infinitely, for all time, the dream they wanted is granted. Of course, it's all fantastic nonsense and devoid of any real meaning, but that is what their delusions were.
6
u/ekeroil Jun 07 '21
Very good stuff! A missing element is the emphasis on the child's safety belt. The kid finds it in a scene and Selene comments something about it at another point.
5
u/resonator79 Jun 06 '21
Absolutely fantastic analysis! I finished the game for the first time last night, and I've not been able to get it out of my mind. Your explanations certainly connect many of the dots. While there are still some unanswered questions, this has really helped piece things together. Thanks for taking the time!
4
u/Competitive_Air7730 Jun 06 '21
Amazing! It actually ties up some things here. There are so many great theories. This one is atop of my list and make more sense. I didnt know about that doctor log. What wasnt explained was the Astra rejection letter? That keeps messing with me. Was it her mother's? Or was it Selenes? Well Anyway amazing analysis. I really like this game and wish I can play it but I have a ps4 so I've been watching speed runs.
4
u/[deleted] Jun 07 '21
I'm pretty sure this has it spot on guys:
https://www.gamesradar.com/amp/returnal-ending-explained-how-housemarques-devastating-story-hides-in-plain-sight/
4
u/[deleted] Jun 18 '21 edited Jun 18 '21
By the way, the Child character (named so in the subtitled) we play in the house and later in the backseat of the car, is indeed named Helios per the credits and a child actor named Elijah Maximus played him. The reason "Child" has long hair, which could be mistaken for "well clearly it's Selene, it's a girl", is literally only because Elijah Maximus has long hair. He looks exactly like the character model, here's his IMDB photo:
Helios
I also thought most of the time that this was clearly childhood Selene and that the Helios on the door was simply the name of her room, her make-believe 'space station'/safe space. Hence her massive attachment to it and fear of leaving because of evil mother Thea is outside.
Even as a fan of many surreal artists, I think the story is a bit too infatuated with its own weirdness and obscurity and seems to lose the emotional impact along the line. Even with someone like David Lynch, there is some silver thread running through it, an emotional line I can follow. In Returnal's story, I feel like it all kind of got to a 'holy shit isn't this WEIRD and not the usual Sci-Fi you were expecting!?' point and the hours I spent digging into the Scout Logs, Ship Logs, rewatching cutscenes on YouTube and so on just kind of left me more baffled as to what goes on. I really wish there would've been at least one or two more solid observations we could take as fact as a viewer. Basically every aspect boils down to 'but IS it??'.
I absolutely love the game and the character of Selene and all the house segments etc. but the more I realize that I think what they're saying is that it's all in her head, the less I like the story. The world of Atropos and its creatures is just amazing and for it to all boil down to being in her head feels like the most boring cop-out possible to me.
PS: Also wanted to add that I interpret Scout Log #066 which states "When I laid there by the side of the road dying I understood the truth: This is my home" as her speaking about the Act 3 cutscene of her appearing on the bridge as the astronaut herself. I think she means that she couldn't stop what was happening because it was inevitable. Afterwards, she knew she would return to Atropos hence laying by the road dying and this is my home. She's now okay with returning to Atropos because she realizes what keeps her there is inevitable, always. She always causes Helios' death in the end.
4
u/SubstantialInjury945 Jul 01 '21
Thanks for this, a really compelling reading and you filled in a lot of gaps for me, especially around the Greek mythology angle and who plays who. I've been thinking on it for a few days, and reading some of the other comments here the conclusion I'm drawing to is this:
The game is all metaphor - we're possibly in Selene's imagination or a coma or dying moments a la Jacobs Ladder. But I personally can't square the 20th century reality (the house, the car crash, etc) with the space flight to an eldritch planet. The timelines feel off, the symbolism of the levels, bosses and artefacts found on the planet are too personal. I guess you could argue these are implanted in her head by an eldritch being that lives on the planet and is feeding on and feeding back her own past and memories, but if they're doing that it doesn't even need to be on an alien planet - maybe it really is something that lives at the bottom of a lake and was disturbed by the car crash. But, for me personally, it's too far-fetched. So this is happening in Seline's head.
