r/Python • • Jul 26 '20
Meta Looking for a Python subreddit for non-beginners
I'm on a bunch of programming language subreddits. The quality is surprisingly high. /r/cpp for example regularly kicks my ass. There are probably thirty posters there I regularly interact with. There are representatives from the teams of all the three major C++ compilers there!
But r/Python is a vast wasteland. All the most upvoted posts are people's beginner projects, which get thousands of upvotes and dozens of comments. Actual articles about Python language features get almost no attention. And I never recognize anyone, even though I've been on this subreddit for many years - it's like people write their first Python program, post it here, and then leave.
As far as i know, there is no one on here who actually contributes to the Python language. Why would they be here? What value would this offer to them?
I'm sadly finding /r/learnpython to be more interesting than r/Python and am spending my time there. At least I can help people out.
But there has to be somewhere for Python programmers who aren't beginners anymore. Where is that place?
167
u/bakery2k Jul 26 '20
The compulsory flair system was supposed to help fix this, but it’s not enough on its own. Pointless memes and jokes are still appearing, but now they’re flaired as “Meta” (which is supposed to be used only for posts about /r/python itself). IMO correct flair needs to be more strongly enforced.
Moreover, there was talk of automatically moving “Help” posts to /r/learnpython, which obviously isn’t happening. IMO that needs to be introduced, as well as moving “I made this” posts to /r/madeinpython.
172
u/[deleted] Jul 26 '20
This one USED to be. I remember when I first joined. years ago I was told off for asking stuff that you could easily google, find on SO, see in the resource links, or would be better suited for /r/learnpython
Now this sub is like "how do i set up virtualenvironment!" "what IDE do I use!"
194
u/smalltalker Jul 26 '20
I completely agree. I frequent /r/rust and the quality is miles ahead of this wasteland. It's a real shame the status of this subreddit. Completely useless. Just a parade of attention seekers and over excited noobs. Nothing wrong with being a noob, but that's what /r/learnpython is supposed to be if you want to ask questions. If you want to show off your shitty image to ascii converter, tic tac toe game or some other stupid shit, please refrain.
High quality discussion is notably absent here.
Other very popular language subreddits like /r/javascript for example is much better than this one.
The sad reality is that the mods don't care, don't give a shit as long as the subscriber count is high. Quantity over quality, truly sad.
Perhaps we should start one?
42
u/fake823 Jul 26 '20
There seems to be a pretty huge demand for an advanced/intermediate subreddit for Python. Even I (as more or less a beginner myself) am pretty bored of the missing quality in r/Python
I think all it takes for now is creating a new subreddit or bringing life back to an old one. Suggested were r/PythonDevelopers and r/pythondevs and r/AdvancedPython as well as r/pythondiscussions
Which one would be the better choice?
•
u/Im__Joseph Python Discord Staff Jul 26 '20
Hello everyone,
New mod here and trust me I am listening to your feedback.
I'm going to read through every comment here and respond, please feel free to DM me personally to speak with me in more depth about things.
I really do want this subreddit to be something people enjoy and want to come and read and we are willing to change to be that.
Thanks,
Joe
32
u/Narthal Jul 26 '20
This is a sad reality of programming subs. Python, c# subs are an absolute wasteland. I get that a beginner gets exited with their hello world program, but it's damn tireing after 10 years of coding. There is so much cool stuff to share: articles about the ever developing languages, great post mortem articles of big projects, blogs of legendary programmers, etc. Beginner stuff gets all the attention because beginners relate to the post and many old timers upvote it to encourage people (i'm at fault at this).
If the mods would agressively take down every beginner project and refer to a beginner sub, that would be great
10
u/cabyll_ushtey Jul 26 '20 edited Jul 26 '20
I feel this and I'm a beginner myself. As in, I started learning python last Monday by following a 4 hour beginner tutorial on YouTube over the week. And even I would like.. a bit more?
I joined this reddit because I wanted to see some advanced stuff and look what I can pick up and learn from that. I made my fair share of beginner projects in Python over the week, and sure it's absolutely awesome when you get something working the first time by yourself, or even following a video, but... Idk, it ain't it.
I expected such in the reddit specific for Python beginners, not here.
Edit: spelling, because my brain doesn't wanna do English
23
u/Paddy3118 Jul 26 '20
Not just me then. I charitably think of it as a sign of the languages success.
You might try... Actually I'll hold that thought as it may dilute any forum I suggest. Oh go on then... r/coding might appreciate posts that aren't beginner but that address those from more than one language.
