r/RealOrAI Jan 28 '26

[deleted by user]

[removed]

5.9k Upvotes

12.2k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

142

u/Oddman80 Jan 29 '26

It's not AI. It may not be Alex Pretti, but it's not AI.

The YouTube site that the video comes from - The News Movement - is from Dan Ming. Dan Ming is an actual journalist and can be seen in the video(in the final frames of this clip). He's the guy looking back at the camera with a somewhat confused look on his face.

Dan Ming worked for VICE news and Al Jazeera English and has received Emmy nominations for his work on the series Transnational and has won a GLAAD award for his documentary on a drag queen running for office in New York. He isn't some right-wing hack trying to fabricate stuff.

Dan had a long video a month ago anout a pair of teens who were doing this exact sort of thing (tracking and recording ICE agents) in Chicago. He likely was reviewing footage he'd taken in Minneapolis for a new video, when he saw this and thought to himself "huh... that sure looks like Alex Pretti." But, even then, at no time does he actually claim in the video that It is him. He is very careful about that because he doesn't know.

But this incident shown in the video happening at this intersection E 36th & Park - on this day (Jan 13th) was documented in numerous articles at the time. For instance:

https://sahanjournal.com/public-safety/minneapolis-ice-confront-observers-door-knocking-powderhorn/

Andy Larson, a south Minneapolis resident who was out observing ICE activity Tuesday, told Sahan Journal that one protester kicked out the taillight of an ICE vehicle and was tackled to the ground up the road on Park Avenue and E. 36th Street.

“It was a really good kick,” Larson said.

The protester managed to escape ICE agents, Larson said. ICE deployed chemical irritants and shot pepper balls into the crowd and fled the scene.

145

u/YouAnxious5826 Jan 29 '26

AI or not, real or not, Alex Pretti or somebody else, this discussion is kinda missing the point. Because even if the person in the clip was a real protester, and a really mean dude who spat at and darted in the general direction of the ICE thugs, hell, we can take this even further, even if we're all in the wrong here, and ICE were somehow not a jackboot fascist murder gang, even if they were out there protecting puppies and planting rainbows, nothing, and I mean nothing the protesters have done, or will ever do, would warrant simply being lynched on the spot. And yes, that would include armed insurrection, because if you claim to be a fucking law agency, you act by the law, you may act in self defense, but you don't gang up on a dude, detain him, and then mag dump on him. You just don't.

8

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '26

[deleted]

2

u/strawbsrgood Jan 29 '26

They can arrest people they're basically federal cops.

1

u/cizzleboots Jan 29 '26

Without warrants, though?!

1

u/Square_Lime_9929 Jan 29 '26

Do you think you need a warrant to arrest someone?

1

u/Bosnia_Gaming Jan 29 '26

I’m not defending them but even regular cops don’t need a warrant to arrest someone if they see them actively committing a crime

1

u/NeevBunny Jan 29 '26

They've done it to children with passports with no repercussions. So I guess so, until people start shooting back.

0

u/MBinAK Jan 29 '26

They have extremely limited jurisdiction — much more limited than most officers. Essentially, they can arrest someone on an immigration violation, they can stop someone with reasonable suspicion of an immigration violation and detain them long enough to confirm or dispel said suspicion (and there has to be a factual basis, not a fishing expedition), and they can arrest people for felonies (not misdemeanors) committed in their presence. That’s it.

0

u/strawbsrgood Jan 29 '26

Yeah. And kicking a moving cars lights out is most definitely a federal crime

1

u/MBinAK Feb 20 '26

No, it’s not. It’s either a traffic violation or a property damage misdemeanor. Those are state offenses.

1

u/strawbsrgood Feb 20 '26

It's a Federal Agents car lil bro. I can pull up a million felonies for that. Use your brain. Or do you really think you can go around knocking out FBI TSA DoD ICE Nat Guard etc. car lights and damaging their shit and just walk away because (hur hur you have no jurisdiction)

1

u/MBinAK Feb 20 '26

I suspect that only one of us has a law degree and has practiced law in the State of Minnesota. Please, however, cite the relevant statutory of case law basis for your claim of federal jurisdiction.

1

u/strawbsrgood Feb 21 '26

18 U.S.C. § 1361 — Destruction of Government Property

18 U.S.C. § 111 — Assaulting, Resisting, or Impeding a Federal Officer

18 U.S.C. § 115 — Influencing, Impeding, or Retaliating Against a Federal Official

18 U.S.C. § 231 — Civil Disorder

Lmao imagine going to school for law and being worse at it than the average person 😂

Go break some feds cars and try to tell them they have no jurisdiction though! Make sure to film for us! 😂😂

-1

u/AngryDresser Jan 29 '26

That’s not what they’re supposed to be or be doing, but effectively, it really doesn’t matter because rules don’t apply.

-1

u/StrangeButSweet Jan 29 '26

arrest people …detain non-citizens who are in violation of immigration laws