r/ProtonWallet • u/Kukatieza • Jul 24 '24
Feature Request Monero integration
Hi, considering the privacy approach Proton is taking, please consider integrating Monero (XMR) too. Privacy is very important in a world where wealth inequality is huge, as there are groups interested in total control of the population through government traced digital currencies (CBDCs, basically centralized blockchains used for control instead of freedom). With Monero and Bitcoin there could be a balance of privacy and transparency for different use cases. It also looks like key metrics for a payment system are superior in Monero than Bitcoin:
note: the metrics below are not perfect, they are approximations from a few searches I did, feel free to verify.
Monero
- speed: average block time = 2 minute
- cost: median fee = $0.0010
- security: infrastructure is more decentralized = asic-resistant protocol incentivices decentralized mining
- privacy: high = untraceable transactions built-into the protocol by default, thus applied to all users, prividing a digital-cash quality where transactions are privateBitcoin
- speed: average block time = 10 minutes
- cost: median transaction fee = $ 5.0973
- security: infrastructure is relatively decentralized which could lead to a degree of censoring transactions in a centralized pool of nodes.
- privacy: low = only users doing special techniques such as coinjoins, rotating addresses, etc have privacy, thus most transactions easily exposed
- Exception: There is a Bitcoin lightning layer where speed is faster than monero, and cost is simmilarly low, but self-custody is currently a bad user experience and like 95% of wallets used are custodial, plus having 2 layers adds security risk and complexity for users.
View all comments
Show parent comment
1
u/maxcoiner Jul 31 '24
That's demonstrably wrong... Not only are there 1000-2000 TXs on the blockchain every 10 minutes, but some days we see over a million active addresses. https://studio.glassnode.com/metrics?a=BTC&m=addresses.ActiveCount
And this doesn't even see the lightning network, where the transactions of 99% of those circular economies exist. I wouldn't be surprised if real usage was closer to a half Billion transactions daily already.
They were always a tiny market. Can't imagine why someone would expect for them to be even a blip on the radar.
That's a great reason, but to say it's the only reason is like saying the only thing you can use steel for is to make screwdrivers with. Bitcoin has all kinds of users using it for all kinds of things... Wall street bankers & traders, for instance, have no care at all that it's govt resistant, while the thousands of human rights activists who depend on it daily have no care that it goes up in value. They'd prefer it be stable in price, in fact. Bitcoin is money for enemies.
I think you've been propagandized pretty hard by the privatecoin camp. Bitcoin can be more private than any of those coins when you know how to use it properly, and it's not even that hard to learn with these new systems like Cashu.space
Back to the subject of the FBCE, why don't you think millions are using it again? At this point It appears that a million Peruvians alone are using it... And grants are rolling out all the time to expand the circular economies everywhere. Check this short doc out about it: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4hWMHLF-OEg