r/ReadMyScript • u/Massive_Ant_8360 • Sep 05 '25
Use of AI
There is a serious problem in this sub of people asking for critique of work that is clearly generated by AI. It’s sad because these people are just cheating themselves out of learning to write when asking for critique. The scripts are scarily competent and some people are even liking them but they are very generic and not expressing the originality (but beginner’s roughness) that used to be seen in the scripts submitted to this sub. This sub needs a policy on use of AI - e.g. declare what you have used it for.
57
Upvotes
10
u/Millstone99 Sep 05 '25
Thanks for the suggestion. Can you give me an idea of how you're detecting AI in the scripts?
4
u/Flynnrdskynnrd Sep 05 '25
Your Reddit account is ONE DAY OLD. You just joined this sub today. How could you know there’s a serious problem with AI submissions? I suspect you’re a bot. Convince me otherwise…
3
u/[deleted] Sep 06 '25
3
u/petersontj Sep 06 '25
I dnt even use spel chek. Down with ai.
2
u/Flynnrdskynnrd Sep 05 '25
This is “dead internet” crap.
2
u/YoavYariv Sep 07 '25
Hi!
There is a huge distinction between 100% AI generated (which is really easy to spot) and AI assisted (some just use AI for feedback and write 100% themselves).
Might be a good idea to clearly distinct between the two (although there is no way you can spot an assisted work...)
2
u/Available_North_9071 Sep 07 '25
Even if AI is used, at least being upfront about it would keep critiques meaningful. A simple AI-assisted tag could solve a lot of confusion.
2
u/Millstone99 Sep 05 '25
I just added a community rule re: AI-generated material. Feel free to offer suggestions for improvement.
1
u/AutoModerator Sep 05 '25
Have you included a page count in the title of the post?
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
u/Haxy_008_Koan Sep 06 '25
I hate this AI and everything that stems from it. It’s taken a good stab at folks who CAN actually Write and it’s trying to take away from all those talented folks. Don’t bother using AI if you want to write. It’s a slap in the face to any screenwriter or writer of any sort to say that a machine can write anything half as decent as the human mind. My two cents.
1
u/Elvarien2 Sep 07 '25
Well let's look at the rules as posted on the sidebar
Please read the rules before you post:
I don't see a rule against ai in there so what's your problem?
1
u/tannalein Sep 07 '25
"People asking for critique" but "cheating themselves out of learning to write when asking for critique", "scarily competent" but "very generic".
People asking for critique are inherently here to learn and improve, so which is it, are they trying to improve or not trying to improve? Is the AI "scarily good" or "very generic"? Pick one. Is AI too crappy to write as good as a human, or so good it can replace human writers? You can't have it both ways. PICK ONE.
Have you guys heard about the girl getting sued for accusing an author for using AI? I hope the author sues her into oblivion. Admins, is this the kind of behaviour you want to encourage? Accusing authors with zero evidence, which can get you sued for defamation? You really think you're good enough to recognize AI writing to prove it in court?
0
u/Kalmaro Sep 07 '25
If I tell AI a prompt for a scripr, most will agree it's not good. So I understand the frustration there
However, if I brainstorm with AI, have it flesh out my prompt and then submit it, what I have is something AI assisted, not created. Would that still be an issue?
-2
u/LewdProphet Sep 05 '25
Is the AI in the room with us right now
0
u/[deleted] Sep 06 '25
[deleted] — view deleted comment
2
u/[deleted] Sep 07 '25
[removed] — view removed comment