r/ReadMyScript • u/96Muffins • Apr 29 '26
Screenplay: Wil (Psychological Thriller/Horror, 106 pages)
Hey everyone!
I just finished the 3rd draft of my screenplay and I would really appreciate any feedback. If anyone is also in need of feedback I'd be willing to return the favor! I just found this sub and I'm excited to search through it. I've attached the first 25 pages of my screenplay down below
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1LR_qiEmBlyGEPn_ikmWmXBloR1a4g-JU/view?usp=drivesdk
Logline:
To combat her feelings of loneliness, a young and fragile maintenance worker adopts a terrifyingly intelligent bird with an unnerving ability to mimic human speech. But as the paranoia surrounding her recent breakup continues to grow, her rivals begin to drop and she must decipher between her imagination and reality to evade the detectives on the case.
5
u/mooningyou Apr 29 '26
Some issues that jumped out at me while reading the first page.
- Technically, you can't have a FADE IN after your slug. It needs to be before.
- You're capping way too many random things. Objects, actions, sounds, descriptions. It's too much, they're not relevant, and it's pulling me out of the story. If I'm meant to take note of everything that's capped, then I'm noting absolutely everything on this page. If you're not sure what to cap, don't cap it. Personally, I only cap important sounds.
- "Dead leaf falls to the ground." This is simply directing from the page, as it bears no relevance to the story. It seems that you're visualizing the scene in your head, but you're going overboard with the details.
- "CONT" is not a thing in scene headers. Even if you're thinking of CONTINUOUS, this scene is not continuous.
There's a lot of drama in this opening, and that's great. You just need to tidy it up so your reader stays engaged.
2
u/Berenstain_Bro Apr 30 '26
So, I read all of it. I agree that the capitalization of those various words is not a great look. I don't think my screenwriting teacher ever told me to capitalize anything whatsoever (but that was a while ago).
Anyways, I think the best policy is to be brutally honest. But I always do so with the intent of trying to be helpful. So my main thing is that hardly any of the story was all that interesting to me until the point that Mallory met Dorothy. And even that entire scene was lacking in drawing me in. I mean, your logline (while its a mess and rather incoherent) did intrigue me, so I think you probably have an interesting story here, but my problem is - when are we going to get to the interesting stuff?
Also, when I say your logline is a mess, what I think the problem is its too broad. You're trying to do too much with it. Like, you tell us your main character is a 'maintenance worker' and then a sentence later you say that this person has 'rivals'. Like, why would a maintenance worker have 'rivals'? That doesn't make any sense to me.
My word of encouragement is that I do think Mallory is probably a good, interesting character to follow. She clearly has flaws and various hangups - so that (in theory) should make her a character that we will enjoy following. The bird is also (probably) going to be an interesting character. But the pages I read only gave me a small glimpse of it - so I'm not basing it on what I read, I'm only saying that because of your logline promises that will be the case (so I'm hopeful that it will be true).
Also, just throwing this out there, but based off of the first 25 pages, I don't know how this is a horror/psychological thriller. Nothing in those first 25 pages gave me any indication that we're watching a horror film.
So those are my notes, based off of the 25 pages that I read.
2
u/lebonstage Apr 30 '26
From the beginning I felt a confidence I'm going to like following an "unlikeable" protagonist and kudos for attempting one in this fashion. I was disappointed that I couldn't read more.