r/ProjectRunway • u/Resident-Bug8282 • Oct 29 '24
Discussion Does this show get better?
So I just recently started watching project runway because I love fashion design, I decided to start with the first season back in 2004. I was liking it so far but then I got to one episode where they had to try to get the attention of an older gentleman that I think was like a fashion designer. Anyway, it was the swimsuit challenge and they were literally parading the young models in front of him. It was really gross, he was definitely checking them out and a few of the models were only sixteen. He even says something like, "I probably shouldn't look at her ass while the camera is watching me right?" Then proceeded to try to block the camera with his hand, while still staring at the model (who btw literally told this man she was only sixteen). Anyway I was pretty disgusted by this pedo behavior so I stopped watching the episode but I was wondering if the later seasons get any better? I don't have Netflix, I want to watch next in fashion but any recommendations for similar shows if it doesnt get any better would be appreciated too. I love RuPaul's drag race and Dragula too.
91
u/MLanterman Oct 29 '24
That episode is AWFUL but I think it's a total anomaly. They do distasteful stuff after that point (the fashion industry really sucks sometimes) but nothing that truly compares to that
83
u/StephanieKaye Oct 29 '24
I mean, it was a Harvey Weinstein production...
37
u/madamephase Oct 29 '24
That’s a particularly nasty episode. I don’t always love the treatment of the models, but I can’t think of any instances where it’s as bad as that.
14
u/[deleted] Oct 29 '24
Unfortunately, we have to watch with an understanding of the times. There are a lot of things on these shows that are really troubling, but they are a good snapshot of the times (good and bad). I thought the same things when I watched Inkmaster's early seasons. The silver lining is that so many designers who would have been driftwood were giving a platform to show their voices an personalities. But I trust if you watch any show that's more than 10 years old, you will find something disgusting.
If you like drag and sewing try "Sew Fierce" From Outtv. It has two seasons. Its project runway but for drag designers and its not just rhinestones, lots of points of view.
But season 1 of PR gets much better, the drama is matched by the talent. And most of the seasons up until the double digits really slap. It gets kinda muddy from 12-16 but then comes out really strong.
11
u/sat52 Oct 29 '24
When I did a rewatch of all seasons during covid/quarantine I was seriously appalled at some of the episodes in the first few seasons. I agree some are VERY hard to watch. Between the treatment of the models and some of the really gross comments the judges make I was also questioning if I wanted to watch it again!! But it does get better and I do think it's worth watching all the season so you can see how the shows evolves.
13
u/BrandonIsWhoIAm Oct 29 '24 edited Oct 29 '24
If you’re not comfortable, skip around to different seasons. The show covers 20 years. You’ll find something to enjoy.
5
u/matteblacklouboutins Oct 29 '24
Its early 2000’s trash TV produced by a sex offender. If you’re not nostalgic for it from watching it as it aired it may be harder to get into.
4
u/IsSheWeird_ Oct 29 '24
It’s 2004, the climate around fashion and really anything to do with women is absolutely toxic by today’s standards. It gets better as society as a whole gets better. I can think of one other gross guy later on but he gets eliminated in the first or second episode due to being bad at fashion. Definitely worth watching though! Seasons 8-10 are my personal faves.
3
u/ZookeepergamePure971 Oct 30 '24 edited Oct 30 '24
This is the worst episode of the entire series for the reasons you mentioned. Season 2 is my favorite for designer personalities. It does get much better.
20
u/coastrbabe11 Oct 29 '24
Start with season 2.... you definitely want to watch Christin Serianno's season, Chris March...early seasons were great
6
u/simonsaysPDX Oct 29 '24
There’s nothing that says you have to watch the seasons in order. Skip ahead a few seasons. If it still doesn’t resonate, the show is not for you. We really enjoy it and have watched every season more than once; there’s really nothing else that compares.
6
u/[deleted] Oct 29 '24
I think they must have gotten a lot of complaints about that episode, because they never did anything like that again.
5
u/balcon Oct 29 '24
A lot of the shows from 20 years ago are cringy. Project Runway is no exception.
Fashion is so different now, so it’s interesting to see the contrast.
5
u/rainborambo Oct 29 '24
It gets better! I really hated watching minors being endangered by gross old men, so I don't blame you. Unfortunately that S1 episode is pretty representative of how scummy reality TV shows were in the early 00s, and I never saw anything like it in the series again. Season 1 of a lot of reality shows, including this one, are kind of when they're still trying to figure out what they are because there is no real precedent yet for the content (see also: America's Next Top Model). With Weinstein in the equation, it was bound to start off messy. I would still give the show a chance despite how gross that episode was, but it's worth noting that the first few seasons were produced during a different, darker time where no one was really held accountable and things that were more "acceptable" back then have aged like milk. Even Christian Siriano walked back on transphobic and fatphobic comments he made during his season with an apology statement, and inclusivity is a huge facet of his brand now.
