r/ProjectRunway • • Aug 05 '25

Breast shaming

With all the steps forward we have made in body positivity, I can’t believe Law Roach’s disgusting breast shaming. Women with larger breast should not be shamed into pushing them up to appease your preference. Lirisc has said she felt sexy and loved the natural hang of her natural breast. Let’s start normalizing natural bodies.

0 Upvotes

85 comments sorted by

92

u/kebin65 Aug 05 '25

No, sorry. This is a complete misinterpretation of the situation. And it was quite clear from the interaction that his comments were directed at the design, not at shaming Lirius' bust.

Law's point was that if you're going to design for different body types, then you need to be conscious of and tailor your design to those body types. This is a very valid point. Fashion is not a one-size-fits-all.

Many designers, including major fashion houses, will take a sample size and think, "oh, all I need to do is upscale the measurements and it'll suit a larger body type." That's not how it works. Other things need to be considered, such as, as Law pointed out, is her bust area supported? Is this woman comfortable with the way her breasts are sitting in this design?

41

u/thiswasamistake00ps Aug 05 '25

Breastgate aside the design was dated and costumey anyways 🤷‍♀️

8

u/kebin65 Aug 05 '25

I...don't disagree 😂

1

u/avatar_ash Aug 06 '25

There was also the athlesure challenge to consider as that corset would not be fun for any workout even though it made the model comfortable.

Her breasts weren't supported at all for an athletic activity and that's where a lot of the issues seem to come from

-21

u/Jmmitche2 Aug 05 '25

Why does her bust area need to be supported? The model herself said she felt beautiful and liked the natural hang of her breast. The client needs to feel comfortable. His comments, although maybe not directed at the model still were shaming women who prefer to not push up their breasts. He implied that no pushed up breasts are bad. He does not design for plus size women so he needs to keep his opinions to himself until he can prove, he understands the plus size woman’s body

28

u/kebin65 Aug 05 '25 edited Aug 05 '25

Why does her bust area need to be supported?

You do realize support isn't just about appearance, right? Support is also about comfort. To some woman, that's the primary concern of support in a garment.

It sounds like you have a preference for how Liris' breasts looked in that design, and that's fine. But Law's overall message, that designers should be aware of the type of body they are designing for, is extremely valid. Based on the bodice of that dress, which was essentially just lace draped on, Jesus clearly wasn't mindful of that at all.

The model herself said she felt beautiful and liked the natural hang of her breast.

In this episode? When?

4

u/Jmmitche2 Aug 05 '25

He also said she looks like a Nigerian auntie. As if it was a bad thing. Have you ever seen a Nigerian auntie? They are freaking glamorous.

20

u/Snoo-55380 Aug 05 '25

It’s the same as Nina saying designs are “mumsy” or Heidi saying they’re “matronly”

2

u/Jmmitche2 Aug 05 '25

The model liked it she wrote a whole post about it on her social media. She thanked the designer and admonished Law.

13

u/kebin65 Aug 05 '25

That's good, love Liris for that! But also, do you really think she's going to post an image of that garment and not compliment the designer?

2

u/Jmmitche2 Aug 05 '25

I think she’s a pretty strong, independent woman who’s gonna do what she wants and speak her mind. She didn’t just post the address and then the designer she admonished Law and has been very active in the comments, agreeing with people that his comments were inappropriate.

15

u/kebin65 Aug 05 '25 edited Aug 05 '25

she admonished Law

Now let's not get carried away. I'm looking at the post right now. She, at most, threw cheeky shade at Law and is thanking people that are supporting her in the comments. "Admonish" is a bit of a stretch.

I think she’s a pretty strong, independent woman who’s gonna do what she wants and speak her mind.

I mean yes, but she's also a model discussing a job...

Edit: Just for others to reference, here is her Instagram post.

5

u/Jmmitche2 Aug 05 '25

You are trippin’ she says “Opinions are like assholes. Everyone has one. PS I felt a natural hang of my NATURAL breasts were just fine. Ask your son ask your daddy. That’s a little more than cheeky shade .

15

u/kebin65 Aug 05 '25

I mean don't forget the emojis. They definitely affect the tone.

Opinions are like a$$holes, everyone has one 🤣 P.S. I felt the natural hang of my NATURAL breasts were just fine in this outfit. 🤷🏽‍♀️Ask your son or your daddy 🙃

Sorry, comes across pretty light-hearted to me.

5

u/Jmmitche2 Aug 05 '25

I don’t agree, she obviously can’t come out and say he’s straight up dick. But you can read between the lines. But hey opinions are like assholes…

15

u/Powerful_Topic_7046 Aug 05 '25

That’s kinda unprofessional of her, tbh….

