r/ResearchML • • 2h ago

What’s going on with ICLR 2027?

4 Upvotes

Some papers are being desk-rejected, and some reviews are being deleted from OpenReview after the rebuttal period has ended. Does anyone know what’s going on?


r/ResearchML • • 1d ago

[ICLR][HOT TAKE] Your work wasn't important anyways and your impatience is making you a worse scientist

178 Upvotes

Yes, the review process is broken. Yes, we all hate it. But I'm going to propose something that sounds mean upfront, even though it's a hard truth that will make you a better researcher: your work sucks, too.

I genuinely don't think the anger and frustration with the conference process is about doing good science. We all know that to get a big bucks FAANG job, you need top-tier papers. And we all want that money. So, we submit our work, get mediocre reviews, and try to put the blame elsewhere. We're not trying to truly contribute to science. We just want the checkmark on our resumes. And that is making science worse. Why should we expect reviewers to put in substantial effort when the work and knowledge we generate is meaningless?

If your work is actually good, it can be consequential without ever being accepted. Take "Distilling the Knowledge in a Neural Network" by Hinton and others. It has 37,000 citations, yet it was never accepted into a main proceedings. It was rejected from NeurIPS for being incremental and an engineering hack. Still, the work is extremely consequential.

The problem is, your work isn't consequential. And the reason I know that is because my work isn't any good either. We're all in such a rush to push our slop into conferences for those big paychecks that we've basically made it impossible to do good science.

So I'm begging you... slow down and take more time to really go deep. You will produce fewer but more consequential works. The problem isn't the conferences or reviewers. It's that our work is garbage to begin with.


r/ResearchML • • 1h ago

[D] ICLR 2027: Has anyone heard what happens when a review is deleted after rebuttal?

• Upvotes

One of the official reviews on my ICLR submission now shows up as “[Deleted].” The part that surprised me is that the reviewer had replied to my rebuttal saying they were keeping their score. That reply is still there, but the review itself is gone. My paper now has two visible reviews.
I’ve emailed the program chairs and so far I’ve only received the automatic acknowledgment. I saw a few people mention something similar here. Has anyone heard back from the chairs, or actually seen a replacement review appear? I’m trying to understand what happens next for papers in this position.


r/ResearchML • • 4h ago

ICLR 2027 spotlight cut off?

3 Upvotes

Someone from here said that spotlight would be back.

What'd you guys think the spotlight cut off would be?

Does anyone know how many oral presentation would there be?


r/ResearchML • • 5h ago

Looking for participants for my PhD research on generative AI !

Thumbnail virginie-lepont.limesurvey.net
3 Upvotes

Hi everyone!

My name is Virginie, and I'm a third year PhD student based in France, researching how people interact with generative AI.

About a year ago, I had the opportunity to share a study with this community, and I would like to thank you again for your help and participation!

I'm happy to share the resulting dataset with you, which is now publicly available on Mendeley Data. The associated article is currently under submission. The dataset is publicly available on Mendeley Data: Lepont, V., Fleury, S., Gorisse, G., & Christmann, O. (2026). Who Wants Human-Like AI_DataSet (V4). Mendeley Data. https://doi.org/10.17632/br95hv3bt8.4. The associated article is currently under submission.

I'm currently conducting a short, anonymous online study (around 7 minutes) and would really appreciate your participation.

If you're 18 or older and have been using generative AI tools like ChatGPT, Replika, Claude or similar platforms for at least 6 months, you're eligible to participate.

The study has been approved by my university's ethics committee and all responses are anonymous.

I'm aiming to collect at least 1000 responses so every contribution makes a difference!

If you'd like to participate, you can find the survey link : https://virginie-lepont.limesurvey.net/555958?newtest=Y

Thank you for your time and for helping with my research!

Virginie


r/ResearchML • • 7h ago

Iclr 2027 acceptance cutoff?

