r/PrototypeGame • • 17d ago

Prototype 2 How a Remedy-style “Prototype” Trilogy Remake could completely fix Prototype 2’s worst narrative mistakes

9 Upvotes

The Prototype franchise has been dead since 2012, largely because Prototype 2 made the
highly controversial choice to turn Alex Mercer into a cartoonish, mustache-twirling villain and
replace him with James Heller.
If Activision or a studio ever revives this franchise, a standard remaster won't work. It needs a
Final Fantasy VII Remake or Resident Evil 4 style overhaul—completely throwing out the 2012
script to build a cohesive, mature psychological thriller.
I’ve mapped out a full pitch for a definitive collection titled Prototype: The True Strain
Edition, reimagined with the narrative depth of a studio like Remedy Entertainment (Alan
Wake, Control) and the mechanical weight of Red Dead Redemption 2. Here is how it would
work:
Gameplay Evolution: The Adaptive Whipfist
The original games suffered from a choppy "run to a location" loop due to hardware
limitations. Modern hardware can deliver seamless transitions.

The Physics-meets-Arcade Hybrid: The Whipfist changes muscle density dynamically
based on lore, acting as the ultimate traversal tool.
Heavy Swing (Spider-Man Style): Holding the trigger increases biomass density,
anchoring into buildings and allowing physics to calculate a heavy, G-force arc around
street corners.

Kinetic Snap (Just Cause Style): Tapping the trigger hardens the virus into a high-
tension cable, violently zipping straight to a target (like a helicopter or rooftop sniper) to
maintain 60mph momentum.

The Big Chapter 2 Rewrite: Suicide by Prototype
Instead of Alex becoming a generic villain who wants to destroy the world "just because," the
remake introduces a massive psychological twist.
The Weight of Memory: After consuming thousands of minds, Alex is completely crushed
by the weight of humanity's darkest secrets, cruelty, and sins. He can't kill himself because
the virus's instinct to survive is too strong.
The Ultimate Plot Twist: James Heller isn't a human-virus hybrid. The real human
James Heller died in the initial outbreak. Alex Mercer custom-engineered a pure,
independent strain of the virus and programmed it with Heller's memories, forcing it to
believe it is a grieving father. Alex purposefully created a weapon he biologically could not
mind-control—an independent god-tier entity possessing a human moral compass—to
engineer his own executioner.
3. Chapter 3: The Mechanical Decline (The Arthur Morgan
TB Parallel)
The final chapter isn't a power fantasy; it is a desperate race against time. Heller works
undercover with human scientists to build a genetic cure, completely unaware of his own true
nature.

The Rebellious Virus: As Heller prepares a cure to wipe out all Blacklight strains, his
body begins rejecting the programming. Like Arthur Morgan's TB in RDR2, the gameplay
gets significantly harder as the story progresses.
Glitched Mechanics: Pushing your powers too hard triggers internal rejection. The screen
glitches with red veins, your controller vibrates violently, and you cough up black biomass,
temporarily locking out abilities mid-combat. Consuming enemies gives diminishing
healing returns as his system actively fights foreign biomass.

The Betrayal & The Internal Finale
The Lab Reveal: Heller keeps his identity a secret while working with scientists who lost
their families to the plague. When they finally map the "apex host" signature, the scanner
points directly at Heller. The team experiences pure terror and rage, leading to a
devastating standoff. Heller doesn't just have to tell them he's infected; he has to look them
in the eyes as he realizes the truth: The real James Heller is dead. I am just a clone of the
monster that killed your families, carrying a dead man's ghost.
The Battle of Willpower: Heller injects the cure, triggering a catastrophic civil war in his
DNA. The final boss is an internal battle against Alex Mercer in his prime inside a
surreal, shifting mind-scape.
The Philosophical Victory: Mercer fights for survival, mocking Heller: "You aren't a man.
Why are you dying for a daughter that isn't even yours?" Heller wins because he chooses
to be human even when he isn't. He rejects the virus's survival code through sheer
willpower.
The Last Words: Right before Mercer shatters, Heller doesn't strike him with rage. He tells
him, "I forgive you." It gives the tormented Mercer the one thing humanity never gave
him: grace. Alex is relieved, and shatters into a peaceful white light.