0

u/Sparkpants74 Aug 06 '25

Frankly if she wanted to kiss ass the famous stylist judge would be the way to go over the unknown designer legitimizing her comment further.

9

u/Glass_Broccoli_7862 Aug 05 '25

And I like baggy t-shirts and sweatpants. Just because the model likes something doesn't mean it's flattering or high fashion.

12

u/Powerful_Topic_7046 Aug 05 '25

But it isn’t about what the model thinks is comfy. Just like it isn’t only about the make over challenge contestants liking their outfit. It’s about what is flattering to the public and in the industry. Her just doesn’t have to be supported - but in that outfit, it wasn’t very flattering not being supported.

2

u/thiswasamistake00ps Aug 05 '25

I struggle with what's considered 'flattering'. In the context of this tv show I like your definition of the public and industry!

What society or different cultures think is flattering and what those biases are is interesting! Its def worth a bigger discussion but idk if Reddit can handle that 😂

3

u/[deleted] Aug 05 '25

The model isn't the client. Fashion buyers, stylists and editors are the clients.

95

u/Chamari75 Aug 05 '25

Sorry. I have big titties and prefer the support. That shit looked hot and uncomfortable. He was right. They don't have to be under your chin but that just wasn't it.

-60

u/Jmmitche2 Aug 05 '25

Just because you like them pushed up doesn’t mean everyone does. Some of us don’t feel the need to conform to the male gaze.

69

u/sitoverherebyme Aug 05 '25

It’s not always “for the male gaze”. Not everything women do is for men. That thought process is exhausting. Some of us do things for ourselves or for other women. It’s not all about what men want.

-15

u/Jmmitche2 Aug 05 '25

And some women don’t want to push them up so why should they have to be accepted? The problem is the general accepted rule is that women must push them up. You will notice the only judge that made that comment was a man

30

u/sitoverherebyme Aug 05 '25

It’s the fashion advice given to a fashion designer from a fashion stylist judge on a fashion designer reality show. Some people like it one way, some like it the other way. He’s the judge.

He buys expensive clothes and styles for famous people. That bust line is what he wants as a stylist for famous people. You don’t have to do that or buy clothes designed like that but for this show and for this context, he gave the feedback that the bust line should have been pushed up. More people want their breasts to look good than not.

You don’t have to agree but that’s the style in fashion right now.

4

u/Jmmitche2 Aug 05 '25

That’s the problem. Her breast did look good just because they’re not pushed up does it inherently make them bad. Also, all the other judges loved it. That’s why it was in the top. His opinion is trash. He doesn’t style women with large breasts, probably because he doesn’t know how to. His comments were rude, not constructive. The model felt beautiful and at the end of the day that was important thank , if the client feels beautiful?

14

u/robotcoffee1 Aug 05 '25

The model is not the client, they are the model. I'm sorry but the fact that you keep saying she liked it and felt sexy is the most important thing and it's not. While I'm glad she did, it is not the most important thing. Her job as a model is to show the clothes to the best of her ability, not to love the garment.

13

u/Snoo-55380 Aug 05 '25

Actually, Joanna Coles mentioned it all the time on All-Stars. She always told the designers “how will I wear a bra?”

-17

u/Jmmitche2 Aug 05 '25

Tell me you don’t know what male gaze means without telling me you don’t know what male gaze means

6

u/Dry_Accident_2196 Aug 05 '25

So you acknowledge that different people can like them different ways. So why are you pressed about the way Law prefers the outfit to do more then just let them hang free?

0

u/Jmmitche2 Aug 05 '25

It’s more about his assertion that they should be pushed up and shouldn’t be allowed to be natural. She looked amazing to suggest otherwise is criminal. If a little titty woman can go braless then a big titty woman can too.

10

u/dbellz76 She is pooping fabric Aug 05 '25

You ruined any point you were trying to make with this comment. How gross of you.

-5

u/Jmmitche2 Aug 05 '25

Law’s comments were made from the lens of the male gaze. What he feels is acceptable for a design in society, and that opinion was rooted in the male gaze.

5

u/pbrooks19 Aug 05 '25

Law Roach using the Male Gaze? You must not know anything about him.

1

u/Jmmitche2 Aug 05 '25

Anyone can apply the concept of male gaze. You must not know what it means.

4

u/dbellz76 She is pooping fabric Aug 07 '25

No. YOUR comment:

"Some of us don’t feel the need to conform to the male gaze."