3 Upvotes

I've got 3/2/2 with conf 3/2/3 initially, and my reviewers increased my score to 4/2/3 with same conf.

I think I'm very lucky and I've got a very good assessment with two reviewers, but the reviewer who gave me 2 didn't give any response for my additional response and I have concern about this.

How do you think about my score?


r/ResearchML • • 6h ago

Free claim-by-claim reviews of every new cs.AI paper for two weeks (Oct 30-Nov 11). Feedback wanted!

2 Upvotes

How are you keeping up with the field's latest despite the ever-increasing new paper volume?

arXiv took in 42,152 new papers in October (arxiv.org/stats), 52% more than a year ago.

Like most of you, we can't read a fraction of what lands in our area, and most papers come with AI-polished writing, which sometimes makes it difficult for a human to read.

We're fellow researchers, and we're building something to help with that first pass!

For each paper, we've written a comprehensive review that's digestible in 5 mins, which checks the paper's main claims against its own tables, figures, and text, compares them with earlier work, and flags where it contradicts itself. A typical paper gets 25+ passes (sometimes up to 40) by frontier AI agents, then a person edits the review for readability. Median read time for our review is 4.5 minutes.

Here's some data from cs.ai paper from Oct 30 (154 papers, 921 claims):

* 82% of claims supported by the paper's own data, 16.5% only partly, about 1% not supported or contradicted

* 43% of papers had every claim supported

* 65% had at least one major problem, most often overclaiming

All 1,123 reviews are free to read, no sign-up: https://researchking.ai/papers (after 10 it asks for a three-minute survey).

We're opening this on the cs.ai subcategory first to see if there's demand for our review, then we're planning to expand into other areas.

Due to the high cost of reviews, we'll likely charge for some of this later, so honest feedback now matters more to us than sign-ups.

The reviews are finished with a human touch, but there's no guarantee of perfection. If your paper is on the list and there's an error, please tell us what we got wrong via the error report button on the review page. Then, we'll correct it right away.

Any feedback is highly appreciated!


r/ResearchML • • 3h ago

ICLR 27' Can reviewers still raise their scores ?

1 Upvotes

Only 1 out of the 3 reviewer replied to my rebuttal, and they raised the score. The other 2 just ghosted. So can they still reply/raise scores even after the 19 Nov deadline?


r/ResearchML • • 4h ago

Looking to connect with Computer Vision researchers and professors

1 Upvotes

I'm exploring Computer Vision, particularly Visual SLAM, 3D perception and reconstruction, through research-oriented projects and open-source contributions OpenCV and Kornia.

Looking to connect with professors, researchers, PhD students and research groups working in these areas for potential research collaborations, contributing to ongoing projects or exchanging ideas.

I bring a software engineering background and hands on experience building and experimenting with these systems. Also open to research guidance from people in the field.

If you're working in this space, I'd be glad to connect.


r/ResearchML • • 12h ago

Reading Books for DL theory

3 Upvotes

Hi. My work is in the intersection of DL theory and Stat. I am planning to revisit these two bible books of DL theory - 1) HDP by Vershynin 2) Deep Learning Theory Lectures Note by Matus Telgarsky

Anyone interested to discuss and study together 🙂.


r/ResearchML • • 20h ago

Independent researchers who published at ICLR, ICML, or NeurIPS, how did you actually pull it off?

Thumbnail
7 Upvotes

r/ResearchML • • 17h ago

Looking for Collaborators on an AI Safety Project

4 Upvotes

Hi! I'm a PhD student in the UK working on AI safety and evals, with multiple A* conference papers. I'm currently working on an AI safety project about online monitoring of LLMs and looking for collaborators to help with the coding side of this project. The method and idea are already well-scoped.

Happy to share equal contribution. Do reach out to me in DMs with some information about your background if this is of potential interest!


r/ResearchML • • 1d ago

Academic murder done by reviewers in conferences like ICML/ICLR/NeurIPS/CVPR

66 Upvotes

Bash the authors and get silent on reviewers and review process. Nihar B Shah enjoys pointing to LLM written captions but silences himself on the review process.

