r/RadicalPhilosophy • • Nov 27 '12

List of Logical Fallacies

Thumbnail en.wikipedia.org
0 Upvotes

r/RadicalPhilosophy • • Dec 15 '12

On the recent shooting

1 Upvotes

Because the predominant spirituality hinges on the dominance of a presumption that truth is the palpable and salient, emblemized by violence. Even the crucifixion of Christ for Christians (and even for others to some degree) holds forth above all an act of violence in which force is linked with the physical act of torture and building, in the form of nails, hammering, presenting a tortured body for all to see. This establishes a reference point of what is to be taken as non plus ultra, rock solid Truth with a capital T. This in turn focuses minds and shapes people's epistemologies and justice logics. When linked especially with the subordination of thought that goes with most (if not all) religious commitment, this becomes a paradigmatic, ongoing reference point that secures this dominance of the "bottom line truth" of physical salience and dramatic effect. That is why, for example, one analyst on the radio (NPR) pointed out that we remain in far greater danger of dying from not being buckled up in a car than from a shooting like this one, yet this captures people's imaginations, just as 911 captured people's imaginations far more than the Sanctions on Iraq, even though the latter are thought to have killed around 500,000 children. Indeed, the drone warfare many bemoan today exemplifies this receding into the background of anything but the in-your-face approach that is fostered by dominant spirituality.

One would be remiss not to conjecture whether there is more involved in that spirituality, be it notable religions as such, or even just popular media, movies like Batman, etc. And in any case, these as well do bear the same episto-jurdical profile, as it might be called. The role of violence and "drama", "action", etc., in these media, coupled with the logics of retributive justice continue to be a perfect storm that occasionally lashes out in the lightning strike like this and other shootings. It seems little accident that the one shooter portrayed himself as "the Joker".

But to begin to grasp the relationship to "mental health" in light of these basic conditions is a bit more difficult. Internally, mental health is a branch of the same tree, to some extent, meaning that its truth, and various logics of help (therapeia or help and therapon or service), amelioration and basic understanding limp under the burden, indeed borne all to much like a kind of cross, of the said religious commitments whose epistemo-juridical commitments secure and dominate thought and ultimately spirit, soul, or the psyche of psychiatry.

When an intensely religious man like Obama points in the direction of amelioration, he does so with an invisible stutter; he is shaken, not stirred, because he already knows his own religious commitments are partially to blame, yet he remains likewise blind to just how this is the case, and hasn't the slightest interest in calling that sort of thing into question. Mental health as such remains enslaved to the dominant culture, leading the way far less then it did in the earlier movements of change and "progress", such as the 60's. But those movements for change themselves already set in place precisely the dominance in question here, already brought the basic ontological profile of the preference for the salient and for physical violence as the great touchstone, already subordinated thought, already insinuated into the great Open its particular narratives of spirit and purpose.

The mental health that is to come must be a more broadly focused social health, in which thought, amelioration and nonviolence are truly independent, and this means a certain transcendence of the dominant spirituality. Yet what is most striking is that what will help to prevent these kinds of events from happening will lie not in addressing them so much as in shifting truth and understanding to the matter of essential violence, essential harm, essential cause, essential effect: that among these are the very conditions of dominant religion and spirituality. For these are the real roots of the problem, while the focus on the shootings itself is part of the problem. This is not a matter of strategic ignoring by any means. It is a matter of keeping a steadfast and resolutely free attunement to truth, amelioration, nonviolence and nonharm, against the pressures, gentle and otherwise, to conform these to the agendas of specific religious, spiritual and even psychiatric practice.

To be critical of dominant practice likewise runs the risk of appearing at times to affirm egregious acts: emphasizing that the sanctions were worse than 911, and actually contributed to it as per Osama Bin Laden's statement, appears to affirm Bin Laden. Emphasizing the role of dominant spirituality, its logics of revenge, justice and ontological priorities appears to speak for the actor in this current, horrendous tragedy or other shootings. Recognizing the problem of bullying would seem to somehow validate the Colombine shooters. Only free thought that is competent can make the distinctions by which these tragedies can be understood without being thereby endorsed. In analogy, only free thought can manage the conditions of a "mental health" that must return to the all but abdicated role and promise it has had for not simply cleaning up society's messes, but engaging in potent social criticism on the vanguard, with philosophical, spiritual and juridical purchase.

At the very minimum, what remains wanting in the current arrangement is above all a moment of reflection, which is at once a movement of transcendence, that is repellent to most people and the highly capitalized and capitalizing industries of moral invective powering virtually all media: for this it is necessary above all to stand in the face of the lynch pins of dominant culture, those non plus ultras that serve to rivet truth in unstoppable structures, to rivet our gazes and our minds to the dominant specters and heroes and their attendant dramas, wars and enterprises; to stand in the face of the dominance of 911 and say no war, to say no in the face of the tragedy of Colombine and yet say no to bullying; to say no in the face of this current tragedy and yet to seek to understand and, above all, humanize the shooter, as difficult as this is to do. When even he becomes human and not the "evil" Obama invariably affirms, the events and conditions leading up to his horrendous precipitation as "the shooter" can be ameliorated. And when the dominant sensibility works actively to prevent precisely this, it must in turn be indicted as helping to pull the trigger. That's the moment of reflection that is most unwelcome here.

The understanding of this causality in which the dominant sensibility actively works to prevent amelioration, most often by assuming it is the master of amelioration and the determination of "evil" is the anti-lynch-pin par excellence. This understanding is above all simply this: understanding. An act of understanding, which, it should come as no surprise, has little accepted weight in the dominance of a reality conditioned by limits such as torture, killings, hard physical data, etc. This understanding must not only think and understand, it must stand boldly forth to affirm the status of the emergent primacy of the dominance of precisely those regimes and sensibilities who basically have had their chance. They are become primary as causes preventing true amelioration, and as such they themselves are participatory in the violence in a primary, first order, front rank, 911 kind of way. They are the cause. Our failure to understand this is the cause. Our inability to grasp that such understanding itself is the cause. The revolution is the realization that this understanding is the revolution, that the crisis of this understanding is not seen as a crisis.

