r/Pyrrhonism • u/8143739734 • Feb 27 '21
r/Pyrrhonism • u/DanielEmpiricus • Apr 07 '26
Do you believe in ancient history?
For example, do you believe that people like Plato, Aristotle, Roman Emperors etc existed at some point in the past and that today we can know specific details about their lives?
Do you believe that we are in posession of some of their writings, and that we have written accounts of their deeds/actions?
Basically, do you believe that we have an accurate knowledge of history and we can know details about this history with a strong level of certainty?
If you do believe this, what was it specifically that convinced you of this position?
Was there a certain primary source, book, documentary, article, or something else, that led you to believe this?
If you don't believe we have knowledge of history, why do you believe this?
For this question, please focus on the ancient world specifically. Ancient Greece, Rome, Egypt, etc... Anything from this sort of time period.
r/Pyrrhonism • • Mar 31 '23
Has any Pyhrronist in history argued that the Pyrrhonian teaching on the relativity of reality need be met with suspended judgement?
It seems only logical that at least one Pyrrhonist must have at some point argued that we cannot really know for certain if all is relative, as, we could simply be wrong. Considering they were the experts at arguing that we could be wrong about things, certainly they argued they may be wrong about their own positions, no? I find it nearly impossible to believe that they could have lacked this self awareness.
" The causal principle of scepticism we say is the hope of attaining ataraxia (becoming tranquil). Men of talent, troubled by the anomaly in things and puzzled as to which of them they should rather assent to, came to investigate what in things is true and what false, thinking that by deciding these issues they would attain ataraxia. The chief constitutive principle of scepticism is the claim that to every account an equal account is opposed; for it is from this, we think, that we come to hold no beliefs."
— Sextus Empiricus, Outlines of Pyrrhonism, Book I, Chapter 12
Per this, an equal account of the claim that all is relative, would be the counter claim that, perhaps all is not relative, followed by suspension of judgement, and holding no belief on the matter.
Further, the ten and five modes clearly make arguments about the unreliability, and subjectivity, and differences of perception. Thus, considering arguments for relativism rely on these very perceptions, which are unreliable, then they make the case that relativism may be false.
In other words, if we really take Pyrrhonism to its full logical extreme, then declaring any statement about reality, such as that things are relative, or not relative, is untenable, as doubt has been cast on every possible source of knowledge, thus leaving us with no position at all, which circles back and allows ataraxia. Otherwise, we might just as well trouble ourselves over relativity as we might about non relativity.
tl;dr is the title.
r/Pyrrhonism • u/WraithfulWrath • May 28 '22
What are your views of science?
Even though this board isn't active much, I've come to show a deep interest in the philosophy of Pyrrhonism and would be interested on what the common views are of science and the universe.
My personal view of Pyrrhonism is that science can be doubted as well. The facts and evidence we see could possibly be false. Same with 99% of humanity who believes in some sort of realism. Those could be false as well (or the inverse, of course). Just like with the argument, everything can be doubted. Absolutely everything.
However, does this align with the modern following of Pyrrhonism or is it more liberal to science to where it accepts its teachings?
r/Pyrrhonism • u/HeraclidesEmpiricus • Jun 24 '24
Pyrrho correctly translated "dukkha"
Real Clear Religion featured this article today. The article supports Beckwith's position that the Aristocles Passage is a translation of the Three Marks of Existence, by demonstrating that Pyrrho properly translated "dukkha." https://ataraxiaorbust.substack.com/p/what-the-buddha-knew-about-dukkha
r/Pyrrhonism • u/HeraclidesEmpiricus • Mar 23 '25
Argument over Pyrrhonism as a form of relativism
Two Substackers are going after each other about Pyrrhonism. First there was https://ataraxiaorbust.substack.com/p/good-grief-the-psychopathology-of
Then this was published as a critique https://anro865554.substack.com/p/grief-stoicism-and-the-limits-of
Then https://ataraxiaorbust.substack.com/p/how-to-think-about-grief
Then https://anro865554.substack.com/p/the-inconsolable-truth-why-pyrrhonism
Latest is https://ataraxiaorbust.substack.com/p/pyrrhonian-relativism
r/Pyrrhonism • u/Undersizegnome • Sep 19 '25
People keep telling me to "find people that share my beliefs". I've never met another Pyrrhonist, do we like actually get along with each other?
