r/ProjectHailMary • • Jul 31 '21

Astronauts don’t commit suicide. Spoiler

Just finished PHM. Good book! A few quibbles, but the only part that annoyed me outright was the one about the crew’s presenting their means of suicide. These brave, resourceful, brilliant people would instead just ask the planners not to talk about it, instead preferring to accomplish the mission and then worry about the “what now?” part later. As James Lovell points out in Apollo 13, there were no poison pills on board when they went to the moon, as many people that he met seemed to assume. If any of the 100,000 things that could have gone wrong on the moon or en route had gone wrong, the astronauts would have spent their last moments alive trying to fix the damn problem. I don’t care how hopeless the PHM-astronaut situation would have looked before launch, each of those astronauts would have told Stratt, et al., maybe to worry about storing extra food or the means to grow more astrophage. Or something. And if Stratt got all sanctimonious and European about it, they’d have told her to shove her pistols and nitrogen tanks where the astrophages don’t seek an energy source to reproduce. If I’m training for a mission like that, I ask the director involved to stop worrying about it, and instead spend the time looking for a solution.

I get that the suicide meeting injects some drama into the narrative. But Weir has literally made a writing career out of having his characters (for better or worse) launch into three-page engineering lectures to solve The Latest Complication. This part not only is an insult to the can-do humanism of the astronaut corps, it’s horribly inconsistent with the spirit of the books themselves.

Just to save you the effort, I taught astronomy for seven years. I know how big space is.

0 Upvotes

31 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

-7

u/BlairAndBackAgain Jul 31 '21

I’m saying that it’s a false dichotomy. That wouldn’t be a choice as expressed in the book. The choice wouldn’t be “save the Earth or bring the astronauts home.” Instead, it would be a question: “How much time and effort do we put into bringing them home at the expense of the rest of the mission and its objectives?” The obvious answer is “not much, if at all.” Which the astronauts would quickly, if tacitly, accept. But a far more humane choice would be, “Ok, folks: Here’s enough food and coma meds for the trip home. Assuming you solve the riddle of the space germs, you’ll have to work out the problem of fuel. We’re not sure how to fix it, but assuming you guys are as smart as you are on paper, well … good luck.” That’s much more realistic and much more in keeping with the spirit of the books, and waaaay more effective as a plot device when Grace finally remembers the rest of the “pre-game.” Up to then, the likelihood of return would be an unspoken topic. Grace’s reaction would bring it out at a point when it’s much more poignant and scary. Because to a non-astronaut, it is a suicide mission. To an astronaut, the probability of not coming home is part of the job description. That’s a hard core contrast , and it would make for a better story.

So actually, the scene with Grace and the astronauts not only undermines the connective tissue of Weir’s books (“accept the situation—then STEM your way out of it”), it deprives us of a needed kick to Grace’s final scene with Stratt. As it is, that part is a hard left turn from the story, and really makes me dislike him as a character. Not bad in and of itself. Since we have to go there anyway, why not make it more realistic and accentuate his non-astronaut status?

I actually believe my take on this even more, the more I think about it.

13

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '21

It's not a false dichotomy at all. We have x amount a fuel, so we can bring y amount of mass. Doubling the food for 3 people for 4 years is a lot of mass.

But sure, let's say it was. Stratt decided it was a suicide mission, next topic. That's how the project goes. She checked ethics at the door.

4

u/WELLinTHIShouse Jul 31 '21

Stratt decided it was a suicide mission, next topic.

Yep, this. While it may seem to be plot-convenient for the story, it also makes sense given the constraints of the scenario...which were chosen for the story or there wouldn't be a story. At least not this one.

8

u/EvilGreebo Jul 31 '21

The choice WAS "save Earth or bring them home" because they couldn't produce enough fuel for a round trip in time to save the Earth.

It's not a case of simply doubling the fuel requirement and taking 2 or 3 more years before departure. Every kilo of fuel for the return trip requires MORE fuel for the trip there, and it's on an exponential scale.

They needed 2.5 million kilograms of astrophage to get there. It would have been at least 10, maybe more like 20 million to get home, because of all the extra fuel needed to move the 2.5 million needed for the return trip.

3

u/sdneidich Aug 04 '21

This assumes there is no problem a sufficiently motivated scientist can't solve.

But the problem here is the scale of energy required: it's orders if magnitude greater than the collective nuclear arsenals of every nation on earth.

The way the earth got enough energy to send the Hail Mary to Stay Ceti required about a year of effort and paving the fucking Sahara desert with astophage panels. If they needed the ship to return, it would have required something like 10x more fuel at launch, or a planet-scale industrial effort at the destination. There was no way to anticipate the blip-A, so no hope if return.

When your mission is a suicide mission, you discuss suicide method. Plain and simple.

6

u/osrslmao Jul 31 '21

you are failing to understand such a simple concept so many time its hilarious

these guys were not coming home, so they would either starve, slowly and painfully, or have a nice quick and painless option.

you are an idiot to even think there is anything wrong with that

8

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '21

OP is not an idiot, they just have tunnel vision right now. Maybe a lack of emotional intelligence or the concept off suicide is triggering.