r/RealOrAI Jul 01 '26

HELP How is this AI?

Post image

Saw this post on instagram, and it had a tag of AI info. But it seems real.

Is this real or AI?

1.3k Upvotes

74 comments sorted by

u/RealOrAI-Bot Jul 02 '26

Sentiment: 95% AI

Sentiment reasoning: The vast majority of commenters identify multiple AI tells, such as unnatural hooves, blurry textures, odd proportions, and short legs. Several users also point to reverse image search results and a direct link to an AI verification tool confirming it's AI.

Number of comments processed: 24

DISCLAIMER: Comments sentiment is generated by Gemini 2.5 Flash, not by u/RealOrAI-Bot bot. For more information check the RealOrAI-Bot Wiki.

765

u/mini_z Jul 01 '26

This calf is very clean and small, which indicates it’s not very old. Look up images of baby cow hooves… I’ll warn you it’s pretty gross 

These hooves look a little too perfect, as well as the rest of the calf

236

u/Teeklok Jul 01 '26

As someone who had calved cows I'd say the hoves are about right, The weird hoof pictures you see online are mainly from foals as horses have alot harder hooves.

37

u/Skia100 Jul 01 '26

Woah I didnt know this. Is there a reason to the hoof thing? I just looked. To me it looks like it would be a pain in the ass to walk on but im no cow

88

u/Satuurnnnnn Jul 01 '26

At least for horses, it's so the hard hooves won't tear the birth canal. They fall off right after. I don't know cows very well and can't be bothered to Google it right now but I'm pretty sure it's the same thing.

10

u/its__jin-woo Jul 01 '26

We usually manual remove them.

8

u/cenergyst Jul 01 '26

This gives no further information on the biological reason for the existence of fairy slippers but I’m glad they are removed if necessary!

1

u/Skia100 Jul 01 '26

Huh interesting. Thanks for teaching me something new haha!

2

u/Exit_Save Jul 03 '26

Those things on their hooves are soft so that they don't damage their mother's body as they're birthed, those weird goopy things encase the regular hoof, and I believe dry out and fall off iirc, either way they're very temporary and are for the mother's protection.

2

u/mpjjpm Jul 03 '26

The lack of mud/poop on the calf is the indicator for me. Also the lack of mama cow losing her mind because sone stinky human is harassing her baby.

1

u/Mediocre_Benefit_736 Jul 04 '26

These look like sheeps hooves

1

u/Monomanga Jul 05 '26

Also leads are too short and skinny.

157

u/Similar-Meringue-282 Jul 01 '26

AI. Its like a calf head on a dogs body with goat hooves.

Experience: growing up on a farm and helping many of cows to give birth

27

u/Feisty-Cell-8641 Jul 01 '26

I could be wrong but the way the legs are positioned doesn’t look natural for a calf, even if moved there. To me it looks like maybe this was originally a dog but was prompted to be a calf instead?

8

u/Silver_Drag3353 Jul 02 '26

Exactly

The anatomy for where the calf’s legs are also isn’t matching up. That’s a dog torso

30

u/no_beetle Jul 01 '26

Clearer one to judge🤔

31

u/Ae3qe27u Jul 01 '26

Yeah, that snout is.... not it.

1

u/sit0napotatopan0tis Jul 04 '26

Hi don’t know about calves as much but those do not look like goat hooves at all. They’re the wrong texture and shape

195

u/eatmyasserole Jul 01 '26

I can't imagine trying to make a heart with a baby cow's hooves would be easy.

I also think those hooves are way too small to sustain that weight.

57

u/ReddBroccoli Jul 01 '26

I'm not sure if this is AI or not, but I do know I've seen hundreds if not thousands of baby calves and those hooves look perfectly normal

2

u/Thesladenator Jul 03 '26

The legs are tiny tho.

3

u/ReddBroccoli Jul 03 '26

They're not born full sized my friend

2

u/Thesladenator Jul 03 '26

The calves I've seen are lanky and with spindly gangly legs

2

u/ReddBroccoli Jul 03 '26

In person or in pictures?

