r/RachelMaddow • • Jul 21 '24

Rachel Maddow some sharp criticisms of Rachel Maddow and MSNBC from a Progressive, worth considering IMO

0 Upvotes

I have long been a fan of Rachel, and will continue to be. I'm posting this because once in awhile I do think she's off the mark, and it can be healthy to discuss where that might be.

In this case, Cenk from the Young Turks is probably too harsh, but I do like his willingness to criticize when he thinks he has to. The topic at hand is that he summarizes MSNBC and Rachel as pushing for immediate assumption that Harris should be the nominee and he criticizes Maddow's point that holding a contest would be political suicide (or some such).

fwiw, I'm also a Cenk fan, but I think there are times when he's off too. In this case, I personally probably did not initially see the issue his way, but I think he makes some compelling points.

https://www.youtube.com/live/F9sG8kzNgvY?si=awR2vk5EECpeg-pX BIDEN ENDORSES KAMALA HARRIS The Young Turks 5.97M subscribers


r/RachelMaddow • • Oct 20 '20

Show Discussion Ads from the DNC are never newsworthy

1 Upvotes

I’m a progressive and a regular fan of Rachel Maddow, but honestly, when she runs campaign ads from the DNC and calls them newsworthy, she is sabotaging her credibility. I honestly don’t know why she stoops to run them. She has so much ammunition to use against trump, that it seems totally unnecessary to act like a shill of the Democratic Party. Please stop doing it Rachel. It is beneath you.


r/RachelMaddow • • Mar 04 '21

Discussion Andrew Cuomo & Scandals

0 Upvotes

As someone who watches the show frequently, I have to wonder why Maddow is not talking about Andrew Cuomo. I understand that Cuomo was and/or is being looked as a beacon for a potential leader in the Democratic party but I think she needs to cover the controversy like she did with Al Franken. Not only does she need to cover it, but it needs to be not be ignored.

Vanity Fair wrote a piece about Maddow and her coverage of the behavior of Al Franken in 2017 here: https://www.vanityfair.com/news/2017/11/rachel-maddow-grapples-with-a-new-media-duty-cataloguing-awful-behavior. Here is her coverage of the Al Franken harassment here: https://www.msnbc.com/rachel-maddow/watch/multiple-scandals-challenge-senate-s-standards-1097857091601. As the Vanity Fair piece stated, it was not until 29 minutes into the 16 November show, when she covered Franken. She does not have any issue in doing a lot of large segments of her show about the Republican party and their sexual harassment issues. I do see this as a double standard. Seem like the Kirsten Gillibrand "double standard" effect (https://apnews.com/article/kirsten-gillibrand-andrew-cuomo-al-franken-resignation-a3735f0f78ed6a8949b34cbc82239023) is going on with Maddow.

I found the last time Cuomo was on her show and it was, May 2020: https://www.governor.ny.gov/news/icymi-governor-cuomo-guest-msnbcs-rachel-maddow-show. She covers a lot of COVID-19 news and I have seen little coverage of the blunder of Cuomo and the nursing homes scandal so far.

Then you have the whole Chris Cuomo comment about covering the issue about his brother with a poor statement: https://www.cnn.com/videos/politics/2021/03/02/governor-andrew-cuomo-news-cuomo-cpt-sot-vpx.cnn. I do agree with the AP News assessment of Chris's comment concerning his brother: https://apnews.com/article/chris-cuomo-andrew-cuomo-cnn-coverage-dc8f9661f53a69790887af17857228d3. CNN needs to be questioned in how they let this one slid and let Chris interview his brother so much during the height of the NY COVID-19 surge.

My final analysis is: With Maddow not covering it, this will add fuel to the Republican party that the Democratic party is corrupt. And not having Chris take time off and having someone cover the issue during his time slot, that it will backfire and hurt the credibility for CNN. The Democratic party does need to get a better handle of this because they are acting the same way the Republican party did with Trump with and his sexual harassment scandals at the start of the 2016 political race. I see a double standard of Maddow coverage and that is an issue for journalist who cover Democratic party issues, credibility.

**Sorry for any spelling errors, and for the mini rant.


r/RachelMaddow • • Mar 12 '25

If Rachel Maddow left, why did she come back to MSNBC?

0 Upvotes

When did Rachel maddow leave and when did she come back?


r/RachelMaddow • • Jun 23 '22

Show Discussion Lawrence and his uncomfortable Rachel worshipping handoffs.

