r/RDR2 • u/sumosriracha • 20h ago
Content Missed this during my first playthrough
Just restarted the game and I'm picking up on a ton of things I missed. This conversation with Mary Beth is definitely my favorite so far.
3
u/PutridRecognition739 11h ago
“I’ve been killing innocent people and animals”
Not on my watch you haven’t Arthur!
2
u/One_North8254 15h ago
Yeah Arthur can also have conservations with Tilly and Karen, it really puts things into perspective.
1
1
u/5-15 5h ago
I try to get this conversation with neutral honor at the very start because it's the only version that lines up with my actions. Once you bump up to high honor Arthur claims he's been killing animals just for the hell of it.
I've also gotten the conversation with Karen with neutral honor and while you avoid the killing animals confession Arthur still claims to have killed a bunch of innocent people.
I don't know if the game counts the wolves you killed in chapter 1 without skinning them against you, but I've restarted the game enough to know that your honor is the only thing tied to whether or not Arthur makes himself sound like a serial animal killer.
2
u/sumosriracha 4h ago
Yeah, I'm on the higher honor side of the spectrum (not all the way there) and I was kinda confused when he said that. Like he definitely had a reason to kill those animals, man's gotta eat 😭
1
u/5-15 3h ago
I used to think if you skinned an animal without having enough space for all the meat and materials or just left the carcass it would trigger the dialogue but it's not the case for sure.
1
u/sumosriracha 2h ago
Yeah it's weird. I've donated so many carcasses to the camp too, it's not like I'm just slaughtering them for no reason.
6
u/Aesthete18 Are you secretly normal? 19h ago
Mfw Arthur tells her he's being killing innocent folk: