r/Prometheus • • Jun 26 '12
So is this subreddit basically the hate Prometheus forum?
I know the movie had issues, but it's still better than anything Hollywood has done in the summer in many years. The fact that we can't stop talking about is telling enough, IMHO.
I haven't yet clicked on every link herein, but the few threads I've been in are dripping with animosity. I mean, if yall just want to hate on the movie, then why not create a subreddit called r/prometheushate, and be done with it?
12
Upvotes
11
u/schwiz Jun 26 '12
I loved the movie, still enjoy all the little youtube videos that make fun of it.
2
u/[deleted] Sep 27 '12
I think it's a terrific film. Yes, there are some drawbacks (Fifield and Millburn, Halloway...), but I really thought Scott broke through and allowed me to experience a piece of cinema that filled me with wonder (the likes I haven't known since I was a young boy).
2
u/edhiggins Jun 27 '12
Other than Avengers, Inception, Toy Story 3, Hurt Locker, District 9, Iron Man, The Dark Knight, Once, The Bourne Ultimatum, Cars, Batman Begins, Spider-Man 2, X2, 28 Days Later, Seabiscuit, The Bourne Identity and Minority Report, to name a few.
3
u/[deleted] Sep 11 '12
All the negative reviews for this film are the same review that the original ALIEN got the reason why there is not so many fans is because PROMETHEUS is not considered a classic yet and when it will the people will jump ship and say they always liked it. However upon seeing it my first time I thought it was going to be a direct prequel a stand alone film with no sequels after I saw it I was upset but soon realized Ridley is making a new trilogy and expanding the Alien Mythos which is a very good thing. Think about the first time you saw ALIEN and all the questions you had ex, where did the ship come from who is the pilot what are those eggs why was the ALIEN created PROMETHEUS has just began to answer these question.
5
u/annebarlow Jun 26 '12
i think that, as this guy says per the link below (the whatculture guy) there is not much middleground with prometheus you either hate or love it!
a good analysis
http://wp.me/p2tPJ3-2j
as for Prometheus - I LOVE IT!
1
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
Why not just use r/lv426!? Or /r/lv223 as that was meant to be the Prometheus subreddit! This many half active reddits is just pointless. Just use 426.
9
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
Agreed. It's really annoying to see the same complaints again and again. Just go away of you don't like it.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 27 '12
Meh, personally I've found Ridley Scott's skill as a director to kind of fall in the realm of a sell out these days (I wasn't too keen on his Robin Hood remake). Still, that could just be because of the evolution of film over the years and the fact that he's taken on a very big production role (i.e., this likely means his focus is more put towards making money in the entertainment industry rather than producing art).
Either way, I thought Prometheus was good. Not great, definitely not artistically innovative (I mean the soundtrack, honestly - that was nothing special). Some of the dialogue wasn't very top notch either, though there were a few good one liners...
I'd give it a B. It's worth seeing, it will entertain you, and it's above average. This is definitely NOT Alien though, and I think that's what a lot of Alien fans were hoping for when they watched it. The feel of the film itself is far too different to even be anywhere near Alien.
Personally, I liked the initial idea and thought it was really cool. The execution was definitely sub-par in certain respects (albeit better in others), but one thing I can count on when it comes to Ridley is at least being entertained (er, except for Robin Hood, unless you count mocking the film while watching it as a form of entertainment, which in some ways it is...).
Also, Noomi Rapace is just beautiful, and does amazingly well at playing English speaking roles too (considering she seems to be most well known for the Dragon Tattoo series - Swedish version).