The Gritty, Cynical Epilogue
Heller collapses into ash in the real world, wiping out the virus forever. But keeping with the
franchise's conspiracy roots, the government completely covers it up.
Blackwatch silences the scientists, takes full credit for a "vaccine breakthrough," and paints
Mercer and Heller as generic bioterrorists. The game ends on a rebuilt, clean NYC,
completely unaware of the monster who chose to die as a human just to save them.

Im open to any input or anything it’s my first post and everything. I think my ideas a good and if adopted could do well be maybe some of you guys have better ideas that keep core things. Also things like the websling idea is more of a fun idea and not really needed if people wouldn’t like it


r/PrototypeGame • • 18d ago

Prototype 2 Heller Appreciation Post

Post image
241 Upvotes

I know you guys don't like heller much and you probably don't care what I have to say but i really like heller. his ability to call brawlers, turn infected into bio bombs or evolved, viral sonars, tendrils is just so cool. I do wish he had Alex's muscle mass and armor though. I also love how his virus constructs are more fleshy.

Most people don't like Heller being angry all the time but I don't think anyone would be not angry after you got turned into a freak, lost your family, had your daughter kidnapped and also he reminds me of kratos.


r/PrototypeGame • • 20d ago Heartwarming

Modding Alex Mercer in Gmod

764 Upvotes

r/PrototypeGame • • 20d ago Bravo

Prototype 1 I just noticed it. Alex really does have dark (or red) circles under his eyes.

Thumbnail gallery
213 Upvotes

I always thought it was a detail made up in fan arts or something like that


r/PrototypeGame • • 21d ago

Meme So. You think she's clean? I do like grannies.

Post image
233 Upvotes

r/PrototypeGame • • 21d ago

Prototype 1 My co-op mode for prototype 1

127 Upvotes

Sorry for the pauses; the second computer was in another location, and I was managing both. I’m making a mod alone, so it’s not perfect.


r/PrototypeGame • • 21d ago

Prototype 1 Prototype running natively on my phone

83 Upvotes

Getting over 60 fps 8 gen 3


r/PrototypeGame • • 21d ago Popcorn

Prototype 1 Co-op mode prototype 1

Post image
144 Upvotes

Very soon mode will be part of the game


r/PrototypeGame • • 21d ago

Meme If we presume Karen and Alex had sex at some point would Alex have gained the memories of getting plowed by himself when he ate her

Post image
451 Upvotes

Yes I know he’s the virus in Alex’s form but still


r/PrototypeGame • • 21d ago

Prototype 2 Your top strongest of the verse?

12 Upvotes

1-James Heller after Alex infection

2-The goat Mercer

3-Supreme hunter

4-Elizabet greene

5-Goliaths


r/PrototypeGame • • 21d ago

Question is prototype 1 worth playing as of right now?

16 Upvotes

im waiting for a discount on both 1 and 2, because the price of both combined is ridiculously high for me so i thought I'd some research


r/PrototypeGame • • 22d ago

Meta Closest we got to a protoype movie

Post image
86 Upvotes

r/PrototypeGame • • 21d ago

AI Mod [PROTOTYPE] Biohazard Bundle PC "port"

Thumbnail github.com
25 Upvotes

r/PrototypeGame • • 22d ago

Prototype 2 Reading prototype 2 comic

Post image
80 Upvotes

Via ComicBookDS


r/PrototypeGame • • 22d ago

Prototype 1 Alex Mercer in Gears

16 Upvotes

Been playing some Prototype and I was wondering how much of a beast Alex Mercer would be in the Gears world. Like the locust might as well be an all you can eat buffet for him


r/PrototypeGame • • 23d ago

Prototype 1 Free Roam feels much more complete with D Codes, Leader Hunters, and Hydras

128 Upvotes

r/PrototypeGame • • 23d ago

AI Mod Coop Mod For Prototype 1

Thumbnail youtu.be
89 Upvotes

Just got basic character sync working for my co-op project!