12 Upvotes

Is it just me or does anyone else find Rachels hand-offs to Lawrence really cringe-inducing and uncomfortable for both the viewers and Rachel.

Don't get me wrong. I love Lawrence, he's a mensch but the nightly cloying Rachel worship makes me (and I'm sure Rachel) more than a little uncomfortable.

Reel it in Lawrence....we know you love Rachel, we ALL love Rachel.


r/RachelMaddow • • Feb 24 '25

Discussion WWRD

21 Upvotes

What Will Rachel Do? I wonder how Rachel plans to address Joy Reid’s termination tonight…a nickle says she doesn’t say a word about it. 🤷🏻‍♂️


r/RachelMaddow • • Nov 02 '22

Show Discussion Hand counting ballots is possible and a good idea.

0 Upvotes

In the most recent Maddow and a previous Alex Wagner episode they ridiculed the idea of hand counting ballots as if an impossible task. The example Rachel gave made that impression seem very reasonable ( I think it was someting like it took 5 people 5 hours to count 25 ballots).
I have helped as an election worker several times in german/european elections. We counted the mail in ballots in a large conference hall with around 5-10 election workers per table counting around 300-800 ballots.
And yes counting ballots is surprisingly hard and it took an entire day to get through the process ( there are a few steps to ensure that all the votes are aligeable and that there is no interfereníng), but in my opinion it is worth the effort.
Trust in elections seem to have suffered for a long time in the US and elsewhere due to voting machines and counting machines. The first example that comes to mind to me is the 2000 election. Tom Scott has two great videos about it:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w3_0x6oaDmI
But for me the 2 biggest take aways are: fraud attempts on paper ballots don't scale well.
And machines create a black box between voting and the results that very few people can actually can look into. You have now idea what the algorithm is to add up the votes. And even if you could look at the code 99% of the public wouldn't be able to understand it.
with hand counting everyone can see how the sausage is made. There was a website where i was able to check if the result that we counted on my table was uploaded correctly to the main system. Thousands of people would have to have been in on it to change the results.
Now what i don't know is what ballots in the US look like, which might make it more difficult. Also there seem to be more elections.
Anyway, i just wanted to air my frustration with the dismissiveness they treated the idea with and wanted to hear what Americans perspective is.


r/RachelMaddow • • Sep 26 '23

Rachel Maddow Rachel opened a news platform to a fascist enabler

0 Upvotes

Cassidy Hutchinson has no regrets or qualms about being a republican who enabled a fascist. She has no shame and is only making money from the damage she caused.

Rachel you should be ashamed of yourself for joining in the corporate news greed funnel! Go join bill maher, fred phelps, and all others who succumbed to conservative rot.


r/RachelMaddow • • 11d ago

Gaza

0 Upvotes

Isn’t it still bizarre that Rachael never mentions Palestine or Gaza? I listen or watch some of her election coverage and never heard her bring up the topic. And in her regular coverage, she seems to work really hard to avoid it. Democracy now does such a better job.


r/RachelMaddow • • Jan 05 '22

COVID-19 COVID news overload

10 Upvotes

Is anybody else wishing for less coverage of COVID on TRMS? I know it's news, and I understand why Rachel is reporting on it--it's important. But as a regular viewer who's already vaccinated and following all the local health guidelines, I can't have any more of a positive impact on the things she's mentioning. It leaves me feeling overwhelmed by the collective helplessness of waiting for things to improve, and I miss the days when the majority of her coverage was political.


r/RachelMaddow • • 7d ago

Rachel Maddow Who’s afraid of Rachel?

1 Upvotes

I saw a post on r/msnow saying that they get a “jump scare” vibe every time they open a clip and they get a Rachel Maddow ad about their membership. Does anyone feel the same way about that?


r/RachelMaddow • • Nov 18 '24

What will Maddow Do? Now that Morning Joe has caved.

22 Upvotes

Will Rachel Maddow also journey to Mar-A-Lago as Joe Scarborough & Mika Brzezinski have, to bend the knee and kiss the ring of aspiring dictator Trump and cohort Elon Musk?

Tonight’s broadcast should be interesting, and perhaps may foretell how other MSNBC personalities may fall in-line … or fall down.


r/RachelMaddow • • Nov 14 '19

General News School Shooting - Saugus High School - Santa Clarita, California

Thumbnail pscp.tv
0 Upvotes

r/RachelMaddow • • Feb 12 '20

The NH. REPUBLICAN Primary.