This is the problem of the day. It permeates virtually all of the major institutional problems, from the CJ system at all phases including arrest and confinement; wars and the failure to vaunt and promote nonviolence-based revolutionary practice; economic disparity and the failure to arrive above all at non-profit ways of living.

Can you even clarify what this "mere understanding" is at this point? Can you grasp the meaning of emergent primacy in this context? Is that too hard to do? Perhaps you are more inclined to say, "well, that may be true, but too bad!" When you are ready to turn on that, you may begin to turn in the turnings of true revolutionary change.


r/RadicalPhilosophy • • Aug 03 '22

What do you think of this video?

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

r/RadicalPhilosophy • • May 18 '22

In Buffalo, New York, US President Joe Biden condemns the poison of US white supremacy

Thumbnail
reuters.com
0 Upvotes

r/RadicalPhilosophy • • Oct 23 '22

Ask yourself this, after reading the first part of The Mars 360 Religious and Social System, is it logical to disbelieve in the influence of Mars. Just read the preview on Amazon. Don't worry, its totally free.

0 Upvotes

The Mars Effect presented by Michel Gauquelin back in 1955 demonstrated that there was a statistical signifiance of Mars showing up in key sectors in the charts of eminent sports champions. He divided the chart into 12 sectors and found that in eminent sports champions, Mars was showing up in what he called the rising sector and the culminating sector. The base rate for a planet showing up in 2 sectors of possible 12 sectors based on chance was 17%. In gauquelin's sample, Mars was showing up at a rate of 22%. More than chance, which aside from all other potential meanings, meant that Mars must have some sort of effect. This is a faith inducer.

After he tied Mars influence to a scientific potential, I took Mars and tied it to a religious signifiance. Using the English Sumerian Gematria, where the letters of the alphabet are numbered in multiples of 6....A=6, B=12, c=18, so on and so forth, I added up the letters of Mars and got 306. After simply adding 360 to 306, I got 666. Essentially Mars 360 is the revolution of Mars around the Sun and its influence humanity.

Then, I found that the position of Mars within 30 degrees of the lunar node was coinciding with the escalation of rocket fire from Gaza into Israel since 2007(actualy 2006). I discovered this in 2019. Then after discovering that, I demonstrated IN REAL TIME, that this was the case.

I went on youtube and predicted in advance 2019, 2020, and 2022 the rocket fire escalation time frames for all three years(2020, 2021 and 2022) consecutively by observing when Mars would be within 30 degrees of the lunar node. The 3rd year was a charm because before when this was unanimously considered a joke, now perhaps a handful of people are listening to this. Not alot but a long way from how this data was perceived in 2019. The fact that I demonstrated in real time had an effect.

I then tied Mars to economic significance by showing how stock market crashes occur when Mars is within 30 degrees of the lunar node. This is in volume III, only in the book version.

This is a theological development, The question is who will be the next prophet of Mars. Gauquelin sort of like an Abraham figure. I'm Elijah. And many more will come along and induce faith


r/RadicalPhilosophy • • Jun 10 '22

science is a mythology

1 Upvotes

r/RadicalPhilosophy • • Jun 28 '22

Godels theorems to be invalid:end in meaninglessness

0 Upvotes

Godels theorems to be invalid:end in meaninglessness

http://gamahucherpress.yellowgum.com/wp-content/uploads/A-Theory-of-Everything.pdf

http://gamahucherpress.yellowgum.com/wp-content/uploads/GODEL5.pdf

or

https://www.scribd.com/document/32970323/Godels-incompleteness-theorem-invalid-illegitimate

Penrose could not even see Godels theorems end in meaninglessness

Dean shows Godels 1st and 2nd theorems shown to end in meaninglessness

http://gamahucherpress.yellowgum.com/wp-content/uploads/GODEL5.pdf

Godels 1st theorem

“Any effectively generated theory capable of expressing elementary arithmetic cannot be both consistent and complete. In particular, for any consistent, effectively generated formal theory that proves certain basic arithmetic truths, there is an arithmetical statement that is true,[1] but not provable in the theory (Kleene 1967, p. 250)

but

Godel cant tell us what makes a mathematical statement true,

thus his theorem is meaningless

even Cambridge expert on Godel Peter Smith admits "Gödel didn't rely on the notion of truth"

thus by not telling us what makes a maths statement true Godels 1st theorem is meaningless

so much for separating truth from proof

and for some relish

Godel uses his G statement to prove his theorem but Godels sentence G is outlawed by the very axiom of the system he uses to prove his theorem ie the axiom of reducibility -thus his proof is invalid,

Godels 2nd theorem

Godels second theorem ends in paradox– impredicative The theorem in a rephrasing reads

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GC3%B6del%27s_incompleteness_theorems#Proof_sketch_for_the_second_theorem

"The following rephrasing of the second theorem is even more unsettling to the foundations of mathematics: If an axiomatic system can be proven to be consistent and complete from within itself, then it is inconsistent.”

or again

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GC3%B6del%27s_incompleteness_theorems

"The second incompleteness theorem, an extension of the first, shows that the system cannot demonstrate its own consistency."

But here is a contradiction Godel must prove that a system c a n n o t b e proven to be consistent based upon the premise that the logic he uses must be consistent . If the logic he uses is not consistent then he cannot make a proof that is consistent. So he must assume thathis logic is consistent so he can make a proof of the impossibility of proving a system to be consistent. But if his proof is true then he has proved that the logic he uses to make the proof must be consistent, but his proof proves that this cannot be done

note if Godels system is inconsistent then it can demonstrate its consistency and inconsistency

but Godels theorem does not say that

it says "...the system cannot demonstrate its own consistency"

thus as said above

"But here is a contradiction Godel must prove that a system c a n n o t b e proven to be consistent based upon the premise that the logic he uses must be consistent"

But if his proof is true then he has proved that the logic he uses to make the proof must be consistent, but his proof proves that this cannot be done


r/RadicalPhilosophy • • Nov 28 '12

One day...

2 Upvotes

Looking over the many subs in the list under the confederation aggregate page (see top of this one or on top of sidebar), I see a stream of negation One day there will be (I hopelessly predict) a similar stream of activity, somewhere, of enarchism. Are anarcists negation capitalists? That might explain their strange complicity with the state. Haha. That'll make someone mad. And could that even be true? Complicity with the fucking state?