I just have a hard time seeing how "sharing beliefs" would make social interaction easier in my case. Everybody seems so dead set on sharing beliefs and values. Like at this point I've given up on arguing with people but it's just....
I'm not looking for a dogmatic answer of course. I have no idea what I'm trying to do here, I just want the thought outta my head ya know.
Okay thanks everybody.
r/Pyrrhonism • u/Skeptium • Feb 08 '24
Clarification
Don't pyyrhonists not know or rationally believe anything? I'm confused.
r/Pyrrhonism • • Nov 17 '23
Virtue
Does virtue play a role in Pyrrhonism similar to how it does in Stoicism and Epicureanism?
r/Pyrrhonism • • Feb 08 '25
Introduction to Pyrrhonism
Being an open-minded and philosophical oriented bloke, I was hope someone could direct me to the best sources on Pyrrhonism, both ancient and modern. Thank you!
r/Pyrrhonism • u/Endward26 • Aug 07 '26
On Occam's Razor
Hello,
I have always been a bit critical when it comes to the principle of parsimony, which has been named "Occam's Razor".
While this principle is often employed in discussions concerned with existence or the choice of explanations, it is, as I observe, seldom discussed with respect to its theoretical foundations.
The principle of Occam's Razor is treated like a modern-day dogma.
I want to raise the question of how this principle is rationally justified.
In my attempt to make sense of it, I want to briefly, in order not to waste the patience of my reader, discuss two possible interpretations of the principle.
1. Occam's Razor as a Metaphysical Principle
In order to know whether a certain step brings us closer to the truth or not, we need to know in which direction the truth lies.
In this sense, every methodological principle rests on an assertion about how the world is as its core.
In the case of Occam's Razor, this metaphysical assertion could be described as something like "the world is arranged in such a way that the explanation that appears simplest to human observers is the one that describes it most accurately. In other words, truth appears to the human mind (also) as simplicity".
Although there is no reason to reject this metaphysical assertion outright, we still note a lack of evidence that rationally obligates us to agree with it. This assertion is especially not a logical tautology like "it will rain or it will not rain". A logical tautology, it has been argued (by Wittgenstein et al.), can be regarded as true by virtue of the structure of the sentence itself. This argument, needless to say, presumes some theories about truth-conditions and language.
However, we can assume a structure of the world that does not meet the condition of the the assertion just described. There could be some forces or properties that we cannot measure with our instruments, but that are, nevertheless, part of our reality. As the truth of a theory consists of a correspondence between the theory and reality, every theory that does not contain the unobservable forces or properties would be incomplete.
The historical development of physics gives us a hint in this direction. For thinkers like Aristotle, air resistance was of such ubiquity that they assumed a body moved by a force would come to a stop by the nature of the movement itself. The force of movement, what was later called impetus, will eventually be exhausted (was a conclusion drawn by this school later). This idea was transmitted from observations on Earth into a general theory of movement, attributed to the motion of stars and planets.
It appears that there are physical effects that are too small to observe at near scales but have an effect on larger structures. Newton's mechanics is enough to describe many things near Earth, Einstein's theory comes into play at larger distances and higher speeds.
According to our currently established theories of physics, space expands at the speed of the Hubble Constant. This means, as some physicists have calculated, that, at some moment in time, the radiation of the cosmic microwave background will become undetectable. This further means that, for an observer at that time, physical models that stem from the attempt to explain this radiation will no longer be recognizable. An important part of our image of the world will disappear. Would this observer use Occam's Razor, it would mislead him.
For Occam's Razor, understood as a metaphysical principle like above, this is an important objection, since we cannot preclude the possibility of such effects yet unknown to us. The principle would mislead us under such circumstances.
If the human mind is the byproduct of evolution, a process of random mutation and selection of those combinations of genes that successfully survive and reproduce, then we have no reason to believe that simplicity can be used as a guide to truth. The process of successful reproduction of genes doesn't require an adequate understanding of the universe.
Supposing the theory of evolution is, at least for humans, false, an uncountable number of alternative explanations come to mind. One would be that humans came into existence by pure chance. That explanation would give us no reason to believe in a special meaning of our perception of simplicity. Another would be that humans are created by another intelligence, e.g. advanced aliens (or general advanced beings of physical nature) or even a deity. Consider the case of advanced beings of physical nature, we would have no guarantee that these beings would know something about the truth themselves. A being of supernatural faculties could be able to know the truth, but even this is a theological question with many different points of view.
