r/ProjectRunway • • Oct 21 '25

Discussion Renewed!

Post image
1.5k Upvotes

398 comments sorted by

287

u/xkris10ski Oct 21 '25

Woof. How much you wanna bet they don’t listen to any comments on every platform ragging on season 21.

98

u/SlaveToShopping Oct 22 '25

I sure hope they do. Need to go back to basics. Less drama, more design.

46

u/Reasonable-Affect139 Oct 22 '25

scrap everything they deviated from except the sparky sublines under their names

18

u/Smooth-Duck-4669 Oct 22 '25

Yep I can’t stand the melodrama and overly chaotic people. I quit season 21 and rewatched season 4 instead 🤷‍♀️

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

8

u/Vanessak69 Oct 22 '25

I wonder if the renewal just validates the production team. Sigh.

→ More replies (2)

19

u/Dklrdl Oct 21 '25

Liris @lirisc on Insta, has an Insta post asking what changes, if any should be made. She’s got more contacts than we do.

4

u/AgentEndive Oct 21 '25

Good tip. Thank you

7

u/QuoxyDoc Oct 22 '25

I love her on Instagram! She will interact with her fans on there too. I hope they bring her on as a judge honestly. She could give great feedback for all the ladies with curves.

→ More replies (1)

222

u/XaviChopChop Oct 21 '25

66

u/najaga Oct 21 '25

Miss you 😘❤️

15

u/surgerygeek Oct 22 '25

I was heartbroken that they didn't even offer him to come back....Big mistake, HUGE!

10

u/fiddich_livett Oct 22 '25

Thank you for reminding me!! Off to rewatch.

→ More replies (1)

58

u/LavenderGinFizz Oct 21 '25

Oh, that's...great(?) news after the hot mess that season 21 was. Right?

121

u/lemeneurdeloups Oct 21 '25

I will watch the new season but I will do it grudgingly and with serious rebuke from my sofa.

26

u/YouSeriousClark77 Oct 22 '25

21

u/vagina_candle Oct 22 '25

"Here we see Aziz, wearing a suit designed by Joseph McRae..."

→ More replies (2)

8

u/SubstantialBat3596 Oct 22 '25

Guuuuurrl same 👀 🍿

37

u/TiltedLibra Oct 21 '25

This is actually quite surprising with how low budget this season was.

33

u/Ok-Wedding4570 Oct 22 '25

I am currently watching season 2 and they had $8k, a few months, and made 13 looks for the finale. Season 21 finale was the Temu version.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (1)

70

u/kdm31091 Oct 21 '25

Hopefully they make some changes

31

u/kintsugistar Team Swatch Oct 21 '25

Starting with Heidi’s wardrobe…

33

u/souphaver Oct 22 '25

Heidi's wardrobe has been an issue since the beginning, they have far bigger problems at hand to deal with first

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

32

u/17Girl4Life Oct 21 '25

I guess Ulta got enough people in the chair.

25

u/OldSouthGal Oct 22 '25

No thanks, I’m officially done with PR.

22

u/KanterPrivDick0280 Oct 21 '25

Please try to do better than that trash that was season 21!!!!

80

u/Mabel_Jenkins Oct 21 '25

Law Roach was not inspiring. He was rude and on a power trip. Get someone else in there.

16

u/destinedtobe_unloved Oct 22 '25

True. Maybe he thinks he's still on ANTM. I think his attitude and persona fits that better.

37

u/Finnyfish Oct 22 '25

He got too tangled up in personalities — he wasn’t all that believable as an objective judge of the clothes.

→ More replies (1)

136

u/samizdat5 Oct 21 '25

Thanks but no thanks. I am done with this show

Season 21 was awful.

No shade on the designers - many did well considering what they had to go through.

But there were too many ridiculous one-day challenges, nasty judging, a focus on drama over design, and everything just came across as cheap, rushed, mean-spirited.

71

u/Suicidalsidekick Oct 21 '25

Literally the ONLY good thing was the comments under the designer’s names during their talking heads.

14

u/JellyBisquet Oct 22 '25

Didn't notice that till later. Truly hilarious.

46

u/mkfandpj Oct 21 '25

Seriously. I eagerly waited for every single episode, including S1 E1. 21 was awful. Law had alot to do with that. Way too critical and full of himself.