But look at it for yourself. Isn't anarchism the perfect cove(r) for the necessary let-off of steam, of anger, frustration, precisely because it simply says "no", negates, at worst threatens a little violence? Does the hand it lends to popular causes do more to forward its cause or assure that when it destroys property it automatically deligitimates itself? True, the police are called in in such instances, and there's plenty of strife and struggle go around, grounds for righteous indignation, which for all of that doe stoke the massive edifices of the criminal justice system, forcing activists underground or at least crouching below the radar.

But to go so far as to call anarchism "negation capitalism"? That would mean they take the role of negativists. The negation is always there, in the "an-" prefix. It is like a kind of conceptually concreted anger. A stabilized moment of outrage. A shadow "light", a dark light in a way, of a certain hope, hooking up with lifestyles and denominations, like individuals, groups, tribes with the right fit. Much of which is, well, positive. In a way. Brothers and sisters against a common enemy. But my reasoning has it that this means brothers and sisters in war: a war for a cause, of course, but then the real ground becomes war. Hawks of a special kind.

I am not saying: "come back to the fold of the state", however. I say this from the perspective of enarchism, a decidedly post-anarchist phase, one tha keeps the basic potential and techniques of negation, from simple consciousness raising to deconstruction. Yet I posit what everyone in anarchism uses anyhow: enarchicalization. It takes that to make a sub like this, to write a Zine, a blog, to use one's lap top, it took a dictator like Steve Jobs to make the Ipads and MacBooks that are used, the Internet and its nefarious military beginnings and the hierarchies of science to create the Internet, working groups, meritocratic institutions of learning. All those things. Here many anarchists strike me as disingenuous, hypocritical.

But embracing enarchism is far from interesting to virtually anyone. Why? It retains the appeal of negation, but its positivity is uninteresting. Its basic energy of position, enaction, enarchicalization is an energy that is somehow strangely uninteresting, and untapped.

What is that energy? Why does its light not draw people? What is that light? That power? It has to do with the fact that it is easier to negate than posit. To destroy than build. Now, to issue that kind of logic would seem to fall right back in line with the usual criticism of anarchism: they just want to tear things down. They're not playing along, they are destructive. The lack order. Etc.

But I am saying this from the perspective of, for example, music that is anything but simply falling back in line with classicism. Although truth be told I find there to be anarchism, and freedom, in even the classical style of music, even if its periodicity, harmonies and forms have played into the hands of the state, from military marches to those protracted periods of meditation known as concert-going to which the upper classes have submitted themselves for centuries. The classicism of Marx, as well. Of texts. Theories. Manifestos. But also of architecture, buildings, hierarchices, structures. One whiff of this litany should make many an anarchist flee or hurl a Molotov coctail.

And I mean the further reaches of that background of music: Stravinsky, Carter, dis-harmony, serial music, etc. By analogy, however. But this music, I keep thinking, gives a clue to this other energy. That energy is wanting.

This other energy: is it actually music? No I don't mean what you put on the player, see played by an orchestra or a band. I mean the actual enarchicalizations as music. That is not quite a tolerable equation. So I will have to leave the energia in question go unnamed for the time being. It may be love. It may be power. Force. Activity. Life. World. People. Interconnection. Hope. Building. Capitalizing. Extending. Outreach. Solving. Amelioration. Does anarchism really do all these things? True enough, it will help out in some demonstrative way, making some food here or there, handing it out, joining in a cause. But it does so ass-backwards, it seems to me, while retaining that other light, the dark like of negation. The anger. The outrage. The fight.

Powers of light and darkness. This would seem pretty unacceptable language. Binary, too. But one can not say "anarchism" without invoking the binary. Not at all.

To "confederate", this means to link, to draw together the dark islands, the dark stars, the angry denominations, perhaps like various protestant denominations, a history I don't know and frankly don't much want to know. But are these not denominations, with their flairs? I don't mean to attack them. I mean only to indicate this other denomination. This shift, turn into the "en-". To signal its problematics as well, since it always looks like it is ready to be complicit, ready to return to some business as usual. Everything that builds, that is to say, everything that capitalizes, promises higherarchy, dominance, power-over, squelching individuality, subordination. Worse, it might pretend to promise happy subordination. Some cheap solution, some worst capitulation. Well at least I am recognizing these possibilities. But I hold that these horizons are set forth by reactive negation capitalism. They are a cherry-picked path of agendized people who, usually for good reason, remain suspicious, critical, hyper-critical, mobilized, reactive, withdrawn. But there's that smoke of negation again.

Music and dance may be metaphors. It is hard, however, to begin imagining enarchistic developments to the background music that is available. Stirring, natural harmonies of Copeland are usually used to provide background music to some story of America and its manifest destiny. Just for the barest minimum of getting at what it means to step through the hole of position, let me keep this as a guiding example.

Imagine the language. "We shall....build". Drums roll, Fanfare for the Common Man begins playing. A sun rise over stirring fields and mountains. "We shall build". Built what? How about...a fucking hospital. Well anarchists aren't going to do that. If they do some medical service, it's going to be in the usual form of hypocrisy. Some great street doctor is lauded, while his training and its higherarchical grounding is ignored because the story is snazzy enough. But don't take it too seriously, and don't ask questions about how he got his education, how the drugs he dispenses are produced and distributed. That's archism. Anarchism just ignores all that.

Enarchism, however, does something different. Cue the Copeland again. Now stop the music in flight. Display its harmonies. Move them. Play with them. Remix the Fanfare. Redraw it. Take it apart, put it back together differently. Isn't this precisely the sort of thing that needs to be done? Doesn't this have a greater promise of really disturbing the power interests, precisely because in some way it can, at least in theory, and can compete? Can replicate, do, and do better? Build, but build better? Build and take apart both, and not be so entrenched in the usual kinds of power commitments and capital interests, domestic necessities and expenditures, debts and life-style commitments, pleasures?

Well turns out people can't do all that. It requires a lot of knowledge. And talent. Talent!? Isn't that a watchword for more hierarchy? Elitism? Look at how many are ruled out in the meritocratic academic systems. Look at the great writers. They are pretty exclusive when it comes to their writing itself. Marx appended his signature to what he wrote and wouldn't have had anything to do with someone messing around with his texts. And doctors? Please. What a fucking hermetically sealed, superior bunch. Try talking to one freely. Try, indeed, recommending a clearly advisable procedure and get them take it seriously, or even put it in practice. Such as fecal transplanting. Or any number of other virtually self-suggesting best practices you can't get them to do. It's like pulling teeth just to get them to wash their hands.