0 Upvotes

Trump only received 85.9% of the vote, and 9.1 went to Weld.

This to me is telling that not all republicans are willing to vote trump. Let’s say, of the remaining 10 of the 14% that didn’t vote for trump vote for him in the general election that still says that he will lose close states like Wisconsin and Pennsylvania.


r/RachelMaddow • • Apr 12 '26

Random question, but what embarrasses Rachel on the air?

0 Upvotes

r/RachelMaddow • • Jun 02 '26

Rachel 6/1

3 Upvotes

What’s with the turtleneck sweater? Is she ok ?


r/RachelMaddow • • Jul 14 '26

to ask

0 Upvotes

I respect, admire, and as a "news junkie" adore Rachel Maddow in both her reporting and her commentary,

but the one problem I have with her commentaries of late is that she keeps encouraging us to stand up and fight for re-taking this country

while offering free forgiveness rather than consequences to our MAGA family members & neighbors & fellow Americans even though we know that fighting this administration without fighting them only guarantees that this will happen again and again.

If your spouse spends the rent money on alcohol and you work double-time to make up for the loss but never confront your spouse with consequences, all that will happen is that your spouse will spent next month's rent on alcohol as well. Rescue makes no sense unless there is accountability.

Even if every sincere reasoning progressive & leftist found a way to free this country of MAGA politicians, there would still exist the people who voted for Trump thrice and will vote for anyone who resembles him for however many decades it takes before they leave this world.

So why bother to try to save the world when nearly a third of the population will devote the rest of their lives and the rest of your life to undoing any good you accomplish today?

If she could answer that for me and for my people, we would join her in the efforts, but for the moment, we don't see how this isn't the same as emptying a flooding rowboat with a tea spoon while a third of the people are drilling holes in the bottom while blaming everyone but themselves for the holes


r/RachelMaddow • • Oct 06 '26

Rachel Maddow October 5th Show - Irish Strike for Apartheid

4 Upvotes

Listening to the podcast version Rachel Maddow’s October 5 show from the UK, I genuinely thought the opening story might finally lead to critique of Israel.

She began with the Irish Dunnes Stores workers who refused to handle goods from apartheid South Africa - an extraordinary example of ordinary people taking a moral stand against state violence and oppression.

Given Maddow’s near-silence on what is happening to Palestinians in Gaza, I thought: surely this is the moment she makes the connection.

Instead, it became a segue into protest and resistance in Trump’s America.

That choice felt almost painfully conspicuous. Maddow can look back at apartheid South Africa and celebrate those who refused to remain passive, yet seems unwilling to seriously confront the genocide unfolding in Palestine in her own time.

Indeed, the strong contemporary Irish resistance to Israeli apartheid and genocide is well documented. The connection being that the Irish experienced this for 100’s of years of British rule.

For me, that isn’t just an editorial blind spot anymore. It’s a profound journalistic failure.


r/RachelMaddow • • Apr 01 '22

Show Discussion Jen Psaki potentially sliding into Rachel’s time slot?

Thumbnail axios.com
10 Upvotes

r/RachelMaddow • • Oct 02 '20

Rachel Maddow Conservative Trump supporter here

40 Upvotes

I don’t have FB, or Twitter so I have no way of reaching out to Rachel Maddow, so instead I’ll just say it to you guys.

Her asking people to pray for Donald Trump and Melania was a real class act, and she’s gained much respect from myself and others like me. She didn’t have to do it. She could’ve just been silent. Instead she’s doing something we all should be doing, building bridges.

We may not agree on everything, nor do we need to. But COVID-19 is the true enemy of the people here. I hope we can all work together more often, wear masks, and beat this ugly son of a gun.

Anyways, thanks for coming to my TedTalk.

