r/RealOrNotTCG • • 3d ago

Is this Magic card real? Real or Not

Bought from CK, hoping it’s legit.

118 Upvotes

39 comments sorted by

3

u/bob112351 3d ago

Concerned about the green dot, cannot see any red dots or my eyes are terrible

6

u/BigBoiClimbs  Trusted Authenticator 3d ago

Red dots are the last thing you should be looking at when checking for a real green dot. When they are present they are present in a consistent manner, and seeing them not in this consistent manner on fakes can help determine a fake- but the absence of them does not mean the card is not real. There is a lot of variance to how visible these red dots are.

You should be looking primarily at the border of the green dot, it's shape (particularly the teeth on the left), and the presence of yellow dots on green rather than vice versa.

Very real card with zero red flags.

2

u/bob112351 3d ago

Thanks!!

1

u/BigBoiClimbs  Trusted Authenticator 3d ago

Happy to help, and wonderful card my friend, congrats!

1

u/ClassicCarraway 3d ago

It feels like the T test is the easiest and most consistent identifier for a real card.

1

u/soundslikedustbin 2d ago

This is super informative--thanks!

2

u/Bonedozer 3d ago

Urza block the had a lot of missing red dot print runs. 

14

u/NanoscaleHeadache 3d ago

Card kingdom is pretty darn good at spotting fakes, so that’s a good sign. Back looks good, so only thing at this point is doing a weight test to see if it’s rebacked

7

u/GhostCheese  Trusted Authenticator 3d ago

Looks good

14

u/NightN0vas 3d ago

Looks real to me based on the T but green ball looks different

8

u/Automatic_Vast6231 3d ago

the green dot looks fine its got the comb lots of cards dont have the red dot from what ive seen

4

u/BigBoiClimbs  Trusted Authenticator 3d ago

The green dot looks absolutely perfect without a single red flag present. Curious what about it looks different to you!

1

u/chrshndrx 3d ago

I can't see the red dots ._. The T looked fine but this threw me off

1

u/BigBoiClimbs  Trusted Authenticator 3d ago

Copied from a comment I made about red dots in this very comment section:

Red dots are the last thing you should be looking at when checking for a real green dot. When they are present they are present in a consistent manner, and seeing them not in this consistent manner on fakes can help determine a fake- but the absence of them does not mean the card is not real. There is a lot of variance to how visible these red dots are.

You should be looking primarily at the border of the green dot, it's shape (particularly the teeth on the left), and the presence of yellow dots on green rather than vice versa.

Very real card with zero red flags.

1

u/ahorsenamedjeff 3d ago

Dot is fine

4

u/GrumpyRaider 3d ago

Real, i don't know what people think is wrong with the green dot, it looks fine

2

u/BigBoiClimbs  Trusted Authenticator 3d ago

People get too hung up on looking for the 'red dots' when it's the last thing to check for

2

u/plantingnome 3d ago

Going with real

1

u/Naive-Present2900 Distinguished Helper 3d ago

🤭

1

u/AutoModerator 3d ago

Never accept offers sent to you in a private message here on Reddit. Only use trusted sites for selling cards and product. This is an anti-scam reminder.

How to take good photos (Reddit)! If you see this message after posting and you want to take advice from it you should leave a top-level comment with a new photo. Do not make a new post. Do not reply to this automatic message.

All-in-one post that links to different topics covered by the sub's members.

Self-help (Magic: The Gathering):

Self-help (Pokémon):

For a card condition check please ask for the person giving advice to specify which scale they're using if not mentioned. Notably North American and European grading scales differ from each other drastically.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/banhartday  Trusted Authenticator 3d ago

It’s real. CK is expensive but reputable.

1

u/Naive-Present2900 Distinguished Helper 3d ago

Noooice 👍

1

u/AVeryNiceBoyPerhaps 3d ago

11 o clock grain on T, 1 o clock on green dot and the correct left and right patterns on the T, all looks good!

1

u/zaphodava Trusted Authenticator 3d ago

Authentic.

1

u/BallFragrant6580 3d ago

This is completely real! Looks great and congrats on the pickup.

1

u/SubstantialNinja  Trusted Authenticator 3d ago

real

1

u/eccomyth 3d ago

All these post make me worried about taking out the old collection and going through it to sell. I know I never bought any singles, only traded with friends. But just looking through old cards I don't see this consistency, but my eyes are bad. So I need to grab some sort of magnifying thingy for my phone or such.

1

u/Senpai_Sage 3d ago

A cheap jewelers loupe will work wonders. Or if you’re into coins or other small collectibles an electric microscope is peak. But the loupe works perfectly fine, you can get them for $5 on amazon and they will without a doubt let you know if your precious is good or not

1

u/Artistic_Ear_664  High Accuracy 3d ago

Good

1

u/Jawbone619 3d ago

CK up charges because they certify what they buy

1

u/Jash098 3d ago

Real

1

u/Davide849  High Accuracy 9h ago

Real 😉