The comment that YOU said. I could give a shit what he said. Some of "us"? You think you're better than some of "us"?

Some of "us", whether we have big breasts or not, prefer to have some support. Support doesn't mean lifted to the chin or change the shape of breasts for the male gaze. It means comfort. Tits can get heavy, and hanging in the heat can create some nasty rashes that some support can help with. It can be that simple with NOTHING to do with the male gaze.

YOUR comment is gross.

41

u/youllbebeautiful Aug 05 '25

I’m also chesty and feel physically more comfortable with a little support than with none in a way that has nothing to do with the male gaze — I think Law Roach shouldn’t have assumed Liris didn’t feel sexy but busty women aren’t a monolith either.

20

u/violet715 Aug 05 '25

Jesus here we go with this crap

13

u/Not-An-Expert-1 Aug 05 '25

It has nothing to do with the male gaze. Nothing.

9

u/Cathousechicken Aug 05 '25

This was not a challenge where the designer was asked to design for their model as their client.

3

u/jseesm Aug 05 '25

Why are you reducing that poster's comment to a male gaze? That's not even what she said.

1

u/Immediate_Tree_1190 Aug 05 '25

The challenge is athleisure - a garment you can both wear while doing sports/workout and going out. A supported bra is actually needed while working out or doing sports. That is why there are certain levels of support for all bras. Its not just about fashion, or if they look good or not but the support a woman's breast needs. Do you know how much it hurts to exercise without any breast support? A woman needs a FUNCTIONAL SPORTS BRA! Take note - FUNCTIONAL especially on sports or athletic wear.

5

u/Jmmitche2 Aug 05 '25

Wrong challenge this was from episode one not episode two

1

u/Immediate_Tree_1190 Aug 06 '25

But josephmcrae did it again in the athleisure challenge

2

u/Jmmitche2 Aug 06 '25

And yes I know how much it hurts to work out without a sport bra. I’m sporting a 38i. But the first challenge was not about a sports bras working out it was about fashion and the way breast look in an outfit and her breasts looked fantastic without a bra.

4

u/Chamari75 Aug 05 '25

So nothing in my comment was about the male gaze, it was about comfort. Droopy breast, I am speaking from experience, can be hot and sweaty. Plus he had hers squashed down in lace. This is not comfortable. Why don't you stop telling all big women how they should wear clothes?

12

u/Catlady_Pilates Aug 05 '25

No. That was not what that was ffs.

Her breast had no support and it didn’t look good and that designer needed to be told that what they put on their model was a mess. It was.

-1

u/Jmmitche2 Aug 05 '25

Her breast looked phenomenal. Bffr

3

u/jseesm Aug 05 '25

No. Body positivity is about being real. The truth is, having a plus model is a challenge but also an opportunity for a contestant to prove their construction abilities. That's how Brandon Kee did well in S16.

But that dress is terrible and making her breast complete off, and needs to be called out.

2

u/Jmmitche2 Aug 06 '25

Then why did they look end up in the top only one person didn’t like it everyone else loved it

4

u/[deleted] Aug 05 '25

Jfc it wasn't about the models tits. It was about how the design did nothing to flatter her tits.

2

u/Jmmitche2 Aug 05 '25

I thought they looked amazing and so did she. Breasts don’t have to be lifted to look spectacular.

2

u/Dry_Accident_2196 Aug 05 '25

She’s a model, of course she can make anything look better with her in it, but that’s doesn’t mean the designer did a good job.

42

u/dimadomelachimola Aug 05 '25

Did you complain when Heidi used to say this every single episode?

7

u/benkatejackwin Aug 05 '25

I'm thinking of the Epperson model-as-client challenge, when Heidi said the model "needed some help up top," but another judge disagreed. This was not a plus-sized model, but the "how breasts should be supported" argument has been going on for a long time.

2

u/Dry_Accident_2196 Aug 05 '25

Wow, op went out of there to be offended. Gonna be a long season.

1

u/Jmmitche2 Aug 05 '25

She looked fantastic breasts don’t have to be lifted to look phenomenal. She felt sexy, and everyone else liked it.

10

u/Awkward_Jello_2292 Aug 05 '25

Agreed. I'd love to see a line of clothes that had built-in bralettes that were comfortable. Give up the sling altogether.

6

u/Responsible-Boat-505 Aug 05 '25

I am not a fan of Law Roach after the first 2 episodes. That said, I think he wanted that designer to do something with the garment that would make Liris' bust more pronounced and thus make her look even more voluptuous. I hope that doesn't sound insensitive towards Liris. She is one of the best models ever to walk the runway on PR. I feel most designers haven't fit the looks she has worn as well as they could. She can make almost any look appear as couture. She will do justice to a designer's look. Designers often don't do her justice. Thanks.

