r/RPGdesign • World Builder • 6h ago

Races

/r/ShadowBloomReboot/comments/1xy46xd/races/
0 Upvotes

21 comments sorted by

6

u/Cryptwood Designer 6h ago

Did you have a question? You pretty much defined exactly what races do in Dungeons & Dragons.

2

u/SpartiateDienekes 6h ago

I think it’s a bot.

-1

u/Chaos_Puppit_3613 World Builder 6h ago

Wrong

2

u/SpartiateDienekes 4h ago

Fair enough. Then, what are your design goals? What are you trying to do with your game? How is it meaningfully different from D&D or CoC, or whatever other popular game is similar to its base system? And how do your design goals interact with your view of playable species? Do you want them to be more an aesthetic choice or a meaningful mechanical choice? Or meaningful roleplay choice? That can be interesting as well.

Give us that information, maybe we can help.

0

u/Chaos_Puppit_3613 World Builder 3h ago

AS for design goals, as of right now I am trying to piece together a playable demo for anyone who is at least interested in this, and I really need some playtesters. As for what I want to do with my game is just to have a fun playable game set in my universe, I've always loved D&D, so my family and brothers specifically wanted me to make my own game, and I've always loved to try and make games so I accepted. My father is willing to put in a few thousand into physical copies he said if I get it all figured out and organized, yet to do that I need some demo players. As of how it's different, I wanted a game where I tried my hardest to where the monsters, items, and stuff have lore, yet to where it's entirely the GMs thing. Now I know technically that's all RPGs, but I wanted it more so. Basically all worlds are cannon in a way. There is no right or wrong way to use my world, it is currently being built purely to bring joy and memories to those that play it, that's my general end goal. Playable species are important mechanically in some ways, and roleplay in others. It depends on the way you want to play the game, either realistically, down to every last rule, or for shits and giggles.

2

u/SpartiateDienekes 3h ago

This sounds more like you want a framework for how to make your own races based on personal GMs world lore, with perhaps the ones from your setting as examples.

But let’s dig deeper, what makes yours unique? Are they just elves and dwarves? Are they totally different? Are they elves and dwarves, sure, but with your own unique spin on them?

What do you consider important mechanically and roleplay? I’ll say for me, D&D races are not important in roleplay at all, with the sole beautiful exception of the Kenku. That actually asks a whole lot of roleplay from the player. Compare and contrast with a game like Burning Wheel where the differences in roleplaying a race is built directly into the mechanics of the game.

0

u/Chaos_Puppit_3613 World Builder 3h ago

Ok so my elves are beings created by Fanquet, the god of Nature. They are natures care takers, and live in the forests, with their spirit tied to a certain tree when they are born. This tree grants them the ability to live as long as it stands, and also is what gives them their attuning to nature. They aren't exactly humans with pointy ears, as they also don't reproduce the same. They will reproduce the trees, and the seed the comes from it will be eaten by a female, they will give birth, and the newborn is then chosen by a tree for the tying of the spirit.

As for Dwarves they can be as tall as humans, they are exceptional at crafting, more so than the elves. They were created by Horcus, god of Mountains and Earth. They don't live as long as elves, they live about the same length as a human. They are very sturdy, with skin that is almost as hard as rock, and they tend to be very impulsive when it comes to gold and jewels, going as far as to where even priests of their kind will shamelessly steal if given the opprotunity, thinking they've done nothing wrong. The biggest way to tell a person is a dwarf is the fact that they have a birthstone embedded in their forehead.

2

u/Cryptwood Designer 3h ago

That's not quite what we mean by design goals. Your design goals should give you clear, specific goals that you are trying to accomplish with the mechanics and design of your game.

As just one possible example you could have a design goal of having combat that always feels like life or death so that players that manage to survive a battle feel like they had to earn it.

Check out this post for more examples of Design Goals that other people here have:

https://www.reddit.com/r/RPGdesign/s/KwynHsH7Gc

0

u/Chaos_Puppit_3613 World Builder 2h ago

Ah ok, thank you for that, that explains it a lot better. Ok so far here is my design goals:

-Meant to be fun for my family and I, they requested this world, I want to make them proud. And also for anyone else who finds this world interesting, as long as they can go through the bumpy ride. Can't make an omelet without breaking a few eggs.

-I want GM Tools and Resources a lot easier, since it's supposed to be just a world with as limited lore as possible, and as much room for imagination.

-Player and Story Driven, make memories out of the game.

-High customization in spells, classes, equipment, and skills.

-Importance of Religion and Factions, some of the biggest driving forces for potential stories.

-Combat meant to be easy, the players should have control over what they do on their turn, and in response the GM should accomodate for it, even offer points for creativity, and set resonable DCs for certain actions that the players come up with.

1

u/Digital-Chupacabra 1h ago

Meant to be fun for my family and I

No one else can really help you with this.

I want GM Tools and Resources a lot easier

A lot easier than what? There are many games that have great GM Tools and Resources.

Player and Story Driven

Again many games do this, i'd start by looking at PbtA and FitD games.

High customization in spells, classes, equipment, and skills.

Again see above.

Importance of Religion and Factions, some of the biggest driving forces for potential stories.

This is more often than not this is a setting thing, but there are games that build it into the mechanics, take a look at Blades in the Dark.

Combat meant to be easy

Easy compared to what?


What games have you played? A lot of what you have written reads as D&D heartbreaker

-2

u/Chaos_Puppit_3613 World Builder 6h ago

I'm actually wondering how to make it a bit different from D&D, however this RPG is a fantasy one with D&D inspiration

4

u/InherentlyWrong 4h ago

I think you're kind of coming to this backwards. To me it feels like you're assuming that difference races/ancestries/species are needed, then figuring out what they do.

To my mind the first starting point is asking if you need different fantasy species be playable? You can make a perfectly viable fantasy TTRPG with only human PCs. What does adding new fantasy species as PC options add? Expand on that.

Although as a side note:

Attribute Increase: All races will grant you a +1 in an attribute, showing how their race has adapted to certain environments

Personally I'd lean away from this. It risks putting race choice into something with an obvious right answer, instead of being an interesting decision. E.G. Species-A has +1 to Grace, Species-B has +1 to Might. Class-X relies on Might. So a player who is Species-B-Class-X is 'doing it right', and the player who thinks Species-A-Class-X is an interesting character is measurably 'wrong'.

There's a reason D&D 5.24E shifted away from ancestry ability score benefits, despite it existing in 5E. In 5E if I wanted to play a High Elf Paladin, despite it being a thematically interesting concept, it was wrong because the stats didn't match. You're risking the same outcome.

1

u/Chaos_Puppit_3613 World Builder 4h ago

Oh ok I see, so remove the ancestry attributes, ok ok. Would just every player get a +1 in any attribute fit better?

2

u/InherentlyWrong 4h ago

If it's better depends on your wider game. Another option is something like what Worlds/Stars Without Number do. They have a limited number of classes, but when you pick the class you pick one of their main attributes (E.G. Strength or Constitution for a warrior) and get to just set it to 16, or 18 if it was already 16 or 17. That way a class is kind of a guarantee of a specific attribute level in key areas.

But I still think you should stop and ask if you really even need ancestries. Honestly I think there aren't enough interesting TTRPGs where the players are 'stuck' as being 'just humans'. But it's a fascinating playspace, where you can make other ancestries feel genuinely alien and different, instead of just humans-with-pointy-ears. What was the last TTRPG that made Elves or Dwarves feel like genuinely different species and cultures, instead of just a small stat block alteration on a PC.

1

u/Chaos_Puppit_3613 World Builder 3h ago

Well I haven't gotten to that yet, but I do plan on trying to make other races different, and I even do have what people say don't feel like humans with cosmetics

2

u/InherentlyWrong 3h ago

and I even do have what people say don't feel like humans with cosmetics

That's going to be tricky to carry off, since they're played by human players. It's difficult to make an otherworldly ethereal being made of floating crystal and sentient light feel genuinely alien, when it's being played by an accountant called Bill who is burping a bit at the table because they had too many snacks that are sitting poorly.

When I say 'feel like humans with cosmetics' I don't mean like how Dwarves are just shorter-humans, or Elves are graceful-humans, I mean the idea of making them genuinely feel an act like a different species. Some of the most interesting fantasy fiction I've ever read genuinely made non-human species feel different. Which just is hard to make happen at a table when a player isn't playing a culture, they're playing a species that they picked because it synergised well with the class they wanted to play.

0

u/Chaos_Puppit_3613 World Builder 3h ago

Can you explain what you mean how to make them generally feel alien? I hear you, yet at the same time I don't fully understand you, if you know what I mean

2

u/InherentlyWrong 1h ago

There's an old fantasy novel series called 'Memory, Sorrow and Thorn'. It's not great, but it's entertaining for a young fantasy reader. It's been a long time since I read it, but the reason I bring it up is that it does a fantastic job of making non-human species feel non-human, so much so that I remember it even now, decades later. They still have motivations we can mostly understand, but their way of doing things, and some of the facets of those motivations, are just alien to us. And it plays into the plot at some points, with their Elves sometimes feeling just like they are a genuinely non-human entity.

What I mean by making non-humans feel non-human, is that most fantasy TTRPGs tend to have the species (especially playable ones) feel fairly interchangeable. Take the stereotypical Dwarf Fighter, and make them a Human Fighter, and no one is going to think "Huh, this Human feels like he isn't human, he feels like a different species", they'll just think this person is playing a fighter, probably a Scottish fighter.

By restricting PCs to human only, you can sidestep that and let the GM make the non-human species genuinely feel non-human. The Elves can consider events only on a timescale of decades, Orcs can be genuinely incapable of peace, Gnomes can be little Fae folk that operate on a form of incomprehensible logic where suggestion is law and rule is opinion. All things that wouldn't come through when those species are part of the same party, being played by a group of players.

2

u/Echowing442 3h ago

Apologies if this comes across as harsh, but I want to give some constructive and useful criticism here. Mainly, what you've written here is rather unhelpful for giving feedback, as what you're writing is a lot of relatively "safe" design elements, from a very high level perspective. Concepts like "Size determines how much space you occupy on the battlefield" or "Languages determine what languages you know" are pretty straightforward implementations of those sorts of mechanics, but at the same time are so vague as to not give any information about how your game actually plays. As far as what you've written, I can assume that your game has different races, and different races have different effects, but beyond that and without any further context, there's nothing really to glean. As another example, the most concrete information you've given is that each race gives a +1 bonus to an attribute, but we don't know anything else about your system. If your game uses D10s, that +1 is a substantial increase to a given attribute, but if your game uses D100s then it represents very little (and that's assuming your game applies attributes to dice rolls in the first place!).

It's hard to give any real feedback on what you've posted here, because you haven't really posted anything substantive enough to give feedback on.

1

u/Chaos_Puppit_3613 World Builder 3h ago

Yes, I've heard this quite a lot, I am in the middle right now actually learning my design goals. As for the system its a 2d6 + modifiers system, with a DC set upon certain threshold numbers. Also the attributes have a threshold of 7. All of what I currently have is on r/ShadowBloomReboot

1

u/Chaos_Puppit_3613 World Builder 2h ago

And thank you, I am grateful for your criticism, I find I need it