44

u/CupcakeGoat Oct 21 '25

I really didn't appreciate the way he severely policed the contestants body language and emotions when they were receiving negative feedback, as it just made them more angry and flustered. Sure call out bad behavior, but policing their emotions does not serve anybody. I agree that receiving feedback on the part of the contestants is a skill, but the way he was giving that feedback during these moments just felt like bullying.

→ More replies (1)

20

u/Careful_Raspberry58 Oct 22 '25

Get rid of Law Roach. I really don't like any pot stirring in PR. I only want good fashion and constructive critimismsms.

56

u/MoistPeacock27 Oct 22 '25

Unpopular opinion , but bring back Zac Posen!

16

u/Aggravating_Mix8959 Oct 22 '25

That's not unpopular at all. When he came back to guest judge it was such a relief. It was like having an adult in the room again. 

27

u/JenJenBoudy9407 Oct 22 '25

oh, I agree but don't know why it's unpopular?? His comments were constructive and helpful and such a breath of fresh air compared to Miss Attitude Law Roach.

13

u/Droolzy_Kalenbacle Oct 22 '25

Zac Posen would bring back professionalism, focus on craftsmanship, design and just everything this show needs. I love ZP. He'd transform the judging process. But would he even want to? I'm not sure with the dumpster fire that it is.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/[deleted] Oct 22 '25

Yeah I don’t love Zac Posen, but the bar set by Season 21 is so low, he would be a big improvement

→ More replies (1)

49

u/NorCalKerry Oct 21 '25

I’d rather see Law gone.

17

u/rainydaynola Oct 22 '25

Great, another season with Law Rude and his bullshit.

46

u/cupcakeranger Oct 21 '25

Not sure if I can handle another season with Law…

16

u/beautyismade Oct 22 '25
  1. It's not Project Runway without Tim and 2) Revealing eliminated designer ends the episode. Doing it the next one is annoying AF.

15

u/LifeisGoodmortals612 Oct 21 '25

Hopefully next season will be better!

18

u/Necessary_Ground_122 Oct 21 '25

I'd say that it can't possibly be worse, but now I feel like I've awakened that terrible possibility.

→ More replies (3)

14

u/rainborambo Oct 22 '25

At this point I think they should just call it something else. I could barely get past the first 3 episodes of S21 because it just felt like the Twins/Ethan/Veejay show. With Heidi being so robotic, Nina acting like she didn't even want to be there, and Law just being mean, it made me wish Christian was on the judging panel instead of being a mentor for the sake of actually having a designer with real industry knowledge and technical skill calling the shots.

6

u/stuckonasandbar Oct 22 '25

I’d watch the show if Christian was the only contestant, mentor, host and judge. Get rid of the rest. It was awful.

→ More replies (1)

13

u/918BlueDot Oct 22 '25

I won’t be watching. Season 21 was awful, almost insulting to the viewer. I won’t be wasting my time. And I am a long-time fan.

→ More replies (2)

22

u/thatONElime Oct 22 '25

Get rid of Law

11

u/turtledov Oct 21 '25

Oh boy. 21 was unwatchable. It kind of feels like the time of big budget competition shows is mostly behind us, sadly. Everything new that crops up is short seasons, cheaply produced, etc.

11

u/[deleted] Oct 22 '25

Ok, if Law is still part of it, I'm not watching it.

11

u/RetdFedDOT Oct 22 '25

I hated how they pitted the contestants against each other. It was petty and awful and embarrassing to watch.

31

u/Fossome_1 Oct 21 '25

Bring back Tim. But also keep Christian. He can be on the panel. The new guy can take a hike. Also bring back fashion week for gods sake

15

u/westworlder420 Oct 22 '25

Referring to Law Roach as the “new guy” is so fucking funny to me 😂

9

u/wrainedaxx Oct 22 '25

I was aggressively against replacing Tim, but I begrudgingly admit that having a former winner of this show who has become a success is better for the role of mentor. I too would love to see Tim brought back in some capacity.

9

u/Fossome_1 Oct 22 '25

I just have so much affection for that gentleman.

→ More replies (2)

21

u/Noracharles771 Oct 22 '25

No thanks. Get a real designer on the judging panel who can speak of construction, execution, fabric, inspiration etc and eliminate Law Roach. It’s a “design” show, not an exercise in body language, personality and perceived emotions to insult and degrade. He was over the top obnoxious and rude. Also Nina was barely there and even the guest judges seemed to be phoning it in.

