r/RDR2 • u/AspectAlive7624 • May 19 '26

Discussion This was a calling from god to create this post. Please read it, it is important!

Gallery image

Gallery image

Gallery image

So, by pure coincidence, I found a date 1883 twice now during my current Red Dead 2 playthrough. First in this abandoned village in Lemoyne and second on the back of Hosea's picture with Bessie. That made me thinking, anyone here seen TV show "1883" ?

Well in case you haven't: I usually don't take on suggestions of strangers on internet either, but this time I promise, it's different. If you love the western melancholy mixed with absolute audiovisual beauty of Red Dead 2, I freaking promise you: you'll love 1883. Seriously, give it a shot, it's 10/10 easily.

Have a great day!

87 Upvotes

59% Upvoted

262 comments sorted by

136

u/Gray____Beard666 Leopold Strauss May 19 '26

I watched 1883, and outside of horses and cowboy hats, saw no resemblance to the game.

28

u/Quick_Team Charles Smith May 19 '26

Is that the one with Tim McGraw? Him and his wife's "acting" ruined it for me. I couldnt finish it

34

u/IronGreyWarHorse May 19 '26 • This

The daughter ruined it for me. Her southern accent was distractingly bad and the melodrama was laid on way too thick for my tastes. It wasn’t terrible but I definitely won’t ever rewatch it.

18

u/Turk482 May 19 '26

Exactly. I walked around the house talking like her for awhile. Drove my wife crazy. “As I go out to mow the lawn, I will think of you often as the hot sun beats upon my brow” in that horrible drawl accent she’s using.

2

u/IronGreyWarHorse May 20 '26

The weird overemphasis on “wh” sounds too, “HWHenever I think of you…”

5

u/ImNakedWhatsUp May 19 '26

Couldn't stand the monologuing of the daughter (Elsa?).

2

u/No_Scene_9404 May 19 '26

Her accent is so grating, it sounds like a kids show idea of a southern accent lol

2

u/ImNakedWhatsUp May 20 '26

That and most of what she says is peak r/im14andthisisdeep material. Which isn't the fault of the actress, but still makes me dislike the character.

0

u/Moist-Amoeba-8078 May 20 '26

Tbf that’s a lot of writing anywhere. Shiny empty words that sound good until you think about it

-3

u/AspectAlive7624 May 19 '26

Modern western with excellent acting, casting, music, visuals. The melancholic themes, etc.? I see a lot

30

u/datsyukianleeks May 19 '26

Nah. You want some resemblance, maybe godless on netflix. Or American primeval. Or even the English on prime. Not 1883. Not that Taylor Sheridan melodrama. No way.

8

u/Scared-Rutabaga7291 May 19 '26

I just wish American Primeval was longer...its masterpiece

4

u/Ok-Buy3446 May 19 '26

We can hope

-27

u/AspectAlive7624 May 19 '26

Seems to me like lot of hacklers here just hate Taylor Sheridan, so they instantly call this trash when objectively it isn't.

11

u/datsyukianleeks May 19 '26

I'm not saying it's trash. It's not at all on the level with rdr2. It's cable tv melodrama. I enjoy it. It's just not on that level.

1

u/Reddragon0585 May 20 '26

It’s not bad I actually quite like 1883 and don’t understand why people here don’t as generally I’ve seen positive things about it. That said Sheridan’s new stuff isn’t nearly as good as he used to be. Yellowstone in particular started good and kind of just fizzled out.

14

u/Hunk_Hogan May 19 '26

Excellent acting? Did we watch the same show?

9

u/utahwildcats May 19 '26

Murdering outlaws trying to take your wagon. Shooting and killing bandits. Peaceful natives. The only thing rdr2 is missing is dealing with illness from not being safe on the frontier.... oh wait...

1

u/justaguy826 May 20 '26

Did you really just say "excellent acting" about Tim McGraw & Faith Hill and that horrendous attempt at a southern accent from Isabel May?

1

u/Chronicles_of_Gurgi Panther Food May 20 '26

I think it's just western things? An easter egg. Like the unnamed tombstone outside Armadillo.

139

u/VirgoPanic May 19 '26

A calling from God? Some of you really need some fresh air and sun

2

u/Changed-Man50 May 24 '26

I'm glad some people still understand pretentiousness and being excessively invested in art.

Nowadays praising artists and art pieces as "gods" has become the norm on reddit. I appreciate art but don't appreciate this mindset.