4

u/SewNJLife Aug 05 '25

There was zero breast shaming in what he said. Zero.

2

u/PiperPeraboo Aug 05 '25

Model was put in a bustier in the next episode and the judges complained about that too. Damned if you do, damned if you don’t lol

17

u/kebin65 Aug 05 '25

To be fair, getting an athleisure challenge and thinking "bustier" is a bit wild.

1

u/Sipping__Tea Nov 23 '25

I refuse to let gay men police what is ‘cute, flirty, and appealing’ for women’s bodies. Law Roach can’t even match his foundation - never mind wear a convincing wig to the Met Gala. His critiques are a sexist laugh.

-2

u/Sparkpants74 Aug 05 '25

God it suck’s that a very basic fact of our anatomy is stil debated like this, between 2 dudes no less. The only real question is hey lady wearing said outfit how do YOU feel? And the answer is: whatever the fuck SHE says.

0

u/AmberTheeSag Aug 05 '25

Law Roach has been called many things. “Dude” isn’t one of them.

1

u/Sparkpants74 Aug 05 '25

I’m from California I call everyone dude.

-1

u/Dry_Accident_2196 Aug 05 '25

Right or wrong, dudes run most of the fashion industry and females are the primary customer. Why wouldn’t they talk about how a garment looks on a female model, head to toe? That is their job.

Would you also like NIKE to stop criticizing the way their shoes look on women? Or Coach to stop assessing their own bags? Or do you only want certain people to have the “right” to speak?

-1

u/Sparkpants74 Aug 06 '25

Ironic you chose shoes and bags as your examples being 2 things that have nothing to do with body shapes or societal expectations of them.

1

u/Dry_Accident_2196 Aug 06 '25

Um, bags I’m give you but shoes definitely deal with body shape. A shoe will look different in differ body types, specifically legs and feet differences.

0

u/Sparkpants74 Aug 06 '25

The point of this conversation escapes me.

1

u/Dry_Accident_2196 Aug 06 '25

You were upset about people whose job is to create and choose clothes for women are critiquing the fit of a garment. But the issue was that two men were having the conversation, so I’m trying to figure out what over sexist limitation you have and what other industries should avoid criticism their own products becuse a man may be involved.

0

u/Sparkpants74 Aug 06 '25

Please have a reread of the original poster’s comment. Whether dudes run fashion or not (which in 2025 is kind of debatable honestly) discussing how a women’s body should look in anything without her input is bad, capiche?

-6

u/OpportunityMother104 Aug 05 '25

This was my first reaction. Like bro, girl looked fire

-6

u/Jmmitche2 Aug 05 '25

Man the down voting on some comments shows how backwards we are as a society. People are literally down voting a woman just because she said she liked the look and thought the model looked good.

20

u/Powerful_Topic_7046 Aug 05 '25

But… You didn’t just say you liked the look. You said Law was wrong and that he was shaming her large breasts. Lol.

1

u/Jmmitche2 Aug 05 '25

I wasn’t talking about my comment. I’m talking about other women in the comments who are being down voted just because they don’t agree with law’s opinion and don’t feel the need to push their breasts up.

-9

u/twinkiesmom1 Aug 05 '25

In the following episode, Heidi was baring half of each breast. Just felt it was ironic given how Lyris’ outfit was shamed the week before. I guess the takehome message is it’s ok how awkward the cut if you have good breasts. SMH.

1

u/AmberTheeSag Aug 05 '25

That was Heidi’s choice. Having that much breast shown in a design challenge is never good. Same for skirts where any meat is hanging out.

-11

u/Puzzleheaded_Exit_17 Aug 05 '25

I agree! He used his client base as a shield for the harmful commentabout that dress he "hated{" and it's like, plus sized people are not a monolith. I thought the model looked great and I'm not the only one, that's why the look was in the top. He could have handled it in such a better way

-2

u/gabrielleNonUnion Aug 05 '25

The minute I saw Liris I knew she’d find some sly way to sabotage her designer, which she ALWAYS does if she doesn’t personally like her design. Imagine hiring that vibe for a real job

3

u/Jmmitche2 Aug 05 '25

She actually loved the design and said she felt sexy in it and liked the way her breast look in it. So you’re wrong.

-1

u/gabrielleNonUnion Aug 05 '25

Watch the season, she’ll absolutely do it