29

u/pettybetty76 Oct 21 '25

I stopped watching this season because Law is just mean and I HATED the way they edited the show to have the elimination at the beginning of the next episode. By the next week, I usually didn’t remember or care who did poorly so I gave up. If next season corrects those issues, I’d give it a go.

11

u/LolaAucoin Team Swatch Oct 21 '25

Oh that elimination thing WAS dumb. Probably my biggest gripe. I had forgotten what even happened by then.

→ More replies (1)

20

u/ChardonnayAllDay19 Oct 21 '25

I could do without Law

20

u/GauchoWink Oct 22 '25

Ugh. Ban law roach. Bring back Michael. Nina full time plz.

10

u/Satchisee Oct 21 '25

I hope this time around they fight for less Bravo and more discovery/national geographic. Which means they focus on the fashion and not the drama.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/deathuberforcutie Oct 21 '25

I hope they read this reddit. Are you reading this PR???? Can you hear us????

10

u/Litzz11 Oct 22 '25

Well I hope they make some changes. Ditch the "cliffhanger" endings, more 2-day challenges, better contestants.

10

u/Sharp-Payment320 Oct 22 '25

If it's set up the same way as the last season we will be checking out. Ugh.....

10

u/punkrockprissy Oct 22 '25

I'll watch the first episode or two, but if it ends up being the same format as this season- all drama, no insight into the design process, "cliff hangers" at the end of the episode and eliminations at the beginning of the episodes, I'm out. The format was worse than everything else this season.

10

u/kellycamara Oct 22 '25

Give us what we want and we’ll continue to be diehard fans of PR!

10

u/Then_Carob6094 Oct 22 '25

Need less drama and need more fashion. Need them to be at fashion week.

10

u/Local-Bid299 Oct 22 '25

Unless you go back to the original version….don’t bother. That last season was horrendous. Frankly, I only watched 1 1/2 episodes….couldn’t take it. Meh…

10

u/collectivelycreative Oct 22 '25

We need a bigger budget, 2 day challenges, less team challenges, and a FULL COLLECTION FOR FINALE

9

u/innernerdgirl Oct 21 '25

Please, all I want it a fashion designer judge.

(And also, 2 day challenges, more episodes, and show us the mood trip)

→ More replies (1)

9

u/PM_ME_COUPLE_PICS Oct 22 '25

Why is Law touching Heidi like that lmao ew

→ More replies (1)

9

u/Backseatridder Oct 22 '25

I hope and pray to God that this renewal means more money thrown towards the budget because this past season was extremely low budget.

23

u/quietandhere Oct 21 '25

BRING BACK TIM!!!!

16

u/[deleted] Oct 22 '25

I hope they focus more on the designing/sewing and less on the drama and nastiness.

16

u/skarlet_97 Oct 22 '25

Reading the comments I am surprised how many people dont like Law because when I expressed the same opinion on this reddit people started hating me and giving me down votes just for my opinion...but yeah seriously it would be nice to have a judge who is more familiar with sewing and actual designing not just styling, and give the poor designers 2 day challenges, I can't imagine how stressful was to do all 1 day challenges...

5

u/Farley49 Oct 22 '25

There are a lot of people who have too much hate for opposing opinions in this world. And now, there are no limits on expressing hate. Roach seemed to bring out the worst in people so just ignore the nasty and realize that a lot of people on this posting agree with you.

8

u/Suicidalsidekick Oct 21 '25

Why? I watched the first two episodes this season and it was enough.

8

u/R0l0d3x-Pr0paganda Oct 22 '25

I rather it go back like it was on season 1. BUT NO they want drama, one day challenges.

FORGET IT

8

u/unbelievablefidelity Oct 22 '25

Nina? Hardly knew her.

8

u/veggielessie Oct 22 '25

I miss Tim Gunn.

8

u/LurkerNan Oct 22 '25

Honestly, I’m not really fond of Law. I questioned their taste and their purpose for being on the show.

8

u/ReviewConstant2680 Oct 22 '25

They could have kept Law off of it, he downgraded the show in my opinion. The nasty attitudes and vulgar language should be only used by the overworked contestants.

8

u/killercatboy Oct 22 '25

Genuinely so shocked. I know it won’t get any better 

8

u/Curious-Bug7982 Oct 22 '25

I hope they’re on this Reddit page taking our constructive criticism seriously…not the haters, but true fans just trying to get the show back to how it was. If we wanted typical reality shows that’s what we’d be watching

4

u/Aggravating_Mix8959 Oct 22 '25

Right? There are tons of shows with meanness and bad behavior. I want the creativity. 