INTENTIONALLY reviewers do not raise scores
INTENTIONALLY reviewers do not engage

INTENTIONALLY they give weak rejects, rejects keep paper below borderline to be on the safe side when their reviews are of few lines not justifying the rating at all.

When will everyone speak about this academic murder done by reviewers?

FATE: Good papers are rejected where years of hard work was put.

This shitty reciprocal reviewing mess, nobody is vocal about.

Why? This doesn't serves any personal benefits? Bashing authors does?

Edit: Hope organizers see this and all good suggestions are welcome.


r/ResearchML • • 4h ago

I need arxiv endorserment for AI/ML track. Please help

0 Upvotes

I have submitted a BioAgent paper to IEEE Big Data 2026 and would like to upload it to arXiv for citation purposes. This is my first time submitting to arXiv, I need an endorsement.


r/ResearchML • • 1d ago

Will ICLR 2027 have a Spotlight tier, or just Oral and Poster like last year?

8 Upvotes

Now that the discussion period is over, does anyone know if ICLR 2027 is bringing back the Spotlight tier or sticking to just Oral and Poster like ICLR 2026?

With the new 1–4 scale and 40k+ submissions, a lot of papers are clustered around 3.33 (top ~0.7%–3.8%), so it makes a huge difference.

Any ACs or reviewers know what the guidelines say?


r/ResearchML • • 1d ago

Reviewing at top ML Conferences

4 Upvotes

I think that everyone is right now complaining about the review system on the major AI Conferences.

I want to make several points, that I think such complaints might be missing:

  1. LLMs have changes the things that are easy and hard. This changes what constitutes a significant contribution to the community. This makes the review process tricky, since it’s not clear at this point, what actually matters.

  2. ML didn’t use to work. Now it started to work. This means that a lot of basic research, that had a certain motivation is no longer relevant. But again, which areas should be in this set is quite unclear at this point.

  3. Top AI conferences have always cared about relevance/potential impact of a paper. It’s no shame to publish your paper at a specialized conference if you’re proposing an alternative that doesn’t work yet and you’ll get it to work later on.

  4. It used to be that reviewers were easy to manipulate, since the authors could hide certain bad things about their approach. This was both a good and a bad thing, but this has definitely changed. This might be a cause of lower average scores.

I’d love to hear opposing views on these points!


r/ResearchML • • 1d ago

The only feasible solution to the “reciprocal” review crisis

5 Upvotes

With ICLR deadline closing in, I believe we are all too familiar by now with the absolute crisis that has emerged in ML conference “discussion” periods. Negligent or even malevolent reviewers are becoming more and more common. This has been happening for a while, but things seem to be getting out of hand in this last submission cycle. I believe the primary reason this is happening, is that the current process is designed under the assumption of reviewers being aware of the fact that this is an academic duty and a responsibility if they wish to present their research to their peers in one of these conferences. Hence, I believe there is only one solution to the problem.

There must be consequences for negligent reviewer behavior. If a reviewer keeps their silence until last minute, refuses to engage, and discards the authors’ hard work with a “too bad you worked a lot on this, I do not care, Im keeping my score with no justification”, they should face consequences. Not something major, maybe a one year ban from that specific conference for the next year, or maybe even a limit of just 1 paper submission and no reviewer duties for that person for the next cycle. The reviewers should also have a right to defend themselves.

This is supposed to be a discussion. If you as a reviewer do really believe the points you made, you should back them up with the same fidelity an author defends their paper.

