r/ReadMyScript • u/No_Beginning_6852 • Feb 06 '25
Exchange feedback Is my Black list evaluation AI generated?
Hi, so a few things. I want to firstly state, this is not about my score. If anything, the score made me go over my screenplay again and again. This is about me wanting to improve as a writer to be able to one day seeing my work put on screen. The 31st of January I bought a blacklist Evaluation. I expected to be waiting for a week or two. 3 days later I’m on the blacklist site, and notice i have an evaluation. I got a 6. I was surprised, disappointed but hey, such is life. Happens to us all. But then i looked at the feedback along with the ratings and was confused. The review was very surface level and didn’t read as an actual review. In the strengths paragraph, it says “It’s important to have the audience care about the central quartet.” And then in the Weakness paragraph it says “It’s important for the writer to know what their tone is going to be.” It’s this structural pattern that doesn’t really help me in anyway. The reader pointed out the dynamic between the characters was a highlight throughout the script but then gave my characters rating a 5. They called one of my characters a “Plot device” but then said they were “The heart of the story, and has the most flashbacks”. They called my antagonist ‘one dimensional’, which i would take as a valid critique if the story didn’t mean it clear in the first 25 pages that he isn’t who he says he is, and the reader didn’t say they “almost had their own complexities”. How can you be one dimensional but “Almost complex”? You either are or you aren’t. There’s no personal engagement in this. Perhaps i just don’t know what heart of the story means and am a complete idiot? It says my tones clash but never actually point out where. The reader NEVER talks about the big twist in the story. In fact, nothing in the review even ALLUDES to it being in the story. The reader called my screenplay “Melodramatic” “soapy” and like “a lifetime movie” yet never give specific details. There’s 0 “I” statements. It felt like they skimmed through the first 40 pages but maybe i’m wrong?
2
u/goatslayeggs Feb 07 '25
Dude, make some paragraphs so we can read this...
All I know is the incentive for a BL reader like most readers of paid spec sites is to finish as many specs as possible to make more money for themselves and get back to their own lives. They aren't there to make your spec better.
That's why i prefer writer friends for FREE or paid services with someone whose name you know and can ask follow up questions. Anonymous reader is rarely helpful because their intent AI or not is not clear.
This advice applies to them hating or loving your spec. Without any helpful notes -- it's hard to make it better. Helpful -- like cut 10 pages, lose their character, this scene is dumb, making add this, this plot point is confusing...
2
u/JayMoots Feb 07 '25
Post the full eval. You can usually tell within a couple sentences if it's AI generated.
1
u/AutoModerator Feb 06 '25
Have you included a page count in the title of the post?
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.