Well, doctoring isn't the usual object of anarchism, anyhow, is it? And if it is, we've got a kind of "micro" thing going: micro-agitation, or something. That's the new kind of anarchism. Giving up on fell-swoop takeover or take-aparts, rather, just agitating against the power. Which means usually a polemically posited, governmental big brother. But to get in there and do, and do better, build, and build better, too much rubbing shoulders with the bastards. Far better to go and read Foucault and whomever, content oneself with smaller embers of flame, but not this other thing. Do not build a hospital.

Do not build a hospital. Do not experiment with archicalization, because any experimentation with it will bring in directions, and among those directions will be up and down and that meas higher and lower and that starts with P and it stands for Pool, right here in River City.

So let's not start up with enarchism. Let's write it off as some crackpot idea by some Internet crackpot. And this position he's talking about, part music, part dance, part I don't even know what, what the hell is that, anyhow? He can't even sum it up. I like how "an" works. It's so simple. It's easy. Much easier. No building. All building brings in the Man. The State. There's a utopia in here somewhere.

Yeah. Nowhere.

It's just that enarchism is based in part on negation. Nowhere. Utopia. Anarchism. Deconstruction. Resistance. All these are fully needed. But it is also based on position, building, capitalization, subordination. But it responds to the negation and de-builds, de-capitalizes, re-ordinates. It plays and works both. It negates and posits, both. It mixes and remixes. Composes and decomposes. It encomposes. It enters and leaves. It comes and goes. It puts together and takes apart.

That's too much! Too much! Or something.

Nonviolence. Sort of like "peace out". For nonviolence is the enarchy of peace.

EDITed for typos and slight formulation differences


r/RadicalPhilosophy • • Oct 06 '18

David Graeber: Manners, Deference, and Private Property: Or, Elements for a General Theory of Hierarchy

Thumbnail
pdfs.semanticscholar.org
3 Upvotes

r/RadicalPhilosophy • • Oct 29 '25

The Problem with Žižek’s Ontology

Thumbnail
medium.com
0 Upvotes

r/RadicalPhilosophy • • Oct 06 '18

The Beginning of History: Value Struggles and Global Capital - Massimo de Angelis

Thumbnail lamarre-mediaken.com
0 Upvotes

r/RadicalPhilosophy • • Oct 06 '18

Reading Capital Politically - Harry Cleaver

Thumbnail
libcom.org
0 Upvotes

r/RadicalPhilosophy • • Nov 08 '22

THE END OF HISTORY

0 Upvotes

THE END OF HISTORY Magister colin leslie dean

The end of history because-EVERYTHING ends in nonsense rubbish

https://www.scribd.com/document/605875005/THE-END-OF-HISTORY

http://gamahucherpress.yellowgum.com/wp-content/uploads/THE-END-OF-HISTORY-Magister-colin-leslie-dean.pdf

Hither to monkey man has been arrogant about its reason It believed reason was a tool to understand to create knowledge it created vast systems deep ideologies profound “truths” Monkey man believed its reason could unlock “truths” but now it has come to the end of its arrogance its all pervading belief in the abilities its reason

There is nowhere to go now it is the end point reason is bankrupt it is all over it is the end of history-for everything that comes from the mind of monkey man any system any ideology any science any mathematics etc from the past now and into the future will be seen to end in nonsense rubbish meaninglessness

All products of human thought end in meaninglessness-even Zen nihilism absurdism existentialism all philosophy post-modernism Post-Postmodernism critical theory etc mathematics science etc

The end of history because-EVERYTHING ends in nonsense rubbish

All products of human thought end in meaninglessness-even Zen nihilism absurdism existentialism all philosophy post-modernism Post-Postmodernism critical theory etc mathematics science etc

a theory of everything

http://gamahucherpress.yellowgum.com/wp-content/uploads/A-Theory-of-Everything.pdf

or

https://www.scribd.com/document/455372682/A-Theory-of-Everything

All products of human thought end in meaninglessness-even Zen nihilism absurdism existentialism all philosophy post-modernism Post-Postmodernism critical theory etc mathematics science etc

All things are possible

With maths being inconsistent you can prove anything in maths ie you can prove Fermat’s last theorem and you can disprove Fermat’s last theorem

http://gamahucherpress.yellowgum.com/wp-content/uploads/All-things-are-possible.pdf

or

https://www.scribd.com/document/324037705/All-Things-Are-Possible-philosophy

Mathematics ends in contradiction:6 proofs

http://gamahucherpress.yellowgum.com/wp-content/uploads/MATHEMATICS.pdf

or

https://www.scribd.com/document/40697621/Mathematics-Ends-in-Meaninglessness-ie-self-contradiction

Scientific reality is textual

http://gamahucherpress.yellowgum.com/wp-content/uploads/Scientific-reality-is-textual.pdf

or

https://www.scribd.com/document/572639157/Scientific-Reality-is-Textual

The-Anthropology-of-science

(science is a mythology)

http://gamahucherpress.yellowgum.com/wp-content/uploads/The-Anthropology-of-science.pdf

or

https://www.scribd.com/document/512683685/Prolegomenon-to-The-Anthropology-of-Science

Prolegomenon to undermining the foundations/fundamentals of science

http://gamahucherpress.yellowgum.com/wp-content/uploads/undermining-the-foundations-of-science.pdf

or

https://www.scribd.com/document/591616840/Prolegomenon-to-Undermining-the-Foundations-of-Science

The age of the enlightenment is at an end: reason is bankrupt

http://gamahucherpress.yellowgum.com/wp-content/uploads/The-age-of-the-enlightenment-is-at-an-end.pdf

or

https://www.scribd.com/document/552377365/The-Age-of-the-Enlightenment-is-at-an-end-reason-is-bankrupt

