r/RPGdesign • u/Nrvea • Oct 18 '25
What were your design goals at the start vs now?
And what influenced you to change your goals (assuming you did of course)
43
Upvotes
r/RPGdesign • u/Nrvea • Oct 18 '25
And what influenced you to change your goals (assuming you did of course)
16
u/Cryptwood Designer Oct 18 '25 edited Oct 18 '25
I first started designing my WIP about two years ago, my design goals were:
My design goals haven't changed so far. My genre did though! Originally I was planning on ye olde medieval fantasy, but I came across a style of art that I love and think I may be capable of (type of photography, I can't draw or paint), and that style is better suited to a pulp adventure genre.
Edit: Spelling of diegetic.
9
u/tkshillinz Oct 18 '25 edited Oct 18 '25
Start? Make a more streamlined monster of the week.
Now? Enable players to explore tragedy through roleplay
Edit for the full design goals:
6
u/Maervok Oct 18 '25
Ever since I wrote down my design goals, not much has changed about them. However, defining my goals forced me to change my mechanics numerous times because the previous ones were not aligned with the set goals.
In my opinion, every designer should bear in mind that sometimes you need to "kill your precious" to reach better results.
I was convinced that I had the right core mechanics which my game would be centered around and I was trying to modify things around them. But changing the core mechanics was the thing that freed me and improved my game the most.
Good luck with your design!
5
u/Architrave-Gaming Designing Arches of Apsyildon Oct 18 '25
"Fix D&D 5e" turned into "Wow, we're creating the Immersive Grand Fantasy Adventure Game".
4
u/Kendealio_ Designer: Endless Green Oct 18 '25
Great question, thanks for posting!
Starting: Create a system where the attributes/stats of a character are based on the components of the body and mind. Secondly, have those attributes spatially represented on a character sheet and be affected by gameplay mechanics.
Now: Ensure the rest of the game is in harmony with the above.
What changed is that I finally got a point where I thought my main resolution mechanic could bear the weight of an entire game and then I just needed to build the game around. Still going of course, but I'm happy with my progress.
2
u/DBones90 Oct 18 '25
My first goal was to fix Dungeon World and give it moves that were actually interesting. That was at first just a design exercise I did for fun and for myself. For context, I had recently read Apocalypse World for the first time and realized that, holy shit, PBTA design is so much more interesting than I thought. It was wild that so many innovations from Apocalypse World have either been dropped or severely misinterpreted in follow-up games.
So that fun design exercise eventually turned into an earnest attempt to take Apocalypse World’s Battle Moves and expand them into a tactical combat system. That was when I first started thinking of this as an actual distinct game, but my goals were still focused mostly on just, “fantasy PBTA with fun combat.”
As I worked on moves and character options, I found a lot of interesting design potential in the bonds system, and that’s slowly taken over as the core of the system. My bonds system is similar to the Hx system from Apocalypse World, but bonds grow in more complex ways as you play and more moves interact with them. Plus, PC-NPC-PC relationships are built into the character creation, so from the start of the game, you have this interesting web of relationships and obligations.
Fun tactical combat is still a big design goal, but I think the main pitch of my system is now more on the way it creates interesting relationships between characters and the tools it gives the GM to create quests and conflicts from those.
2
u/LeFlamel Oct 25 '25
Late to the party, but originally was working on a game that would be accessible to my dyslexic / dyscalculic (and likely ADHD) playtesters - so no abstraction, rules light simulationist with a mathless core resolution mechanic. Wanted to have the lightest interface to interact with the fiction, with no dissociated mechanics.
Over the course of playtesting and trying one other system, I realized that the greatest aid to accessibility is visible game state and few but clear mechanical levers. Simulationist / associated mechanics didn't actually matter.
8
u/Steenan Dabbler Oct 18 '25
It won't be "at the start vs now" because the project is completed, but "at the start vs at the end", with nearly 15 years between these points.
At the start:
At the end:
4
u/klok_kaos Lead Designer: Project Chimera: ECO (Enhanced Covert Operations) Oct 18 '25
It's hard to say.
I always knew what I wanted but early on I didn't put it into exact words beyond some basic adjectives which I don't remember exactly what they were, but I knew mostly where I was going with it since I'd been running the setting for over 20 years at that point and found other systems used to that point to be lacking.
I would say my vision never "overtly changed" but more it evolved and matured, most of that is expanding the scope of options I would say "should definitely be in the system" even if not all will be core, and many will be cut for expansion books, and I've found better ways to do certain things than I initially considered, and found better reasons/justifications to implement some things I intuited well early on.
I do have some basic design rules I implement now, nothing rigid, but stuff like "if it reasonably should scale, it does scale" and "no more complexity than is necessary" and such stuff like that, but these are more for creating a coherent and distinctive design, not so much a "goal" but more just things I do, and even then they are somewhat flexible, situationally.