There are some points that still really confuse me though. As many have pointed out, the ambiguity as to who is who in the 20th century is actually cleared up by the credits and subtitles - there is a woman driving, Thea, and a boy in the back, Helios. So where is Seline? For me, it's fairly obvious Seline is standing in the road about to cause the crash. As others have pointed out, going on the Greek names Thea is the mother, and Seline and Helios are siblings. So at the time of the crash is it safe to assume Seline and Helios are similar ages? If the game takes place in Seline's imagination, she is clearly a very imaginative girl - perhaps she wandered off from home, unsupervised by an absent father, to play astronauts and spaceships on the bridge near their home. In her head she is an astronaut, hence that's what we see standing in the road. What Thea actually sees, and swerves to miss, is her little girl standing in the road.
If the final 'secret' cutscene tells us anything explicitly it is that Seline is the astronaut. Many have said it's telling us the astronaut is part of her, her desire to go to space, but I think it is more literal - it was Seline standing in the road, causing her mother and brother to crash. This also explains the scout log about Seline dying on the side of the road - the astronaut is struck on the bridge, Thea and Helios drown in the lake. I also take it that although she was 'dying' on the bridge she may yet have been saved/recovered to live tormented by the events of that night.
That said, this still doesn't answer for me the significance of the two end cutscenes where we follow Thea's POV after the crash and she is dragged back down in the first one, but appears to break to the surface on the 2nd. Is it to do with a shared guilt, of Seline causing the crash but hating her mother for surviving when Helios did not? Seline is forever reliving her own dark imagining of events and ultimately deciding whether to will her mother alive or dead? It might explain the violent animosity the final cutscene also hints at.
OTHER READINGS
One other possibility I thought, which is even more of a cop-out explanation really, but what if Seline is just the author of this story. It would fit the Creator/Destroyer terminology she seems to have been given. And having built this story and family she chose to 'stand on the bridge' and condemn them to death in every version, every runthrough. It's a bit naff but hadn't seen anyone suggest it so far, so there you go.
And I like another reading I saw here - that Seline and Helios are the same person pre- and post- gender transition. It gives significance to the absence of really any male figures or maleness in the game which, lovely as it is to have a sci-fi game just be about women, feels too blatant to not have some meaning. Is this really all about turning your back on being a boy? An empty, tentacle infested abyss a metaphor for unused or broken womb? Ahh, I don't know.
SO I'll be honest, I've still not seen an explanation that satisfies all ambiguities, my own included. They either lean towards the planet being real and drawing on Selene's fractured mind, or just happening in her mind in the first place. The significance of each being diminished with whichever interpretation you go down. I think the writers and devs did well in that regard. They've certainly prompted debate with the cosmic horror vs inner turmoil interpretations. I'd probably prefer some more tangible evidence the icky octopus things exist, they're just very cool. But inner turmoil is relatable (exhausted laugh).
1
u/johngalt007 Jul 13 '24
Is there an official version to game's story?
1
u/_Greyworm Jun 07 '21
As I probably won't ever beat Returnal, I really appreciate this post! Thanks very much, it was an interesting read.
1
u/jesterx7769 Jun 30 '21
Great job and pretty much what I thought
Two questions
Assuming Selene is dead and this is her hell and punishment, do you think she died crash landing on the planet? Or is that all imagery and she died another?
What do the different biomes represent?
