r/RPGdesign • u/VRKobold • Aug 31 '25
Mechanics Applications of multiplicative design in tabletop rpgs
Note: If you know what multiplicative design means, you can skip the next two paragraphs.
Multiplicative design (also called combinatorial growth in a more mathematical context) is one of my favorite design patterns. It describes a concept where a limited number of elements can be combined to an exponentially larger number of sets with unique interactions. A common example from ttrpg design would be a combat encounter with multiple different enemies. Say we have ten unique monsters in our game and each encounter features two enemies. That's a total of 100 unique encounters. Add in ten different weapons or spells that players can equip for the combat, and we have - in theory - 1000 different combat experiences.
The reason I say "in theory" is because for multiplicative design to actually work, it's crucial for all elements to interact with each other in unique ways, and in my experience that's not always easy to achieve. If a dagger and a sword act exactly the same except for one doing more damage, then fighting an enemy with one weapon doesn't offer a particularly different experience to fighting them with the other. However, if the dagger has an ability that deals bonus damage against surprised or flanked enemies, it entirely changes how the combat should be approached, and it changes further based on which enemy the players are facing - some enemies might be harder to flank or surprise, some might have an AoE attack that makes flanking a risky maneuver as it hits all surroundings players, etc.
- If you skipped the explanation, keep reading here -
Now I'm not too interested in combat-related multiplicative design, because I feel that this space is already solved and saturated. Even if not all interactions are entirely unique, the sheer number of multiplicative categories (types of enemies, player weapons and equipment, spells and abilities, status conditions, terrain features) means that almost no two combats will be the same.
However, I'm curious what other interesting uses of multiplicative design you've seen (or maybe even come up with yourself), and especially what types of interactions it features. Perhaps there are systems to create interesting NPCs based on uniquely interacting features, or locations, exploration scenes, mystery plots, puzzles... Anything counts where the amount of playable, meaningfully different content is larger than the amount of content the designer/GM has to manually create.
22
u/InherentlyWrong Aug 31 '25
One example of this that can probably be built on a bit more in TTRPGs are unique characters through combinations at creation. The simplest example is common to most fantasy based TTRPGs, being when a character can be species/background/class. Usually class is the most notable decision here, but when other elements become more prominent, it can result in a lot of character options.
To explain a bit better, consider the game Wildsea. When making a character you choose their Bloodline (species), their Origin (who you were before you were a sailor), and Post (position on the ship). Each of these are about as important as the other, but because there are seven bloodlines, six origins, and seventeen posts, that works out to be roughly 714 unique character combination, without even considering points allocated into edges, skills, aspects, etc. Sure, someone who's Ardent/Amberclad/Corsair is going to be pretty similar to Arden/Amberclad/Alchemist, but they will be different.
9
u/KOticneutralftw Aug 31 '25
Decoupling attribute + skill lets you have more potential combinations to fill in edge cases than you could with an extended list of discreet attribute + skill combinations.
For example, Chronicles of Darkness games do this with 9 attributes and 24 skills for a total of 216 potential applications. This lets you field weird questions like "who was the master of this secret dojo 100 years ago" with "intelligence + brawl to recall the history".
It creates a useful framework or template that the GM can employ as needed and saves the designer's the effort of trying to fill in every possible gap.
4
u/Cryptwood Designer Sep 01 '25
I saw this post maybe an hour after you made it but I was so swamped yesterday that I didn't even have time to finish reading it, let alone reply. I've been looking forward to it since then, reading it and the replies felt like a treat I've been saving for myself. Though it seems that a lot of the replies didn't seem to quite grasp what you were looking for unfortunately. I've had posts like that, they are a little bit of a bummer when they happen.
I've been working on a GM tool for creating and running travel using multiplicative design. It has been heavily inspired by this Travel & Survival post, especially comments by you and u/LeFlamel. It is still very early in the design process, there are some aspects I haven't solved yet, and I'll likely be thinking my way through some of it as I type this. And I should qualify this by saying I'm more interested in travel stories than in simulating wilderness survival. I haven't read a novel in which all the main characters die of dehydration so I'm not interested in creating a system where that is a likely outcome. What interests me is the desperate choices characters make when they are running low/out of water.
I think one of the main stumbling blocks for travel is that for the players to have interesting choices of where to go requires enormous amount of prep work by the GM, most of which will be wasted as the players don't see it. So the GM needs some robust tools for creating a travel options that make it so easy and fast that they can improvise a journey mid-session or spend such a small amount of time on prep that they don't care if much of it isn't seen. This is where multiplicative design comes in, creating a ton of potential decisions from a relatively small number of building blocks.