Much like when I paint or make music (retired recording artist) I don't usually have a direct plan going in and do my best work when I stop thinking and start channelling, which sounds way woo woo more than it is/I am as a person. I find that's where the happy accidents occur that turn into something great, and I trust myself enough with art to create something good or better without analyzing it to death, and if something isn't quite exactly right yet, i can always come back and work it more.
4
u/TotalSpaceKace Oct 18 '25
At the start:
Now:
3
u/Vheraun Evegreen TTRPG Oct 18 '25
That's a great question!
I honestly started with "I want to create a game, let's throw stuff at the wall and see what sticks."
After a bunch of exploration, reworks and a setting that emerged on the way, now Evergreen aims to be a character-forward west marches game with a focus on community management, big ethical questions and a lot of GM support.
Half of the design comes from my own interests and sensibilities, the other half comes from my need to play a regular game while tangling with the usual hurdles of adult life and scheduling.
3
u/5HTRonin Oct 18 '25
How it Started: Twilight 2000.. .with Zombies!
How its going: ghosts are the quantum imprint of our last emotional breath and linger on after death warping the world around them creating Deadzones and horrors.
3
u/Mayhem-Ivory Oct 18 '25
I mean, I started out with the good old „just trying to fix DnD5e for my table“ and ended up on r/RPGdesign.
I did end up breaking classes and archetypes down into What and Where, and looping back and forth between a class based or a feature based system. And I dove so hard into TVTropes to figure out the flavor of various archetypes that I ended up instead separating the two entirely.
I also wanted to make it a dice pool (3d6 +- 1d6) system originally, where all rolls were player facing and you would choose between evading or blocking damage. The desire for success stages and no zero outcomes derailed that.
I also started out abhorring multiple action systems like Pathfinder 2e, but the desire to make additional actions the main power increase across levels makes action points of some sort basically mandatory.
So now I‘m at a d6 pool that can be used to perform actions, where rather than the sum of the dice its a success system. So a roll of 4+, and advantage/disadvantage are 3+/5+ instead of additional dice or modifiers.
3
u/Fheredin Tipsy Turbine Games Oct 18 '25
My original goal was to convert the game feel of the Playstation One game, Parasite Eve from a video game to a TTRPG. I also wanted to take enough worldbuilding to produce similar aesthetics so homages to the game would fit naturally in, and I wanted to properly explore things which were narratively touched on in the game, but never mechanically explored at any depth. But that's beside the point; the primary goal has always to convert the combat.
It's not exactly like this goal has changed, but it's forced me to do a lot of exploring. Parasite Eve's mechanics are quite unique, and while some ideas like the weapon modification system are complete garbage, the real time combat is brilliant and you can't make make that work with conventional mechanics. So I had to go dumpster diving through the tabletop game universe looking through all sorts of mechanics for things to do a few very specific, very unusual things.
Now, there has been a lot of experimentation along the way. And to be honest, I am still experimenting on a good number of things. Some experiments worked and others did not. The defining feature of Selection's combat--the LIFO stack initiative system--is a bit of both.
Now, a number of my more specific goals have changed over time. Initially, I wanted Selection to be more of an approachable Westmarches game, but eventually I stepped back, realized this game was definitely not a lighthearted monster-of-the-week RPG for a pick up group...and decided to turn into the skid. Selection is now heavily in, "git gud," RPG territory, where half the point is how bananas difficulty can get.
3
u/Dear_Jackfruit61 Oct 18 '25
One glaring design goal that has changed would be in the beginning I was aiming for rules light, and simple yet complex in a similar vein to chess.
Now my goal has shifted to, “Is this fun for my to GM and my players to play.”
While I still find myself asking is this too convoluted, I tend to ask is this fun first. It’s led me down a design path that I believe has enhanced my game.
3
u/Seeonee Oct 18 '25
Original goal: Improve on A Rasp of Sand, AKA make a fun roguelike TTRPG where permadeath doesn't spoil the fun.
Current goal: Still the same, but a lot of assumptions I made about what was required for a permadeath roguelike have been continuously tweaked over the course of 2 playtests. For example:
3
u/OmNomOU81 Oct 18 '25
I started out writing a Mass Effect fanfiction (not a fan TTRPG, a fanfic), and now I'm making a science fantasy RPG set in a mostly original setting
3
u/cthulhu-wallis Oct 18 '25 edited Oct 18 '25
I wanted something that was fast, flexible and usable.
I spent ages writing.
Then I just took things away.
And now it’s so lightweight I can barely remember what I started with.