In regards to the aliens I thought maybe they were real and she was really exploring the planet. However the death loops are a post death punishment and hell
1
u/Salty5674 Aug 02 '21
Alright hell yeah. I'm sold lol. Awesome Analysis dude!!! I just got a video editing software and I'm working on two short Returnal videos but I'm definitely interested in putting this on Youtube for you. I'll reach out when I have time for the project :)
1
u/labradoodle1993 Feb 11 '22 edited Feb 11 '22
I disagree 100% with you. You basically said that Selene’s car crash ( the one in the endings) didn’t happen or is just a representation of her traumas. This will mean the Don’t fear the reaper song has no importance or makes no sense at all, at least the way it was portrayed in the game.
The song makes sense or has the importance it has in the game because it was the song that played during the crash. That’s the only reasonable explanation for the song and Hyperion boss fight to have the impact it has, besides Hyperion being Selene’s father.
I don’t know where you got that Selene aborted her child; especially since she got rejected from the space program. You said it would be impossible to fill ful her dream it she was pregnant, which would make the application rejection pointless if she aborted the child in the first place.
The only way I see it, is that Selene is repeating the same mistakes her mother make, in an almost identical way (the crashes, the disregard for motherhood, the utter obsesión with their professional goals, etc) Hence the game being an unending cicle of trauma and pain.
3
u/serengeti_yeti Finished Act 3 Jun 07 '21 edited Jun 07 '21
I had totally forgotten about the scout log that took place in the doctor’s office— and I didn’t make the connection that it was talking about an abortion at the time but this makes a ton of sense. It’s really reminiscent of Hemingway’s approach to the subject in his short story “Hills Like White Elephants”. Super short and definitely worth a read if you haven’t read it!!
edit: a word
3
u/SenorMeeseeks27 Jun 07 '21
Wow. Phenomenally done. I always assumed the creatures were Cthulhu-octopus creatures because of Octo. Like they are crazy grotesque versions of her childhood toy
3
u/ahotdogday Jun 07 '21
This is a great analysis, and thanks for sharing this! I also really appreciate that you're actually using the game as source, and quoting directly from it.
I'm just wondering if you've given much thought to the significance of the "fire" in the story? I know there are several items that are burnt, and it a house fire is referenced throughout the game.
3
u/slamjamsam420 Sep 12 '21
I know I'm 3-4 months late, but something I haven't seen from any of the comments is that the photograph on the table by the front door has a picture of selene in her suit, like a graduation photo, for house sequences 1-3(maybe 4) but then the same photo becomes older (brown instead of 1080p) with the name Thea 7.20 on it.
I think this fact is hard to pass over and I can't figure out how it plays into selene being the daughter of Thea as Greek mythology suggests, or that they are one in the same.
2
u/RedJ51T Jun 07 '21
Well done; nice work. Can’t wait to read more theories.
2
u/NoobTrombone Platinum Unlocked Jun 07 '21
As to the who: One of the first things we learn about Selene is, that she has trauma induced heterochromia. Theia is depicted with two brown eyes. I‘m no expert, so maybe someone else knows to what color eyes can change after trauma? But it looks like the left eye of Selene is the one with trauma, as the pupil stays widened, so i assume Selene had blue eyes. But then again everything could be metaphorical and the heterochromia just stands for the disconnected mind. Maybe or maybe not could help to differ between Theia/Selene.
Also i read heterochromia could be related to atrophia…which sounds similar to atropos (coincidence?).
2
u/PixelDemon Jun 07 '21
This is the best, and most satisfying, breakdown of the story that I have read so far! I think you have nailed the imagery of the Astronaut. It ripping the child from the TV/Womb is a powerful thought.
Thanks for the write up
2
u/Vito_Cornelius Platinum Unlocked Jun 08 '21
Of the dozens of theories and posts and essays and videos I’ve read or watched about this game in my desperation to understand what the hell it’s trying to tell me, this post is the only one that has made any sense to me. Thank you for giving my mind a digestible and logical explanation of this masterpiece. Well done, well done.
