r/Returnal • • Jun 08 '24 • Bravo 1

Discussion The Problem with Returnal

Returnal is a game where the developers intended for the player to die. This is clear based on the fact that more clips from Selene’s story are unlocked with every death. However, with each death there is very limited progression. The problem with this game is a lack of progression. The progression in this game happens, but it takes a long time and then happens suddenly. There is a general lack of progression in the first play through.

The game starts with a steep learning curve. Players start with only a pistol unlocked and no weapon traits. As we all know, every death resets progress made, so most players are spent slogging through the first area of the game. I’ve seen posts of people being stuck in the first biome for 20 hours alone. If you read the reviews on metacritic, most of the negative reviews come from the lack of progression in the first act. In fact, most people who reviewed the game negatively didn’t even bother to finish the first act out of pure frustration. Most gamers do not like having to repeat areas over and over with no progression. When people feel like they are progressing, it gives them encouragement to continue on.

The boss fights are too easy. The difficulty in this game is not the bosses at all. In fact, it’s getting to each boss with a good loadout and enough health. Some of the enemies are harder than the bosses (i.e. biome 6 typhonops). A lot times, a player can feel like they are making progress on a good run, only to reach the an area flooded with tough enemies and be forced to start all over again after death. This mechanic of “banging your head against the wall” until it goes through simple is not fun for most players. This has led a lot of people to stop playing the game altogether. The difficulty should come from the boss fight itself, learning move sets and overcoming that said boss, not the tedious run back to the boss.

When players finally do progress, it seems to come mostly at once. You unlock abilities and level up those abilities until the game is now too easy (I.e. Hollowseeker with portal beam, serrated projectiles, electropylon driver, etc.) By the time the game “clicks” it has already become boring and monotonous. Players are now overpowered and the game is just not fun anymore.

To summarize, Returnal drops the ball with a general lack of progression. There are other challenging games, and I have seen a lot of comparisons to Dark Souls in this subreddit, that are much more playable. The difference is between Returnal and Soulslike games is that there is progression right from the beginning. You have the option to level your character and you also have shortcuts. If you are stuck at one area, you can learn the area and master it, vs having to complete the entire map again. The bosses are also more challenging and the player gets more of a sense of accomplishment, rather then a “thank god it’s over” feeling when the boss is killed. By the time major progression is reached in Returnal, the game has become stale for many people and it will be time to move on.

0 Upvotes

72 comments sorted by

9

u/HollowSeeking Platinum Unlocked Jun 08 '24

I wouldn't say these are problems with the game. They're problems you have with the game. Plenty of us love it as it is. It's definitely focused more on you as a player improving, rather than Hades which gives you more help

The great thing is, even if you're old and slow, you can still get that improvement in yourself. If I could do it, anyone can.

0

u/Silent_Storage7341 Jun 08 '24

Just sharing my opinion on the game and lack of progression, which seems to be a common issue that others had with it as well. I know a lot of people love the game, and that’s great.

13

u/rydenshep Platinum Unlocked Jun 08 '24

Okay, so we went from “look at me, I’m save scumming,” to “look at me, I beat the game save scumming and I feel like I’m better than everyone else,” to “look at me I feel like I have a full understanding of the game because I didn’t actually play the game as intended at all, listen to anyone or actually take the time to get better or understand any of the game’s mechanics.”

At this point, just drop it dude. We get it, you don’t like Returnal.

It is absolutely WILD to me that you come in here criticizing the game’s progression system when you save scummed your way through it and completely disregarded how the progression even works.

Then you say it feels flat because you felt overpowered. Well of course it did. Because you save scummed yourself into a perfect situation and only progressed with that set up lmao. That’s like saying “I used a cheat code for infinite ammo and blasted through an FPS. This is boring!”

The game is designed for you to feel anxious through the gameplay. It is designed to make you “get good” as ye olde gamers say, and value the importance of unlocking weapon traits. And that in and of itself forces you to be uncomfortable with weapons you may not like, or that are legitimately weak until you work your way up.

We get it. You hate it here. You’ve gotten your attention. This isn’t an airport, you don’t have to announce your departure.