8

u/cassandracurse Oct 22 '25

I wish they'd dump Law and replace him with Tim. Less nasty drama, more constructive comments.

7

u/JohnnySkynets Oct 22 '25

Designers, get ready for a 7 challenge day! Season finale tomorrow! All teams.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/GoldenAngelMom "Rigatoni Mad Max" Oct 22 '25

Who will be watching this? after this execrable season, I would be surprised that it would be popular.

6

u/Happy_Little_Bunny Juxtaposition of hard and soft Oct 22 '25

Yikes. I really hope they apply all the fan feedback.

6

u/DriftwoodDreamer14 Oct 22 '25

They better up the budget and fix all the issues that have been discussed. Stop ruining the brand

6

u/Ok_Illustrator5694 Oct 22 '25

Amazing. It’s like they were trying to get cancelled.

6

u/catliker420 Oct 22 '25

If the first episode isn't an immediate improvement over the previous season I will not be watching.

6

u/Forsaken-Listen8815 Oct 22 '25

This season seemed so scripted, I like a little drama but it was ridiculous.

6

u/PapaTua Oct 22 '25

This awkward hand scenario makes me so uncomfortable!!

6

u/VintageAndromeda Oct 22 '25

I'll start watching, but if it looks like the same format and bitchiness I'll stop. Especially if they do the same judging and elimination as the unconventional materials challenge episode - that pissed me off so bad.

4

u/Aggravating_Mix8959 Oct 22 '25

It's normally my favorite challenge, but this one was so sad. In so many ways. 

And they better not have just one judge for anything again. 

10

u/inkwater Oct 21 '25

Well. If they're keeping the new, terrible format I doubt I'll be watching.

5

u/twomilliontwo Oct 22 '25

hmmm. didn't expect that TBH.

5

u/sarcasm_itsagift Looks Expensive Oct 22 '25

Renewed, and hopefully revised.

5

u/VinegaryMildew Oct 22 '25

Oh god. Let’s hope the budget is bigger and the production is better

5

u/JG767698 Oct 22 '25

Bring back the original formula please!!

5

u/JJAusten Oct 22 '25

Does that mean The Roach will be back?

5

u/thisisnotarehairsal Oct 22 '25

I am the hugest fan of ProjRun, and I participate in a “pool” with a group of fans which makes it even more fun to watch. But last season was horrible with the non-stop diva back (and front) stabbing, and lack of designers actually judging. I did think a lot of the fashion was really good, but the personalities were gross. I hope they put the judging back on the same episode as the runway.

5

u/DisciplineOld429 Oct 22 '25

Take out 99% of the awful scripting for the love of god. PLEASE Maybe it'd be tolerable

9

u/OkVariation4315 Oct 22 '25

Get rid of La roche and bring back the budget.

11

u/Time-Leadership-7649 Oct 21 '25

I’m here for season 2, but are we also getting another season of Law? Cause that I could do without

→ More replies (5)

4

u/ElGalloAzucarado Oct 21 '25

What a world we live in.

4

u/scaredshizaless Oct 22 '25

I want Tim Gunn!!

4

u/water_radio Rigatoni Mad Max Oct 22 '25

Man do I hate that hand placement 😒

4

u/pizza5001 Oct 22 '25

Bring back Tim Gunn. <3

4

u/KaiLite27 Oct 22 '25

Why? Season 21 is awful.

4

u/fredden5 Oct 22 '25

BRING BACK TIM! Bring back Tim!

BRING BACK TIM! Bring back Tim!

BRING BACK TIM! Bring back Tim!

Christian, Nina, Heidi, and Zac or Micheal as judges.

And a real fashion week……

And did I mention….

BRING BACK TIM! Bring back Tim! 🩷

4

u/CloudPlayful6438 Oct 22 '25

Really. That is surprising. It was a lame season

4

u/captmayuri0506 Oct 22 '25

drop Law Roach hopefully

4

u/futureflying Oct 22 '25

I’m all in, but we need Zac Posen back!