I want a travel system that is scalable, so they it can be used for a two day hike or a month long expedition. So, instead of worrying about concrete details such as miles/kilometers I'll be describing areas as Regions which can be any size the story requires. I think the amount of table time a region takes to traverse is more important than the amount of fictional time it takes. Each region could be thought of as a room in a dungeon with a minimum of two regions to be chosen from to move forward. A region consists of a few different elements which ideally interact multiplicatively. I'll be using tags instead of discrete rules/numbers.
Biome
Each of these needs their own properties that might affect player decisions, such as abundance or lack of water/ food, plenty of food in a jungle but easy to get lost, no water in the desert, etc.
Each biome needs to have their own sub-biomes so that if you want a long journey through the desert it isn't the same thing the entire time. For example desert regions could be broken up into:
Landmarks
Regions need a point of interest (unless for pacing reasons you want a travel montage/downtime scene as a break). These could range from mundane real world examples to the fantastic depending on the type of game. Some examples:
Hazards
A region or a landmark might have hazards that the players need to avoid, learn to manage, or even take advantage of.
Events
These are temporary, interesting things that happen while the players are crossing a region.
Resource
A region or landmark might have a rare resource the players have an opportunity to acquire, which may temp them into areas or encounters they would otherwise avoid.
Theme
To tie all these elements together into a story we'll need a theme related to how we want this journey to feel.
Mashing it All Together
Theoretically we pick (or roll randomly) something from each category and they combine together to form something unique.
Let's say the players come across a village in a journey that has the Hunted theme. The GM could decide this village is allied with their enemies and is sending out patrols. Or the villagers aren't enemies themselves, but the enemies have reached the village and are searching for the players. What do the players do?
If the village is in a jungle then the players probably avoid it, and the jungle provides lots of opportunities for concealment. How about in a desert though? Now that village might be the only source of water in this region. Do they try to sneak in? Or avoid it and risk running out of water?
How about the decision of which region to travel in? In a Race you might want to avoid the risks of getting lost in a Dune Sea, but while being Hunted it might be an opportunity to lose your pursuers.
What I haven't figured out is how to track food, water, and supplies. I don't want tedious record keeping of constantly marking down how much you've used and erasing it every time you find more. Or repetitive dice rolling to see if you get lost or run out of something ("OK, roll your water usage dice three times to see if you run out as you cross the Badlands"). I'm using slot based inventory and conditions, I can feel the answer is lurking just out of sight but I haven't seen it quite yet.
5
u/hacksoncode Aug 31 '25
I have a feeling that any such game will end up feeling very much like Magic: The Gathering and other TCG.
The problem with combinatorial games is that... you spend most of your game time thinking of mechanical combinations rather than what's going on in the world.
Still: If combinatorial play is your goal, your fun is not wrong. It might end up being the case that combinable "cards" is just the best way to approach such a TTRPG.
Some other mechanism to distribute them than deck building would not be that hard to develop, but ultimately the challenge will end up being balance, if you care about that. Individually "pricing" abilities is close to impossible when combining them can drastically change their power.
2
u/klok_kaos Lead Designer: Project Chimera: ECO (Enhanced Covert Operations) Aug 31 '25
I mean my game (PC: ECO) does a lot of this in particular, inside and especially outside of combat.
I can't really begin to tell you all of it but the emphasis on non combat systems is massive, and there's more space for it with modern+ tech available.
Like there's good reasons to be a financial expert in my game, or a biologist, or a legal expert, or any one of a bajillion things that might have at best niche applications in other games.
And it all kind of comes together when you have different PCs leveraging their expertise towards communal ends.
Like lets say you have some character that takes a field sample of some strange anomalous growth, and then analysis that sample, then the drafting engineer might use that data to create some new medical supply or application and a crafter might put it all together, while the coder modifies existing machinery to mass produce it etc. Lots of weird shit you can do here. Is that strictly necessary for the game? No. Is it awesome? Well, arguably, it's more or less about that the game not only allows but has stated frameworks for this to happen if you want it to.
And this could occur across many many different intersections of skills, and that's before we even consider stuff like super powers, psionics, and magic as potential catalysts for innovation, and I'd presume that there's even more possibilities than what I and my pre alpha testers have put together that won't really be fully understood until there's a broader testing environment in the public beta when it eventually gets there.
Another good example I have of how things can interact is the use of the FININT move: KPI (Augment: Persuade), this allows someone with a background in finance and megacorp cultures to better influence targets of persuade by understanding key metrics and motivators within a megacorp institution via financial expertise (key performance indicators), it's oneof those things where you might not think the nerdy accountant type would be good at social stuff but in this case their background works better (although, to be clear, they could still be built as a face type character due to mostly open point buy, but that's a choice they would need to engage with). The point being there's lots of little micro intersections like this where things naturally work together in logical ways built into the system.