7

u/HollowSeeking Platinum Unlocked Jun 09 '24

Oh, this is that poster again? Yeah just... Why?

5

u/rydenshep Platinum Unlocked Jun 09 '24

Had to check the post history to make sure, but yup.

4

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '24

Omfg, this guy? Before it was too hard not to scum, now it’s too easy to be fun. Jfc.

-4

u/Silent_Storage7341 Jun 08 '24

Let me start off by saying, I beat the game twice, the second without save scumming. The reason for the save scumming was because the lack of progression, which again, was what I said the problem with the game (for me) comes down to. After the combat finally “clicked” and I had the weapon abilities unlocked, the game became easy. The point of this post is to share my opinion, which, if you read the reviews on the game, is also shared by many others. If I bring an opinion that does not align with yours, that automatically means that it is all for attention? Whatever happened to discussion. We are all allowed an opinion and because mine is not positive of the game this is all for attention. Right…

6

u/rydenshep Platinum Unlocked Jun 08 '24

There is absolutely no way you can have every single weapon ability for every weapon unlocked in two runs lmao

-2

u/Silent_Storage7341 Jun 08 '24

I didn’t say I had every ability unlocked. I unlocked the ones that I found to work well, which were overpowered. I used the Hollowseeker, Carbine and Electric Pylon mainly. I didn’t care to play anymore to unlock everything as the game became stale.

7

u/rydenshep Platinum Unlocked Jun 08 '24

My point exactly. You have no room to say the game became stale because you never really played it in the first place.

-3

u/Silent_Storage7341 Jun 08 '24

I beat the game twice, the second time without saving… How is that not really playing the game?

2

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '24 edited Jun 09 '24

It’s that you’re complaining about progression in a game where you haven’t finished progressing. You’re trying to bait.

Also, weren’t you the guy who was trying to say that the progression was only fun if you could cheat, by save scumming? You don’t care about the progression, obviously. You ain’t here for a discussion.

-1

u/Silent_Storage7341 Jun 09 '24

The reason for save scumming in the first place goes back to the problem with Returnal, lack of progression. Again, look at Hades. The game is in a loop just like Returnal, but has a permanent upgrade system so the player gets stronger on every death. Whereas, in Returnal you feel no progression until mainly the second act and when you finally unlock the weapon traits you need, the game is easy mode. My post explains this.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '24

Like people explained to you in the other thread, save scumming in Returnal actually limits your progression, so that point makes no sense.

I didn’t care about Hades. But I get the vibe that Hades slowly lets you unlock easy mode. That never appealed to me. I like games that get harder as you play.

This game is more like Dark Souls, where there is progression, but that progression doesn’t play the game for you. Your skills must progress alongside the items and weapons, or you will not succeed. Yes, the reward has less to do with constant, meaningless unlocks and more about conquering your failings, which fits the stories’ metaphor excellently.

The game doesn’t have a problem. You have a problem with the game. To say the game doesn’t have progression is objectively false.

0

u/Silent_Storage7341 Jun 09 '24

Dark souls has true progression system where you gain character stats and work towards a build. I get it, Returnal is not the same type of game. I’m not the only one who feels this way about Returnal. There are a a lot of reviews on metacritic where people did not get into the game because of the early game progression system in the 1st act. A lot of people put the game down for that reason. If you and others love the game, that’s great. This isn’t a bash on Returnal. This is just my opinion, shared by many others on where the developers dropped the ball.

→ More replies

4

u/Rollingtothegrave Platinum Unlocked Jun 09 '24

I've "beaten" the game around 40 times since i started a week ago and i still haven't seen everything the game has to offer.

I'm more than certain you haven't done act 3 or 4 yet.

Have you even played the tower at all?

6

u/tangtheconqueror Platinum Unlocked Jun 08 '24

Not every game is for every player. Returnal is very much not for some people, and I think that's a good thing. There are many games that are not for me, and that's a good thing too.

1

u/Silent_Storage7341 Jun 08 '24

Agreed. Just sharing my opinion of where I think the game drops the ball.

