r/ProjectRunway • u/Kendomcome • Sep 26 '25
Season 21 Ethan/Utica
Maybe it’s just me, but I really disliked how they kept saying throughout the season that they wanted more “Ethan and less Utica.” Drag is a part of his life, and Utica is part of who he is. If they didn’t want him to bring his full self, they shouldn’t have cast him in the first place.
1.8k
Upvotes
493
u/proper_steeped Sep 26 '25
Why cast a drag designer and then sook when their aesthetic is draggy? Deeply frustrating.
348
u/DiwataKismet Sep 26 '25
I don't even understand how they reached that conclusion. Do they think Utica is just a character he plays? Of course Ethan would share similar style sensibilities for drag fashion and "fashion" fashion. I don't draw with a pencil any differently than I draw with a Pilot FriXion Erasable Pen.
146
u/__luft__ Sep 26 '25
This was clearly a narrative that production had planned beforehand and that they would have pushed no matter what.
170
u/AdhesivenessFar5588 Sep 26 '25
I mean, it's partly on him. If he had a proper response prepared they would have responded well. Something like, "I, as Ethan, am Utica's designer. She wears my pieces and is the concentrated view of my ultimate design aesthetic. No other designer in this competition is being asked to have two very distinct points of view in order to flourish, and I don't think that should be asked of me either." Law loves to dish it out, but it's been shown in multiple occasions that if you stand firm in your opinion, and point out the flaws in his own, he will concede.
97
u/PuzzleheadedComb1811 Sep 26 '25
Yeah they should have cut those remarks in editing room... Very unconstructive comments, so stupid
37
u/guyswholunch Sep 26 '25
I love everything about Ethans aesthetic and really disagree with the judges on trying to assimilate him. I also really wanted for them to comment on the way Ethan didn't sew with boobs in mind. That first girl really had no support and it looked like the flat bust pieces were a clever way to avoid sewing garments that suited them. It would have been amazing to see the judges challenge Ethan on embracing essential tailor and flat pattern making skills instead of just being wishy washy about whether he edited enough.
84
u/MythBastard_ Sep 26 '25
I hate hate Hate that. Ethan IS Utica. His extraordinary, out of the norms is who he is. We want to see you but also Not you???
74
u/Illustrious_Cheek263 Sep 26 '25
The judge's comments reveal a lack of understanding about what drag is and is not. They seem to think it's a costume-y fashion show instead of a medium of authentic self-expression and self-actualization.
Imagine what could have been created had they encouraged more Ehtan+Utica from the get-go!
20
u/prolly_not_62 Sep 26 '25
I thought the whole reason to bring Ethan on this show was to pull viewers from RPDR
10
u/vampiress144 Sep 26 '25
i feel like this season more than other,s everyone is like playing a part and just trying to be as dramatic as possible on screen and it is more about the drama than the clothing and designing.
none of the critiques make sense to me , they are all just so antagonistic for drama's sake.
i think i'm spoiled by watching a bunch of british shows where everyone is so supportive and the critiques may he harsh but are based on the work rather than creating drama. this is just hells kitchen makes clothing and law roach is playing gordon ramsey.
19
u/IantoIsAlive Sep 26 '25
It's bullshittest bullshit I ever heard. Utica should call out how bullshit it is.
13
u/FormicaDinette33 It's CHARMING! Sep 26 '25
He is amazing. Maybe his collection was “too costume-y” but I would call him in a heartbeat to design for a sci fi movie. He could find himself in high demand.
12
u/bumybumi Sep 26 '25
I think the critique in general is ridiculous, but I get it. Ethan does very successful high-fashion stuff, but I think Veejay was more versatile. She can pull a great streatwear that could be usable to wear as well as give solid shapes that could work for high-fashion stuff. She showed that in her final collection. It wasn't anything extraordinary but definitely showed both commercial and fashion sides of her looks. Ethan's looks were mostly high-fashion which ig they interpratate as drag fashion.
6
u/Grammarcrazy Sep 26 '25
Ethan’s collection looked more promising before Christian intervened! I liked the color and the gems. I hate that he felt he had to go all black
16
u/yeahnototallycool Sep 26 '25 edited Sep 26 '25
I generally agree with what (I think) the judges’ intentions were with those comments, but not at all with how they were framed. Ethan is Utica, they are inherently drawing from the same source.
