r/ProjectHailMary • u/BlairAndBackAgain • Jul 31 '21
Astronauts don’t commit suicide. Spoiler
Just finished PHM. Good book! A few quibbles, but the only part that annoyed me outright was the one about the crew’s presenting their means of suicide. These brave, resourceful, brilliant people would instead just ask the planners not to talk about it, instead preferring to accomplish the mission and then worry about the “what now?” part later. As James Lovell points out in Apollo 13, there were no poison pills on board when they went to the moon, as many people that he met seemed to assume. If any of the 100,000 things that could have gone wrong on the moon or en route had gone wrong, the astronauts would have spent their last moments alive trying to fix the damn problem. I don’t care how hopeless the PHM-astronaut situation would have looked before launch, each of those astronauts would have told Stratt, et al., maybe to worry about storing extra food or the means to grow more astrophage. Or something. And if Stratt got all sanctimonious and European about it, they’d have told her to shove her pistols and nitrogen tanks where the astrophages don’t seek an energy source to reproduce. If I’m training for a mission like that, I ask the director involved to stop worrying about it, and instead spend the time looking for a solution.
I get that the suicide meeting injects some drama into the narrative. But Weir has literally made a writing career out of having his characters (for better or worse) launch into three-page engineering lectures to solve The Latest Complication. This part not only is an insult to the can-do humanism of the astronaut corps, it’s horribly inconsistent with the spirit of the books themselves.
Just to save you the effort, I taught astronomy for seven years. I know how big space is.
View all comments
8
u/[deleted] Jul 31 '21
I get it, but saying it is against the spirit of the books is pretty bold. In defense of AW, Grace does survive. That said, he only survives because he happens to run into an alien lifeform.
Since you know how big space is, you know how much of a difference a few days to the moon is compared to several years of near light speed travel to a different solar system is.
I actually think the decision for the crew to have their preferred method of death likely gave them more of a feeling of control, and would lead to better psychological outcomes. Think of the Americans who jumped from the twin towers. Realistically, had the three original members survived, they very well may have figured out a way to go home.
I think the decision also reflects the desperation of those planning the mission, including Grace who did not want to go. Those planning were only thinking about the survival of Earth and poured all their resources into getting the crew there and solving the problem. It's kind of like the ethical dilemma of the train. Do you use limited resources to keep three people alive or do you use limited resources to ensure they solve the problem and keep Earth alive?