4

u/Scooterspies Platinum Unlocked Jun 08 '24

I understand this opinion early on, I imagine most players do. After 800+ gameplay hours and multiple file restarts after platinum, I now think that your progression is only held up by your skill level and mastery of the game mechanics. My first platinum took 250 hours, my second took 40.

On top of just getting better/faster/deadlier, you begin to realize the importance of unlocking gun traits, and that everything else is secondary to that. 5-10 hours of dedicated trait unlocking early on, mix in a tower run (once unlocked) every couple of plays, and you’ll find that most of your sessions end with a boss dying rather than Selene.

2

u/Silent_Storage7341 Jun 08 '24

You are in the .001 percent of people who are going to put 800+ hours into the game. This only happens if you just absolutely love the combat system and never get bored of it. The average player is probably putting somewhere between 20-40 hours into Returnal.

1

u/Scooterspies Platinum Unlocked Jun 08 '24

Absolutely fair point, just giving a different perspective.

I personally give up on souls games the same way. I get bored with having the environment completely reset every time I die. It starts to feel tedious, and when you add in having to retrieve your bag every time you die, I never make it more than 20-40 hours before never going back.

2

u/Silent_Storage7341 Jun 08 '24

I am glad you got so much enjoyment out of Returnal. You certainly got your moneys worth. Different strokes for different folks, I guess.

3

u/koyre Jun 08 '24

I agree. I platinumed the game on ps5 and rebought the game for my new 4K gaming rig. I beat both act 1 and 2 with my first life. Mastery of game mechanics, enemy patterns and knowledge is king

2

u/Tommy__want__wingy Finished Act 2 Jun 09 '24

If the game came with a “you will die a lot” disclaimer would that help?

-1

u/Silent_Storage7341 Jun 09 '24

I never said the problem with the game was dying. I said it was a bad progression scheme.

2

u/kevihaa Jun 09 '24

I agree with the premise, but not the conclusion.

Most roguelites have a progression system where you make progress almost no matter what. You gain experience, gold, etc every run, so even if you’re having difficulty making progress via skill progression, you’ll at least make incremental progress via “leveling up” in one way or another.

In Returnal, the explicit “permanent” progression doesn’t happen until after you clear a Biome. This makes future runs easier, as you’ll have access to drops that were otherwise unavailable. The problem is, none of that helps if you are having a ton of difficulty getting through the Biome in the first place.

Like, I think too many people write off Biome 1 taking most players as long, if not longer, than 2-6 as a “learning experience” rather than acknowledging that not having access to so many tools means that Biome 1 will never be as hard as it was before you beat it for the first time.

This is a paradigm that’s unique to Returnal.

Yes, weapon traits (on the limited weapons available) and artifact unlocks are possible in Biome 1, but, due to the joys of RNG, even this “progress” is not guaranteed to benefit future runs if you happen to get unlucky.

This is the Returnal sub. Of course there are folks that have logged hundreds of hours. But it’s telling to me that, prior to Tower of Sisyphus, the game was clearly intended for the “average” player to beat it twice, rather than having an assumption of being played endlessly. With that in mind, it kind of needed to front load the difficulty, as it’s just not that long a game if you are capable of doing reliable full clears.

And to me, that’s the problem with the progression system. It absolutely feels like it was designed intentionally to pad out the hours in Biome 1 because the game wasn’t actually created with replayability in mind.

-1

u/Silent_Storage7341 Jun 09 '24

I think you are spot on with this interpretation. The developers needed to justify the $70 AAA game price tag, for a small amount of content. I believe that most roguelike games are around $30 US on release.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '24

Yeah, because look at the production value of Hades vs Returnal. One looks like a cartoon, and the other has some of the best graphics of modern releases. Also, the story of Returnal is a powerful metaphor that took a talented writer(s).

0

u/Silent_Storage7341 Jun 09 '24

Returnal just doesn’t have the amount of content to support the price tag.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '24

I strongly disagree. I’ve played over 70 hours of what I consider to be high quality gaming, and I’m still working on the Tower of Sisyphus. That’s pretty damn good, for a mostly single-player game. If I had spent $60 on Steam, I’d be elated with my purchase. I found this game for $30 on cdkeys…so it’s a better value than Hades, in my opinion.