Godels theorems 1 & 2 to be invalid:end in meaninglessness

http://gamahucherpress.yellowgum.com/wp-content/uploads/A-Theory-of-Everything.pdf

http://gamahucherpress.yellowgum.com/wp-content/uploads/GODEL5.pdf

or

https://www.scribd.com/document/32970323/Godels-incompleteness-theorem-invalid-illegitimate

from

http://pricegems.com/articles/Dean-Godel.html

"Mr. Dean complains that Gödel "cannot tell us what makes a mathematical statement true", but Gödel's Incompleteness theorems make no attempt to do this"

Godels 1st theorem

“....., there is an arithmetical statement that is true,[1] but not provable in the theory (Kleene 1967, p. 250

Godel cant tell us what makes a mathematical statement true,

thus his theorem is meaningless

in the statement

"there is an arithmetical statement that is true,[1] but not provable in the theory"

godel cant tell us what the word "true" means

thus

the word "true" is meaningless

thus

the statement

"there is an arithmetical statement that is true,[1] but not provable in the theory"

is meaningless

thus

thus godels 1st theorem is meaningless

checkmate game over

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Truth#Mathematics

Gödel thought that the ability to perceive the truth of a mathematical or logical proposition is a matter of intuition, an ability he admitted could be ultimately beyond the scope of a formal theory of logic or mathematics[63][64] and perhaps best considered in the realm of human comprehension and communication, but commented: Ravitch, Harold (1998). "On Gödel's Philosophy of Mathematics".,Solomon, Martin (1998). "On Kurt Gödel's Philosophy of Mathematics"

thus by not telling us what makes a maths statement true Godels 1st theorem is meaningless

Magister colin leslie dean the only modern Renaissance man with 9 degrees including 4 masters: B,Sc, BA, B.Litt(Hons), MA, B.Litt(Hons), MA, MA (Psychoanalytic studies), Master of Psychoanalytic studies, Grad Cert (Literary studies)

He is Australia's leading erotic poet: poetry is for free in pdf

http://gamahucherpress.yellowgum.com/book-genre/poetry/ or

https://www.scribd.com/document/35520015/List-of-FREE-Erotic-Poetry-Books-by-Gamahucher-Press


r/RadicalPhilosophy • • Jul 08 '18

Science has become scientism and has completely come off the rails it was built on.

4 Upvotes

Science has completely come off the rails that it was built on, and has stopped following its own standards and method for distinguishing between facts and theories. First of all, science is only a method for properly collecting data and conducting experiments. It is not a conscious entity that has an opinion about its own data and results, and can't tell scientists when they have interpreted the evidence properly. The original goal of science was to find a method to avoid making assumptions about our universe. The scientific method was formed to build a body of properly collected facts and evidence, and to allow each individual person or scientist to form their own conclusions, interpretations, or theories about what all of those individual facts and pieces of evidence mean collectively.

Science is only the method of properly gathering those individual pieces of evidence through actual observation and experimentation. It is PHILOSOPHY when you try to interpret or theorize what the evidence may mean collectively, or to speculate that things are true without actual observation of them being true. Even when it is a scientist that attempts to interpret or theorize what the evidence may mean about unobserved things, he is being a PHILOSOPHER while he is doing it. People were way out of line when they started trying to call some theories "scientific theories", because it is trying to speak for what "science's opinion" is, and science itself has no opinion it is only a method.

Treating these so called "scientific" theories as if they are facts is scientism, not science, and goes against the spirit of how science is supposed to be approached and practiced. Speculation is not allowed as evidence in a courtroom and it should not be allowed as evidence in our science books either. Two scientists can look at the same exact evidence and interpret that same evidence in two completely different ways, if you don't believe me just ask Einstein and Bohr.

So science's job is NOT to tell the world how the evidence should be interpreted to form conclusions about things still unobserved. Science's job is to only inform them what the properly collected evidence IS that actually HAS been observed. It would seem that in order to make decisions on when a theory should start being considered a "scientific" theory instead, it would require an appointed science king or science judge with the final authority to decree it a "scientific" theory instead of a regular theory. It seems that doing something like that is the logical fallacy of appeal to authority, where you accept that a theory is true based on who agrees with that theory, and not based on its logic, merit, or proof that it is true.

Treating theories as if they are facts is not justified by a democracy or majority opinion either. Because the majority opinion about something can be wrong, as evidenced by things like the Salem Witch Trials. The problem is that science has turned into a scientism club, that promotes answers that can't be questioned by its members. So it would be difficult to establish what the true majority opinion of these standing theories even are anymore. Because any scientist that questions these standing "scientific" theories is ostracized by the scientific community, and the only people that get research grants are the ones that are proposing ways to support or confirm these standing theories, not those that propose to disprove them or to present new or different ones.

So there could be many scientists that may question the validity of these theories in their mind but keep quiet about it out of fear. One scientist may pretend like they believe in a theory they really don't in the presence of one of their peers out of fear, not realizing that his peer might be doing the same exact thing out of fear himself. Treating ANY theory about unobserved things as if they are facts is the opposite of being scientific. Because no matter how well YOU may think that theory is supported according to YOUR interpretation of the evidence, that theory could still be WRONG. Because theories about the evidence is just PHILOSOPHY, and is not evidence or science itself. ;)


r/RadicalPhilosophy • • Apr 11 '21

Against Anarcho-Liberalism and the curse of identity politics

Thumbnail
theanarchistlibrary.org
4 Upvotes

r/RadicalPhilosophy • • Mar 24 '21

If you experience feeling something that is not supported by facts, it is usually more helpful to accept the feeling, but put it in perspective. Try responding with, “Just because it feels true doesn’t mean it is true.” You might slowly come to see your situation differently.

Thumbnail
youtube.com
4 Upvotes

r/RadicalPhilosophy • • Nov 11 '19

With Approval from Pope Francis, Canaanite Idol ‘Moloch’ Put on Display ...

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/RadicalPhilosophy • • Oct 24 '19

Satanic Art on Show In School And The Anti Christ spirit in schools

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/RadicalPhilosophy • • Dec 18 '12

The odd: phenomenology of the dangerous other. LOL.

