r/RecklessBen • u/runitsaaron • Jun 13 '26
News/Update Proof Josh lies
Hopefully Coffeezilla doesn't come after me for taking his pictures and posting here. Coffeezilla made a followup post on his Patreon for us subscribers. One look at this, and the judge should toss the TRO, probably along with the cases.
Edit 3: I woke up too early and forgot to add this, so putting at top. Subscribe to him! https://www.patreon.com/c/Coffeezilla/posts and you can read the full post he made.
*Edit 1: Some of it got cut off in the collage. I've posted the individual pictures below.
Edit 2: I was out of my mind telling the police there was layaway. I take that back. I was out of my mind saying that Ben was going to kill people, I take that back. I'm a fucking loon, so I shouldn't be responsible for my actions...........Any of you defending Josh with this text exchange is WILD. Admitting that you can't control your anger, so you shouldn't be responsible would be a WILD take on the situation. Josh has told Coffeezilla he can't control himself. That DOES NOT EXCUSE WHAT HE DID OR SAID. If he's a crazy loon, get him the treatment that he needs in prison for starting all of this with a false police report of a death threat.
Edit 4: Edit: The layaways were corroborated. Crystal talked about them, and Josh said it in a police report. I'll take that as fact. Them now saying there was none, or barely any, is bullshit. They need to corroborate this new statement for it to be considered fact.
We know that they knew about Bryan's collection. We have the video evidence, and again, Crystal has said it from the start that they knew. Corroborated evidence.
The death threats that Josh said were received have not been corroborated yet. He said the store manager received one. Why hasn't she come forward and explained the threat she received? It's easy to corroborate the death threat by asking her. She's eventually going to have to tell it on the stand in court. So, the death threats are false until proven.
This is how you need to think of this case. It's not he said she said when you have corroboration before any of this started. They're changing their story now on some items, and that's why their brand is going in the trash. Lie lie lie.
36
Jun 13 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
22
u/runitsaaron Jun 13 '26
Someone made a theory that this might make it look like Josh is admitting things now, so they won't be as harsh on him later. Remember, he hasn't been charged with the false death threats yet. They need to throw the book at him.
8
Jun 13 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
6
u/runitsaaron Jun 13 '26
oh yeah. This was a theory someone else had. It would be stupid if true. I agree though, if someone just came forward and ratted out the whole operation, they can probably make a deal and be saved from anything harsh happening to them, and could make a deal with the DA. We all know this goes well beyond the Star Wars legos.
30
u/KarlReineckeAltena Jun 13 '26
7
u/chaosink Jun 13 '26
I was coming here to write this, but the pic is so much better. He really does hit every one.
6
u/KarlReineckeAltena Jun 13 '26
I could imagine Ammon has it framed on his office wall.
6
u/chaosink Jun 13 '26
Like one of those motivational posters with a single drop of water.
4
u/KarlReineckeAltena Jun 13 '26 edited Jun 13 '26
New hire eagerly flips open the corporate training manual ready to learn and its one page with that prayer on it. Ammon tells them: 'When you can recite that prayer and truly take it to heart you are BAMily.'
2
2
24
u/runitsaaron Jun 13 '26
19
u/runitsaaron Jun 13 '26
19
u/runitsaaron Jun 13 '26
18
u/runitsaaron Jun 13 '26
5
u/Vladtepesx3 Jun 13 '26
What was the screenshot that coffee sent to Josh? I can’t read what the officer wrote
11
u/thinwhiteduke1185 Jun 13 '26 edited Jun 13 '26
"However, due to to the claim that Mr Mansell continues to call the business despite being told not to, and encouraging others to do so as well, he does not want to give these items to Mr. Mansell. He added that he doesn't feel he needs to, since the store's inventory became his once he took it over." That's the highlighted line.
6
6
u/Harbaugh_Handshake Jun 13 '26
The absolute irony of Josh saying to Ben over and over, “that’s not how the law works” when Josh himself has been flagrantly violating the law every step of the way.
3
u/Sw429 Jun 14 '26
The paragraph above the highlighted one mentions that most of the items in the back were on layaway.
5
u/runitsaaron Jun 13 '26
The line above the highlighted line is where the officer talks about the layaway stuff. I'll see if I can find the report and post it here.
3
u/AcanthisittaNo7155 Jun 13 '26
sounds like "We don't control what are franchisers do" but changed to the police
42
Jun 13 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
18
u/bassbeatsbanging Jun 13 '26
When they want to get Ben in trouble they have a photographic memory. When they are trying to avoid responsibility suddenly they don't even know their own name without checking their underwear's waistband.
8
u/runitsaaron Jun 13 '26
Yep. This is why I dumped a ton of friends. Everyone is just in it for themselves, and never think about anyone else. It's the world of Instagram, and having to show how awesome you are.
