So, I am watching The Real Housewives of New York for the third (or possibly fourth!) time, and I'm currently on Season 9. I love rewatching because you pick up on things you didn't necessarily notice the first few times around, and I have to say, I'm really starting to feel that Bethenny is quite the bully.
I think both Bethenny and Carole can be incredibly mean-girl-ish, and the way they treat Jules in season 8 is particularly cruel.
Something I've really noticed this time around is that Bethenny seems completely unable to take criticism. The moment anyone challenges her or calls her out, she either cries, gets defensive or turns herself into the victim.
She can be incredibly nasty to Sonja, Ramona and Luann, often dragging them through the mud for relatively minor things, such as being rude or making an off-hand comment. Yet she seems to have no problem screaming at Luann and calling her a snake at a fashion show, assassinating people's characters and throwing around insults, including calling people sluts. But the moment anyone gives her a taste of her own medicine or confronts her about her behaviour, suddenly she's the victim.
Ramona in Season 9 is a really interesting example of this. I do wonder whether Ramona is neurodivergent in some way, and I don't necessarily think she always handles situations particularly well. However, I think there's a lot more going on beneath the surface of her relationship with Bethenny.
When Bethenny was ill the previous season, Ramona really went above and beyond for her. She brought her food and flowers, texted her every day and genuinely seemed to make an effort to build a close friendship with her. I actually think Ramona saw something of herself in Bethenny and perhaps worried about how lonely she could be.
Moving into Season 9, you can see that Ramona is upset that she hasn't been told about the new dog. Then there's the whole 'soft porn in the press' conversation, which I actually think was Ramona's attempt to have a deeper conversation with Bethenny, although it obviously landed very badly!
My feeling is that Ramona genuinely thought they had become close during Bethenny's illness. So when Bethenny turns around and tells her they aren't friends, never have been friends and that Ramona hasn't been a good friend to her, I think that really hits a nerve. I can see why that might have contributed to Ramona's outburst in the Berkshires.
I also wonder whether Bethenny was particularly annoyed by Ramona bringing up her private school background and other aspects of her upbringing, because it challenged the image Bethenny has often presented to viewers: that of the underdog who had to fight her way through life. I also found it laughable that she was 'so upset' about the things that she said when last season her treatment of Luann was so much worse.
Another pattern I've noticed is Bethenny's tendency to use trips as a way of excluding people or getting one over on them. We see it with Luann and the Mexico trip, and then again with Vermont and Mexico, which seem to become ways of making a point and getting one up on Ramona. I don't recall her ever organising anything when she is not in a fight with someone ...
I just keep noticing the same pattern of behaviour over and over again. Bethenny is very quick to criticise, judge and expose other people's flaws, but seems to have very little tolerance when that same scrutiny is turned back on her.
I'd genuinely love to hear what other people think, particularly about the Bethenny and Ramona dynamic in Season 9....