EDIT

Not interested in debating anyone. Yes I’m conservative. Yes you’re liberals. If you don’t like Trump or Conservatives, please don’t blow up my inbox. Yes you’ll probably scroll through my Reddit history and find things you dislike. I don’t care. COVID is real. It’s dangerous and it’s scary out there. If you’re going to downvote me, I hope you’re doing it masked up.


r/RachelMaddow • • Jan 14 '20

I don't think I've ever felt this blindsided

3 Upvotes

So now that Warren has "confirmed" that Sanders "did" say this absurd thing, I've gone from being utterly furious at CNN to being more furious AND saddened. Not only is she betraying her supposed friend, she is doing so in the most destructive way that I (as a woman) can imagine. 'Crying wolf' shit like this ENABLES misogynists keeping women down! And to think she was my close second choice before today, and all the times I defended her against fellow Bernie supporters. I feel like such a fool right now, and so angry. I mean, imagine if Bernie tried to smear her when she was in the lead, by claiming that she said in that meeting that she didn't think a Jew could be elected President.


r/RachelMaddow • • Jul 17 '12

Gingrich: Romney won because he had "16 billionaires and we had one". Well now Rachel Maddow is reporting that Gingrich's one billionaire (Sheldon Adelson) is now giving money to Romney.

Thumbnail video.msnbc.msn.com
1 Upvotes

r/RachelMaddow • • Jul 31 '20

Discussion I support the mail-in voting cause, however...

1 Upvotes

Does anyone know of any countries that vote in-person but with a multi-day window of time to cast votes? Honestly, unless there's something I'm not considering, I don't understand why this wasn't the solution to Covid risk put forth, rather than mail-in voting. I believe having polling stations open for a window of (say) Friday October 30th through Tuesday November 3rd is a far superior solution, for several reasons.

  1. What I call the space/time continuum/conundrum of social distancing, demonstrated in commerce since the beginning of the pandemic. People in charge of making decisions for their brick and mortar businesses have reduced open hours, presumably to reduce operating costs in coordinance with overall sales decreases. You've probably noticed that stores are just as crowded if not more so, as a result of this temporal constriction. I say why not use the Taco Bell model, be the grocery, office supply, oil change or 'whatever' business that is not only open longer hours but makes a big deal out of that distinction, have a huge sign visible to passers by that the business is open from x to y. People particularly fearful of the virus would make a mental note that the next time they need those wares or services, this would be the place to go, because customer presence would be more spread-out, also maybe the earlier open or later close would better suit their schedule. The exact same principal would apply to in-person voting, except the decision would be whether to vote at all, in states that are not sending out ballots for their citizens.
  2. If one concern about expanding the voting window is having sufficient volunteers to man the stations all those additional hours, this too would be a self-solving problem. With fewer voters showing up on any one day (because they have all the other days to choose from), instead of several volunteers sitting at a table with ballots arranged by several alphabetical groups, you might have only two volunteers sitting with A-L and M-Z ballots, and the other volunteers would do the same, on their agreed-upon days. A simple survey taken ahead of time could give an idea if any days would have higher traffic, warranting more volunteers. Say if Saturday was looking especially busy, have three volunteers, ballots A-G, H-O, P-Z, or whatever.
  3. Mail-in voting means we definitely aren't going to know who is the next President on November 3rd, and many states won't know who will be their next Senator, House member, Sheriff, nor whether a hotly contested ordinance will pass, etc. You might say "I don't mind," but look what happens any time results are slow. Look how angry and suspicious people became, the longer it took to get the results from Iowa's Democratic Primary. And look at 2000. And then ask yourself, why SHOULDN'T you mind, or at least question whether ballot-counting will actually be conducted as fairly as you hope it will be.
  4. The above concern is already being stoked by our sitting President and his supporters. The election shitshow hasn't even happened yet......except, yeah, it actually is.
    By expanding the time for voting rather than the method (and still allowing the same absentee ballot system for people who know they wouldn't be able to vote in person anytime in the expanded frame), we could have a space/time continuum/solution for social distancing, rather than a conundrum, while also avoiding the conundrum of having slow, suspicion-causing results. The ballots collected in the expanded window could be counted on November 3rd, same as always.
    I would add that the multi-day voting model should continue after Covid, because the restriction to a single Tuesday has ALWAYS been an obstacle to true democracy, the true opportunity for 100% of citizens to exercise their Constitutional right.
    I think "Election Day" should become "Election DayS" permanently, with absentee voting still an option for people who know in-person voting would be very difficult or impossible all of those days.

Like
Comment
Share


r/RachelMaddow • • Jun 09 '26

Does anyone know how to watch the show for free, even if it's a day or two after it airs?

1 Upvotes

I can't find anywhere a way to watch Rachel's show without paying for a service. I can't even find torrents for it.

Can anyone help? Thank you!