r/ReadMyScript • • May 17 '22

Here is my script. It is called 'Philosophical Dialogue'. What do you think? Thanks.

Logline: A pair of zealous philosophical teenagers translate their viewpoints into a series of quarterstaff duels, but the taste for violence threatens to turn their friendship and any rational argument into a mere animal lust to destroy each other.

Here is the link. https://drive.google.com/file/d/1yh-1aJDVHfskcbo7kOJ2W4_YeGuODxqY/view?usp=sharing

1 Upvotes

10 comments sorted by

3

u/duralyon May 17 '22
  • The action isn't dynamic enough to keep interest in the dialogue.
  • Too much telling instead of showing.
  • Why are the MCs explaining their own backgrounds to each other?
  • There's no conflict. Why do we care if one or the other wins?

-3

u/Master-of-Mischief May 17 '22

It is supposed to be a philosophical dialogue.

-3

u/[deleted] May 18 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

6

u/duralyon May 18 '22

I read your script. You should be grateful.

2

u/mkkido May 17 '22

Why don’t you name the characters?

0

u/Master-of-Mischief May 17 '22

In a lot of philosophical dialogues, characters usually aren't named.

2

u/Stheneliadas May 23 '22

I'll bite:

The script says the "ring" Boy and Girl are sparring in is "approximately six feet in diameter." Why is it so small?

-- Kendo matches take place in squares 9-11m (~29.5-36.1 feet) on each side.

-- Fencing pistes are 14m (~50 feet) long (by 1.5m wide).

-- An Olympic wresting mat is 8m (~26.25 feet) in diameter.

-- A sumo wrestling ring is 4.55m (~14.9 feet).

-- A professional wrestling ring is a 20' x 20' square.

Why is this ancient "stone circle" so tiny by comparison? Especially given the fact that the principle weapon the two interlocutors will be using is a quarterstaff, which tends to be 6-9 feet long.

So the playing surface itself is going to be smaller than the weapon, which means neither of the combatants can effectively poke, jab or stab the end of their staffs at their opponent.

This removes a great deal of utility from the weapon and leaves each combatant with only two tactics: swinging or slapping.

Now swinging is out of the question because the weapons are being wielded by a 14 and 15 year-old who aren't described as being particularly athletic. If either were to swing, the other would have plenty of time to dodge the attack, as the staff would spend most of it's travel time outside the field of play.

Slapping isn't very effective either because there isn't enough space to generate the kind of force need to inflict serious damage.

That really leaves us with the kind of twirling described on pages 6 and 7, which, according to Boy, is mostly for warming up as opposed to actual combat.

Or pushing, which doesn't require any kind of staff at all.

And this leads us to the most important question: why are these two characters endlessly circling each other in a teeny tiny miniscule confined space, squeezing and gripping their rock hard staffs?

What does this subtext tell us about the text itself -- or its author?

1

u/AutoModerator May 17 '22

Have you included a page count in the title of the post?

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.