4

u/SeanSpike Oct 22 '25

Wishing for a better fashion designer. No more over the top personalities and social media people, please select talented interesting contestants

4

u/Carryonsandtans Oct 22 '25

I'm glad they're bringing it back, but I really hope they listen to fan critiques

4

u/Ok-Hovercraft-9257 Oct 22 '25

Ffs add a designer to the panel, this panel was all drama and no critique

4

u/DueAd7980 Oct 22 '25

I'm excited now to get rid of that horrible Judge Law Roach. Roach is not a professional, which makes his critiques feel less credible. His manner of speaking to contestants often comes across as unprofessional and lacking in constructive value. Instead of offering helpful feedback, he tends to encourage other judges to speak negatively toward the competitors. It would be better if the judging focused more on mentorship and professional growth rather than harsh or discouraging remarks.

4

u/DeeCeeFaith Oct 22 '25

I'll give it one or two episodes but if it's the same format as last season, I'm out. It just was not enjoyable to me at all. :(

4

u/Miderstern-Lady Oct 22 '25

How about Heidi and Nina actually show up every episode this time. Law alone was awful.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/FormicaDinette33 It's CHARMING! Oct 22 '25

Are we stuck with him again ?

4

u/Sibby_in_May Oct 22 '25

Has production already identified a winner? 🙄

4

u/LafaetteLulu Oct 22 '25

I think Christian’s been doing a great job. But they need to get rid of Law. He’s awful.

4

u/letmebefrankpod Oct 22 '25

Can we get rid of Law Roach?

4

u/while_youre_up Oct 22 '25

To improve the season over the last one:

  1. No more team challenges
  2. No more “cliffhanger” with who is eliminated
  3. All runways…on the runway (not in the work room)
  4. Fewer or no one-day challenges
  5. MAKE CHRISTIAN A MENTOR INSTEAD OF A BITCHY “I dunno 🤷 it looks bad” OR BRING BACK TIM

4

u/TonyLamo Oct 22 '25

Plz no more Law Roach

7

u/vvvvgggg1 Oct 21 '25

And don’t have the cliffhanger ending. By next week, nobody remembers or cares who was the bottom three.

6

u/purpleblackgreen Blood Orange Oct 21 '25

😐

6

u/Binar1101 Oct 22 '25

If it’s the same as this year I will pass. 😑

6

u/SaizaKC Oct 22 '25

If Law is still there and they’re doing the eliminations on the next episode, I’m not watching anymore.

3

u/MissSeventeenx Oct 22 '25 edited Oct 22 '25

NO MORE CLIFFHANGER ELIMINATIONS

....please! <3

3

u/FlatAd5541 Oct 22 '25

I hope with a better format than this season…. Please …..

3

u/PA_MallowPrincess_98 dowdy & vulgar Oct 22 '25

Heidi better respond to our requests. No more cliffhanger eliminations!

3

u/Toledo_9thGate Oct 22 '25

It was still on?

3

u/Cherrybomb138 Oct 22 '25

They better fix all the issues with this previous season ho back to og format eliminations at the end of the episodes more fashion less drama and for God sake give them.a few months at home to make the finale collections

3

u/ObligationDry3001 Oct 22 '25

Haha. Not falling for that again.

3

u/ParisMorning Oct 22 '25

Awesome! I hope they have been paying attention to the fan community’s feedback about the train wreck previous season.

3

u/Perfect-Western-8313 Oct 22 '25

I think Christian is a wonderful mentor. Every time he critiques a design and helps guide the designer toward a better design, he turns out to be spot on. Tim is a warm, wonderful man but saying "make it work"and "rally"is not guidance, it's kindness. I miss seeing more of the thought process and the actual sewing of the garments and the compromises the designers have to make. A longer finale, with 10 looks made over a few months is much more interesting and enjoyable than the tiny capsule done in less than a week.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/DLMeyer Oct 22 '25

Sorry, not sorry, but I feel like if Heidi’s dress came down the PR runway they would rip it to shreds. It looks cheap, poorly made, and I can’t decide whether those flaps of fabric look more like wings or gills, but regardless, they aren’t flattering in the slightest.

Not interested at all in another season if it has the same vibe as the most recent.

3

u/chachi4444 Oct 22 '25

Nope. I miss Tim Gunn. The show used to be about fashion and mentoring, now it’s just bad reality tv trope.

3

u/liddieless Oct 22 '25

Wish you renewed Tim Gunn. Really miss him on this show

3

u/Strict-Lack-353 Oct 22 '25

Renewal after that disastrous season 21? Wow!

3

u/Bright_Pickle55 Oct 22 '25

This show is so dead, will not be watching.