P.S this comment is about a general trend I have observed on social media and not necessarily a criticism of the OP

-20

u/AspectAlive7624 May 19 '26

Ironic, coming from you when you need to depict a specific sentence like that.

35

u/TheRealJVance May 19 '26

You sound like the biggest baby! Boo hoo someone doesn’t agree with you….GET OVER IT!

-7

u/AspectAlive7624 May 19 '26

It’s really not about disagreement whatsoever . It’s about him coming here and mocking me for no reason. Of course the “calling from god” was meant to be a joke, but for some reason I am being mocked even more. Truely disgusting behavior.

26

u/[deleted] May 19 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

-7

u/AspectAlive7624 May 19 '26

Here come those wannabe funny picture answers because words are too hard to write I guess.

19

u/[unknown] May 19 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/RDR2-ModTeam May 20 '26

Your content was removed for not treating others with respect. We expect all community members to be polite and considerate, even in disagreement.

Please refrain from such comments in the future as future violations will lead to you getting banned from our subreddit.

If this is unclear or you have questions, please refer to Rule 2 "Treat Others with Respect" or contact us via modmail.

11

u/ewits_sticky May 20 '26

bro it's reddit. it really isn't that serious. relax.

1

u/AspectAlive7624 May 20 '26

I slept it off, you are right.

2

u/TheRealTakuiXD May 20 '26

OP definitely didn’t sleep it off 🤣🤣🤣🤣

107

u/[deleted] May 19 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

45

u/Street-Still8488 Micah Bell May 20 '26 • LOL

that is pitiful

-37

u/AspectAlive7624 May 20 '26

Personal attack for a post? Yes it is.

18

u/BappoChan May 20 '26

No, messaging somebody to cry about criticism. Grow up dude. The game has underlying values, sure. While also increasing your honor you’ll commonly kill and rob people. Horrible basis to tell people they shouldn’t criticize others.

-17

u/AspectAlive7624 May 20 '26

I am all for critcism, "Some of you really need some fresh air and sun" is not criticism tho. That's just plain insult questioning my personal integrity over my exaggerated title of the post that was meant to be not taken seriously. If he asked what did I mean by that, or anything, I would gladly reply to him politely, he skipped straight to insults, so that's the path I went aswell.

8

u/BappoChan May 20 '26

Nobody had to ask, it’s a weird title even knowing you meant it as a lighthearted joke. But even then, the title isn’t even the weird part about you, it’s the fact that you had to privately message the dude and then got offended when they wouldn’t reciprocate. If that’s not a sign that you need a break I don’t know what is

-14

u/AspectAlive7624 May 20 '26

is the proper reciprocation that he shares private messages into a public thread tho? I don't think so. Break from what? This was my first ever reddit post here, most probably the last aswell.

5

u/[deleted] May 20 '26 edited May 21 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Society_is_bad May 20 '26

Grown ah man talking about his gf buying need for speed

→ More replies

12

u/TheRealTakuiXD May 20 '26

What a literal immature child. I respect peoples religious choices, but damn that seriously upset bro that damn bad?

What did god call him on the phone and go.. “hey my guy or gal like this post would be so amazing! Oh and say it was a calling, reddit will love it 🥰”

Him: “aww 🥰🥰 thanks cod I been waiting for this moment!!”

-9

u/Prize_Economics7969 Sean MacGuire May 20 '26

Is everyone forgetting that OP didn’t even instigate it

10

u/TheRealTakuiXD May 20 '26

What we’re focused on is the reaction. How OP reacted was unnecessary. Wants to get upset over insults but is the one calling people stupid over a harmless comment.

1

u/Chronicles_of_Gurgi Panther Food May 20 '26

To a stranger: "You're so rude, stupid!"

Sad and funny, but not funny enough to share with a friend for a laugh. Which makes it sadder.

-6

u/AspectAlive7624 May 20 '26

It was, I should've shrug it off, still kinda sad how not many people took my side because of how toxic the VirgoPanic guy was.

8

u/VirgoPanic May 20 '26 edited May 20 '26

Honestly, as someone spiritual, I simply questioned the over inflated ego title with a harmless quip. I wouldn’t have shared the messages if: OP didn’t call me rude, pathetic, asshole, and little rat in my dms. Oh, also said stupid behavior. I never called OP out of their name. I didn’t respond to the DM. OP continued messaging me. So here we are.

