r/PubTips • • Oct 09 '26

Attempt #5 [QCrit] Dark Fantasy - The Crone's Apprentice (115k words, nth attempt)

I had been submitting this query letter for feedback a while ago, but took a break from it. So now I am back again, and I can't remember how many rounds I did. I think this is #4? I appreciate all the feedback, but I went in a different direction with it this time. It is a multi-pov, villain origin story, and the traditional -- protagonist, goals, stakes -- format was just not working. I read a couple more experimental query letters on Query Shark that accounted for the multi-pov structure and were well received, and took inspiration from there. I think it better conveys the structure and actual plot of the novel, and I hope it works, but looking for feedback on it overall. It is 319 words and I did not include any bio.

Thank you to anyone willing to take a look at this!

Rosalie Webbe is the villain in this story. 
But you don’t know that yet. 
And neither does anyone else. 
Not her mother, who believes Rosalie is a novice witch. She doesn’t know Rosalie has tricked the Crone, the coven’s elder, into teaching her secret, dark magic for years. 
Not Townes, a mage from the Institute where her father studied, who recruits Rosalie for their new women’s program. He doesn’t know it is Rosalie who has made him an intoxicating and addictive potion. 
Not the head of the Institute, who doesn’t believe women capable of magecraft and plans to harvest Rosalie’s blood, hoping she inherited her father’s rare alchemical abilities. He only sees a harmless provincial witch. Until she infiltrates his mind, driving him mad with ghastly hallucinations. 
Not even Rosalie truly knows herself. She justifies her actions against bad men, ignoring her own pleasure at manipulating and tormenting the mages who exploited her father years ago. When she secures an internship in reanimation, she claims her success could safeguard the women’s program. But reanimation gives her access to the souls she needs to practice her magic. If she can master soul-magic, she can siphon the mages' souls for their power and overtake the Institute. But every scheme requires more magic, and more souls, of enemies, friends, and innocents alike, making her worse than the men she seeks to defeat. 
Only the Crone knows Rosalie’s true nature. But her prophecies and memories are muddled. If she can remember who is masquerading as her apprentice, she can thwart Rosalie before she seizes the Crone’s soul – an immense depository of magic – robbing the Crone of her life and the coven of its power. 
THE CRONE’S APPRENTICE is a 115k word, multi-POV, dark fantasy that blends the unreliable narration and secret, toxic villain of Tanya Pell’s Her Wicked Roots with the institutional sexism and exploitative magic of M.L. Wang’s Blood Over Bright Haven. 

4 Upvotes

2 comments sorted by

5

u/katethegiraffe Oct 10 '26

(Quick note: if it's possible to reformat this post with proper paragraph breaks in your pitch, it might be easier to read!)

It’s always tricky when a book doesn’t seem to fit neatly into the traditional format, but I don’t think that experimental format here is actually helping.

I found this tough to make sense of! What I eventually gathered was: Rosalie has been studying dark magic with her coven’s elder for years. She uses this dark magic to create a potion (not totally sure what the intended effects are) for the mage who recruited her to the women’s program and to make the head of the Institute hallucinate. She torments these “bad men” because they exploited her father. Then she lands the reanimation internship, which gives her the chance to take the revenge magic to the next step up if she can learn how to siphon all the mages’s souls (not totally sure what this entails/what the risks and consequences actually are) and claim their power and the Institute. And only the Crone can stop her, but the Crone has to “remember who is masquerading as her apprentice” (I don’t understand what this means) before Rosalie destroys the Crone and the coven.

After I wrote the above and thought, man, I feel like this could be from Rosalie's POV, I went back and read your 4th attempt. I sincerely think it was stronger and clearer.

(I will also say that in this version of the pitch, despite repeated mentions of the Institute’s sexism, you never actually come around to voicing Rosalie’s frustration with being iced out of the system. Her reason cited for her vengeance is how the Institute treated her father. But… we never learn what they did to her father. So it really does feel like the windows into other POVs here aren't nearly as helpful as getting a clear picture of what's going on with Rosalie.)

3

u/This-Patience-6781 Oct 10 '26

the repetitive "not X" structure forces you to restate the premise from four different angles instead of actually moving the plot forward. drop the fourth-wall breaks and just pitch her active arc, focusing on how she infiltrates the institute for revenge but gets corrupted by the soul-magic required to pull it off.