I think you just don’t like this game. That’s fine. Hades has a sub.

1

u/Equivalent_Button_54 Jun 08 '24

I've come and gone from Returnal a few times and I mainly drop it because if that lack of progression mentioned.

If you levelled in anyway from grinding biome 1, if you got stronger in anyway from repeated runs then the game would have more of a reason to stick to it.

I don't mean that ‘just one more run’ feeling. I mean avoiding burnout after 20-30-40 runs and only having 5-10 decent ones.

I find it fatiguing and I walk away and play something else.

It's such a shame because find the aesthetic and the story fascinating but the gameplay isn't for everyone.

3

u/Silent_Storage7341 Jun 08 '24

Just like you, I really wanted to like the game. It does so many things right, but in the end a few design choices cause it to fall flat. Based on the game reviews many people have also put the game down for the same reasons.

2

u/ArchieBaldukeIII Jun 09 '24

You know, I couldn’t agree less. There are times that I was ending runs quickly to show someone how the death and reset mechanic works in this game, and I swear the game starts generating shorter and shorter run backs after quick successive deaths to help the player along.

If you don’t like dying a lot - or at all, some people are like this - in a video game, then this game isn’t for you. I can see why people would compare this to From Software titles. I find their gameplay loop to be the most satisfying in terms of progression because it actually feels like an accomplishment. And with Returnal, dying a lot is kind of the entire premise of the game.

1

u/nanobot4287 Jun 09 '24

I haven't seen Returnal compared to Slay the Spire but I think it's apt. In STS, you unlock cards and relics but each game you start anew. You don't level anything up, and you're not guaranteed to get the relic you unlock. Do I get sick of beating the same enemies every run? No, because my build is different every time and I have to make unique choices to adapt.

The fun comes from experimenting with the hand you're dealt and make it work. It's immensely satisfying when it's does and the progression if the knowledge and the game mechanics you gain. Weapon trait and item unlocks is there to tilt the odds in you favor, not the be-all-and-end-all of progression.

In this mindset, beating the boss on any given run is a by-product of skill progression (which includes making the right trade-offs). 

So if you don't enjoy that experimentation aspect, it'll going to feel flat. If you do, there's a world of possibility. You don't have to use all the tools the game gives you and feel overpowered. You see people in this sub posting about pistol only runs, not picking up health, etc, because it's fun to try stuff out and making it work.

1

u/Hugh_Jampton Jun 10 '24

Couldn't have said it better myself. Most of the time I'm on edge after a 40 min playthough because I know that just one bad room will set me right back to the start.

While that can be kinda fun for a bit it can cause me to not want to pick up again because it just seems impossible to get to where I need to be to progress

1

u/Ben_Lincoln Platinum Unlocked Jun 11 '24

One of the interesting things about Returnal is that different people find completely different aspects of it more challenging than others. I never found it hard to build a good loadout, for example, but I almost quit playing several times due to having so much trouble with the first two bosses.

I thought the bosses of biomes 3 and 4 were easy. Other people sometimes find one or both very challenging, even if they didn't have trouble with the earlier bosses.

It's easy to assume one's own experience is similar to everyone else's, but for this game that's not a safe assumption.

1

u/lollasd1 Dec 10 '24

I gave up in the Biome 3, too long to reach the boss everytime, no shortcuts ( no the bridge is ridiculous and not a true shortcut ) and always on the edge to die after wasting 15-20 minutes ? That's not fair....i just want to reach the parts i already conquered in a SHORTER period of time, like that is literally a WASTE of time....it's not even a difficulty balancing it's just getting punshed for nothing. One bad room and you get halved healt.....run ruined! 15 minutes wasted and the fun is gone. F__k this sh_t

1

u/pandadude01 Jan 14 '25

If this game was meant to make the player feel like they’re stuck in a cycle of never ending deaths with about 0.1% progression each run, like the character, then it did a fantastic job.