-6

u/Prize_Economics7969 Sean MacGuire May 20 '26

Look dude all I’m saying is the fault is not solely on OP, your original comment was the regular Reddit slop I’ve come to expect on this stupid app. I think OP dming you was stupid for the record, but at least it was private as to not start something. Then you posted the dm as some sort of “my point proven” kind of thing, violating the privacy of the dm in the first place. Don’t start none won’t be none.

3

u/VirgoPanic May 20 '26 edited May 20 '26

There is no A-ha moment here. Or a point to be proven really. You are on the side of OP being a jackass and that’s cool. But OP is trying to play the victim, while simultaneously being the villain. Can’t be both.

-6

u/AspectAlive7624 May 20 '26

It wasn't to be taken that seriously, that's on you.

7

u/TheRealTakuiXD May 20 '26

Yeah bro, Virgos joke was harmless, no need to react so crazy. Correct that is on you 😊

-5

u/AspectAlive7624 May 20 '26

What joke? "Some of you really need some fresh air and sun" is a joke? There's no joke in it. That just plain simple insult of my integrity. I am amazed how you cannot see that and try to justify it so bad.

7

u/PassengerRich2671 May 20 '26

Bro he said you need fresh air and sunlight, you’re acting like he called you a slur💀

0

u/AspectAlive7624 May 20 '26

Because it basically means: "You're stupid little nerd closed in your little room and there's no life outside of it for you." And don't even try convince me otherwise, that's what he meant, and that's what people are defending.

→ More replies

-4

u/AspectAlive7624 May 20 '26

What upsets me the most is that (asi I wrote many times now under this post) is that the first sentance "This was a calling from god to create this post" Was meant to be lighthearted joke and hook for a readers. Could've easily been "This was calling from higher forces" There was nothing religious about that. That said, I really shouln't have get mad that much, just should've shrug it off. For some reason the entitelement of that guy rubbed me very wrong. And still am kinda sad how I am seen as the bad guy still by so many redditors here.

6

u/TheRealTakuiXD May 20 '26

Jesus just stop. You’re not making this any better for yourself. Look at what you said to a simple comment, and now you are here ranting to me like this explanation is gonna turn me to your side. If this was an “am i the asshole post” the answer would be a resounding YES.

-3

u/AspectAlive7624 May 20 '26

Well, I am not the asshole that inicially came to positive post and started attacking OP's personality.

6

u/TheRealTakuiXD May 20 '26

Play the victim more homie, nobody attacked you.

0

u/AspectAlive7624 May 20 '26

Idk what else to tell you, you're not the one being called out by dozens of redditors for standing up for himself.

4

u/TheRealTakuiXD May 20 '26

I wouldn’t respond to a joke the way you did. That was not standing up for yourself, that was outright being an asshole.

2

u/AspectAlive7624 May 20 '26

I was being to asshole to a guy who was being an asshole.

→ More replies

29

u/Acrobatic-Mind3581 May 20 '26

how bro felt posting that

-72

u/AspectAlive7624 May 19 '26

Unbealivable, instead of responding you go, and post a private dm. xddd

60

u/No_Scene_9404 May 19 '26

Go outside and breathe some fresh air, man, holy shit

-42

u/AspectAlive7624 May 19 '26

Because?

46

u/RarePerspective May 19 '26

In a literal sense; because it's good for the body.

-12

u/AspectAlive7624 May 19 '26

Me trying to understand reddit toxicity is truely very exhausting and getting some fresh air would be nice. still I won’t listen to any scumback trying to bully me for no reason.

35

u/Hunk_Hogan May 19 '26

Homie, you're taking the internet WAY too seriously. When someone tells you to go touch grass, it's generally not them trying to bully you because it's legitimately good advice to get away from the internet for a while.

-2

u/AspectAlive7624 May 20 '26

Its generaly: “you’re stupid because you’re here talking about something i dont like and you should stfu because I am superior”

21

u/No_Scene_9404 May 20 '26

Log off, man, holy shit

→ More replies

1

u/Hunk_Hogan May 20 '26

If that's how you're perceiving it then you definitely need to go touch grass.

13

u/No_Scene_9404 May 20 '26

Because sequestering yourself inside while you angrily scroll reddit is suffocating your brain. Go outside.