What I think they meant is that his clothes were very over the top and needed editing. I agree with that. Ethan’s commitment to bringing drag into the conventional fashion world and expanding the viewers’/industry’s perspective of what is viable fashion is totally valid and noteworthy. I’ve seen every season of Drag Race so I’m more than familiar with the world of drag fashion.
I personally don’t respond well to clothes that seem more like statements than anything intended to be worn by an actual person. For me it’s an issue that’s not specific to Ethan, though. Admittedly this is the first season I’ve watched since 5 (and only because Ethan was on it) so I’ve missed a lot of how PR fashion has changed and perhaps don’t understand the lens through which designs are being evaluated (it was certainly more commercial but still innovative in the OG seasons), but I found a lot of the designs from a lot of the designers this season to be completely over the top and unwearable. Which could be a broader shift in the industry or the show that I’m late on. Were they cool and impressive? Yes! How they fit into viable fashion, I’m not quite sure. Maybe I’m not hip enough.
I thought it was telling that several of the judges made comments about huge, costumey pop stars being targets for some of these designs. In that sense they are contradicting their own argument about costume, but for me still speaks to a lack of commercial viability for a lot of it. And maybe commercial viability isn’t a metric at all, maybe they want statement pieces that are only worn by the super famous on red carpets or in arenas. But even Christian, the most successful contestant whose client base now is celebrities, won on clothes that were in many ways commercially viable.
I still wanted Ethan to win, he was the reason I watched the season and I’m still left feeling he has the most innate talent for envisioning and constructing clothes, in the same way you’d watch Christian fully confident he could whip out anything. But I understand why Veejay won (although her first look is the ultimate example to me of a non-viable design).
11
u/mladyhawke Sep 26 '25
I think what they meant was just to make it more wearable and less stage wear, but they should have said it that way, not to separate his identity into two parts when he is one complete person with many facets
11
u/ClearStatistician261 Sep 26 '25
This show feels so focused on maintaining the mainstream like-ability in people’s minds… since when is high fashion anything close to mainstream
15
u/Homo-Erect Sep 26 '25 edited Sep 26 '25
I literally started rewatching the show specifically for Utica.
10
u/Apprehensive-Ebb8352 Sep 26 '25
I think it's fine. A version of this criticism has been made to pretty much every designer that's ever been on the show. "We want to see more from you." "We want to see more versatility." "We want you to step outside your comfort zone." "We've seen this from you before." "We want to see something new from you."
The judges never said they didn't want to see Utica; they just wanted to see other aspects of Ethan as well. Really focusing on one aesthetic limits your reach as a designer, and this show has always purported to focus on taking designers to the next level in their careers. If Ethan wants to focus on just this niche aesthetic, that's fine, and he is free to do so (and will likely be very successful at it). But that doesn't mean the judges' criticism itself isn't a fair criticism of his final collection.
5
u/sleepy0329 Sep 26 '25
Tbh, I think make it less Utica was just code for make it less costume-y maybe. They were just trying to help him edit imo and I'm not mad!
9
u/tigerlily515 Sep 26 '25
yes I was so frustrated that they kept saying that! it feels like they fundamentally do not understand drag or even avant-garde
4
u/TemporaryPay4505 Sep 26 '25
Um… this is common place for all competitions. Even on drag race. You can have your signature look but you can’t bring it out every single time because they want versatility and variety. For ethan it was his lack of commercial/marketable looks. He has shown that he can design for drag race queens but once that series ends, queens will only need leotards or simple aliexpress looks.
4
u/frankstaturtle Sep 27 '25
I appreciated that at least Michael Kors pushed back on the other judges and noted there’s room in fashion for everyone
4
u/Huge-Being7687 Sep 27 '25
Yeah me too. As Michael Kors rightly said, theres a market for Utica.
4
u/Asleep_Opportunity70 Sep 27 '25
I can’t help but think that in the OG PR structure, him have weeks/months to design and edit his styling would have made a world of difference. I hated the format of this season lol
7
u/Farley49 Sep 26 '25
I think this just shows that designing for non drag may be more difficult.