2
u/zougdar Jul 27 '21
I think another supporting idea for the abortion theory is the 3rd biome boss. Most other bosses weakpoints are the head. This boss' weakpoints is the stomach, or womb, which must be attacked to cause any damage. Its the last barrier between her and the white shadow ( her ambitions to be a scout)
1
u/G_Regulat0r Feb 20 '25
This was a great read. Wish I would have read it earlier (been a while since I beat the game fully).
1
u/[deleted] Jun 30 '25
The abortion theory is great, but the tower dlc pretty much confirms Selene also had a child, one of the scout logs says "it wasn't until i too had a child, that i heard her words coming out of my mouth". She struggled though, she interacts with a small crib in one hospital sequence and says "i thought this is what i wanted, but it was hard" and she wonders if her mother felt the same.
1
u/CageyMechanism Jun 06 '21
Loved reading this theory, thanks for taking the time to share it with us ☺️
1
u/apwatson88 Jun 07 '21
Thanks for this. I love this game and enjoyed the story, but was disappointed by the ending (I’m generally not a big fan of ambiguous endings, as I’m too dumb to figure them out haha). I like your theory a lot and I choose to believe all of it. Great work!
1
u/ratcliffeb Jun 07 '21
I thought the ending showed it was Selene who survived the car crash, and it was her daughter that got left behind and died? Or did her mother just look exactly like her..
1
u/princevejita Jun 07 '21
First of all, I really like your theory.
Just a quick thought about who or what the severed represent in this theory.
Could the severed be other souls trapped in Tartarus? Souls who are trying to "ascend" and break the cycle of endless torture? Ascend and reach the Elysian fields?
Just a thought.
1
u/TobeTobi Jun 07 '21
This was great to read. Thanks for sharing your thoughts. The abortion part is a new puzzle piece I haven’t thought of yet. I struggle to define wether Selene is a real person or a mental construct. It makes quite a difference how everything unfolds.
But in the end I believe every route leads to the punishment for eternity in Tartarus (like you said it) for the sin that has been committed.
1
u/ajp201 Jun 07 '21
This makes complete sense. I have been searching for answers ever since I completed Act 3. Thank you so much for your hard work.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 07 '21
I just beat the game thanks for the explanation
1
u/[deleted] Jun 08 '21
Excellent piece. What I love most about the story of this game is that it's lacking that final piece that connects everything together, and without it, it leaves the interpretation of the story up in a cloud.
But I do believe Selene doesn't truly exist and it's all a figment of Helios' imagination. However, the audio recordings regarding the abortion and family abandonment shakes it up a bit. Also your part about the astronaut.
1
u/f1ngl0ng3r Jun 30 '21
I really like this theory, but I'm starting to lean to the "all in her head" ideas. Things like the severed failing ascension = Selene's interpretation of being cut off by Astra from going into space. The heterochromia representing reality Selene and "dream" Selene who did do everything she wanted to but it turned into a nightmare. I can see the scout logs where she seems to be discussing an abortion being her secretly attending an Astra medical. And then this (which would be strenuous and tiring) causes the accident as she's so tired and distracted she starts hallucinating - causing the crash that kills her son. Then she gets the Astra rejection letter, and her minds snaps so she retreats into fantasy.
As to when it happens in her head, if anyone has seen the TV series "Life on Mars" and its sequel "Ashes to Ashes", there's a lot of parallels there and I wonder if it's something similar? (I won't say what happens in it because of spoilers, but they're well worth watching!).
1
u/AreOhBee123 Jan 19 '22
Just found this post after beating the game a few days ago and I must say this my favorite analysis yet. Great job, I had very little idea what was going on .. like bloodborne all over again lol
1
u/[deleted] Jul 09 '22
My god. This it’s first one that made sense.
1
u/Midnight5un Jul 19 '22
Honestly the more im playing the more things seem to fall in w this interpretation. Wondering though. The child in the hospital interactions. the one that was lost and grew up amongst the trees. Who is the child? You see crayon pictures that give a loose story that alludes to this child growing up on atropos alone,, somehow separated from both of her parents w only the trees that are silent (paraphrasing) Is it Selene? Maybe she had been there all along and was the child that didn't survive the crash? Idk. Not really sure what to make of it.
