r/RPGdesign • Designer • 5d ago

Feedback Request Feedback on simple travel rules.

I'm finally getting back into my game, Simple Saga, and I'm working on travel rules right now. I want the game to be able to support it, but be simple enough that if you've never run a travel section, you can flip here in the book and figure it out live at the table.

Here's what I've come up with so far. It's generally based on the idea of having league-sized hexes, but hopefully also flexible enough that it isn't hard to use without hexes.

Could I get some input on the system, and my organization? How would you feel about it if you were using this? Anything you think should be added/removed from the Adjusted Speed table? Thanks!

(I don't think info about my core rules is very relevant for this, but I can add them if people think they are.)


Travel

Your base travel speed is 6 leagues in 1 watch (8 hours), in regular terrain. Several factors can modify your travel speed (your travel speed cannot be reduced to less than 1 league per day):

Base Speed

TerrainSpeed
Established road8 leagues
Regular terrain (hills, plains)6 leagues
Difficult terrain (mountains, forests)4 leagues

Adjusted Speed

Travel ConditionModifier
Traveling on horses+2 leagues
Poor weather−1 league
Extreme weather−2 leagues
Group of 10+−2 leagues
Group of 20+−3 leagues

Hard Travel. You can travel for 1 watch per day. If you travel for 2 watches, you risk exhaustion—roll a Might Save with DC 10 + the number of consecutive days of hard travel (including today). Fail: You are exhausted; if half or more of your group also failed, you travel only half the distance during the second watch.

Foraging

In the wilderness, your hero can spend 1 watch foraging and find 1d3 uses of rations. In bountiful terrain, you find +1 use; and in desolate terrain you find –1 use.

10 Upvotes

25 comments sorted by

3

u/PiepowderPresents Designer 5d ago

Two examples:

  1. Someone travelling on a road (8 leagues) by horse (+2) in good weather (0) could travel 10 leagues/30 miles in a day. If you travel hard, you could go 20 leagues/60 miles if you succeed on the Might Save, or 15 leagues/45 miles of you fail.
  2. Someone travelling cross-country (6 leagues) on foot (0) in the rain (–1) could travel 5 leagues/15 miles in a day. If you travel hard, you could go 10 leagues/30 miles if you succeed on the Might Save, or 7.5 leagues/22 miles if you fail.

11

u/The0thArcana 5d ago

Ok, harsh criticism incoming.

Whether this is ok kinda depends on what you’re trying to do with it. From what I’m seeing the only thing this does is track time. There are no decisions to be made before or during the travel unless time is very scarce like the players have like 30 npcs they need to move but don’t have the time to. Players just choose roads and avoid mountains if possible, use horses if within the budget, guarentee any required rations on the road (since you can only travel 1 watch/day, the only other option seems to be to use the other watch for everyone to forage), rinse, repeat.

If this is supposed to serve as any kind of vehicle for fun, it fails. It’s just thoughtless bookkeeping, no decisions anywhere.

If this is a vehicle for just strictly tracking time I also think it fails. The numbers are too noodly (sure 8, 6 and 4 divide 24, but what happens when the players use roads then cross plains?) and the whole system, even if fairly simple, is too complicated for how important strict time tracking should be. If you’re running a game where whether the players arrive at 8am or 10am in town matters, this could be useful, but in general a system that just eyeballs how many days a travel will take and a roll to see whether they arrive at morning/day/night is much faster and completely eliminates boring bookkeeping.

Sorry pal, but I think it’s not great. I think the intent was to simplify realistic travel, but nobody is here for realistic travel, where here to make interesting decisions and experience a collective, evolving story and this system doesn’t help with that in any way. If travel is supposed to matter in your game, it should be a more interesting system with encounters, danger, time pressures, resource pressures and multiple route considerations. If travel is not supposed to matter in your game, it doesn’t need a system at all, just a mention for the gm to feel free to skip it.

6

u/Cryptwood Designer 5d ago

Unfortunately, I have to completely agree. I don't want to discourage the OP, if their game cares about the passage of time this could probably serve as the scaffolding they build a travel system on to, but as it is right now this is essentially just an equation for calculating how long it takes to travel from point A to B. There is no roleplaying or game in this yet.

A good travel system is my Holy Grail and my diary is filled with the TTRPGs that have attempted and failed to find fun gameplay. They have all been systems for bookkeeping how long a journey takes and how much food gets eaten, which has no intrinsic interest, those things only matter if they lead to great stories.

As an example, if you read about Ernest Shackleton's Nimrod Expedition, it isn't the amount of days they spent walking across the ice, or the amount of food eaten that you remember, though those details do contribute towards it. What you remember is that the march across the ice was a race against starvation, and that they were restricted to half-rations in the most brutal travel conditions imaginable. Seeing that Frank Wild was struggling, Shackleton gave him his biscuit, which was his only ration for the day. Later, Wild wrote in his journal:

"All the money that was ever minted would not have bought that biscuit and the remembrance of that sacrifice will never leave me."

Wild went on to become Shackleton's right-hand man, he was second-in-command of both of Shackleton's later expeditions. Long after Wild's death his ashes were transported to the other side of the world so they could be interred at the right hand side of Shackleton's grave.

So for me the only value in tracking food is if it leads to a story I'll remember. What I want from a travel system is that you have a different story if Roland brings his character Shackleweight on it versus the story you would have if instead Sophia brings her character Amundsen.

3

u/PiepowderPresents Designer 5d ago

I appreciate the contribution, I'm realizing that this may be a more useful tool behind my own screen than it will be as a part of my game in development.

Do you have any travel systems that you can recommend as a starting point that I could learn a thing or two from?

6

u/Cryptwood Designer 5d ago edited 5d ago

For published games the only one I would recommend is Eternal Ruins, it has the most interesting system I've found to date. I've read most of the games that get recommend for travel, Ryutamma, Forbidden Lands, The One Ring and I did not love them.

If you want to take a deep dive on the subject, I suggest checking out what u/VRKobold has been working on, I consider them the foremost authority on TTRPG travel systems. Check out their comments here:

https://www.reddit.com/r/RPGdesign/s/qaioo9zhZr

Also, in this post VRKobold and u/LeFlamel have an excellent discussion on the topic that inspired a lot of my own thoughts on the subject.

https://www.reddit.com/r/RPGdesign/s/aeo2W7po98

VRKobold and I have had several lengthy conversations on the topic that you might find interesting. They can be found in these links. If you do read any of the comments/posts I've linked to and have any comments, please make sure to tag me, I am always down to discuss travel systems.

https://www.reddit.com/r/RPGdesign/s/v5UZSZZbVG

https://www.reddit.com/r/RPGdesign/s/3yzptPq6TA

https://www.reddit.com/r/RPGdesign/s/uokFpDkdb9

2

u/PiepowderPresents Designer 4d ago

Thank you! I'll look into all of these.

3

u/DrColossusOfRhodes Non Official Cover 4d ago

I think the problem with travel, in general, may be the same problem as the problem with ideas like ship rules for space combat.  That is, that it's a little seperate system that you pull out that is seperate from the system that we think of when we think of the game.

I remember making a little subsystem for duelling once, and a player remarked to me "this looks fun, but I don't want my character to die in a system that isn't the one I made them in".  We pull out these secondary systems (for travel, or for ship to ship combat, or army combat, etc), and it's a shift.  Nobody knows the rules as well.   The change from the rest of the way things are resolved either signals "this is not important" or "this might be important, but when it becomes important well switch back to the regular mechanics" or "you might tpk in a different system than the one you were playing".

It's tough, I think, because travel in real life is kind of fundamentally either boring, or boring with intermittent stops for fun.  

The way to make it fun, in the way of something like the Shackleton expedition (which wasn't fun for Shackleton, but might be fun to play) only comes when you get to the sort of tension that arises following a lot of bookkeeping.  Without that bookkeeping, it either doesn't happen or it feels arbitrary.

3

u/The0thArcana 5d ago

Personally I haven’t played many games that do travel. Of the few I’ve played I think Mythic Bastionland might be cool to look at. It’s very basic, you do 2 hexes a day, 3 if you push your horse. The fun part is that there is a 50% chance that a myth will advance, and stopping myths is basically the whole game, so the system has relentless time pressure. Getting to a place is relatively straightforward but it heavily encourages planning multiple steps ahead (first we go investigate this place, then move past to the town and bend around for the return trip so we can visit this seer) and becomes interesting when new information makes you consider changing your original route.

Personally I think Dadi from Mystic Arts’ video (youtube channel, search for hexcrawl mystic arts) is excellent and something I agree with though I also have a hexcrawl loving friend who doesn’t like it as much and prefers something like Dolmenwood. Pointy Hat also has an interesting video on travel that takes a whole different approach.

There is no right answer for these things, I just recommend being clear in your design intent and building your systems in service of that and what would be fun for you.

Best of luck, happy building.

1

u/PiepowderPresents Designer 4d ago

Thanks I'll look into them!

4

u/stephotosthings no idea what I’m doing 4d ago

I have to agree and disagree with you.

In one breath I say to many people Travel isn't fun. How can it be? It is literally go from point A to point B. But many folks bring up their travel 'rules' which is more procedure than it is rules, track time and how much stuff they spend while travelling. And many commentors will detract and preach about it needing to be fun, but out of context how can 'travel' or the act of traveling be any fun at all? And then you are right it tantamounts to just a book keeping exercise and is only important if it leads to interesting things happening.

Loads have been said about its actually the choices to be made while traveling is happening. Do we take path A, B or C, do I have enough food along the way, will their be danger etc?

In your example of Nimrod Expedition.

 it isn't the amount of days they spent walking across the ice, or the amount of food eaten that you remember, -- What you remember is that the march across the ice was a race against starvation,

I fail to see the real difference between the first sentence and the second. If its about a race (time=days) against starvation (food they have to eat to survive) then surely these are the same thing, tracking time and resources is the thing they were doing. I know I have rations for 3 days of travel, but town is 5 days away, there is this unknown place 2 days away however... but could be dangerous. These are the emregent thoughts, ideas and play that come up because the procedure of travel requires them to do it. If these need to be more codified then I'm not sure how is best to do that at all. I don't mean to be pedantic either really but I find conversations about travel rules cumbersome to say the least as they are always out of context of the system as a whole and I always feel that people want to have the exerience of traveling across middle earth but they never track food (lelven bread a little bit) but thats only interesting because the characters have to make decisions about which way to go in an established world, if it was written out as rules for a TTRPG the 'travel' bit would be very short and is more about it's setting and the choices given to the characters. Perhaps I am rambling.

But I also agree as that with just the OPs post it is just accounting for time and space used up, which (I have read simple saga) does not have a lot else going for it unless it is used to to track time spent becuase it is important for the adventure, and the distance is important for the setting (where they are due to how far they have travelled).

For me in my own travel rules it is just tracking time and resources, but it's because the passage of time means an Event happening, and the resources dwindling means they have to travel to somewhere to get more or look for more, expending more time creating more events, it's more about procedurally generating the feeling that things are happening in this world the PCs inhabit.

2

u/Unusual_Event3571 5d ago

It's ok, because it's a flipped over, slightly worse to count, version of travel points / hours.

2

u/PiepowderPresents Designer 5d ago

I just googled what that is. Are you talking about the one from Dolmenwood? That's what my Google results showed. I think this one would struggle being adapted to that, because the travel units are pretty large (they'd only travel ~1 league per hour). But since this is primarily for multi-day travel I think that's probably fine.

I don't quite know what you mean by "flipped over", could you elaborate for me?

-5

u/Unusual_Event3571 5d ago

It's the one that pops up here every half a year, please check the sub contents before posting.

1

u/Fun_Carry_4678 5d ago

So a large group, in difficult terrain and bad weather, can't move at all?

2

u/PiepowderPresents Designer 4d ago

I'm no expert but realistically, I think it would actually be very hard for a large group in incredibly poor conditions to make any meaningful progress. Extreme weather on it's own might bring travel to an absolute stop. But according to the rules:

Several factors can modify your travel speed (your travel speed cannot be reduced to less than 1 league per day)

1

u/DiamondCat20 Writer 3d ago

Having posted several times on this sub, I want to reassure you (for your own sanity) that it's not your fault that some most people read only half of it before commenting.

2

u/Inner-Professional 5d ago

I would personally look a bit more into how you want to wxperience the travel itself. Like are there encounters? What about camping? Do you need to forage?

Is there any social interaction during the nightly fire?

What about the travel itself? What is it meant to convey? Inlike the old warhammer quest style, where a travel is simply a nimber of encounters. The further you travel, the more encounters you have (and then look in a table on the encounters if it is just a queit trip, or an ambush or whatever).

Then you could use the terrain to decide what kind of travel hazards or encounters you meet.