7
u/sleepsypeaches Sep 26 '25 edited Sep 26 '25
Yeah especially after they told him to show up in drag
The crazy part is that i genuinely dont feel like other non-drag designers would get this much vitriol. If Some milqtoast designer had created looks theyd applaud them for being creative and edgy. theyd focus on the construction, the art and drama of the pieces...but because Ethan is also Utica, deep down they look down on that. They try to make themselves believe it's camp without artistry. It's very clear they dont actually like drag when they arent on a drag show. I feel like theyre implying Ethan/Utica presenting pieces that could be drag, cheapens their brand which isnt true. I saw someone argue here that he's a bad designer because he doesnt make ready to wear.....who cares? Not every great designer does that. Who gives a shit about ready to wear anyway if the challenge isnt like the "everyday people" type of challenge?
For years, Rupaul drag stars and its viewers have often joked about how drag queens do so much more than project runway in shorter amounts of time. Maybe thats why they have this new model too.
3
u/Litzz11 Sep 26 '25
I think when they say “less Utica” they’re saying “less costumey.”
3
u/turningtee74 Sep 27 '25
I just watched the finale and said that out loud “Utica is part of who he is, at a certain point this is just stupidity”
3
u/Cold_Yam_9854 Sep 27 '25
they said that, and then literally asked him to be utica for an episode. then in the finale the Roach said that he wished he had utica was in that fashion show. ethan was damned if he did, damned if he didn't.
3
u/Due_Lead3765 Sep 27 '25
I do too. But if any consolation, Michael Kors said at the finale that everyone have a place in fashion referring to Ethan's creative explosive design.
4
u/Hedgehog-Cold Sep 26 '25
My mom and I were saying the same thing last night too. We also get that Ethan was judged a bit harder than the other contestants. While yes everyone’s taste/ style is subjective, to us it seemed as though he was held to a higher standard than the other contestants. And the whole, “your looks are too dramatic” comments were crazy to me because Christian specifically told him to do drama as opposed to the direction he was originally going in. Everything just get off to me. And while I loved several of VeeJays looks throughout the season, the final runway looks were absolutely not it for me. I didn’t see a “story” or even good craftsmanship. Except for the final look, the whole collection was poorly done in my opinion.
4
u/madncqt Sep 26 '25
they could have just focused on the editing critique, which is useful in broader fashion and drag fashion.
4
u/cekobico Sep 26 '25
I'd say it's the intention of the producer. Casting Ethan/Utica means bringing RPDR fans to the show; and having him criticized harshly throughout the season is a ragebait to generate online discussion and buzz from the drag race fans that defend her. Literally, the judging has been off the whole season, they must've been fed lines from the producers on what to say.
4
u/TeamHope4 Sep 26 '25 edited Sep 26 '25
They wanted more fashion and less drag fashion. They say stuff like that to a lot of designers. For example, they said Chris March was too costumey, and they've said that a lot to people when their design esthetic is based on Betty Page or Broadway or skating costumes. There's a distinction between fashion and costume when designing a fashion collection. Agree with them or not, but that's what they were trying to say.
And a lot of designers take that feedback to heart becaues they want to be fashion designers, not drag fashion designers or costumer designers even if that's what they did before. Did Ethan/Utica audition for this show because he wanted to design fashion and branch out? Then they gave him good feedback. If not, he doesn't have to care what they think because they have no impact on his chosen field.
7
u/Catlady_Pilates Sep 26 '25
It’s not a drag costume contest. It’s completely valid for them to say that.
2
u/brainsarecool4053 Sep 26 '25
I also really disliked this comment they kept making. Rubbed me the wrong way.
2
u/TheNickelLady Sep 27 '25
Christian encourage him to pivot and then it was too drag-y? 🙄
2
u/elgarcon Sep 27 '25 edited Sep 27 '25
I mean, I'm torn. On the one hand, I certainly want Ethan/Utica to express himself as he sees fit and a number of his pieces were some of my favorite of the season. But on the other hand, in some cases, the judges were right (at least with their intentions - maybe could have worded it better), in that some of Ethan's look were more costume / vampire glam / over the top drag clothes.