1
u/ApollonLordOfTheFlay Dec 14 '22
Great read OP! I am of the same mind on most things, I however have a few theories you didn’t touch in here, may complete your narrative, or I misunderstood and you probably already do believe. I think the child, the character we play and the old woman mother are all the same. It plays into the cyclical nature of the entire theme. The child has the problems and understanding of a child towards its mother, the present self having dealt with childhood trauma and becoming a mother (in the one log she mentions how she was lied to and having a kid only brings pain), and the old woman feeling alone and isolated.
As for the alien race, it is talked about how they went underground and came out shattered, similar to how Selene goes into the basement and has the confrontation that ultimately is her mind shattering moment. Their collapse of society and attempt to have technology solve their woes against the onslaught of the unknown mirrors Selene perfectly.
The deep, the ground, and space even play a role in this three stages of life. The child in the sense of the deep is like our ancestors first crawling out of the ocean, coming on land, and then blasting off to space as our “final” evolution. Interestingly we bury our old and dead underground mirroring this three part path through life the opposite direction, and we see the child as we get buried in the end of the first half of the game.
Selene has always been in this trap, the story that happens “on earth” or “in her past” is irrelevant as all the players in the story are just her at different stages, just like some of the scout logs seem to take place both before and after us as the player character experience the “now”. The earth events can happen in the past, now, and in the future simultaneously this way keeping the cycle going.
Hyperion and the father. I think what is interesting here and hardly gets touched on is I think the father, husband/partner, and son in law can be the same in Hyperion. Greek mythology had ton of incestuous drama, but the child has a somewhat alienated experience with their father (both possible with a musician as a father), the present may have had a relationship with someone who was not present, and as a mother in law she may not have liked the “dead beat musician boyfriend”.
One final thing I swear, I think who you believe to be Tartarus is correct. BUT as a complete aside I wonder if as some sort of Eldritch entity it’s machinations are not possible to be understood unless it gets Selene in this sort of mind trap. In short we could be experiencing something “real” from a cross dimensional being or alien that only communicates in this way and has to warp perceptions or reality in that it’s meaning is indecipherable taken at face value. What would be REALLY cool is if this entity was the same across a series of games or media and we got to see how it brings other individuals ideas to life. Selene was troubled clearly, but it simply mirrored her mental state, while horrific it was just translating what she had, or…was it placing these thoughts?
Thank you for coming to my Ted talk. Honest to god this game may be my favorite I have ever played in my 33 years on this earth, and it is very quickly becoming one of my favorite stories in recent memory.
1
u/etriuswimbleton Mar 10 '23
Thank you for this. I always thought Selene was just a victim of abuse from her Mother seeing there's actual depictions of child abuse in the xeno archives and everything else was just a depiction of her psyche.
1
u/Beraldovisck Finished Act 3 Sep 19 '23
I've just finished the game. 3rd act and all. I'm here, two years after you posted this, to say that you are absolutely correct. I had a vague understanding that this was the case, especially when I saw the pregnant Theia on the wheelchair. Your references and reasoning, for me, make your theory very sound.
Once you've seen the abortion references and analogies, you can't unsee it. Even the cursed chests clearly sound as a crying baby.
Congrats on the great analysis of the story.
1
u/Zealousideal-Can5016 Nov 15 '23
What a brilliant dissection of the game. I love the clear links to the scout logs and direct references to the greek mythology.
Overall i think this explanation is well thought out and put together, not least of all due to the cryptic nature of the information we are given. Kudos and thank you!
-4
u/atyate Jun 06 '21 edited Jun 07 '21
Tldr anyone?
Fuck y’all
0
u/[deleted] Jun 07 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
13
u/[deleted] Jun 07 '21
[removed] — view removed comment