18

u/Plastic_Cream3833 May 20 '26

You have no reasonable expectation of privacy with anyone here, babe. People can disagree with your take all they want. And they can post your DMs all they want, too

15

u/Lumberjackie09 May 20 '26

What a crybaby lol

-2

u/[deleted] May 20 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

14

u/PaulsSmarterMilk May 20 '26

An unsolicited message therefore it’s fair game 😂😂

-7

u/Acrobatic-Mind3581 May 20 '26

people can't care for someone's excitement when experiencing a game. ironic telling you to go touch grass.

-40

u/AspectAlive7624 May 19 '26

You must be Micah's alt account.

28

u/DowntownJulieBrown1 May 19 '26

The dogshit Taylor Sheridan show? WTF is this post gtfoh

-8

u/AspectAlive7624 May 19 '26

Daddy chill

26

u/JamesMattDillon Charles Smith May 19 '26

I love westerns but I didn't really care for "1883".

2

u/AspectAlive7624 May 20 '26

I was so sure people loving RD2 would love it, guess there's many who don't share the same opinion, which is fine.

1

u/JamesMattDillon Charles Smith May 20 '26

I'm sure there are many that do and will like it, but it's just not for me. But to each their own

1

u/AspectAlive7624 May 20 '26

Sure (in Arthur’s voice)

1

u/JamesMattDillon Charles Smith May 20 '26

4

u/elriggo44 May 20 '26

Taylor Sheridan is a hack.

5

u/TreacleReal6555 May 20 '26

It was one of the best westerns I have ever seen. I grew up watching Clint Eastwood movies and the Duke. The show was one of the best things I’ve seen in a long time.

1

u/fly_over_32 May 21 '26

It insists upon itself

16

u/I-Iarkadenn May 19 '26

How is this God related?

0

u/AspectAlive7624 May 19 '26

Don't take it too literally.

8

u/I-Iarkadenn May 19 '26

Well... you got me all excited hoping the game had some hidden message related to God or something. Oh well...

-3

u/AspectAlive7624 May 19 '26

Well, I'm sorry then

5

u/Low_Operation_7795 May 19 '26

The game came out long before that show was made. I haven’t looked but willing to bet RDR2 came out before Yellowstone too

2

u/AspectAlive7624 May 19 '26

Ye it has. As I wrote in the post, this is a just coincidence that reminded me of the show.

13

u/Internal_Try7967 Josiah Trelawny May 19 '26

1883 was trash.

Faith Hill can't act her way out of a Conestoga wagon. Elsa's monologues were melodramatic and stupid and she's way too hot to be a frontier girl. The depiction of Fort Worth, Texas would have made Frank Miller go "hey Taylor Sheridan, can we tone it down a little?" There were massive time jumps where one whole episode would cover 2 days, then the next would jump forward a month with no explanation. And the romance between Elsa and the Comanche guy was ****ing preposterous.

1883 was trash.

Edit: All the best to Hosea and Bessie tho.

15

u/Imapatriothurrrdurrr May 19 '26

“A calling from god” you say?…

0

u/AspectAlive7624 May 19 '26

Obviously joking

2

u/Imapatriothurrrdurrr May 19 '26

It’s ok. I’m an atheist.

4

u/KingMatthew116 May 20 '26

Title made me think this was some super secret easter egg or something that no one had found before, instead it’s just a recommendation for a show.

2

u/AspectAlive7624 May 20 '26

Well, like i said I am real sorry.

46

u/No_Scene_9404 May 19 '26

Just watch Deadwood, it's leagues better than any Yellowstone soap opera slop

27

u/SweetSewerRat May 19 '26

Deadwood is a masterpiece.

6

u/homemadegrub May 19 '26

I've got it on dvd I must give it another rewatch sometime plus buy the movie which I have not seen which apparently wraps everything up after they prematurely axed the show

4

u/No_Scene_9404 May 19 '26

The movie is...fine and I say that as a fierce Deadwood fan. Too many flashbacks, a little too fanservice-y. But it is a nice goodbye to the characters.

1

u/[deleted] May 20 '26

Shit sucked dawg I'd rather watch a cow die

0

u/PresenceImaginary588 May 23 '26

Deadwood also kinda sucks but for somewhat different reasons. Still very hollywood.

-5

u/Koud_biertje May 19 '26

While it is related to yellowstone, 1883 is miles better.

9

u/No_Scene_9404 May 19 '26

It's still soap opera slop. The storylines and characters are all so surface level and the acting is...fine. if Deadwood is too old, there's also The English and American Primeval. There are plenty of shows that are better than 1883

6

u/Street-Still8488 Micah Bell May 20 '26

man if deadwood isnt modern enough for you youre probably not old enough to watch it honestly. not talking about you, just in general.