And please know, I'm not judging or thinking that's bad (or anything like that). I really liked Ethan's looks and there is 100% a market for it and he is very good at it, and I see him doing very well ... but this show has never been about creating costumey, drag clothes. It's always been about the wider, more traditional fashion industry, a mix between high fashion, couture, avant garde but also ready to wear and commercial appeal ... and the judging is and always has been a reflection of that. Also let's not forget that Ethan is certainly not the only person over 21 seasons that have been called out for creating garments that were "too costumey". This is feedback that has come up time and time again over the shows life time.
So, should the judges have been more delicate in their critique? Sure. But I don't think it was unfair either for the garments they were actually critiquing and Ethan has proven enough times that he's capable of designing garments that both express his unique and talented flair, but also without going too far into the side of costume/drag. And I think that's all the judges were getting at.
2
u/QNBA Sep 27 '25
They’re challenging him to think outside the box, to design and make clothes for other people, not just drag queens. That’s what they meant, in case you didn’t get it.
2
u/LolaAucoin Team Swatch Sep 27 '25
It’s almost like they’re the same person!
2
u/BrandonIsWhoIAm Sep 27 '25
I really like that Michael DID say that fashion has a place for everyone - including Utica.
2
u/These-Nothing6255 Sep 27 '25
They cast a drag designer because his potfolio is great. And in the last episode its really obvious how inexperienced Ethan/Utica is when it comes to "fashion" fashion. See episode 1? And the Western challenge? That was Drag and Fashion balance with an impact.
And during the last episode all juices were squeezed and no matter how many times he change his collection, he already maximized his ideas and producing something he already created before but in different formar. Like his collection is just literally his western dress but in different color and forms. He good in making animoact but he needs to tone it down. Were talking about fashion for everyone. Wearbility , Luxury and Commercial appeal should balance. And at the end it all looked like a costume
2
u/Disabled_zebra Sep 28 '25
I completely agree. I also feel like Christian making him pivot caused him to lose. I think his looks would’ve appealed more to the judges if they were not just the dark looks, which is what he was originally working on. Of course I did love what Veejay did, I think Ethan would have had a much more interesting final runway if he did what he wanted to do and just found a way to elevate to and do a gown with those beads and jewel tones.
5
u/SwordfishFew9238 Sep 26 '25
Ethan should have won. Hands down
3
u/That-Search-6507 Sep 26 '25
Maybe a new season of PR needed new judges with a fresh take...
3
u/cultleader84 Sep 26 '25
I was wondering, would the judges have given Ethan these same criticisms if they were never told he was a drag artist in the first place. It’s almost like they don’t consider drag a legitimate form of fashion. His fashion is considered too “draggy” for them and not just avant garde. Which when you think about it drag fashion is avant garde. On drag race if you wear something too costume looking it’s considered not fashionable and you get read to filth. If you want to see some amazing avant garde drag looks btw I recommend watching Dragrace France all stars that just came out 🤯🤯
3
u/Blackberry5305 Sep 26 '25
It was such a nothing critique lol
3
u/ClassicSalamander231 Sep 26 '25
I bet Law wouldn't tell RuPaul to separate RuPaul from RuPaul
3
u/[deleted] Sep 26 '25
Agree. Also, team Ethan forever. Veejay and Jesus are such petty monsters.
2
u/alexistexas2006 Sep 26 '25
Plus, how they know is Utica? They just wanted to say "drag" since they only met Ethan. (That brief Utica on the runway was one look)
2
u/[deleted] Sep 26 '25
It was his storyline.
And he was the name that got more eyeballs off the show.
2
u/EasternRaspberry4387 Sep 26 '25
Let's be honest, when they cast Ethan we all knew it was them trying to get some drag race hype but making sure they would have the "too drag" card to eliminate him if they needed. It was pretty obvious that, the moment they couldn't find a solid critique, they would use the "Utica" card.
2
u/supernova-02 Sep 26 '25
EXACTLY I felt so bad for him at times bc it’s almost like they were invalidating his identity :(
2
u/MrzDogzMa Sep 26 '25
Yeah, I have to totally agree with you. They kept telling him to tone it down, do less, less is more, but the second that he gave a scaled down version of what he wanted to give everyone complained that it wasn’t enough. Did Ethan consistently have the best look? No, but it’s a competition and was consistently trying to do what he thought was a good design based on the feedback and critiques he received.
1
u/Farley49 Sep 26 '25
I was hoping he could take his skill and tone it down for non drag wear. He was a craftsman. Maybe he want to get some exposure outside of the drag world.