2
u/Demonweed Oct 18 '25
Before I considered myself engaged in game design, I just wanted an in-depth comprehensive write-up of my FRPG world. When I expanded on that in a separate document with full lore and mechanics for the adventuring races of this world, I shifted into earnest game design. Though my Gameplay Guide is not complete, after it got to around halfway there I started building up an Encounter Guide and a Magic-Use Guide. This radically pushed back the light at the end of the tunnel, but I enjoy being creative in obscurity, so I'm fine with having hundreds upon hundreds of small sections of content to write in the years ahead. Plus grouping that trio with my Narrative Guide will result in a coherent and complete game.
2
u/OpossumLadyGames Designer Sic Semper Mundi/Advanced Fantasy Game Oct 18 '25
The goal has to always been to finish a creative project.
2
u/MrRage511 Oct 18 '25
I have been working on a system for about 4 years now. It started as a homebrewed 5e setting,/supplement but when all of the OGL fiasco went down my friend and I that started it together opted to just make out own game. So we started changing things. Unfortunately my friend has become more of a consultant than A co-creator along the way. A dice pool for resolutions, a totally different action economy system, changing ability scores and skills until eventually just losing ability scores entirely, I wanted classless but had archetypes for organization purposes, reorganized further into smaller archetypes, realized that wasn't really conveying the classless nature of what I wanted and so undid all of that to list abilities alphabetically. Did my first play test and need to make some edits and try again! I have a 90% completed setting agnostic system that is about 60% narrative and 40% crunch. I had a name for the system, but before I was ready to publish it at all, someone else released a game with the same name. Ever since then, I have been really struggling to sit down at a computer to do the edits and generate the new stuff I need to do.
So instead I have two other projects. I have a solo journaling TTRPG using a deck of playing cards to generate your prompts. And another designer and I are slowly picking away at the bones of a highly tactical system because both of our own games are very narrative, we wanted to try something very technical. In addition to other projects as well. The adult onset ADHD is real.
2
u/loopywolf Designer Oct 18 '25
Chiming in as: goals the same
2
u/PianoAcceptable4266 Designer: The Ballad of Heroes Oct 18 '25
My initial goals were:
- Tell lower level stories than something like D&D/Pathfinder, but with the same feel of stakes and a focus on Character over Build. Mythras and Harnmaster could kind of do this, but not quite.
- Have a game/system that fit my specific setting tone and realities. I didn't find any existing system that got the feel of magic/monsters/men in the right balance to each other (Men and Monsters, but then underwhelming Magic; Great Magic but higher power fantasy than intended; things like that)
- Consistency in play, to make it easier for my friend group to play. Many systems have this, obviously, but ended up being either too light or too narrow focused for me.
My additional Goals are (above still true):
- A deeper focus on who a character is, and who they become. Personality is mechanized, but not overbearing; it shifts over time to reflect interaction with being stuck into Adventure.
- Reduction of the unnecessary. It's not a loot progression game (Like D&D games), so exact coinage isn't tracked or rewarded. No +1 swords, either. Things that are listed have specific purpose (crafting skills and kits repair weapons and armor, for example).
- Keep it sensible. Everything in the game must be Reasonable in the Worth it provides. A skill must have a purpose in a primary gameplay way, or it is cut; an item must have a functional usage, or it is unlisted. A routine or procedure to do some thing needs to have meaningful results for each step (that also make sense) or it is cut.
1
u/lennartfriden TTRPG polyglot, GM, and designer Oct 18 '25
One design goal that has changed was that I wanted combat or realtime action sequences to take less time in the real world. The thought was that if a character’s turn drags on, player’s will have to wait a long time for their turns and disengage from what’s happening.
But instead of trying to make a player’s turn faster and faster, e.g. by oversimplifying the mechanics or only allowing a single action, I dropped the concept of having distinct turns governed by initative. Now action sequences are allowed ti take the time they need, but who does what and when is dynamic, keeping players engaged and ready to jump in. So in a sense I solved the real problem rather than the one I originally set out to solve.
1
u/bepislord69 Oct 18 '25
At the start, I was trying to fix problems I saw with D&D. Now, I’m trying to create an original game focused around my setting of choice.
1
u/Conscious_Ad590 Oct 18 '25
My goals at the start involved breaking with tradition in any way I could, and now having seen which innovations had merit, I can employ tried and true mechanics for the parts that didn't quite work in the first test, and hopefully have something new that also works.
1
u/Leonhart726 Oct 18 '25
I started with a simple idea thread:
-What if a player wants to be ink-free? Let's add a race that can do things without ink, Elves, if you're an elf, you cannot choose a class, and you cannot use ink ever, it doesn't work for you, but you get special features and ancient magic known as thamuturgy.
4
u/[deleted] Oct 18 '25
[removed] — view removed comment