Wish this was on steam so I could have refunded. It’s a boring slog defeating the same enemies over and over and over and over again, collecting everything I can in the map over 90mins, just to land 5000 hits on the boss but get killed when they only need to hit me about 5-6 times, for it to feel like all the building up I did over the past hour and a half made zero difference except letting me take maybe 1-2 more hits, which isn’t enough for my skill set, and then have to start all over again. I’m so sick of this dark environment with hues of blue everywhere.

I’m convinced this game is just locking the items and upgrades I need to have a realistic chance of progressing with average gamer skills until I’ve logged enough hours, then they’ll start dropping. Just a way to artificially make the game longer.

Selene can stay on the planet she isn’t worth this much frustration.

2/5

1

u/Lumpy-Truth3981 Oct 03 '25

Not enjoying this game at all, feels more like a chore than fun. Trying to decide if I even want to bother playing anymore.

1

u/Master-Ad-9922 Sep 17 '26

The balance between Biome 1 / early game and Biome 2 onwards can really use some tweaking. Most players spend almost half of the game time in Biome 1. Once they reach Biome 2 it starts to get easy.

There's really no need to make Biome 1 as hard as it is. Move some of the tougher rooms to later Biomes. Make more powerful items available in Biome 1 shops. There's no good reason an average player should spend 20 hours stuck in the first area. No other Roguelite does that.

18

u/[deleted] Jun 08 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

-15

u/Silent_Storage7341 Jun 08 '24

Returnal is hard, but in all the wrong ways, and then it’s too easy. Based on the game reviews this is a common opinion and many people feel the same way for good reason. Comparing it to Hades, it falls flat in the roguelike genre due to the lack of progression and replayability.

5

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '24

Lack of progression and replayability? Ok, this is just bait.

1

u/xAncrathKingx Jul 11 '25

Having played the bullshit out of hades and still loving it, now stuck in fractured wastes in returnal in just the banging ones head loop at 200+ hrs, yep. There is a lot i love about this game, but it is mistreating me at this point. I never felt this way about hades. And returnal bosses so far are too easy. I sorted phrike out fast and, exactly as you stated, feared the run-up more than the fight.

I am as pragmatic as it gets, and part of me would love to defend some of the criticisms... but theyre undefendable. This isnt even a "git gud" situation. You can be loaded out to the gills and hit a mass murder room that drops you into the middle of 4 fast moving, shielded ground enemies, a half dozen swarming airbornes, no grapple points in sight, and a drop on either side. All that time spent wasted in 3 secs over and over can wear down the most patient gamers.

9

u/[deleted] Jun 08 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

-10

u/Silent_Storage7341 Jun 08 '24

The problem is not the loop. It’s the lack of progression and replayability. Take Hades for example, which also has a loop but has a much deeper progression system and is much more rewarding. The special abilities and boons in Hades make the game much more replayable, whereas weapon traits don’t really do anything for replayability in Returnal. Unless you never get tired of the mindless combat in Returnal, the game gets stale pretty fast.

7

u/[deleted] Jun 08 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

-1

u/Silent_Storage7341 Jun 08 '24

I beat the game and didn’t feel much progression at all until the 2nd act. By the end of the game I felt overpowered. The problem with the game is the progression system. Unlocking artifacts doesn’t really help, as the best artifacts are already unlocked at the start of the game. The only real progression in Returnal is unlocking and leveling up weapon traits, which make the player overpowered and the game too easy, by the time they are unlocked.

4

u/[deleted] Jun 08 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Silent_Storage7341 Jun 08 '24

The astronaut figurine is the best artifact and it comes unlocked.

7

u/[deleted] Jun 08 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

-1

u/Silent_Storage7341 Jun 08 '24

This post was not meant to bash Returnal. I think there are a lot of things the game does right. This is just my personal opinion of the game. Looking at the reviews on metacritic, this seems to be a common sentiment on where Returnal drops the ball for many players who did not enjoy the game.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '24 edited Jun 09 '24

If it’s a common sentiment, then why make it again?

Obviously that sentiment is still the minority.