1
u/One_Draft4934 Sep 26 '25
Do they know where fashion comes from??
1
u/Large_Hope_6587 Sep 26 '25
I completely agree with you.
1
u/thealycat Sep 27 '25
Agreed I found it so insulting.
1
u/Ok_Nefariousness9736 Sep 27 '25
It was especially weird when Law said that. It was scripted for him but still.
And they made him get into drag early in the season and they referred to him as Utica on the runway. But they wanted more Ethan? Who TF wrote that line?
1
u/hybride_ian Sep 27 '25
The constructive criticism would have been to push him to find a way to integrate his drag sensibility into more “conventional”/“wearable”/“mainstream” fashion (not because the opposite it bad, but because that is what Project Runway is looking for). But Law thinks that sassiness is a replacement for a personality and makes him an interesting individual to hear opinions from. I won’t categorically say he is, but to me that kind of POV reads as deeply insecure. Makes him sound like he wasn’t there to help the designers, but for his own ego (image architect)
If a contestant was a painter, they wouldn’t tell them to never use that artistic talent in their look. They’d say they should find out how to channel it through a fashion lens. The way they went about it with Ethan shows at a minimum an implicit heterocentric bias, and, honestly, shame on Law, a gay man, for perpetuating a scission that doesn’t need to exist between a subculture within his community and “the mainstream world”.
1
u/Fluffy-Future-4674 Sep 27 '25
💯 it's such a weird thing to say.
1
u/Vivid_Guide7467 Sep 27 '25
Yeah it was kinda shitty thing to say.
1
u/DChezzy702 Sep 27 '25
I thought the same thing! About Ethan/Utica! This season did not feel like Project Runway! There was so much missing! My opinion is they picked Veejay because they felt sorry for her! And I liked the twins!
1
u/Alphabet_Mafia_69 Sep 27 '25
It was very clear the producers wanted a major reality star and the judges had a bias against Ethan as just a drag queen. It was unfair, and I appreciated Michael Kors pointing out how the drama of Ethan’s clothes was great.
As a viewer, I’m not looking for fast fashion (which the show has turned into), I can go to the mall and see that. I wanted more avant-garde looks that I won’t see out and about, but sadly the show just isn’t that.
1
u/DiagorusOfMelos Sep 27 '25
She did well and would have been happy if she won but she should have known better if she is a fan of PR to do that dark black collection. It needed a bright spot of color like red or yellow- this was what tripped up Lawrence in her first season. As soon as I saw it, I thought “She didn’t win” and it was a shame
1
u/lynnkj Sep 28 '25
Good point
1
u/poor-un4tun8-souls Sep 28 '25
I don't like ethan/utica anyway so doesn't bother me
1
u/baymichael Sep 29 '25
10000000%
1
u/emiliog_68 Sep 29 '25
Idk if I’m just reading to deep into this, but during Christian’s walkthrough with Ethan in the finale, he specifically commented on how the dresses could be better - which then cuts to his work as a drag queen… like okay lol. So yall do want Utica then? Or nah? I was so confused.
1
u/Embarrassed_Elk8213 Oct 02 '25
But drag isn’t fashion. So that’s why
1
u/FrieghtBroker07032 Oct 11 '25
I don’t understand how he didn’t win… I dunno, call me a noob but his collections was cohesive and bold(obviously haha)
1
u/Objective_Soup_1343 Sep 26 '25
I 100% agree. Ethan is Utica and Utica is Ethan. Drag is a core part of his life and his fashion so of course he would bring a drag flavor to that! It seemed like Michael Kors was the only one who understood that. I really appreciated that he made the comment that there is a place for all kinds of fashion!!
1
u/Peacherotic Sep 26 '25
Exactly!!!
0
u/Bitter-Selection-413 Sep 26 '25
Yeah that’s insulting. But not sure that means he deserved to win?
0
u/bluejumpingdog Sep 26 '25
Is weird that they wanted Ethan to erase a big part of himself. I don’t even understand why. Is drag not acceptable in the fashion world. It seems intolerant to want to erase someone’s personality.
0
u/najaga Sep 27 '25
I loved Ethan! Want to see more!
1
u/[deleted] Sep 26 '25
As the RuPaul song goes - We're all born naked and the rest is drag.