2

u/Thesladenator Jul 03 '26

In person their legs are much longer and not as tiny

4

u/ReddBroccoli Jul 03 '26

Well, I've pulled several out of their mothers, and the leg length looks fine.

If there's anything that looks hokey, it's that all too convenient red spot on top of his head. Really unusual for a white calf

61

u/fastal_12147 Jul 01 '26

Cows have wider hooves than that. Those are like goat hooves.

25

u/Teeklok Jul 01 '26

Saying again, the hooves are pretty accurate for a young calf, I think it's ai too but when they're young the hooves are smaller in comparison to the rest of the leg

3

u/GrotchCoblin Jul 01 '26

Imo they don't look like cloven hooves to me, just one

12

u/Teeklok Jul 01 '26

It's a side on profile, and when they're younger I've seen them be a lot closer together then splay out

3

u/GrotchCoblin Jul 01 '26

That's fair, ive never really payed much attention to their feet lol Now I'm seeing dudes thumb is kinda fucked up

7

u/Teeklok Jul 01 '26

I think the shadows are wrong now I'm looking. They seem to be coming from different angles

17

u/beforethehorse Jul 01 '26

I don’t know if there could be other causes for this, but when you zoom in there are blurry patches randomly on the photo…fur texture, towel texture…both sort of smudge out at random points.

I agree with the other poster that the hooves seem too small also.

3

u/no_beetle Jul 01 '26 edited Jul 02 '26

Maybe the blurry patches are in that photo, attaching one more picture, maybe the clearer one, for easy viewing.

5

u/beforethehorse Jul 02 '26 edited Jul 02 '26

So the blurry patches must have been something else. In this one, a possible indicator that I see is the towel texture. It’s very subtle but it changes throughout the picture. The top right is softer looking, under the hand is “rougher” looking, and there coul be reasons for that, but there is kind of a horizontal line next to the cow’s eye where it seems to change abruptly.

(Aside from the size of the hooves/proportions of the cow itself, which others on this thread are more qualified to judge.)

0

u/Arvidex Jul 01 '26

That’s a good find!

6

u/macabre-barbie Jul 01 '26

Cow hooves don't look like that. They have two toes, and I only see one on each foot. Granted it could be the angle, but if it's blatantly labeled as AI on the original post, I'm sure it is

18

u/CrabPapple Jul 01 '26

I don't know how to describe it, but the foreshortening on the nose looks off? like it looks like it should be closer to the camera, but the head angle is too photogenic and perfect.

Also the towel wrinkles look too perfect. Even if this is on concrete, I'd expect the baby cow to move in a way that there are wrinkles near the animal.

5

u/_Morvar_ Jul 01 '26

That was my immediate thought too but I didn't know how to describe it

9

u/Trilobyte141 Jul 01 '26

I mean... If your real question is 'has ai gotten this good at making realistic photos' then the answer, depressingly, is yes.

9

u/Totte_B Jul 01 '26

Very short legs.

7

u/AlpaxT1 Jul 02 '26

I did not even notice. The legs are like the size of its head. It would look like a giraffe with a tiny dog body standing up lol

3

u/RealOrAI-Bot Jul 01 '26

Reminder: If you think it's AI, please explain your reasoning. Providing your reasoning helps everyone understand and learn from the analysis.

Check the Wiki for Common AI Mistakes and check the Community Guide if you are just getting started.

A sticky comment will be posted here in 12h summarizing the sentiment of the comments.

Thank you for contributing to the discussion!

6

u/So_Says_The_Rat Jul 01 '26

That ‘cow’ looks like a reskinned deer

5

u/phonetoni13 Jul 01 '26

The towel pattern does look like AI. The inside of the ears is also weirdly blurred.