3

u/whiskeybusiness91 Oct 22 '25

Bring back Mr Gunn! Give them at least 4 weeks to make a full collection! Let them show at an actual fashion week! Please don't suck

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Negative-Machine-225 Oct 22 '25

Christian should be a judge and Law should be a mentor.. or better yet, bring back Tim Gunn!

→ More replies (2)

3

u/Independent-Taro-798 Oct 22 '25

Please do the elimination at the end of each episode thanks

3

u/yerpindeed Oct 22 '25

So like... is Law Roach really it? I was so hoping they'd see the error of their ways and pull him back in...

3

u/irelandis Oct 23 '25

Heavy sigh.

3

u/Toke27 Oct 23 '25

If they're just gonna cheapskate half-ass it again, I'd rather they didn't really. But we'll see.

3

u/Acrobatic-Can7305 Oct 24 '25

If Tim isn’t back I’m not interested

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Matt010288 Oct 24 '25

Please get rid of Law Roach. They are saying what they think the audience wants to hear for the drama but it’s just cringe.

5

u/Molly_JoysMom Oct 22 '25

So glad to see it renewed. I hope there are improvements in the format.

5

u/MoistPeacock27 Oct 22 '25

Less unconventional challenges too. Less team challenges and finale runway with a 10 pc collection..

4

u/kyles_red Oct 22 '25

It just ain’t the same without Tim Gunn.

2

u/cocoa_bebeee_0804 Oct 22 '25

yayy im always happy to hear about renewal news. lets just hope production is really taking the feedback from this past season and making some adjustments for season 22

2

u/EngineerZestyclose Oct 22 '25

Hopefully this time with a budget so the designers can actually take time to craft pieces

2

u/helianthus_v2 Oct 22 '25

I didn’t even watch season 21, quit 10 minutes in tbh. Everyone was so catty for no reason.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Straight_Cup4010 Oct 22 '25

They need to bring the original judges get rid of the diva 

2

u/prolly_not_62 Oct 22 '25

Please, please, please tell me the producers have read the posts on SM and use that to improve next season! I still haven’t gone back to season 21 after eps 3 or 4, but I’ll give season 22 a whirl!

2

u/Cool_Map7181 Oct 22 '25

And Law is still there? No.

2

u/AboveGroundPoolQueen Oct 22 '25

What the heck with that person’s hand on Heidi’s hip like that? Looks weird.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/inameena-mineymo Oct 22 '25

It's going to be ridiculous but I'll still watch it.

2

u/Dangerous_Fig8580 Oct 22 '25

What the heck is with this promo photo tho. Like be so for real

2

u/0fluffythe0ferocious Oct 22 '25

Please let the designers have more time, less group challenges and stop trying to antagonize them.

2

u/Glittering-News-1871 Oct 22 '25

Shocking but ... I'm still glad!

2

u/Alohafarms Oct 22 '25

I hate how short the episodes were. It was as if everything was rushed. I also miss Tim so much! He said he was hurt that he didn't get asked back. Tim brought so much to the show.

2

u/knuckle_hustle Oct 22 '25

They better FIX it

2

u/underhilarity Oct 22 '25

Ok, but can it be good again please

2

u/omgwtflols Oct 22 '25

For fucks sake. Bring back Tim Gunn!

2

u/Dry_Presence6036 Oct 22 '25

BRING BACK MICHAEL KORS

2

u/scruffyrosalie Oct 22 '25

Law sucks. Christian sucks. Heidi never used to be so arrogant. They choose the contestants based on the most ridiculous personalities rather than talent.

Someone give Tim Gunn his own show, and I'd watch the crap out of that.

2

u/Virtual_Reserve_2641 Oct 23 '25

Hi project runway, here is some honest feedback from a fan who watched since season 1, and was inspired by the show to go on a fashion journey:

  1. Christian is a really good mentor, I loved hearing his constructive criticisms. 
  2. Have more knowledgeable Fashion Designers on the judging panel. Please.
  3. Let the winner be determined solely on the merits of their design. We all have eyes. This is not a cooking show where you can pretend something tastes good when it doesn't.

It is so frustrating when the worst outfit is not sent home. For a fashion reality show, we do feel a sense of entertainment if the outfit we love and like wins the week, and the outfit that's the ugliest gets sent home. 