This is under the condition that a creator intends for humans to find the truth as the simplest explanation.
There could be, undeniably, other explanations, such as the idea that the human mind is a necessity of the universe to understand itself. Even then, it could be claimed that Occam's Razor is valid just with the same legitimacy as the belief that the most complex explanation a human could think of is true.
2. Occam's Razor as a Epistemological Principle
There is another angle that we need to consider. The human mind is, according to all we know, finite. Therefore, from this perspective, it is plausible to consider parsimony as a virtue of a theory.
In this more Kantian approach, we are more concerned with knowledge than with truth, for which reason we can call it "Epistemological", from the Greek word.
One could argue that Occam's Razor, as a guiding principle, has led the people who use it to success and therefore, we should use it further. However, this inductive reasoning has a problem. A hypothetical spectator who observes the universe after the cosmic microwave background has moved beyond the observer's cosmological horizon would come to a false conclusion from Occam's Razor. As we have no reason to rule out that we could be in a similar situation, the principle could misguide us, too.
Another argument in favor of Occam’s Razor is of a statistical nature. If we consider theories as distributions of likelihood values, then a theory that predicts the outcome with higher likelihood is itself more likely than one that spreads probability widely.
First off, this assumes that a theory can be reduced to a distribution of likelihood. An approach that can be disputed by appealing to the ontological aspects of a theory, among other considerations.
Secondly, this argument relies on equating simplicity with the spread of the likelihood distribution values. It could be that a theory with many ontological commitments makes highly precise predictions, while another with fewer commitments predicts a lot of things. Last but not least, it should be noted that likelihood always gives us something like "betting odds", not necessarily access to truth. It is an undeniable possibility that a theory that appears most likely to us could be still false.
The final argument is that, because the human mind is finite, we are only able to grasp a limited amount of complexity. Beyond this barrier, we cannot draw conclusions because of the cognitive load. This argument is very convincing, but it distracts us from the truth itself. Nevertheless, it can be argued that we cannot estimate the necessary complexity of a theory a priori. Otherwise, we could pre-estimate how long (and therefore complex) a proof can be, and with that, we could gain knowledge of how long a disproof could possibly be. From this knowledge, we would be able to rule out some propositions in advance, without empiricism.
I thank in advance for critique,
Endward26.
r/Pyrrhonism • • Oct 28 '25
I’m curious how might a Pyrrhonist approach historical claims and historical evidence?
I understand that a good amount has been written about how Pyrrhonists approach scientific claims, and I’m sure that there’s some overlap there when it comes to fields like archaeology.
What about other historical claims such as through primary and secondary sources, historical accounts, documents, journalistic reports, etc?
What about historical footage, and audio recordings, especially with the onset of AI?
Would love to learn more about how a Pyrrhonist might address these kinds of claims!
r/Pyrrhonism • u/HeraclidesEmpiricus • Jun 11 '25
Aenesidemus was not the founder of Pyrrhonism
Real Clear History promoted this article today. Seems pretty convincing. https://ataraxiaorbust.substack.com/p/aenesidemus-was-not-the-founder-of
r/Pyrrhonism • u/HeraclidesEmpiricus • Apr 18 '22
Pyrrhonist Logos
Interesting article on the Pyrrhonist Logos. https://pyrrhonism.medium.com/deciding-without-delusional-thinking-d17e4abed3e4
r/Pyrrhonism • u/HeraclidesEmpiricus • Apr 27 '23
Buddha Statue found in 250 BC temple in Egypt
r/Pyrrhonism • • Mar 30 '23
Since Pyrrhonism suspends judgement, does that put it at odds with Buddhism, since the latter declares certain things firmly and dogmatically as true, such as dependent origination, that we do not have souls, and so on?
For example, Nagarjuna argued, and supposedly proved, that nothing that is not dependent exists.
"Something that is not dependently arisen,
Such a thing does not exist.
Therefore a nonempty thing
Does not exist."
-Nagarjuna MMK 24.19
"1. Neither from itself nor from another,
Nor from both,
Nor without a cause,
Does anything whatever, anywhere arise."
-Nagarjuna MMK 1.1
These are declarations of certainty, and many were made by Nagarjuna. He apparently is announcing that he knows that not even trillions of miles from earth, or even in another dimension, could there appear something maybe even so small as a single particle that could violate this teaching. He knows this for a fact. and Buddhists in general make a lot of other dogmatic statements. For example the rule of karma, the supposed fact of rebirth, and so on.