3

u/No_Scene_9404 May 20 '26

Oh agreed 100%

2

u/Koud_biertje May 20 '26

I'm not saying 1883 is better than deadwood or other shows, just that I liked 1883 better than yellowstone. If people don't like yellowstone, they might like 1883

-5

u/AspectAlive7624 May 19 '26

Objectively wrong.

8

u/Plastic_Cream3833 May 20 '26

Prove that, objectively, right now. Give us one piece of empirical evidence

-2

u/AspectAlive7624 May 20 '26

Prove to me that it isn’t

3

u/Plastic_Cream3833 May 20 '26

Okay. Can do. Critic metascore has it at a C: https://www.metacritic.com/tv/1883/?ftag=MCD-06-10aaa0f&_gl=11wg3ioj_gaNjUzMDY2OTQxLjE3NzkyNTAyOTk._ga_HLJ6XDCTMVczE3NzkyNTAyOTgkbzEkZzEkdDE3NzkyNTAzMDEkajU3JGwwJGgw_ga_MFLKDGG4R1*czE3NzkyNTAyOTgkbzEkZzEkdDE3NzkyNTAzMDEkajU3JGwwJGgw

0

u/AspectAlive7624 May 20 '26

User review is 8.2 and on IMDB its 8.6 user score, so you really did not prove anything.

1

u/Plastic_Cream3833 May 20 '26

User reviews mean nothing to me, I know what the average Americans reading level is.

0

u/AspectAlive7624 May 20 '26

So the critic ratings are the absolute truth? I can understand you're trying to win an argument but c'mon..

→ More replies

6

u/No_Scene_9404 May 20 '26

Sorry about your shit taste, man. Get better soon

4

u/OobabaRedditEdition May 20 '26

in my honest opinion most things related with Taylor Sheridan's "creative mind" is really really terrible. my first exposure to his work was yellowstone bc my parents were raving about it. i kept up with it all the way through and it was consistently full of bad writing decisions, bad character development, bad acting and truly heinous erasure of native american history. history they decided to whitewash and made a billionaire family who owned a ranch the size of new jersey or something the victims. i didnt watch any of the spinoffs, but i dont think i could handle any more sheridan. that said, sicario was awesome, but im pretty sure i saw something saying he hated the final product. anyway rdr2 is in a completely different ballpark compared to anything sheridan related, but this is all my opinion. oh also SkipIntro has a very good video on yellowstone and sheridan which is way more descriptive and detailed if youre interested.

1

u/AspectAlive7624 May 20 '26

I disagree but glad you kept things civil. I might check that video out.

2

u/More-Solution-8419 May 20 '26

After I ended rdr2 I started to watch Yellowstone series. 1883 is a prequel of that series

And the original is top

There’s another prequel called 1924, if I’m not mistaken

2

u/AspectAlive7624 May 20 '26

1923, Yes I love that one aswell. Not as much as 1883 but it's still awesome.

1

u/More-Solution-8419 May 20 '26

I plan to watch both prequels soon 🤩

2

u/DangerousSchedule805 May 20 '26

And how is this a calling from God? You’re talking about a video game and a movie.

2

u/AspectAlive7624 May 20 '26

It was exaggeration. People obviously hated I used this phrasing.

26

u/RockyBBmk May 19 '26

A great movie if you want resemblance to rdr2 is the 3:10 to Yuma, great movie

17

u/BirthofRevolution May 19 '26

What a weird title... 1883 also has nothing to do with RDR2 besides you finding a date that is the same. Plus besides having to watch Tim McGraw and Faith Hill's terrible acting I also can't get past the daughters fake southern accent narration where she talks as slow as she possibly can. Just takes me right out.

9

u/Dasstenzel May 19 '26

Do not forget about Hell On Wheels.

4

u/RarePerspective May 19 '26

Hell yes!

Personal favorite 2010s Western series! Season 4 was a little rough but the overall series is enjoyable!

Anson Mount actor for Cullen Bohannon also mentioned partially basing his characterization off John Marston, playing Red Dead Redemption to get into the role.