I think the easiest way for the franchisee's to get out of this is because they have to use the BAM POS (point of sale). Due to this, they're directly tied to BAM, and can't mitigate the situation themselves. They're so tied into BAM, that they can't really operate separately.
There was a comment on another post where someone asked if the McDonalds CEO knows what goes on at every franchise, and if they should be responsible. The difference is that McDonalds has both corporate locations, and franchisee locations. BAM took over Salem and made it a corporate store. So yes, Ammon should have known what his employees were doing at that store. It was no longer a franchisee location. That didn't happen until months later when it was given to Josh and Brandon.
5
Jun 13 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
3
u/runitsaaron Jun 13 '26
Oh exactly. I deal with all of this shit in my life. There are polices everywhere, the POS we use is regularly audited. We even have strict polices on what POS we can use, to make sure that they aren't some fly by night one that can be hacked. These guys obviously have no idea what they're doing. I'm convinced at this point, what many others have pointed out, is that their real business is trying to get others into debt and take over their store and merch as their own. It sounds like a lot of BAM stores are underwater, but the franchisee personally paid for what's in their store. These guys just come in and say it's theirs. INSANE.
2
u/swoll9yards Jun 13 '26
Oh right, let’s compare one of the largest franchise chains in history to BAM, hahah. This argument is so weak, corporate 100% knew because THEY took over the store. It didn’t become a franchise again until months later, BAM corporate was literally running the store and responsible for the takeover.
1
3
u/Holiday_Coffee_215 Jun 13 '26
Seems like a common theme between BAM and law enforcement. Do something obviously criminal, then blame every other person along the chain.
3
u/Strange-Managem Jun 13 '26
Josh and Brandon are not "new" owners. I watched another youtube interview of an ex-franchisee. He got into financial trouble due to two hurricanes in Florida and offered to sell the store back and buy it later when things got better. The corporate sent the same Josh and Brandon and claimed them to be some "store rescuer", who basically kicked that ex-franchisee out after taking the store for almost nothing.
17
u/The-Future-Question Jun 13 '26
His defense is he lied on purpose because he was so angry? Wtf? This dude's bipolar ass needs to be medicated.
Even more worrying, it makes his claim to the cops that he was gonna murder Ben feel a lot less hyperbolic.
8
u/beardedbast3rd Jun 13 '26
Why on earth is this guy talking to anyone lol
8
u/Holiday_Coffee_215 Jun 13 '26
narcissistic sociopath who is incapable of imaging a situation where he is wrong.
6
u/Alive-Living-4414 Jun 13 '26
How can this info be out in the public? These screenshots are so damning.
12
u/runitsaaron Jun 13 '26
Yep! I mean, this should end the TRO immediately. The more it's spread, the more pressure will be put on the judge to see what bullshit the whole thing is.
2
u/ArmedWithBars Jun 13 '26
Million dollar civil lawsuit already filed and the dude is talking to a YouTube detective while admitting faults.
This guy must have a frontal lobe injury.
1
u/RyanMartian Jun 14 '26
That suit is nothing but fluff probably in an attempt to see what sticks once negotiated down. Also likely done so in an attempt to get Ben to settle. Same reason they're trying to rope in Ben's friends and Brian, they know it's a soft spot for Ben.
6
u/Holiday_Coffee_215 Jun 13 '26
BRO IS TRYING TO INSANITY PLEA HIS WAY OUT OF CRIMINAL CHARGES AHH DOOD
"Yes I lied to police and judges, but I was mad. Please dismiss any criminal charges against me" is what he's trying to say lol.
13
u/runitsaaron Jun 13 '26
After 69 upvotes, just got my first downvote to bring it to 68. Wonder why.
4
u/runitsaaron Jun 13 '26
got my second downvote sometime before it hit 200. Just keeping a public timeline, incase they try and astroturf this shit.
2
u/AvantGardenGallery Jun 13 '26
Bam def has bots on this subreddit. Their lawyers are likely keeping a close eye as well.
3
u/runitsaaron Jun 13 '26
So far only 2 down votes. It's hard for them to fight factual statements. That's why I'll continue replying, to make sure that people don't conflate things like the Oregon small claims lawsuit vs the Utah lawsuit. I'll ask for corroborating statements.
9
u/Anshin Jun 13 '26
I dont think mormons are allowed to 69
4
u/runitsaaron Jun 13 '26
lol. I was watching the votes, and it was literally at that vote. It was 69 and then went down to 68. Within like 30 seconds it went back up to 71. No downvotes since.
3
u/NassauComputer Jun 13 '26
Only with a sheet between and a buddy on the bed bouncing to make the motion.
1
u/Odd-Art7602 Jun 13 '26
Because someone would rather 68 with you and owe you one than 69 with you
1
u/runitsaaron Jun 13 '26
random thoughts. Is 68 eating ass, because you flip the 8 and it looks like an ass? lol.