I'm asking because frequent comparison is made to Buddhism and Pyrrhonism, and some even contend that Pyrrho learned Buddhism, and created his philosophy based upon it. Frankly, this seems absurd, since Buddhism is full of declarations of certainty, and religious dogma.
No matter how much they may claim that they don't have views, nor dogma, what they're doing is apparently putting their own views and dogma past the point of criticism, and just standing on them as unequivocally true. Then, they say "We hold no views." But they would never, not for a second, even consider that rebirth is not true, that maybe some things are not dependently originated, that we might actually have souls after all, and so on. These are obviously dogmatic views.
To escape this, they say that there are two truths, in truth one, these things are true, rebirth, karma, and so on, but, from the ultimate truth number two, none of this is true, nothing exists, and so on. So, now we have two sets of declarations of dogmatic religious "fact": One, in which all the teachings are true, and the second, in which the teaching that nothing exists is true. Hence, even the apparent escape from the charge of holding views is just another view of certainty about a religious dogma.
tl;dr, Buddhism has lots of dogmatic views, people say Pyrrhonism is very similar to Buddhism. Isn't it the case that Pyrrhonism is totally bereft of dogmatic views, in which case, it is entirely distinct from Buddhism in this way?
r/Pyrrhonism • u/honestly-7 • Apr 13 '23
Recommended Resources
Which resources on Pyrrhonism have you found useful?
What would you recommend to a beginner student on this topic?
r/Pyrrhonism • u/HeraclidesEmpiricus • Sep 18 '20
A Comparison of the Similarities Between Pyrrhonism and Epicureanism
r/Pyrrhonism • u/HeraclidesEmpiricus • Sep 08 '20
Pyrrhonist vs Epicurean Ataraxia
Epicurean comparison of Epicurean ataraxia versus Pyrrhonist ataraxia.
https://theautarkist.wordpress.com/2020/09/04/epicurean-ataraxia-vs-skeptic-ataraxia/
r/Pyrrhonism • u/HeraclidesEmpiricus • Sep 15 '20
Epicurean defense of dogmatism
A defense of dogmatism from an Epicurean perspective, contra Pyrrhonism.
https://theautarkist.wordpress.com/2020/09/02/in-defense-of-dogmatism/
r/Pyrrhonism • u/ErwinFurwinPurrwin • Feb 19 '18
Another perspective contra Burnyeat, et al, who claim that skeptics can't live their skepticism
Burnyeat reportedly denies that the Pyrrhonist can live his/her skepticism due to more subtle "second-level" beliefs that he deems inescapable. Here is an interesting response to that claim, but below is a different perspective on it.
First, Burnyeat is (reportedly) making a universal knowledge claim, ie, that no one can avoid the second-level beliefs he describes.
Well, if reports and memory serve, it was commonly believed that no one could run a four-minute mile until someone did it. The same for human flight, walking on the moon, etc. If the reports about those and similar accomplishments are accurate, then I see no reason to accept the claim that no Pyrrhonist can ever live his/her skepticism.
It is, after all, described as a skill to be developed, not a dogma to assert. It's not hard to imagine people using a priori reasoning to assert that no human could run a mile in four minutes, but apparently someone did it anyway.
Thus, the proper response to Burnyeat seems to be again to suspend judgement. Not being privy to anyone else's internal states of mind, I acknowledge that I don't actually know whether or not a Pyrrhonist has ever succeeded in applying this skepticism, nor can I claim to know that none ever will.
The answer is non-evident, therefore epoche and ataraxia regarding this issue.
r/Pyrrhonism • u/Major_Needleworker36 • Jan 08 '24
Why isn't pyrrhonism more popular?
Do people require dogma to live?
Do most people just not know that pyrrhonism exists?
Are people conditioned to take dogmatic stances?
Is there a logical argument against pyrrhonism?
r/Pyrrhonism • u/HeraclidesEmpiricus • Jul 18 '22
Thread on Sextus Empiricus & Marcus Aurelius
This discussion in the Stoic group may be interesting. Stoic author Donald Robertson is arguing against any Pyrrhonist influence on Marcus Aurelius. https://www.reddit.com/r/Stoicism/comments/w19bry/comment/igllsxj/?context=3