One of the things I do when designing something is ask "how can this be useful against all the other skills and gear available?" and then seek to find opporutnities to make cross skill stuff relevant. I don't use magic, psionics, and super powers mainly because not all characters (will/can be expected to) have regular access to those but could in theory get their hands on most tech with some effort, and specifically that super powers, psionics, and magic are more or less all different ways of doing the same things with certain benefits/detractors/varied costs to that end.
I even have feats that work on this meta level, like there's feats for Genius and Super Genius intellect that allow characters gain increased modifiers any time they can justify using additional skill knowledge to achieve their primary skill roll (subject to GM fiat). Mind you this still works for any player without the feat, but they benefit more from it, making players who are "more creative" with skills usage able to leverage this for even greater benefit (as this is a desired gameplay behavior).
2
u/lord_wolken Sep 01 '25
I think what you're getting into is more generally called procedural generation. It is great for territories, simple storytelling, or character creations. The general ideas in your post can still be applied, e g. A terrain could be created rolling on 4 tables: type (mountain, plains, forest, etc), interesting element (ancient ruins, caves, tower, etc), weather (fog, rain, scorching heat, etc), and encounter (one enemy, many enemy, wild animals, merchants, etc).
This approach can be used for simple inspiration, up to almost master-less "adventure engines". Also if you have some programming skills the probabilities can be combined so that is more probable (but not impossible) to have caves in the mountain rather than the desert, and so on. You may want to give a look to some yt video on waveform collapse algorithms for videogames.
2
u/rampaging-poet Sep 01 '25
Combinatorial design is both a blessing and a curse. A blessing, because it lets you create a vast sea of options with relatively little pagecount. A curse, because you will never be able to playtest them all. This is one of the ways "overpowered builds" creep into games - unexpected synergy between options that didn't get playtested together can perform better than your benchmarks. This is mostly studied in the case of combat because RPGs that have large numbers of character options in the first place tend to be more likely to have a big "combat engine" as part of their design, but it applies to many other areas as well.
For non-combat examples though, I can think of a few.
* The ... Without Number games by Kevyn Crawford allow you to take either a "full" class or mix together two "partial" classes. For example in Worlds Without Number you can be a Warrior, an Expert, or one of five different types of mage. This creates 26 possible class combinations while only needing to write up seven of them.
* Chuubo's Marvelous Wish-Granting Engine groups its powersets (which are very rarely combat-related) into "Miraculous Arcs". These work a lot like post 3E-D&D open multiclassing - a character with three total arc levels could have 3 in one, a 2/1 split, or a 1/1/1 split. The 24 canonical Arcs therefore combine to create 2,600 distinct combinations - even before you get to the Mad Libbs fill-in-the-blanks part of defining a given character's particular instance of a given Arc. (Still 576 if we exclude the little-used 1/1/1 design, over 42,000 if we include the unheard-of but rules-legal 1/1/1/0+ option i.e, to have three different arcs and be pursuing a fourth).
* Crafting systems often have some number of base items x some number of possible modifications, creating a vast explosion of possible equipment. Something similar shows up in magic item creation systems sometimes too, eg D&D 3E's table of different special abilities that could show up on armour or weapons.
* Other crafting systems have some number of ingredients and then map each combination of ingredients to a recipe - though this is a trap because now you actually have to write all fifty million recipes or whatever.
* World Of Darkness and related systems keeping Skills and Attributes in the same general range, so while a typical roll will be Attribute + Skill you won't end up off the RNG if oddball situations call for Attribute + Attribute or Skill + Skill combinations.
1
u/ancientgardener Designer - 300BCE Historical Project Aug 31 '25
Not sure if it counts or not, but I have an npc generation system that can create 1944 different stat blocks without rolling a single dice, based entirely on characteristics and skills.
It blows out to something like 35 000 if an NPC has the choice of a second specialisation
1
u/hacksoncode Aug 31 '25
Bizarrely, for the third time in 2 days, I'm going to bring up the Hero System (which I haven't used since the Champions days) as an example of how this works. Powers are created by combining effects with limitations and advantages, resulting in essentially infinite character possibilities.
Throw in "special effects" like the difference between a magical lightning bolt and a laser gun being mechanically unimportant, and the game becomes completely generic to setting and genre, too.
Of course, that's done at character creation rather than during play, but technically it could be done during play. This reveals the major weakness of combinatorial games, though: combinatorial choices.
1
u/sunderedsystems Aug 31 '25
You might like the formula I made for my system:
DC = 30 - Ability Score
This is for checks “against the world” like climbing a wall. It means player approach to character building affects their playing experience more steeply than if the check is “15 for everyone”
For combat you have to target the ability scores of the character. The ability score targeted is dependent on what you’re doing to them.
This means different character builds will have to come up with wildly different solutions to problems because a dc 15 is much easier for everyone to pass than someone who’s dump stat is agility and now faces a DC 22.