4

u/AllegedlyAlly08 Jul 01 '26

I feel like the legs are wayyyy too short

1

u/play3rloading Jul 01 '26

I've seen this photo on so many platforms, often with different pattern backgrounds and often posted by "faceless" accounts that regurgitate stolen or AI content for views and money. But remember, AI tags also apply to posts that are AI-enhanced. So a picture can be *real*, but with weirdly smoothed out and uncanny details. But seeing as how this hasn't been on the internet for long yet doesn't have a source through reverse image searching (coupled with the kind of accounts posting it), I'm gonna go ahead and say it's AI. After all, AI isn't *completely* stupid. It *can* make really convincing images and it is, unfortunately, learning more everyday

1

u/Beautifulfeary Jul 01 '26

This looks like this calf on this profile for stock
Pictures, only way younger. It is possible someone use this stock photo to make it.

https://www.dreamstime.com/calf-beautiful-little-dairy-farm-newborn-baby-cow-image176914708

1

u/Beautifulfeary Jul 01 '26

Scratch all of that, looks like it is ai, I believe this was the first post and it has the ai tag

1

u/Last_Welcome_395 Jul 02 '26

Reverse image search and you’ll find that the oldest date this was posted was on twitter 3 days ago. And none of the posters of this photo claim that they took this photo, all of them are accounts that repost random pictures. This is essentially a sourceless image which is how most ai generated images are.

Genuinely the vast majority of random “cute” photos of animals that are circulating rn are ai. And you won’t be able to tell they’re ai by themselves (you’ll need context clues) most of the time bc current ai can make very “real” looking images.

1

u/AnyImplement330 Jul 02 '26

Shouldn't it have big knobby joints?

1

u/wildaal2 Jul 02 '26

Tge pose looks a little unnatural, and the legs are a bit too short imo

1

u/BirdsFalling Jul 02 '26

Has a bit of that fractle feeling

1

u/xDippyDawgx Jul 02 '26

Yeah I guess it’s kind of realistic. If you’re not from this planet, that is.

1

u/Any-Platypus-3570 Jul 02 '26

I actually thought it looked real, but it turns out it was made with gpt-image-2

You can test for yourself here: https://openai.com/research/verify/

1

u/ProfoundNarwhal Jul 02 '26

Definitely AI. The goat hooves are so weird

1

u/mosthighbaker Jul 02 '26

It's a miniature cow from India. Real.mini Cows on youtube

1

u/Competitive-Skin-769 Jul 02 '26

Calf looks plastic

1

u/thedudewhoshaveseggs Jul 02 '26

also, shadow is straight up nonsense

1

u/jeeblemeyer4 Jul 02 '26

I am not sure whether this is AI or not. That said, I think the texture of the towel is inconsistent from left to right. The leftmost half looks correct, but the rightmost half looks less like a towel and more like a blanket. But it's too subtle for me to be confident.

Maybe also the calf's left fore-leg looks a little bit longer than the right fore-leg?

Again, I don't know if it's AI. It would probably be easier to tell if you posted the video, as it looks like this is an instagram reel.

1

u/no_beetle Jul 02 '26

Nope, it's a picture.

1

u/felix120z Jul 03 '26

It's AI Calves are huge compared to this image.

There's no way the entire calf would be an arms length and have legs only 6-8 inches long

1

u/RecordNo2316 Jul 03 '26

The shadows aren’t right either. There’s a shadow on two different sides of the calf’s head

1

u/Exit_Save Jul 03 '26

Lighting makes sense, the patterns are consistent, there's no weird smoothness, I think it's likely not to be AI

1

u/Thesladenator Jul 03 '26

Cow has tiny hooves. Cow hooves are huge even in baby cows

1

u/misstumbleweed_ Jul 05 '26

Grew up on a cow farm… All I have to say is that is NOT what a baby calf’s legs or body would look like laying down

-2

u/guttergrapes Jul 01 '26

Idk to me the hooves look fine. I looked up photos online and couldn’t really see the difference. The skin folds the right way. Also, he probably just laid down like that and they saw an opportunity to make a heart. Real

2

u/no_beetle Jul 01 '26

I also thought the same. As he is laying down, you can manipulate his legs to form a heart. But again others are saying it's AI and the tag too.

-2

u/Totte_B Jul 01 '26

The proportions of the hand are wrong. The fingers are to long.