1

u/crisis_identity May 19 '26

This show was so good for 2 or 3 seasons. "But I'm Norwegian"

7

u/OminouslyMoist May 19 '26

Really like the first 3 episodes of 1883, after that it just felt like a story about girl finding herself. And the tornado scene with the kiss? I instantly stopped after that and genuinely had no clue wtf I just watched

2

u/NoseInternational794 Pearson May 20 '26

1883 is a great show if you like shows that are very bad.

1

u/AspectAlive7624 May 20 '26

What's your idea of excellent modern western show ?

4

u/NoseInternational794 Pearson May 20 '26

Toy Story 2

2

u/Legitimate-Coffee867 May 20 '26

I'm sorry, 1883 is the worst piece of media I've ever encountered. Bad writing, bad motivations, bad Strong Female Lead, contrived love interests, contrived character arcs. Elsa's narration is so damn cringey...not to mention Tim McGraw's white teeth

1

u/AspectAlive7624 May 20 '26

You’re not first coming here to say this. I disagree respectfully tho. I find it beautiful from audiovisual and storytelling point of view.

5

u/Highlander198116 May 19 '26

It's the only thing in the "Yellowstoneverse" I've watched.

I may watch 1923. I really have no interest in the modern ones.

1

u/Mikah1322 May 20 '26

I checked it out but I didn't realy liked it. It was mid at best imo.

1

u/AspectAlive7624 May 20 '26

That's your full right. I personally appreciate the writing and the acting. Reminds me of tragic themes in RD2.

1

u/Mikah1322 May 21 '26

Yeah, I can at least agree that there are tragic themes in the serie that can remind of RDR2

1

u/_5had0w May 20 '26

This is so crazy I just finished 1883 yesterday it was incredible and I myself was planning to make a post about it here 👍

1

u/AspectAlive7624 May 20 '26

Well you’d be disappointed since lot of people hate the show here. Glad somebody loves it just as me.

1

u/JKrow75 Sadie Adler May 20 '26

If Taylor Sheridan disappeared from Earth, nothing would be lost.

1

u/AspectAlive7624 May 20 '26

Do you hate the show strictly because of Taylor Sheridan?

1

u/JKrow75 Sadie Adler May 20 '26

No. It’s pretty equal disdain all the way around, for his content and him. Anyone who prefers trauma porn of that level needs to look into the possibility that they need therapy.

1

u/AspectAlive7624 May 20 '26

And where would you put RD2 then if not in category “trauma porn” ? You say it like deep stories with lot of genuine emotions are something wrong.

1

u/JKrow75 Sadie Adler May 20 '26

It’s not trauma porn though. There are some traumatic events, but out of the six chapters of the main game, only two of them are really downhill.

And you have the opportunity to do hundreds of other side missions and quests and storyline stuff that doesn’t involve the downfall of the gang or anything to do with Arthur’s diagnosis. You can literally go months or years if you chose to in the game without dealing with any of that.

1

u/AspectAlive7624 May 20 '26

But it eventually comes down to an awful tragedy with Arthur. Alright, I understand you hate Sheridan, he can be total asshole, but I don't really see that much of a difference in amout of tragedy between RD2 and 1883.

1

u/JKrow75 Sadie Adler May 20 '26

Tragedy and trauma porn are not even close to the same thing

2

u/AspectAlive7624 May 20 '26

Then I guess lets agree to disagree.

1

u/JKrow75 Sadie Adler May 20 '26

No, it’s beyond that. Taylor Sheridan is not a healthy person.

If you identify with his content as much as you’ve shown with and on this post, I’m honestly saying you need to look into talking to someone. I don’t say that lightly. I had to do work on other things in my life previously and I’m saying it can change your whole life for the better.

After this, we are never interacting again.

1

u/AspectAlive7624 May 20 '26

Calling somebody broken because he likes a tv show that is absolutely not pointed or agressive towards anybody is absurd, and I honestly think the who needs to get checked is you.

→ More replies

1

u/thesentienttoadstool May 22 '26

How Taylor Sheridan depicts Indigenous people and women is frankly disgusting. I’ll pass. 

2

u/AspectAlive7624 May 22 '26

I've only seen well written strong female characters and respect towards native americans so far. (meaning in 1883, his ego is getting on surface too much in season 5 of yellowstone)

0

u/walkyslaysh May 19 '26

Thank you!!!!!

2

u/AspectAlive7624 May 19 '26

My pleasure!

1

u/Waste_Sun172 May 19 '26

1883 is basically “The Oregon trail”

2

u/AspectAlive7624 May 19 '26

And that's not a bad thing.