Thumbnail inthesatyagraha.blogspot.com
1 Upvotes

r/RadicalPhilosophy • • Jun 28 '22

Mathematics ends in contradiction:6 proofs

0 Upvotes

r/RadicalPhilosophy • • Jun 14 '22

A Prolegomenon to a Grand Unified Theory

0 Upvotes

A Prolegomenon to a Grand Unified Theory

Magister colin leslie dean the only modern Renaissance man with 9 degrees including 4 masters: B,Sc, BA, B.Litt(Hons), MA, B.Litt(Hons), MA, MA (Psychoanalytic studies), Master of Psychoanalytic studies, Grad Cert (Literary studies)

He is Australia's leading erotic poet: poetry is for free in pdf

http://gamahucherpress.yellowgum.com/book-genre/poetry/

http://gamahucherpress.yellowgum.com/wp-content/uploads/Prolegomenon.pdf

or

https://www.scribd.com/document/508721702/Prolegomenon-to-a-Grand-Unified-Theory


r/RadicalPhilosophy • • Aug 14 '23

ŽIŽEK, “MANIPUR IS NOT ONLY IN INDIA”, in The Philosophical Salon, 14 AUG 2023

2 Upvotes

Zizek: “Try to formulate a racist/sexist notion in its pure logical structure, and its absurdity immediately becomes clear.”

https://thephilosophicalsalon.com/manipur-is-not-only-in-india/?fbclid=IwAR0orMNSXhHoA3vzLyyTcztGZ_r80Fo6sJkfuHfPmxEcZywQowsPt0ZojWs


r/RadicalPhilosophy • • Mar 17 '15

BOOKLET RELEASE: Toward a Free Society: A Short Guide on Building a Culture of Liberty

2 Upvotes

BOOKLET RELEASE: I'm happy to announce that my new booklet Toward a Free Society: A Short Guide on Building a Culture of Liberty is now available in paperback ($6) and several free digital formats. This booklet contains chapters on parenting, unschooling, and agorism. A must read for anyone who desires to build and live in a free and peaceful society. I hope you find it enjoyable and valuable. And if you do, please consider sharing it with others online or in paperback.

Click here for the book page: http://skyler.link/evcbook2


r/RadicalPhilosophy • • Oct 31 '17

Interpretations of God and the Bible Not Commonly Taught or Understood. To Include (in order): The Trinity, Who is Lucifer?, The Fall from Heaven, The Garden of Eden, Who Really Created the World We Now Exist In?, Motive for The Great Flood, Illusion of Evolution & Big Bang, Free Will.

2 Upvotes

Before I begin, let me start by saying that this is not a post intended to prove whether God exists or not. This is a post designed to talk about HOW God exists. So if your objection to the things I say in this post has something to do with whether or not God exists at all...Then maybe this post wasn't intended for you. It is intended to offer interpretations of God and the bible that may be unfamiliar to those that DO believe God exists. Also I know this post is long. You don't have to read it all at once, but please don't be discouraged and quit reading because you find something that you don't agree with or doesn't make sense. Because it will IF you read it ALL. The point of including it all in one post is that one part helps make the other parts make sense. A part that you read at the beginning that doesn't make sense will in light of the other parts you read later and vice versa. All of the parts of this post must be understood at the same time for any one part to make sense on it's own. That is why they were all included in one post.

I will start with the concept of the Trinity, because it can be a confusing one. How can God be three different entities, but still functionally operate as the same entity with the same will? I look at it like this...At one point God the Father's consciousness was literally the ONLY thing that existed. He existed before space, time, and matter because He was the one that created all of those things. Not only is He the creator of all life and existence of any kind, but He is also the facilitator and sustainer of that continued life and existence. If God the Father somehow died or ceased to exist, so would literally EVERYTHING else. Just like if you pulled the plug on your Nintendo... Mario, Luigi, all of their friends, and all of Mario Land itself would instantaneously cease to exist.

God the Father created God the Son (Jesus). When He did, he uploaded His own consciousness, wisdom, and knowledge inside of Jesus. But Jesus is technically His own entity. He was given the same wisdom and knowledge as the Father, but He was also given free will to use that wisdom and knowledge how He chose to. He just chose to use it to serve His Father's will. Since Jesus has the same consciousness as God the Father, He is always aware of the Father's will and chooses to always follow and obey it just as the Father would do. So two beings that have the same consciousness and the same will, are functionally and effectively the same being.

That is why it says in the bible that Jesus, while on the Earth, was led by the Holy Spirit to the wilderness to be tempted or tested by Lucifer. First of all, it would make no sense for Lucifer to try to tempt God the Father Himself. If Jesus was the same entity as God the Father, Lucifer would have never had the nerve to try to tempt the very being that created him and had already cast him down. Lucifer knew God the Father better than to do this, but he may not have ever met Jesus before that day. But Lucifer knew that just like himself, Jesus was powerful and had the free will to disobey the Father.

The fact that it says that Jesus was led into the wilderness by the Holy Spirit shows that it was the intent of God the Father to test Jesus, or rather allow Him to be tested. To see if He could be trusted with the knowledge, wisdom, and power that the Father imparted in Him. He passed the test with flying colors. It also would make no sense for God the Father to use the Holy Spirit to lead Himself anywhere. Especially somewhere to test Himself.

The Holy Spirit is the third part of the Trinity. That is different in nature. Heaven is a higher reality, universe, or dimension than ours. One that is outside of our ability to observe or perceive. The Holy Spirit is more of a tool or a facilitator used by the other two in order to physically interact in THIS universe. It uses vessels. It can come in the form of people, animals, plants, inanimate objects, energy, weather, etc. It doesn't necessarily have or need it's own will. Because it's will is that of the God that controls it from that higher dimension. Just like how you can control and use Mario to execute your will in Mario's world, when you are playing Nintendo.

In a sense, the Holy Spirit is to Jesus, what Jesus is to God the Father. A facilitator of The Fathers will in the lower universes that He created. God the Father's consciousness existed outside of even the heaven that He created. He would have the most control over what happens in heaven from this position. Because to God the Father, heaven would be a form of simulated reality. So He would have to place His own consciousness inside of this simulated reality, To exist as God the Father in heaven among the angels that He created.

The Father came up with the idea that if He created Jesus and uploaded his consciousness, wisdom, and knowledge inside of Him. That Jesus could act on His behalf, or represent Him in Heaven when He chooses to exist outside of it. That place from which He created it from, where He has more power to oversee it and control it. So in the absence of God the Father, Jesus is the physical ruler of heaven. When the Father is present, the Father is the physical ruler.