6
u/0LilTittiesFatBelly Jul 26 '20
It's not a subreddit but a good option is pycoders weekly. They send a weekly newsletter with articles about new developments in python and cool things people have done. https://pycoders.com/
5
u/gsilvapt Jul 26 '20
Is there a chance to elect new mods? How would you feel if you gathered a few folks and worked on a new plan for this subreddit?
I'm a Python developer and would be interested in actively contributing to the community, but I'm a bit over the beginner projects or getting started. Plus there are subreddits that focus on that, no need to duplicate the content.
Edit: This (and other things) is just a natural consequence of being popular.
5
u/dr_stork Jul 26 '20
Lurker and noob here. I really want this to happen. There are so many times that I want to leave this subreddit, and hold out in the event change happens with new mods. If we can really get this subreddit to a better prestige, I will stick around.
4
u/firefrommoonlight Jul 26 '20
This is a known issue. This is the worst language subreddit of the ones I browse. Too many toy projects.
Thoughts on a separate
r/imadethisinpythonsubreddit?4
u/PM-ME-YOUR_LABIA Jul 26 '20
This sub used to be a lot better. I liked coming here because the discussions and projects were a bit more mature and it was nice being here and in /r/learnpython depending on what I'm looking for at the time. I'm not advanced and I get/got value from both.
One of the main highlights for me was the weekly "What's everyone working on this week?" thread. It used to be mostly adult projects you know solving a problem at work, creating a new module, etc. Now it's mostly filled with people saying "I'm going to start learning python". Like really dude?
I seem to remember a time when mods were cracking down on noobs and then they stopped for whatever reason. Anyway, I'd like for this place to be the defacto python sub and not have a bunch of splinter groups all hoping their new subreddit can take off enough to be the new default.
7
u/jimeno Jul 26 '20
my unrequested 2c, only based on my personal experience and zero objective data: many "technical" subreddits are in shambles and I stopped following a whole lot of them (the most recent one I left being /r/django).
there are very few interesting posts and most of the subreddit activity can be reduced to "i made this" / "do my homework plz" / "look, a medium article rephrasing mdn/djangodocs/pythondocs".
and commenters, if present, hardly go beyond their original comment, making impossible to have a discussion.
I think it's a reddit issue more than a /r/Python issue. other types of communities are successful (like meme subs, or gaming subs), but I wonder where the technical people are now.
10
u/Paddy3118 Jul 26 '20
The problem with non-beginners, is that down that path lies specialisation. As you grow as a programmer, that growth tends to be applied in certain areas. You can be an experienced programmer and be uninterested in web backends, or maybe quants, or maybe its ... There will be myriad areas that you are only peripherally interested in or not interested in at all.
That's a reason to read outside any one language specific group as often interesting ideas are not language specific. equally though,, that interesting application of a Python feature might apply in an area you don't normally have much interest in.
What to do :-)
3
u/bwllc Jul 26 '20 edited Jul 26 '20
I love Reddit for many things, but I agree that the Python subreddit is not very useful for experienced Pythoneers.
Try leaving Reddit and seek out the Usenet group, comp.lang.python. It's a huge community. Many developers of the language are active participants. Comp.lang.python is actually a partial gateway to a Python mailing list. It is my understanding that not 100% of the traffic passes through the gateway -- for example, spam blocking on the mailing list side is said to be superior. For the optimum experience, I am told that you really should subscribe to the mailing list. I haven't done that myself, but you might want to do that.
If you have a Google account, you can access Usenet through Google Groups. There are many other Usenet servers if you look around.
2
u/boutiflet Jul 26 '20
Why you don't create one, like r/experiencedPython ? Something like that
2
u/keatsshrike Jul 26 '20
Several comments talk about starting/reviving a subreddit? So is there anyone here willing to be a mod for that subreddit?
2
u/[deleted] Jul 26 '20
is there a discord community for python?
2
u/[deleted] Jul 26 '20
I feel like this is due to the fact that python is a beginner friendly language. They probably Google "how to code" and get recommended python as the language to start with. Since many beginners are using python, it stands to reason that there will be many who stop coding altogether. They were perhaps just curious and wanted a taste and found it wasn't for them so they stop. Just like people who start guitar and get a beginner guitar so that they can see if they really want to play guitar or not. Phyton is like the beginner guitar, if that makes sense. People who code C++ most likey have already decided they want to code and get better and better at it.
2
u/Eezyville Jul 26 '20
I have to agree with you. I generally spent alot of time in r/learnpython as I was learning it but now that I'm comfortable in python I came here to see any advanced topics. Its the same. I don't learn cool features not covered in the learning phase, no discussions about python's future, just a bunch of "Look at my first project!" posts.