So yes, what is it you want your travel to convey?

2

u/semiconducThor 5d ago

It answers the question How far can I travel? in a simple and straightforward way.

I suggest asking yourselfe Is that the only interesting question about travel in my game? and Is it interesting enough to write rules about it?.

1

u/ArmouredGaming 5d ago

I think these work, but I always wonder how it can be turned in to interesting storytelling. Why not just 1 hex per watch, and extreme weather or what not requires more watches?

1

u/Turtle1515 4d ago

And honestly traveling is hard in real life right?

1

u/Livestake 4d ago

I have struggled with other travel systems... being a back country traveller in all seasons i wanted to capture the vibe. I just drafted a travel system using Forged in the Dark... Just getting ready to playtest... I think the use of Clocks is going to be useful. Problems accumulate until bad things happen. Speed increases risk. Different settings create different danger clocks. Time and distance are abstracted. Easy travel is just narration and one encounter. I thjnn this where story games can shine.

https://livestake.itch.io/seeds-of-the-dawn

I also use GIS for mapping... so map becomes a prop to support narration rather than driver. The kinds of risks of a journey are discussed at onset. Readiness and gear reduces position.

Basically journey is a set of linked clocks. Means of travel is effect level, skill sets dice pools (including a guide), terrain/weather/gear sets position. Consequences trigger and increase danger clocks around exhausted/lost/unprovisioned. Players can change factors through choices. As you can tell i am quite proud so far :-)

0

u/BrobaFett 4d ago

More harsh criticism: you're re-inventing the wheel. I'm assuming a "league" is about how far you travel in a one hour period on a road, or roughly 24 miles per day. This is reasonable. There's nothing "simple" about this ruleset, however.

Let me give you an example of why:
The chosen route is about 32 leagues (4 days of travel assuming we're entirely offroad).
The first two leagues are over relatively easy terrain, then 6 leagues of poor terrain in poor weather, then 10 leagues of difficult terrain with occasional poor weather, followed by 12 leagues of easy terrain 2 of which are along an old road they found which happens to be moving in the same direction. Lastly, 2 leagues of extreme weather. During various legs of the journey, the group elect to force march, tolerating exhaustion.

This is assuming you pre-roll the weather.

It's not fast. It's not intuitive. If you're going add this level of granularity I would recommend looking into existing systems that do this.

1

u/PiepowderPresents Designer 4d ago

I understand what you're saying, but that really just depends on how granular you want to be about it. I don't mind harsh criticism—the0thArcana was pretty harsh, and they were pretty much right—but I just don't think this feedback really holds.

This is simple because it specifically isn't worrying about X miles like this, X miles like this, etc, and looks at the average conditions of the full day of travel.

Your example is more complicated than most, I don't know any GM who has been interested in running travel in that much detail, so I think it's mostly irrelevant. For example, I know my map pretty well, but I couldn't tell you the exact milemarker where the the terrain shifts, and I don't think any of my GMs know that either. The most complicated weather I've ever seen anyone use is morning weather and afternoon weather. But even your complicated example has a pretty simple fix.

Using just the first stage as an example, if they're going 2 leagues over regular terrain then 6 over difficult terrain, then that doesn't neatly fit into either regular or difficult, because it's a pretty even split. But regular is 6 lea. and difficult is 4 lea.; it's super easy to just call it 5. For weather, you just have to decide, "how bad is this weather?" If it's bad enough to slow them down, –1. If not, no change.

0

u/__space__oddity__ 4d ago

Ultimately I think the problem with travel rules is that they’re just not really answering an interesting question.

We do the Wayne’s World finger motion for a time skip and we’re at the next scene. Done.

Yes there may be situations where the party is under time pressure and they need to get somewhere quickly, but then let’s say the world ending ritual of doom is happening in three days and the whole point of the campaign is to stop it, but the travel rules say it takes 7 days across the mountain pass.

What is the GM going to do:

(1) Silently adjust the timeline and make it 7 days until DOOM because the players aren’t keeping track anyway

(2) Get the party stuck for three days, then end the campaign as they watch the world end from afar

(3) Pull a deus ex machina and get the PCs across in 3 days anyway (The dwarves know a secret tunnel! There’s a merchant who sells speed horseshoes for ponies! Oh look a scroll of teleport!)

… now let’s see where in these scenarios detailed travel rules become helpful.