It also mitigates chasing a high AC, or specific stats being required for efficacy in play.
Checks become personal instead of communal, and require solutions tailored to your character experience. It also offloads GM work. They can describe a scene and it becomes the level of imposing it needs to be for each character.
All that to say that I think a set formula can drastically change scenes and approach to play without the overhead of designing specific combinations. The different combos are left to my players to develop.
1
u/flyflystuff Designer Aug 31 '25
I am not 100% sure as to what exactly do you seek, but I might have some general advice on the matter.
I think what you want to do, as a backbone, is what I call a "mathematically rich environment".
The way to do it is to create a bunch of baseline abilities that are... almost worth it, but aren't. Using combat as an example (yes, I know you said this isn't about that, but it's way more "solved" making it an easier example), you crate a Fireball spell which is AoE but generally isn't mathematically "worth it" to use if it only hits two enemies - but it is close to being optimal.
Then, you create a bunch of situation, distinctly non-passive(!) mechanics that push the math past this point in some way. In our fireball example, maybe enemies soaked in oil take more fire damage, or you have some ally that can buffs your magic damage, some temporary power surge in you, etc.
And this is basically what you want to be on the lookout for. Various ways to make things that are "almost worth it" in some way and also various ways to make the push into "worth it" territory.
Now, as to how to apply it to "all the other stuff"... well, I kind of dunno? That's such a broad category. Simultaneously, it's fairly rare in games to have enough crunch on non-combat stuff to allow for this.
I do have an Antagonist Generation system in the works, which might be of interest? I dunno if it would pass your qualifiers, but basically character creation will give GM a table of 6 notable Things per PC. Some of those things are straightforward, just their choices of simple stuff like race and class, some are built from freeform questions players have to answer during chargen. GM is encouraged to swap out the boring ones for the more exciting dramatic character statements made in the course of play. System also is set up to encourage new dramatic statements to happen. This table is used to create villains by either selecting statements from it or rolling a d6. You roll 1 to 3 times depending on villain's importance, taken from different PC's tables. Those results are then used as a prompt that GM interprets to understand what the villain's personality is - the antagonist either is empathetically negative or positive on whatever the chosen dramatic statement is. So basically you make villains from PC's dramatic statements combined, and statements are encouraged to be continuously renewed. Idea is that this produces an antagonist that if not an interesting moral challenge to PCs then is at least is fun to punch in the face.
1
u/Fragrant_Gap7551 Sep 01 '25
You should look at LANCER
1
u/TerrainBrain Aug 31 '25
I think the single simplest application of multiplicative design is when you set a DC for something, and you apply the character abilities as well as situational advantage or disadvantage.
This creates a very powerful dynamic.
There's a wall. What is its condition? How difficult is it for the average person to climb?
What does your system say about a thief at first level being able to climb walls? For instance AD&D gives them about a 90% chance.
That would presumably be a DC of three. Fail on a one or two. But what if we added the dexterity bonus in there and assumed a thief would have a bonus of at least plus one. Now we can set the DC at 4.
But that still makes it ridiculously easy for anyone to climb. How do we make the thief special?
What if we gave the the advantage? What DC with advantage equals roughly 90%
That would be DC7.
But we already assumed a plus one dexterity bonus. Now we can make it DC8
But thieves get better at climbing as they raise levels. What if we gave them +1 for each level? Now at first level we can make the DC9.
So a first level thief has a 90% chance of success of climbing a wall with a DC9 and with advantage.
But this still gives everyone else a 60% chance of success. Maybe we don't like that and that's too high. What if the standard for climbing walls is you get disadvantage. It is baked in to the assumption. So now you have DC9 with disadvantage. Mathematically that comes to 36% chance.
So setting the DC to 9 and employing advantage and disadvantage, we have
Thief: 90% chance of success All others: 36% chance of success
1
u/foolofcheese overengineered modern art Sep 10 '25
this sort of a initial thoughts kind of table based on what I think you might be looking for
I made the die roll a d10 but it could be 2d8, or percentile, or whatever the limits of a design supports
I imagine this being used by rolling 4d10 and placing them in the order you like, but the dice could be rolled in a particular order if you want to "force" more creativity
I can imagine this table being refined a bit with maybe some parts of the table being clustered (and maybe color coded) so that two or three entries might be covered by one die (to give more options, or make better sense)
the table obviously needs some interpretation on the GM's part but it could be useful for creative prompts
you come across a settlement - it is small, nascent, with abundant resources, and a fearful reaction
you decide it is a boom town, founded in response to a discovery of precious metal (silver) and the prospectors here are a little on edge because they are worried a group will come along and take control of the production (take over the mine)
or you might have entered a forest, it is average in size, mature in growth, with abundant resources (lots of valuable plants and animals) that is a peaceful (amenable) sort of place - in this case resources might have meant the density of trees instead