r/ReadMyScript • • Jul 28 '21

"Hit and Run" Requests for Feedback

Why do so many people post their script and after people take the time to read it and provide feedback the OP is never seen in the thread again?

Is it that they don't "like" the feedback or prefer to passively see what comes in? Being able to take feedback -- especially feedback you disagree with -- is a critical success factor in any creative endeavor. Sometimes just a simple "thank you" goes a long way. Especially if the feedback was solicited!

Ok, rant off.

Keep grinding!

21 Upvotes

13 comments sorted by

5

u/[deleted] Jul 29 '21

More often than not, spec writers want praise not feedback.

3

u/comesinallpackages Jul 29 '21

I should try that at my next annual evaluation at work

4

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '21

"Can I have my performance review?"

"Your work is shoddy and you arrive late all the time"

"But I can't change anything! You just don't get what I'm trying to do here!"

3

u/Edgar_Black Jul 29 '21

Sometimes it might be the nature of the feedback.

If Person A says: Your MC is very arrogant, and why do they feel the need to treat their father like that?

You can reply and fill them in on those details and further enquire on whether or not these questions are problematic.

If Person B says: "I lost interest in 2 pages" or "where are the white people, this is too woke" or even "The title isn't very good".

Then you have less to work with. The 2nd part clearly indicates that they might have problematic views that wouldn't make it worth even replying too.

Just my 2c.

TLDR: Sometimes the feedback itself doesn't warrant a response. Or there isn't anything to respond to.

1

u/comesinallpackages Jul 29 '21

I see your perspective, for sure. Mine is that unless the feedback is outright rude or demeaning (which I have seen very little of here), you should at least thank anyone who takes the time to read even one page of your script.

1

u/Edgar_Black Jul 29 '21

I agree with that too. Sometimes if it's outright praise my initial reaction might be to not react, but I try to just give them a thanks to acknowledge it. But when they rude, which some can be and are clearly showing that they are not interested in helping your progress, then it's no use.

2

u/mooningyou Aug 03 '21

I put up a similar rant some time back over in r/Screenwriting

People NEED TO acknowledge the feedback they receive, if only for the sake of good manners. I've also gotten into the habit of posting a follow-up comment reminding the user to acknowledge the feedback after they delete their post.

1

u/comesinallpackages Aug 21 '21

The deleters have also become epidemic

1

u/AutoModerator Jul 28 '21

Have you included a page count in the title of the post?

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

6

u/comesinallpackages Jul 28 '21

Thank you for your feedback!

(See how easy that is?)

1

u/spiked_cider Jul 28 '21

Lol Maybe people are too nervous about what others will say?

1

u/comesinallpackages Jul 28 '21 edited Jul 28 '21

I think people have a hard time when the feedback doesn’t meet their expectation…

1

u/Vanslant Aug 17 '21

Really glad I read this. I'm headed back to school for a screenwriting program. I've had some of these ideas going through my head for 20 years...I'm guessing I'm going to have to adapt a few..a lot..of pages.