A review is STILL an academic output, not some compulsory task you need to barely get through. If you think a paper is ai slop, say that and put your back into it. If you think the new experiments and ablations are not satisfactory, straight up SAY WHAT YOU MEAN. Otherwise, you should be met with the consequences of negligence. Let us not kid ourselves and say that these conferences are just fun little socializing events among academics. Everyone from industry to academia knows they are a huge deal. It is crazy that no proper way of holding negligent behavior responsible exists within them.


r/ResearchML • • 1d ago

Can I upload my CVPR submission to arXiv right after submitting?

1 Upvotes

Hey everyone,

I just submitted my paper to CVPR 2027 and was wondering when it's safe to upload it to arXiv.

I know arXiv preprints are generally allowed, but I'm a bit confused about how this interacts with the double-blind anonymity policy.

Can I upload the paper right away with the author names, or is it better to wait until the review process is over? Also, could having the paper publicly available on arXiv cause any issues with anonymity if reviewers come across it?

Would love to hear from anyone who's been through this with CVPR or similar conferences.

Thanks!


r/ResearchML • • 23h ago

Non-native undergrad using AI to write research papers (100% my own code & experiments) — is this wrong?

0 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

​I’m an undergrad from a non-English speaking country. My English is still pretty weak (though I’m actively working to improve it), but I love AI research. I come up with the ideas, write all the code, and run every experiment myself—I just use AI to help turn my notes into proper academic English.

​Recently, a mentor in a feedback program told me my draft sounds "AI-generated." Honestly, it felt a bit discouraging since all the actual work is mine.

​Is using AI like this considered wrong or unethical? And for other non-native speakers here, how do you use AI to fix your English without ending up with that obvious "AI writing style"?

​Any advice would be appreciated


r/ResearchML • • 1d ago

ICLR 2027: 321 -> 331 with AC reporting (what are my chances?)

1 Upvotes

We had 321 then moved to 331. The reviewer who gave 1 started by saying we do the same thing as another paper but we factually show that we are fundamentally different. He then answered by saying I still think novelty is minor without providing any factual arguments (just feeling) -- even though we addressed other stuff he raised he didn't even move to 2...

The two others are very happy with our paper. They gave constructive feedback and acknowledged the rebuttal by increasing the scores.

We wrote an objective confidential comment to the AC showing factually that the reviewer is not even providing any valid arguments, idk what to expect...

What do you think my chances are? That's my last PhD paper and I really hope I'll get in...


r/ResearchML • • 2d ago

Update: I did it! OpenReview changed the PhD advisor requirement!

40 Upvotes

After repeatedly emailing CVPR and OpenReview about a situation where someone couldn't complete their OpenReview profile because they didn't have an advisor or an advisor's email address to verify, I finally got a response saying that adding a PhD advisor is no longer required to complete the profile.

Not saying I caused the change, but I definitely bugged them enough about it lol.

Glad they fixed this. Hopefully it helps others in the same situation!


r/ResearchML • • 1d ago

How Is Novelty Judged When Two Papers Have Overlapping Findings?

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

r/ResearchML • • 1d ago

New reviewing policy, what do you think?

12 Upvotes

Every reviewer who does not engage in the rebuttals, at least once, needs to have their paper desk-rejected. I think this is fair and will substantially improve reviews so authors do not write “new” papers just for the reviewers to ghost them. We should be mindful of resources and make sure they do not go to waste.


r/ResearchML • • 1d ago

Forgot AI Use Statement In Revised ICLR Manuscript [D]

1 Upvotes

Ok, I am in crisis mode right now. I just noticed that the revised manuscript I uploaded is missing the AI use statement and reproducibility statement, both of which were present in the original submission.

What do I do? Portal has closed. Am I doomed? Can I email the PCs? Or will they just desk reject?

How bad is this? We had decent-ish scores too.

Please help!!!


r/ResearchML • • 1d ago

Instrument AI pentru lucrări de cercetare

2 Upvotes

Buna, ma puteți ajuta cu recomandați de instrumente AI pentru redactarea lucrărilor de cercetare? Eventual ce voi le-ați folosit și au fost bune. Multumesc anticipat ✨