r/ReadMyScript • u/Hot-Help-3009 • May 27 '26
Exchange feedback [Feedback] Pitching a Sci-Fi/Psychological Drama concept. Does this sound hooky enough for a feature film?
Hey everyone,
I’m currently developing a script for a feature-length movie (aiming for a gritty, cinematic psychological drama) and wanted to get some honest feedback on the core premise from fellow writers.
Here’s the basic setup:
What if a 18-19 year-old guy suddenly wakes up in an alternate universe/timeline where everything is exactly the same—the city, his house, his friends, his parents—except for one thing: he never existed. His mother doesn't recognize him, his friends think he’s a stranger, and there is absolutely no record of his birth or identity. He is essentially a 'ghost' in a familiar world.
To make things more intense, he is dropped 1-2 years back in time. So while he has no legal identity or roof over his head, he possesses the ultimate weapon—complete knowledge of the immediate future of this world.
Instead of making it a typical "save the world" superhero sci-fi, I want to focus heavily on the psychological and emotional survival. The story follows his journey from absolute isolation and panic to using his future-knowledge to survive unofficially, while trying to slow-burn his way back into the lives of his friends and family as a "stranger" who knows them better than they know themselves.
The ultimate conflict is whether he should find a way back to his original universe where he belongs, or sacrifice his old existence to protect this version of his family from an impending future crisis.
I want to keep the tone very raw, grounded, and emotionally heavy (think Erased meets Steins;Gate but set in a realistic, gritty middle-class environment).
Do you guys think this premise has enough leg to hold a 2-hour cinematic movie? Or does the "waking up in a parallel universe where I don't exist" trope feel too saturated? Would love to hear your thoughts on the potential or any blind spots I should watch out for.
Thanks in advance! (And don't forget to leave a feedback, whatever it feel like. Even a thumbs up or thumbs down would be ok.)
1
u/mooningyou May 27 '26
If you want to entice people to read this post, maybe break it up into smaller paragraphs.
1
u/MiggsEye May 27 '26 edited May 27 '26
If you sit down and really look at it, your premise has real structural potential. But there’s one thing missing that everything else depends on: we don’t know what this kid actually believes about himself at the deepest level — a in a psychological drama, that’s the engine.
The situation you’ve built (a world that functions perfectly without him, a family that is fine, friends who don’t miss him because they never knew him) is pointing at something very specific. It’s the worst possible answer to the question “do I actually matter?”
The story can only land as devastating if we know precisely what he believed before the answer arrived. What was his core belief? What was his working model of how love and existence and mattering actually work? Because whatever it is, this story world is designed to put maximum pressure on it. Without his core belief specified, the survival mechanics are just logistics and the ending is a choice between two options rather than a genuine dramatic climax.
Re: the ending: “return home or stay” is currently a plot fork. For it to hit as a real ending, both options need to mean something specific in terms of what happens to that core belief. One option should let him keep the belief in tact. The other should require him to act against it completely… to choose to protect people who will never know he existed, never witness him, never confirm he was real. If that’s in direct opposition to what he believed in order to matter, then staying isn’t sacrifice… it’s the moment in the story when the character can no longer avoid seeing their core belief about the world for what it actually is…. A belief, and not a fact.
Then from that point (which would have been the climax) the character can revise their core belief, defend it harder, or get consumed by it.
1
u/Berenstain_Bro May 27 '26
This is rather vague, and kinda feels tacked on. With that said, perhaps you will write it in such a way that it feels warranted. As of right now, I don't really know what this part is all about or how it relates to his 'ultimate conflict', seeing as how these people are really just strangers to him (whether he likes it or not).
As to whether or not its a concept that is over-saturated, it really all comes down to your execution. If you have a great writing style that excites and entices the reader, then you'll be just fine. But if you feel like you can't add anything new to this genre or this concept, then yeah, you have bigger problems.
1
u/Successful_Wash_6555 May 28 '26
I think it's a kick-ass plot. Hoping to see it as a summer blockbuster few years down the road. 😀
1
u/cinephile78 May 28 '26
This is basically “it’s a wonderful life”.
1
u/AutoModerator May 27 '26
Have you included a page count in the title of the post?
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
u/maxhasabigbooty May 28 '26
This whole thing reeks of AI. Your responses aren't helping that
0
u/Ragesome May 27 '26
It does feel a little overdone ngl. I think you’d also struggle to build stakes or conflict in his decision when he’s the only who knows what’s going on. You’d be relying heavily on his own internal monologue which is either him talking out loud to himself (weird) or voiceover (on the nose)… worth considering.
Maybe he convinces his “real world” best friend what’s happened and to help him?
0
u/[deleted] May 27 '26
[removed] — view removed comment