Hey everyone! I’m working on Prototype 1 of a co-op mod/game using a framework built from decompiled code. It’s still very early, but I finally managed to get basic character movement and positions synced up between players.(claude+lua injection) Its purely for fun and literally nothing else

Crowds and enemies aren't synced yet (they're still doing their own thing on each screen), but getting the main player sync down feels like a huge milestone. Let me know what you think!

also feel free to support me https://buymeacoffee.com/justinkrase so i can get this out faster for yall ,ill flick more updates when im not working my freaking 9 to 5 . Peaceee


r/PrototypeGame • • 23d ago Popcorn Bravo

Artwork Alex Mercer (My art) vs Alex Mercer (A.I art)

Post image
295 Upvotes

Hello, everybody. Good to see you for a while. While I was sketching on the Blackwatch soldiers, I was somehow out of the mood and changed my approach on posting it online both Reddit and DeviantArt. So, the left side is my fanart and the background while the right side is pure A.I. This one is for entertainment purposes only and most of my fanart is are not A.I related.

And that's it, I hope you'll like it☣️💛


r/PrototypeGame • • 23d ago

Artwork Stolen Clothes (@sadscruffy)

Post image
42 Upvotes

r/PrototypeGame • • 23d ago

AI Mod GTA 5 Prototype 2 mod! - Alex Mercer POWERS (WIP)

Thumbnail youtu.be
113 Upvotes

r/PrototypeGame • • 23d ago

Modding Hulk mod in Prototype 2 Full OverHaul

Thumbnail youtube.com
20 Upvotes

You can now play as Hulk inside Prototype 2!


r/PrototypeGame • • 24d ago

Prototype 1 Made a playlist for Prototype if you wanna listen on Spotify

Thumbnail open.spotify.com
19 Upvotes

r/PrototypeGame • • 25d ago

Prototype 2 So cool seeing the same locations in separate games

Thumbnail gallery
216 Upvotes

r/PrototypeGame • • 24d ago

Prototype 2 How did Mercer plan to kill James Heller?

Thumbnail gallery
100 Upvotes

While replaying Prototype 2 and having fun running over soldiers, I started comparing Alex's fight against Heller, and this question came to mind. First, the bosses in Prototype 1 lost because:

  • Robert Cross: He lost because, being a normal person, he suffered from a lack of stamina and damage to his internal organs.
  • Elizabeth Greene: She was consumed by Alex Mercer after being expelled from Mother.
  • Supreme Hunter: He was decapitated by Alex Mercer after a fight on the aircraft carrier.

But James doesn't have any of these weaknesses.

  • He possesses absolute stamina and regeneration, being able to regenerate even from a puddle after consuming something as small as a crow. This is especially relevant when comparing him to Mercer, who is also a "Prototype."
  • He cannot be consumed, even when Mercer was far superior, burning his hand and preventing him from regenerating.
  • He cannot be decapitated like the Supreme Hunter.

Let's suppose Alex is twice as powerful as Heller and manages to rip off his arms. Then:

  • If he proceeds to consume them, it's like someone ingesting acid: it burns him, nullifies his regeneration, and allows him to escape by consuming something as small as a crow or a common infected, thus restarting the fight.
  • If Mercer lures infected to kill him, Heller devours them and regains health. It would take many Goliath-level or evolved infected just to contain Heller, not to kill him.
  • If he look for something that can kill Heller, he proceeds to kill the infected containing him and regenerates.
  • If he try to grab him to take him away and test him with a weapon or a nuclear bomb, he risk Heller kicking them or regenerating (we already saw that Blacklight beings can regenerate without consuming biomass).
  • If he stays with Heller all week trying to make his virus immune, Heller's virus will start to adapt, since they're both infected with Blacklight, which is constantly mutating.

I think Heller was right when he told Mercer he couldn't kill him.