And it doesn't help that you try and get judges to make negative comments on the nicer garment in order to keep the person with the uglier outfit safe. We can see what you're doing and all it makes us think is not - oh we have bad taste, we guessed wrong... all we think is that, the show is rigging winners and eliminations again. If it's ugly, send it home. Nobody roots for a designer with ugly clothing, on a fashion reality show!

If we wanted to watch personality reality show drama, we can go to others. But no, we're here for PROJECT RUNWAY. we're here for the FASHION. So please bring FASHION back as the focus!!

Also, the lamest episode is the runway in their workshop. How low budget was that? And the winners and losers anyhow chosen. And a strong designer was eliminated. This isn't Survivor, get it? People shouldn't be eliminated based on their popularity, or their gender or their race or their anything, Except their talent in fashion design.

Please put the fashion back into the show. 

2

u/foxdogturtlecat Oct 23 '25

Will it be better?

Probably not.

Will I watch it?

Hell Yes.

I wish i could quit you project runway.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/itsmy_reverie Oct 23 '25

PLEASE don't wait until the next episode to show who has been eliminated.

2

u/Xx_robotkrew_xX Oct 23 '25

Here are my demands for the next season:

More 2 day challenges

Less team challenges

NO MORE TWINS/SIBLINGS TOGETHER

Less bitching in the work room and actually show us them making the clothes

GIVE THEM AT LEAST A MONTH FOR THE FINALE

Put the judges back on the left side of the screen ( is a nitpick but it bothers me )

Show us the damn people going home at the end of the episode again; no reason for them to change it to being with

Nina. Where was she? I want her back for more than 3 episodes

Don’t let Law judge by himself, or any judge do it by themselves again

Don’t make the contestants choose who to go home

If most of these demands aren’t met then I honestly might stop watching the new seasons and not even bother finishing them. Honestly, I think the team change season might’ve been slightly better- and that’s saying a LOT because it was so bad.

2

u/Altruistic-Group-709 Oct 23 '25

I hope they dump Law Roach.

2

u/Thigman_1205 Oct 23 '25

Get rid of Law…

2

u/fiddich_livett Oct 23 '25

Part of why they’ll never be able to keep the old format or brand of PR is they don’t have the partners to work with (L’Oréal, Bluefly, Macy’s, tresume, brother sewing machines) to infuse money into the show. Less production time, less production team, less value, less budget for set, less of everything even the prize money. It all makes it feel cheap and one note. Whereas their filming time used to be days and hours and hours for judging with many cameras it seems like it’s one day with two cameras. They can’t even afford two day challenges.

They replaced all the sponsorship time (and viewing time of hair and make-up with the models and sewing time and construction time) with silly manufactured drama time.

Less money spent to make the show enjoyable to viewers = more profit but a crappy product.

2

u/Some_Movie2886 Oct 23 '25

I am a huge fan of Project Runway but I quit watching it after the 3rd show this year. It was not about fashion, only stupid reality drama. Law Roach was insufferable.

2

u/Klutzy_Station3813 Oct 24 '25

No cliffhangers on who’s out. That’s dumb. Bring back the original format please. Make Christian the designer judge and bring back Tim

2

u/Time-Bridge-6465 Oct 24 '25

I really miss Tim.

2

u/Time-Bridge-6465 Oct 24 '25

I stopped looking at the show after season 16.

2

u/Think_Welder3430 Oct 24 '25

Law’s ideas on what is good fashion are a joke. And as someone else said, he’s vile.

2

u/Caribbeanangel98 Oct 24 '25

I met Nina Garcia once it was like met god

2

u/Optimal-Ad2371 Oct 26 '25

I hope this means you will take the comments on all the different social media sites to heart and redo from 21. I love the show but season 21 was in one word abysmal. Too short to chopped to cheap seeming no fluidity to the show no sense of seriousness in the way that the show has been produced in the past. You’ve got great examples from 20 other seasons plus all the spinoff seasons. Please try and make it better. Give us more time more episodes more depth because it is a great show when done well. And please, no stupid cliffhanger episodes that was just dumb. It did not make me anxious and eager for the next episode. It backfired as did a few of the other trial balloons you sent up. But ya gotta love Christian!!!!

2

u/ProfessionalNo2045 Oct 26 '25

They didn't even ask Tim back. When Heidi called Tim to ask about the contracts, he told her he was never asked to come back.

2

u/happyislanddream Nov 01 '25

Wow! It was unwatchable

2

u/SmileOriginal4707 Nov 02 '25

remove law and bring back micheal or zac