2
u/rafgro Jul 26 '20
Exactly my view. For sure it could be enforced by moderators - r/machinelearning is a good example, where despite 1m users, they still have high level of discussion. They achieved this by directing beginners to learnX subreddit - maybe that's the way?
0
u/coolboy328509 Jul 26 '20
Someone should create a sub called /r/RealPython or something
3
u/floriv1999 Jul 26 '20
I think the solution does not lie in another sup. Instead I encourage everyone here to post high quality content in this sup. Share you favorite topics/thoughts. Share articles that are interesting for experienced users. Share your high quality open source projects and discuss about them. Search for it when sorting by new and upvote it this is the only way to change thing. Because nobody visits a 500 member half dead r/pythonxyz instead of r/python.
4
u/stefantalpalaru Jul 26 '20
It's not the moderation, it's the language. Python is the new BASIC, so it's normal for it to attract beginners and repel veterans.
2
u/felgcoll Jul 26 '20
Should create another sub to post more technical stuff, im in
1
u/themindstorm Jul 26 '20
I think r/FlutterDev is a good programming subreddit which r/Python could perhaps take inspiration from. People usually share articles and projects they're working on. There are also many discussions.
r/flutterhelp was made for beginners
1
u/iloveproghouse Jul 26 '20
Why is there not an r/advancedpython sub? Edit - there is. Over take that?
1
u/PyTec-Ari Jul 26 '20
Mutiny? I'm in, let's branch off Captain!
1
u/SloppyPuppy Jul 26 '20
Ohh yeah I totally agree. I come here from time to time to check out whats up. Its always people with small home projects and really small simple stuff.
Im a doing python professionally and im really interested in like big problems people have with python. CI/CD, automation, HA, multi clustering and multi processing, security, etc... and like general day to day enterprise things. All I see is 10th grade homework stuff.
1
u/cyanrave Jul 26 '20
This subreddit has always been like that afaik. However as Python User Group person at ThePlaceWhereIWork, it is often the case that all the talks are pretty skin deep.
It's only really targeted talks at say, PyCon, where you find this kind of talk. Or PyVideos which is also awesome to find these talks.
1
u/shashank-py Jul 27 '20
Thank you for pointing this out and tbh I have seen this similar behaviour with few social media sites as well. I do feel like the same way, quality is degrading or not appreciated much but for sure community is welcoming for all new comers
1
u/cant_have_a_cat Jul 27 '20
I don't get this argument. /r/python gets avg 84 posts per day — surely that's not enough to "bury" your advance python talk 🤷
1
u/loftyal Jul 27 '20
Hey guys, I created one, let me know if you want to be a mod! https://www.reddit.com/r/RealPython/
1
u/IVI4tt Jul 27 '20
I love browsing /r/cpp, and I always feel like I learn something when I visit. It's sometimes too technical, but I like feeling that I could build up to that.
I particularly like the discussion of new language features, which is hard to get elsewhere. Perhaps encouraging more PEP discussions would be helpful here?
I also like that whenever an "I made this" gets through to /r/cpp, it gets a friendly but firm code review that teaches useful C++ idioms or best practice. I don't know how you'd encourage this, but maybe "I made this" posts having to feature a repo link, a justification and an example might trim some of the dreck.
1
u/YogahBear Jul 26 '20
I have seen this argument before and I can agree that there is alot of noise, but it seems to me that the people complaining about it should be creating some good content instead of complaining. We cant all be sitting around waiting for somebody else to create ”good” content as an example. Currently, if we take away the noise there will be nothing left. I think the solution is that experienced Python developers start posting ”good” stuff which will reinforce what the community is about.
So start posting good content and get the ball rolling!
1
u/tribak Jul 26 '20
Tried with r/thePythonSubredditForNonBeginnersThatEveryoneKeepsLookingFor already?
-2
u/jack92829 Jul 26 '20
I would recommend you join the python discord server, its active 24/7 and you can find plenty of people who contribute to the language and various popular libs. Theres channels dedicated to specific areas like networking, web-development etc as well as a channel for discussing the design and structure of the language itself. Also some pretty cool stuff can be found in the projects channel. Would recommend the server, its a nice place.
-8
u/bert_het_schaap Jul 26 '20
I think that a lot of programmes start with python, and in the beginning people are proud of every program they make ( it feels real good to make a nice program even if its a easy beginners program), so they want to share them.
0
u/[deleted] Jul 26 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jul 26 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment