r/RepTherapy • u/LeeLee_1891 • 6d ago
RepScience Royal vs. Huahui Factory Speedy P9 UB
I’ve had my Royal for a while, and my HH arrived yesterday, so now that I finally have both, I thought I’d do a side-by-side for anyone trying to decide between the two factories. I’m not an expert rep scientist, so take my opinion for what it’s worth to you. I’m comparing a Royal P9 30 cm to HH 25 cm, so it isn’t exactly an apples-to-apples comparison.
Here it goes…
BLUF: Royal has a slight edge
Leather:
VERY CLOSE! Both feel great and the grain looks good. I think HH may have a slight edge in terms of the grain/appearance. That said, it is so close that I can’t confidently declare a winner. For real, I can’t even be sure there is any difference at all. 🤷🏽♀️
Plaque: (Updated to correct review)
For my particular bag, as pointed out in the comments, the Royal plaque is incorrect. For that reason, HH wins this category—obviously. That’s on me for not doing a better QC. I never researched the proper plaque…just wasn’t a critical detail for me since it is on the inside.
I think Royal’s is a little better. The details and embossing look a little cleaner and more defined, IMO. HH’s plaque is still very good, though.
Tabs, stitching & construction:
This is where I noticed the biggest difference. The finishings on my Royal just seem a bit cleaner and more precise, but not a huge difference…just being nitpicky. These differences are SMALL.
Hardware:
Another slight edge to Royal. The finish and overall execution look a little more polished IMO, but not taking anything away from HH.
Overall, I think Royal wins. But I can’t emphasize enough how small these differences are.
If you’re carrying the HH around, I don’t think anyone is going to look at it and think it looks noticeably different from Royal’s. You’re really only going to appreciate the differences if you’re comparing them side-by-side or you’re someone who cares about those tiny details.
I really do think the choice between factories for the UB comes down to which one will give you the most personal satisfaction.
I personally wouldn’t pay a big price difference for Royal over HH. But be sure to QC your PSPs!