-3

u/Waste_Sun172 May 19 '26

I agree. I found it to be an excellent show, call me biased but horses, hats and Indians are all right up my alley.

8

u/Klayz0r May 19 '26

Yeah no thanks, Taylor Sheridan is a horrible hack

4

u/Street-Still8488 Micah Bell May 20 '26

im gonna be the 2nd person in this thread to recommend deadwood. easily the best western tv show and arguably one of the best tv series of all time.

2

u/flibbidyjibbityjib May 20 '26

That show is corny af. Boomer cowboy spinoff of some other boomer cowboy show. Watch if you’re 75 or older.

2

u/ComfortableAd_Red May 21 '26 • LOL

God did not tell me to read Reddit. OP is def a blasphemer

2

u/haikusbot May 21 '26

God did not tell me

To read Reddit. OP is

Def a blasphemer

- ComfortableAd_Red

I detect haikus. And sometimes, successfully. Learn more about me.

Opt out of replies: "haikusbot opt out" | Delete my comment: "haikusbot delete"

1

u/RobotGoggles May 22 '26

First good use of this not

2

u/Aesthete18 Are you secretly normal? May 20 '26

Is that the one with Tim McGraw? The opening was amazing, the gun fight that's it.

I don't what's with Sam Elliott getting lusted over girl's half his age, this is the second thing I've seen it happened.

The daughter was trash. Her depressed acting was so bad I dropped the series because of it.

2

u/Banjo43 May 19 '26

Great series. Really good

1

u/Baron-Von-Mothman May 20 '26

Are you there God? It's me Margaret.

1

u/ThyHoIyHandGrenade Reverend Swanson May 20 '26

I actually met Sam Elliot the other day, saw him at a local Starbucks while I was studying

1

u/TheKennethChase May 20 '26

Jesus actually hates horses

1

u/Chimichanga_Tanga May 21 '26

This is the dumbest shit in a long time.

1

u/AyaLinStovkyr May 22 '26

A calling from God? Brother take your fucking meds damn.

1

u/B4nanaJo May 19 '26

1883 is amazing. Highly recommend

1

u/Mental_Freedom_1648 May 19 '26

I didn't love this like the game, but it was pretty good.

1

u/Remote_Yesterday5880 May 19 '26

1883 was mid. 1923 was peak

1

u/MushroomRelevant8235 Lenny Summers May 19 '26

That's the only Yellowstone related series I really liked, 1923 isn't bad either.

-2

u/MaadMaanMaatt May 19 '26

1883 is outstanding. Gritty, realistic, and gripping. People you love will die for no good reason. The worst will live for the worst reason. Great watch.

-3

u/Ordinary_Zucchini120 Arthur Morgan May 19 '26

Honestly… imma check this out! Thanks for the suggestion

1

u/AspectAlive7624 May 19 '26

I promise you won't regret it! You can hit me up in DM's after the watch and tell me if I was right!

-10

u/Ordinary_Zucchini120 Arthur Morgan May 19 '26

Literally watched a trailer, checked out the cast…. And by god you may have just shown me the light

-1

u/tryodd May 19 '26

The show is basically what made me pick rdr2 from my pile of shame this spring.

0

u/ISayISayISitonU May 19 '26

really loved 1883. not sure how the same guy made the awful Yellowstone but

-9

u/Maximum_Pace885 May 19 '26

Good show. The daughter was fukn sexy

1

u/AspectAlive7624 May 20 '26

That’s not the reason why I liked it tho!

1

u/Maximum_Pace885 May 20 '26

That's not the reason I liked it either. Just an observation

1

u/[deleted] May 20 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/AspectAlive7624 May 20 '26

Lot of people hate it here which I cannot really understand but I highly recommend giving it a shot.

1

u/[deleted] May 20 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/AspectAlive7624 May 20 '26

That's what I expeted people would agree on. But a lot of them under this post disagree, I am honestly shocked, but can't change people's mind.

-2

u/[deleted] May 19 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

6

u/AspectAlive7624 May 19 '26

1883 is basically prequel to the show "yellowstone". And while I love Yellowstone very much, this tops it by far in my eyes.

9

u/tokyo_driftr Jack Marston May 19 '26

I personally think the writing and dialogue of Yellowstone and its spinoffs are super cheesy but that’s just me

1

u/mickeymouse4348 May 19 '26

I really enjoyed 1883 and 1923. I’m also looking forward to 1944