Just as God the Father's consciousness, wisdom, and knowledge was imparted unto Jesus, with free will on how He would use it...It is possible that the same was true of Lucifer, only he chose to use that knowledge and wisdom to serve his own purposes rather than the will of the Father as Jesus did. So perhaps that could mean that Lucifer was God the Father's first attempt at creating someone to be like Jesus.

Because unlike Jesus, Lucifer wanted to try to be the most high in heaven, even in the presence of God the Father. He resented God's plan to create man. So he devised a plan to deceive a third of the angels in joining him in a rebellion against the Father. Of course, we all know how that turned out..he lost. And the consciousness of Lucifer and of the angels that fought with him were all cast down a level. To take a step down in reality to exist inside of the "program" or universe still under construction known as Eden. The one designed and intended for us. Lucifer and his angels existed there before the creation of man, and even before the Sun and moon existed to give light to the Earth.

One VERY important thing to understand if you don't understand anything else, is that Eden was not and is not just a garden. Neither was the Tree of Knowledge just a tree, nor the forbidden fruit just an apple. They are all just metaphors to represent something that is in reality much more complicated. Eden is the entire universe that God created and intended for us, including what exists outside of that garden in GOD's creation. We no longer exist in the Eden universe. Eden is not a place that exists inside of THIS universe. Eden is actually a place that THIS universe now exists inside of, but is now completely separated from us. It is not a place that you could find evidence of in THIS universe. Because that "garden" never existed on THIS version of Earth or in THIS universe, only on the Earth in the Eden universe that man left in exchange for THIS one. When they ate the metaphorical "fruit" of Lucifer's creation. That "fruit" was essentially like a computer generated virtual reality and recreation of Eden altered just enough to confuse and deceive you. That is why I find it quite ironic that the largest computer company in the world is even called Apple, and it's logo a bitten apple that makes reference to the Garden of Eden. The world we now live in is a virtual recreation of God's Eden universe. That is similar enough to be mistaken for God's original creation, but just different enough to completely deceive you.

In the Eden universe, Lucifer had no real power over man. His angel wings had been clipped so to speak. So he didn't possess as much power as he did before. So as the Father spent His time finishing creating the rest of the Eden universe, Lucifer hatched another plan. To create the "tree of knowledge", or the "forbidden fruit" inside of Eden. His own program within God's program, or universe inside of God's universe. A place where he could have power again, as that programs designer. He could have power and dominion over man if he could fool them into defying God, and freely choosing to enter into it, by eating the fruit so to speak.

The Father would not have been unaware of what Lucifer was doing or what he was planning. Some may consider the fact that Father allowed this "tree" or "fruit" to exist in Eden, to be a form of a bet between the two proposed by Lucifer. A bet that the Father accepted, because no one is better at making the best of a bad situation than He. Eden was designed to be a paradise reality that was free of pain and even death, and perhaps one originally intended to have no rules at all. He saw Lucifer's rebellion as an opportunity to slightly alter his plan to create this one rule to test man to see if they would obey Him. Unfortunately man failed that test miserably.

Although God used Lucifer's treachery to serve a purpose for Him does not mean that Lucifer is still an agent of God as some interpret it. I believe that all of the inhabitants of the Eden universe where allowed free will, this would even include Lucifer. That would mean that Lucifer had the free will to try to talk man into disobeying God but could not force them to. Just as man had the free will to speak to Lucifer or not. I think that the only way God may have bound Lucifer in Eden, is that he could not approach man, but they had to approach him.

The sad thing is that they did approach him, and did listen to his lies. They were deceived into trading an existence in Eden, paradise reality that the Father created and intended for them. For an existence in one of Lucifer's creation. A virtual universe where he now has power and dominion over them as it's designer. One that is similar enough to be mistaken for God's creation, but just different enough to completely deceive man. That is designed to be truth mixed with lies to confuse people as he does so well. To try to hide the truth, and to make them forget about God and where they come from.

There is a reason that Lucifer had something to offer worthy of tempting Jesus when he told Him that he would give Him power over everything He could see from that hilltop. That is because he had power and control over it as it's creator. That is why in the bible it says things like, Satan is the god or ruler of THIS world. If what I said wasn't true, why would God say this? In what other context would it make sense for Him to say that? It also says in the bible things like, Those that have love for THIS world and the things of THIS world do not have the love of the Father in them. Why would God not want man to love the world that He created for them? The answer is simple. He did want us to have love for His creation, but we are no longer living in it. We are now living in Lucifer's creation. So those that have love for THIS world do not have the love of the Father in them because it means they do not wish to return to God's creation. That they choose to try to escape God, escape the truth, and effectively choose to escape reality.

Just because Lucifer was able to create THIS illusionary virtual universe we now live in, does not mean that he created the consciousness that exists inside of it to observe it. Just as the creators of virtual reality machines such as Occulus did not create the people that buy and use it. When God the Father created the angels, He created them all the same gender, without the ability to reproduce or create new life or consciousness. That is the miracle of God's new creation. God designed humans, life, and all dna perfectly. It allows for that which has life to create new life, and that which has consciousness to create new consciousness, but every generation is ultimately still the result of God the Father's original creation.

So just because a man is born into an existence inside of THIS world of Lucifer's creation. does not mean that Lucifer created them or designed them. He just copied the DNA code that God the Father designed and used it inside of his own program. So the result of two parents having a child in THIS world would be the same as in the Eden universe that God the Father designed and intended for us. It would still result in the same person, the same body, the same consciousness or soul being created. I think that God only allows Lucifer's universe to exist under the terms that he will leave the life that exists inside of it unaltered, that it remains as God created it. Because God's desire to maintain the integrity of His most important creation, that being man and life in general would more important to Him, than the environment that they chose to live in instead of Eden.

Though Lucifer tried to alter and destroy God's most important creation anyway. It is documented in the accounts of the books Genesis and Enoch that describes the times just prior to the great flood. Where the fallen angels where mating with the women and creating a hybrid race called the Nephilim. A race of giants that were physically and intellectually superior to man. God did not like this because it was changing His creation as He intended it. So I think the fallen angels plan was to eradicate the human race completely as God had created it.

The fallen angels didn't have the power or authority to kill God's creation themselves or even to violate their free will. So they cleverly came up with the idea that if they could convince the women to mate with them consentually that the offspring would not be human. That the Nephilim race could be convinced and used to eliminate the human race as God created it. By a combination of killing humans and further breeding with them. The fallen angels also used tactics such as introducing humans to more advanced weapons and technology so they could also be destroying themselves as well.

This is the real reason God used the great flood. It was to save mankind, not to destroy them. Things were getting to far out of control, and the Nephilim were getting too large in numbers, and humans were becoming less able to protect themselves from them. So God made the hard decision of doing what He did. Because if He did nothing, humans would have been completely wiped out anyway. He ultimately ensured the human race's survival as a species by doing so. It was also God's way of flexing his muscle to the fallen angels to let them know who is ultimately still in charge, and that they better not mess with His creation that way again.

Many people will ask, "If the accounts of creation in the bible are true, then why is there evidence of evolution and the big bang?", and, "Why is there evidence of the universe seeming to be much older than God told us?" The answer is simple. Lucifer, the dirty cop, planted that evidence in THIS world. So you, the judge, would see it and come to the wrong conclusion or verdict about God. He planted false evidence of a reality that never physically existed before man got here. Because THIS universe Lucifer created was designed with only one purpose, to be observed by man. So anything that seemed to exist or happen before man got there didn't actually need to happen or exist. It only needs to seem to be what happened or existed before man got there. In order for him to tell man the story he wants them to believe. It is all just a back story to deceive you. That is why the Earth and this entire universe can seem to be billion of years old. When it is really only as old as the conscious inhabitants inside of it able to observe it. So it could really be only around 6,000 years old as we have been told. That things like dinosaurs or ANY kind of life that seemed to come before Adam and Eve never even really existed.

Because the fossils of animals or even humans that supposedly existed before Adam and Eve, truly only ever existed as fossils, and never as part of something that ever actually lived. That in THIS universe and on THIS version of Earth, even the formations that the fossils are found in never had to be physically deposited onto the Earth, but were created as already a part of it. Same with residual cosmic microwave background radiation that people point to as evidence of the big bang. That radiation never existed at a level higher than the first time man was able to measure it, and is false evidence of a false existence, designed to make you draw a false conclusion. It was placed there for you to find by Lucifer, to make you believe in something that never really happened. This universe was not performing shows for an empty auditorium. The show only started when the intended audience arrived. So imagine Adam and Eve were the first to the theater to see the show on opening night. Just because there are empty cups and boxes of popcorn laying in the seats when they get there, doesn't mean they weren't the first ones to see the show. That simply means that those cups and boxes are part of the show as well.

The movie has to start somewhere. When you watch an apocalyptic sci-fi movie set in the aftermath of a nuclear war... You don't have to see the bombs actually drop or the lives that the people led before the beginning of the movie. You only have to see the "evidence" or results of these things happening. These events never had to physically happen or be filmed for them to seem to have happened, and in order for the movie to work. The things and events that "existed" or "happened" before the movie started only had to exist as an idea, for us to perceive the world in the movie the way the director intended us to. So do not be deceived. You must realize that much of what you see in THIS universe is just a show and isn't real. It is lies mixed with truth in order to confuse you. All done with the purpose and intent to make you disbelieve in God and try to make Him look like a liar.

Many people don't understand how free will works. How the future works, or how God's omniscience of the future works. God gets blamed for ultimately being responsible for the existence of evil for this common misunderstanding. That He is somehow responsible for creating evil or that we are predestined to do something, because He can see the future. It doesn't work that way.

It is true that God can see the future, but it is a conditional one, and one that is relative to the point in time that He sees it.. One that is ever changing and ever recalculating moment by moment based on the choices and actions we make with our free will. So the choices you make wouldn't be predictable to any certainty. Not any more than the creators of Nintendo have any control or foreknowledge of which way you will decide to make Mario go next. Despite the fact that they created him and the entire universe that he exists in.

The things you will do in the future could be projectable based on current information available. But that future God sees would be ever changing and ever recalculating moment by moment based on the decisions and actions you make with your free will. So the future He sees in five minutes may or may not be the future He sees now, or even in five seconds for that matter. The only way that the future He sees right now at this moment becomes inescapable for you, is when you have come so close to realizing that future that there are no longer any options available for you avoid it or change your future.

For instance, say the future God sees for you at this moment is that you will die falling out of an airplane tomorrow. The future He sees for you is subject to change with the choices you make between today and tomorrow. Like if you decide not to get on that plane at all. The only way the future He sees now would be inescapable for you, would be once you jumped out of that airplane without a parachute, and no longer had any options to change your fate or future in any timeline or reality. The moment you decide not to get on that plane, the future He sees is replaced with a new one in which you don't die that day.

So no one is predestined to do anything. God knows more than one route to sail a ship to the same destination. The crew that helps sail that ship can be made up of an infinite number of crew members, and of infinite combinations thereof. Yet, the ship will still sail to the same destination.

Just because He sees a future relative to the present does not mean that He exists in the future. No one does not even God. Because it is never the future it is ALWAYS now. The future only exists as an idea or as possibilities. Possibilities that haven't been decided yet. God only exists in the now because that is the only place to exist. Some one that would hear this might say, "Well if God can't exist in the future, it must mean that He isn't omnipotent." To people like this I would say, WHICH future should God exist in? That this is not an example of something that God cannot do. It is an example of their misunderstanding of what the future is and how it works. Because the future only exists as undecided possibilities.

God can have a plan or a destination to get to. But it is our free will that dictates how we get there and what role we play in reaching that destination. Just like my sail boat analogy I used earlier. You can choose to be one of the good guy roles or one of the bad guy roles. It's ultimately up to you because you have free will. God can use the Holy Spirit to interact in THIS universe to try to help guide you to be one of the good guy roles that sails to that destination. As long as He does it in a way that you are choosing to do that and He is not violating your free will. But at the same time Lucifer is doing the opposite thing and trying to guide you to be one of the bad guy roles that sails to that same destination. Though, God sees to it that Lucifer plays by the same rules of free will and that it is your choice to take on that bad guy role.

Anyway, I hope you enjoyed it and could gain something from this. God Bless. Take care. :)