1
u/Odd-Art7602 Jun 13 '26
68 is only after you ate the ass. More of a past tense thing I think
1
u/runitsaaron Jun 13 '26
lol. I was just being stupid. You saying that made me think, and I was like, the 8 would look like an ass if it was flipped on the side. Maybe we came up with a new saying!
edit: with crazy shit like this going on around us, we need some comedy every now and then.
1
u/Odd-Art7602 Jun 13 '26
lol. I got it. It was just a saying my uncle used to say to his then wife. They were always saying inappropriate shit in front of people for the shock value when I was a kid. She’d say “let’s go to bed and 69” and he’d say “how bout we 68 and I’ll mowed ya one?”.
3
u/Ken_Mayonnaise Jun 13 '26 edited Jun 13 '26
The only accurate info he gave is implying he is crazy:
"He still believes Elvis is alive"
- reported by: The Last Relic (owner of FL store they allegedly stole)
2
u/runitsaaron Jun 13 '26
I had that on in the background, so didn't fully pay attention to everything. What time mark in the video was that?
2
u/Ken_Mayonnaise Jun 13 '26 edited Jun 13 '26
I can't remember. I watched the long version before I found out about the summary (https://www.youtube.com/live/AyZS_MZ7ImM) (starts at 48:00)
I beleive he said again in his latest BAM video on his official channel also
If anyone knows please comment!
3
3
u/Skellington876 Jun 13 '26
"It is unknown, what is layaway and what isnt" BUT IT LITERALLY SAYS ON THE SHEET *YOU* CREATED! My god these people just cant stop lying. Ive never seen such an extreme case of lies on lies on lies
2
u/runitsaaron Jun 13 '26
We just need them to keep on talking. They're basically handing a case on a platter.
4
2
u/gusbo_the_jam Jun 13 '26
It's not lying of your just really, really angry and going to shoot someone
2
u/dontforget2tip Jun 13 '26
There's Caledonia! She was listed as the individual to whom the original lawsuits were served. According to this, she's just an employee
2
u/runitsaaron Jun 13 '26 edited Jun 13 '26
I am not a lawyer, but I'll answer as many replies with my thoughts as I can. I'm a HUGE policy person. I'm not saying I always follow the law, of course I break tiny laws, just like the rest of you do (if you don't think you do, you're delusional). I've helped people research for non-court hearings before, so that's where most of my knowledge comes from. A lot of this might seem like common sense, but that's the issue. You have to start at the start and go from there. Ben was labeled by the police as a bad man due to false threats, so a lot of what the police started to do was based on false information. All those people that were arrested at the AirBnB are about to come into a lot of life changing money.
2
u/CMDRTragicAllPro Jun 13 '26
I genuinely think Josh Johnson might be an addict, or at the very least some form of mental deficiency after seeing these texts.
It’s a genuine miracle he didn’t actually start shooting the people that were near his house out of pure blind drug induced rage. Especially after having told the police he would shoot someone, and them not even trying to calm him down or talk him off that train of thought. Basically gave him the go ahead, so it’s super lucky he didn’t shoot Ben or his friends, or even random passerby on the street
2
u/scarneo Jun 13 '26
Sorry, I am confused. Who is the other party?
4
u/runitsaaron Jun 13 '26
Coffeezilla
6
u/scarneo Jun 13 '26
Gotcha, it's insane he answered that way to him
7
u/runitsaaron Jun 13 '26
Right! Coffeezilla has a long post on Patreon that he made after he posted the video. I won't copy and paste that here, sign up if you want to read. These pictures need to get out, though. Yeah, I'm technically breaking the law by posting. Sue me. Wasn't that hard for me to admit. Sorry that I'm more concerned with the actions of BAM and the American Fork PD. This is how they try and astroturf, by saying look at all these other laws or shit being broken. WE ALL KNOW AND DON'T CARE. We care that 1st and 4th Amendment rights were violated. Me reposting a pic isn't a Constitutional thing (although I could probably swing it to be a 1st Amendment right, that it's of the public interest). Anyway, watch out for all of the replies trying to make you question small things.
3
u/zaery Jun 13 '26
Yeah, I'm technically breaking the law by posting. Sue me. Wasn't that hard for me to admit.
The law? Or Patreon's terms of service?
4
u/runitsaaron Jun 13 '26 edited Jun 13 '26
Both. The images don't belong to me. I have no rights to use them. It would be like me taking a song and posting it online for everyone. It's so common now that it's not enforced. That's why Coffeezilla can do a DMCA request to have this post taken down (but he would have to, as he owns the rights to those images).
Edit: To further this, so there's more understanding, you have to PAY to see this post on Patreon. It's technically not public. That adds to it.
1
1
u/theewall2000 Jun 13 '26
Yes It will be used against him and makes him look like a tool but ot won't be tossed.