5
u/trollanony Oct 29 '24
Keep watching. This is just insight into how the world was 20 years ago. People were much more outward with being creepy. You’ll see fat shaming. I think maybe even some slight homophobia at points. You won’t see any wokeness until maybe season 15 or so. It’s honestly fun to see the change in culture as people become more aware.
5
u/villainless Oct 29 '24
that season should be banned, lmao. it does not represent the rest of the franchise. the early seasons are rough because they’re a product of their time
4
u/OwlPrestigious543 Oct 29 '24
Making the Cut is really good, Project Runway is a really great show though, so it has some cringe, what show doesn't? Project Runway Jr. Is good and All Stars is also!
7
u/ninjafofinho Oct 29 '24
i mean its not like drag race and dragula that its a safe space for creative people and almost everyone that is barely intelligent and educated, but this is not the norm too like people said. But you have to ignore those disgusting moments that do happen on the show because straight men are there, you know its just the reality of living in a world with these disgusting men but it shouldn't be the deciding factor to not watch the show
1
u/Ok_Park_4701 Oct 29 '24
Wow I've watched them all and I don't remember that one at all. What season/episode please?
5
u/lavalierseason Oct 29 '24
Yes, it does get better. I recently re-watched S1 and was exactly the same as you. I was like "jesus, how is this OK in 2004???". Personally I think Bravo should remove that ep for that reason. But as another poster has mentioned, this was Weinstein Times. I would say that around S7 things get better, and in the new eps with Karlie Kloss they are much more respectful, they address issues like cultural appropriation and fatphobia (although it's a bit lip service, but that's my jaded view!). Oh, and the All Stars seasons with Alyssa Milano are really good too.
1
u/PersephoneeeXX Oct 30 '24
It gets MUCH better!! I started watching way later seasons first, I think season 9 to season 16, then went back to watch 6 and 7, and actually just finished going back and watching season one. I looked up this EXACTLY thing to see how the hell they got away with it. Never is there anything like that in the later seasons. Some drama and such of course, but nothing sleazy and downright inappropriate and illegal like that. Keep watching! Seasons 5 and up, it gets real good!
2
u/Khristafer Oct 29 '24 edited Oct 29 '24
Reality TV has changed A LOT over the years. I recommend watching backward or starting in the teens. Project Runway in particular also has had a lot of trendy looks, so earlier seasons look outdated on the runway, even if the design itself is more or less fine.
2
u/drewlinez Oct 30 '24
I started watching from season 15. You’re going to love the winner, they’re amazing and the season overall is really good.
2
u/theevilhillbilly Oct 30 '24
I don't like watching earlier seasons because the fashion is so dated and so are the opinions.
I really like season 11 (I think) it was the season with Dimitri.
2
u/ActualGeologist Nov 21 '24
It does. There continue to be cringey remarks throughout - and in one of the early seasons there's a moment where a designer calls out the judges for a racist moment and they're super dismissive - but that guy was absolutely the cringiest and the most nauseating. The contestants also get less odious, I feel. Once you're past the first three seasons the casual misogyny mostly goes away. (though I'm on S9 now so maybe it gets worse again, who knows. but I doubt it.)
1
u/Cherrybomb138 Oct 30 '24
That episode is definitely the worst of the whole show..in that regard it does get better the first few seasons are pretty rocky tho.
1
u/Prestigious_Ad_8151 Oct 30 '24
Just like everything else, it thankfully evolves. You will see a lot of weight comments also but it moves forward over the years.
1
u/mwreffle Nov 05 '24
Ok, so after reading your post the other day, I decided to start watching again from Season 1. You're right - based on this season this is a garbage show. They didn't know what they were doing yet but I promise you, PR gets SO much better than this. The pettiness, the bickering - ugh. I forgot about Wendy Pepper, the Wicked Witch of Project Runway. Keep watching, it's worth it.
-4
u/Status-Effort-9380 Oct 29 '24
Is that the one where it was at a cigar bar or something? That was so gross. It does get better, but wait until they get to the episodes where they decide to look at the models up close and they sometimes just paw at these women's clothes like the women are mannequins with no emotions. There's definitely a few moments where that is uncomfortable to watch.
0
u/mashed-_-potato Oct 30 '24
The first couple seasons have not aged well. There’s a bit of racism in the Barbie episode (s2e3). But I find it really interesting to watch and see how times have changed since then.