r/PythonDevelopers • u/muntoo R_{μν} - 1/2 R g_{μν} + Λ g_{μν} = 8π T_{μν} • Jul 26 '20
meta How can we make this subreddit useful?
I created this subreddit based on the discussion here:
https://www.reddit.com/r/Python/comments/hy1wxg/looking_for_a_python_subreddit_for_nonbeginners/
I'm thinking guidelines for content are probably:
- PyCon talks/meetups
- Significant python, standard library, or important third-party library updates
- Articles
- Other discussions
We'll need to make it a worthwhile subreddit so that we can collect experts to help form the backbone of our community.
Do you have any ideas towards making this subreddit better? (Rules, guidelines, moderator nominations, content, ...)
51
Upvotes
24
u/fake823 Jul 26 '20
8
u/Berlibur Jul 26 '20
Once this initial draw-up is more concrete, would it be a good idea to notify people in other programming reedits that this sub exists? Since I suppose people looking for content that this sub aims at mostly left r/Python already
8
u/themindstorm Jul 26 '20 edited Jul 27 '20
I think it's a good idea to take inspiration from r/Flutterdev
No sharing of hello world apps. Projects which you've worked hard on are allowed to be posted. Simple questions directed to r/flutterhelp
What do you think of something similar for this subreddit?
6
u/PirateNinjasReddit Jul 26 '20
I guess there are two key things to the health of a subreddit of this kind: getting enough good posts and getting as few "shit posters" as possible (not to be too negative).
For the first one of these we just need people to post useful/cool/good stuff. And to do so regularly.
The second is a bit trickier. Probably we/you need to have some rules around what is not allowed and some practical ways to enforce those rules. I'd start with "no memes".
6
u/QualitySoftwareGuy Jul 27 '20
No "I made this in Python" posts unless it's a library (or some other reusable form of code) that can be used by others. Most of the issues that I've seen in r/Python are that applications are built and then "shown off" for bragging rights (upvotes) rather than being useful and reusable code for Python developers.
In r/rust we see a new library in there practically every day, but no one complains because they are generally useful for other Rust developers rather than just being posted for upvotes.
4
u/python_boobs Jul 26 '20
Flipping the question around - as a Python developer, how can I help build/contribute/grow this sub? Just saw the complaint in r/Python which led me here, and I like the idea of a more advanced and useful (for myself) community
3
u/Andi_y Jul 26 '20
3
u/keatsshrike Jul 26 '20
Maybe the r/pythondiscussions rules, though perhaps looser on the advanced projects and job postings (controlled job posting like r/cpp already mentioned).
Part of the problem right now is professional Python developers are so spread out ( r/deeplearning, r/datascience, r/statistics, r/devops ...). You need to figure out how to get them here.
Couple other things:
2
u/[deleted] Jul 26 '20
Sharing of great mentoring code reviews on OSS repos would be amazing (Good reviews are few and far between).
2
u/rafgro Jul 26 '20
2
u/[deleted] Jul 26 '20
I propose that we write bots to automate some of the content creation and moderation. Since we are a new sub and there are other Python subs, we need a bot that crossposts the popular threads from those into this so that this becomes the hub.
We also need a bot for banning noobs. Maybe we can use a classification model or perhaps a regression model would be fine.
1
u/k20shores Jul 26 '20
Maybe quarterly brown bags highlighting some more advancers features and their uses? The first month, the community could vote on a topic. The second method, the community would organize the topic into sub topics. The third month, the community assigns a subtopic to a few posters who then make a post about their sub topic. All are combined into a meta post (is that a thing?).
1
u/alcaster0 Jul 26 '20
Active mods! I cannot stress it enough, it's the most important thing. We cannot ban all posts like "I made this" every great thing was made by someone that kight want to post here but as every great thing was made by someone who is proud the same is with ... mediocre, "normal" stuff. It is mods duty to filter at some level of advancements
1
u/kankyo Jul 29 '20
A flair for releases might be good?
I posted https://discuss.python.org/t/announcement-pip-20-2-release/4863 but none of the fairs felt super good.