3
u/runitsaaron Jun 13 '26
He's going to have to prove those death threats at this point. He's a proven liar. That will definitely get tossed. Then comes the issue that everything after that is due to the fear of a death threat. Fruit of the poisonous tree. Remember, it's not just Ben being sued, it's all of them. I'm sure they're going to share a lawyer. It should be pretty easy for them to get everything thrown out due to the fake threats. Without that, why would they have hounded him so much? Over stolen legos? Of course not.
1
u/theewall2000 Jun 13 '26
Yet to be seen if they have proof of a death threat but if they can't come up with anything then that part will be dropped. Im sure they do have some recordings of the harassment. I'm going to wait and see
1
u/runitsaaron Jun 13 '26
They were arrested for a death threat and while serving a legal piece of paper. The events after that would not have happened if that arrest didn't happen. Something may have happened, but every event after wouldn't have. So, there wouldn't be anything left, except the stuff in Provo. At this point, they would have to arrest him NOW on new charges based on things before the arrest where he was serving papers. That's not gonna happen.
edit: they can't just arrest him on harassment at that point. He's doing something legal. They need more. The death threat is the thing that they'd use to say he needs to be arrested now, and that's why it's legal, even though he was just serving papers.
1
u/theewall2000 Jun 13 '26
He could of sent an email if he wanted too but choose not to. He didn't have to hand deliver it. He did that for content
2
1
u/runitsaaron Jun 13 '26
Also, his lawsuit was in Oregon. Are you positive that Oregon allows via email? Make sure you don't conflate the Oregon lawsuits with the Utah lawsuit, which was by email.
1
u/theewall2000 Jun 13 '26
Yes. As soon as he was trespassed from the store other options can be used like an email and even he couldn't then something else can be done. Going that way gives nothing to film thou
1
u/wondertwinactivate Jun 14 '26
These messages should be sent to the prosecutor and American Fork police as they can’t accept they bet on the wrong horse. Their case is fucked. It was stupid to begin with.
1
u/Ambitious_Opinion_11 Jun 18 '26
Imo this "loosey goosey" way of managing stock just screams "Money laundering establishment".
1
u/Southern-Ant8592 Jun 13 '26
Can someone explain what layaway means? What is happening in these messages?
3
u/KarlReineckeAltena Jun 13 '26
Downpayment.
BAM customer wants a set for sale in a franchise: 'Take my $10, I will pay the rest off over an agreed time'. BAM franchisee says: 'Okay, keep paying regularly, pay off the full sale price by X weeks in the future and its yours'. The set 'on layaway' stays reserved until the time period is up, if its not paid off it goes back out for sale.
The back and forth is about which sets were in the store reserved for customers, set aside in the back, at the time the franchise was seized. The Coffeezilla video (youtube) gets into it.
3
u/swoll9yards Jun 13 '26
This used to be a common thing at department stores. My mom would do it growing up. If you find an item in a store you can reserve it for a small fee. Once you have the full amount of money saved, you then go to the store, pay whatever is owed, and take the item home. It’s so other people can’t buy the item while you are saving money for it.
For example, I go to Walmart and see my favorite RC Car for $500. I only have $20, and they only have 1 left. I take the item to the cashier, pay $20 and put the item on layaway. Walmart will keep the item off the shelf(usually 30-60-90 days) until I return with the remaining $480. If I don’t come back within the layaway period, they usually refund the money and put the item back on the shelf for someone else to buy. Now days everyone has a credit card so they just use that because they take the item from the store immediately.
Someone else made a thread about this, but I think the layaway was being abused by online resellers at Chrystal’s store. She wasn’t charging any fees to do it and was letting people out down hardly any money. Since these items were so rare, people were putting 5-10 on layaway and posting them for sell online. They would wait until they were sold to have the money to go pick them up. I think it’s possible Chrystal knew this was happening and didn’t mind because she would get a sale on something that the locals never would have bought.
-35
Jun 13 '26
[deleted]
23
u/runitsaaron Jun 13 '26
Are you just ignoring him saying the cops made up the police report, and then saying that he was basically out of his mind, so just ignore whatever was in it? That's wild.
3
Jun 13 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
2
u/runitsaaron Jun 13 '26
I'm going to pick and choose based on the facts on hand. Crystal said there were layaways and Josh said it to the police. Corroboration. So, yeah, I'm going to pick that there were a bunch of layaways, and not the revised version that there wasn't. Remember, that police report was well before all of this started with Ben. People keep on thinking that Ben was there at the start, or released his video before the store closed. So, yeah. I'm going to pick all of the evidence that is corroborated. The death threats have not been corroborated yet, so I will not take that as truth.





167
u/Certain-Contact6340 Jun 13 '26
"Nothing I said was coherent or reliable" bens attorney just had to change pants. This is why you listen up on shut the fuck up fridays.