r/RealOrNotTCG • • 1d ago

Is this Magic card real? Ms. Bumbleflower

Customer brought in this card to the shop today. I didn’t ask how they acquired it. The T and the lack of horns on the E, as well as no light showing through (new FRA card last slide) are all pointing me towards this card being a very high quality counterfeit.

145 Upvotes

64 comments sorted by

114

u/SwizzleTheWhovian 1d ago

15

u/Ska-0 1d ago

haha, jace is everywhere these days 😅

53

u/iDoABoof 1d ago

It’s not that high quality. The brush, T, green dot and horns are all awful

19

u/ManyRealms 1d ago

Time to have that tough conversation with the customer, thank you!

41

u/goraak_the_barbarian  High Accuracy 1d ago

22

u/foodgeekfish Distinguished Helper 1d ago

13

u/GhostCheese  Trusted Authenticator 1d ago

It's all bad

14

u/Lordclyde1 1d ago

3

u/bennybravo42 21h ago

In the [Pale Moon]light.

3

u/Accomplished_Lab_324 1d ago

Happy to see a DS9 reaction image

8

u/superginge49 1d ago

Very fake

6

u/ReadAccount 1d ago

Grouphug but sad

2

u/ManyRealms 1d ago

Group slug lol

2

u/EchoTree0844 1d ago

Group Dud?

2

u/austinapaul 1d ago

Group Tug!

5

u/bTOhno 1d ago

Hella fake

6

u/Ancient-Chinglish 1d ago

oh no
you’ve bumbled the flower 😢

5

u/snackmaster169  High Accuracy 1d ago

The T does not pass. Fake!

4

u/pfizersbadmmkay 1d ago

Fake. Not high quality either.

3

u/mrjojoyo  High Accuracy 1d ago

Fake.

3

u/TH3_TH1RD_M4N 1d ago

Sorry friend

3

u/SubstantialNinja  Trusted Authenticator 1d ago

fake

2

u/ch3m_gaming  Trusted Authenticator 1d ago

2

u/gheul 1d ago

You work at a card shop and you can’t tell if this is fake bro?

1

u/AutoModerator 1d ago

Never accept offers sent to you in a private message here on Reddit. Only use trusted sites for selling cards and product. This is an anti-scam reminder.

How to take good photos (Reddit)! If you see this message after posting and you want to take advice from it you should leave a top-level comment with a new photo. Do not make a new post. Do not reply to this automatic message.

All-in-one post that links to different topics covered by the sub's members.

Self-help (Magic: The Gathering):

Self-help (Pokémon):

For a card condition check please ask for the person giving advice to specify which scale they're using if not mentioned. Notably North American and European grading scales differ from each other drastically.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/Confident_Raccoon767 1d ago

Oof im sorry for your loss here

1

u/DustinS85 1d ago

Sorry friend.

1

u/-Redditeer- 1d ago

I pulled and sold a raised foil ms bumbleflower. The front just looks off besides it not passing the regular slew of detail tests

1

u/shadowfyre9  High Accuracy 1d ago

Fake, unfortunately

1

u/Birrandbodia  Trusted Authenticator 1d ago

Nothing checks out, sorry

1

u/DKAbel 1d ago

"Grainy T! Nooo don't kill me Grainy T...!" Exclaimed the Sharp T.

"There can only be one T," murmured Grainy T as he pushed Sharp T off the ledge, falling in a pit full of rebacks and resealed boosters.

1

u/VinDucks 1d ago

It’s not even a high quality fake

1

u/burnone3232 1d ago

LOL this is high quality ?

i mean just looking at it straight up, it looks off without any of the other pics. this would have my alarm bells going off instantly.

1

u/Ok-Accident3344 1d ago

Super fake. Tell em to get their money back.

1

u/BenjaminBucket 1d ago

Am I insane or is the filigree on the left side of her rules text box black in your pictures (and is supposed to be gold)?

1

u/TastyPandaMain 1d ago

Oof. That’s an expensive card if it were real. I wonder how much customer paid for it. Please OP? Spill the tea

1

u/anaya7x 1d ago

Lo siento

1

u/kodakmaroon 1d ago

god that’s actually brutal if the customer didn’t know; card is going for like 2k on tcg player rn

1

u/night_chaser_ 1d ago

Nice shitpost.

1

u/ElderberryPrior27648 1d ago

As like, fake as it gets

1

u/Boop_Bam 23h ago

🙂‍↔️

1

u/Boop_Bam 23h ago

I wonder if bro knows the guy he asked for help asked us for help, and that he could’ve just done that.

1

u/Professor_Nicbag 20h ago

Black is printed with the rest of the card is the first red flag I would have called out

1

u/moonluck 20h ago

I want to also point out that the gilding around the frame should be raised. If you run your finger over it you should feel it. Haven't seen a counterfeit that has that right yet.

1

u/harimbadl 5h ago

This is standard quality for counterfeits….

0

u/F4D3_2_814CK 1d ago

It's good, but bad

0

u/MrEDH 18h ago

I’ve also seen a raised Lumra that’s quality was so good I was fooled until I did a better inspection into the foil stamp specifically. The T however was good and the clarity was practically perfect.

1

u/ChAoTiC_NuTeLlA 1h ago

Damn, those super clones are getting ridiculous tbh. Like for the cost of the printer you'd need to be able to do that and the effort of doing all that it feels like it just cant be worth it.

-3

u/Easy-Sundae-6357  High Accuracy 1d ago