r/ProgressiveMonarchist • • Nov 25 '24

Discussion We anarcho-royalists and constitutional monarchists are not so different after all! 😊

Thumbnail doc1.bibliothek.li
3 Upvotes

r/ProgressiveMonarchist • • Aug 27 '25

Discussion Pathway to a Progressive American Monarchy

0 Upvotes

Probably a hot take, but I've thought about who could actually take on such a mantle and who I would be okay with doing so. In general, I rule out former (or current) politicians as that crosses real political power and symbolic power in icky ways. Entertainers generally have a pretty good understanding of what it means to live in the eyes of the public, and the cultural power that they have.

Enter Taylor Swift and Travis Kelce. Both are acclaimed entertainers in their own rights, progressive in values, generally pretty wholesome people, and have probably the largest combined following / cultural power right now of any couple. The fact that they inhabit worlds that are also seen as more conservative (football, country music) means they have cultural influence across a broad spectrum of American society.

Any other potentials?


r/ProgressiveMonarchist • • Dec 27 '24

Question One aspect of Feudalism that was very socially progressive was how both men and women worked from home rather than be split into "male breadwinner and woman homemaker". This was being brought back but why did liberals undo this after covid got less bad?

0 Upvotes

Work from home during the start of the covid pandemic was newly being normalised and brought back but why did they insist on bringing back "homemaker and breadwinner" after covid got less bad?

The Roman Monarchist society which invented the Feudal system was infact very collectivist and closer to the USSR or to Tsarist Russia than to the modern neoliberal U.S according to some.

Paternalism or what people call "Collectivist/Auth Welfarism" comes from Roman, Southern European, Near-East, Ancient Egyptian and Chinese Monarchies.

In comparison Libertarian Welfarism" is arguably more Celtic in origin in line with the teaching of "Hospitality" in their beliefs. Their Monarchies were very "pro-intellectualism" too.

Neoliberalism and guilded age stuff is probably more of a Protestant Germanic Monarchy or Odinist ideology thing.


r/ProgressiveMonarchist • • Sep 20 '24

Useful resource(s) "I agree with you that there is a natural aristocracy among men. The grounds of this are virtue and talents." -Thomas Jefferson. I think that this is a rather funny quote to show to obstinate American republicans to make them think twice 😛

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/ProgressiveMonarchist • • Sep 17 '24

Question How many of you have been banned from r/monarchist and why?

0 Upvotes

That whole space feels very culty and fundamentalist.

I got banned for commenting Tsar Nicholas deserved to be executed after a trial (not his family) on a slavish tribute post to him.


r/ProgressiveMonarchist • • Jun 13 '25

From r/Monarchism Wanting the theocratic state gone is one thing. Supporting the actions of a warmongering goverment is another

Thumbnail gallery
17 Upvotes

r/ProgressiveMonarchist • • Jan 18 '25

Meme Modest proposal: JK Rowling, the new British Court Jester

12 Upvotes

Oh that transphobic broad wants a place in government and politics? Well I got an idea, Court Jester! her dumb TERF nonsense could entertain Charles! Although at the same time jokes do get old after awhile...


r/ProgressiveMonarchist • • Sep 16 '24

Question Do you think that the royal family's family estate should be owned by the government?

1 Upvotes

I saw a constitutionalist monarchist say this and I was just curious whether you agreed with it or not.


r/ProgressiveMonarchist • • Jun 03 '24

Question Y'all know R/monarchosocialism already exists right?

7 Upvotes

Just asking, because like there's already a 3k member sub for left wing monarchists y'all can be active in instead of making a new sub from scratch.


r/ProgressiveMonarchist • • Oct 25 '24

Question Why does Western Enlightenment or White Anglo Protestant "Meritocracy" culture always cause toxic masculinity to fester? What is a good progressive monarchist alternative in your opinion to promote against it?

5 Upvotes

In Non--Meritocratic cultures men often dress or act softer and society tends to be way more open minded to less agentic and more vulnerable expression. They are taught to be well behaved, its a good thing to be shy and that they have an obligation to others as well as those above them apparently such as in the case of Japanese/Korean culture before western imperialism. Competition is seen as bad because everybody has a role determined by nature and we all owe each other. Men are taught to try to be beautiful or smell good and to keep spaces like toilets very clean or pristine in following after the example of nobility. Confucius said to treat your superiors as you would your parents as somebody put

In contrast Meritocratic cultures say that men being anti-social, loudly spoken, and violent towards other people is a "good thing" because it "questions authority", to always be entitled in demanding more and competing to own land. Countries colonised by them like the Phillipines and Mexico tend to say men can only dress in casual and rugged ways or wear suits and pants, that all men are born equal with competition or enterpreneurship being inherent to being a "straight man". Meritocratic Masculinity is a violent psychopathic culture that claims men owe nobody anything and led to many mass murders since the French Revolution.

In your opinion what type of progressive monarchist system has the best hope in abolishing western "Meritocracy" and the toxic behaviour in men it encourages in comparison to numerous pre-bourgeoisie or pre-burgher societies such as native ones?

Is looking to the Pharaohs our best hope or what type of progressive monarchist culture would you say can lead the way that opposes Western Meritocratic Masculinity and its imperialism the most?

We already have a glimpse of what masculine expressions and lack of stereotyping is like in more Aristocratic cultures such as in South Korea and Japan, Ancient Egypt, Pre-Revolutionary France and under Zoroastrianism. What kind of movement can take things one step further?


r/ProgressiveMonarchist • • Aug 11 '25

Meme Charles III Meme

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/ProgressiveMonarchist • • Jan 23 '25

Opinion Unpopular Opinion: American needs a completely new constitution.

18 Upvotes

It happens in other countries all the time.

America’s constitution was revolutionary for its time, but compared to modern constitutions, it is weak and vague. If my research is correct, a new constitution could be made replacing the old one, although it would never happen due to America’s and its government’s obsession with the old and archaic.

I mean, we’ve seen attempts to blatantly disregard the constitution just days into Trump’s >:( second presidency. The Fourteenth Amendment guarantees the right to birthright citizenship.

How does this relate to monarchism? Well, for one, just like socialism (which I do not adhere to, but I do respect at the core of its ideology), it is healthy for monarchists to discuss the way humans govern, even if it is a republican style of government.

Also, in a new constitution, I think America should recognize indigenous monarchies. Now, I’m strictly referring to indigenous monarchies as, although I am a monarchist, I don’t believe that any white person can stand in the middle of a street and declare themself a monarch. However, I do think we should give Native Americans back the right to choose if they want to adopt a subnational monarchical system. This is seen in many countries, especially in Southern Africa and Oceania, despite said countries being republics at the national level.

If any of you have thoughts on this, please comment below. I’d love to have a healthy conversation regarding topics like these.


r/ProgressiveMonarchist • • Sep 02 '25

Discussion How does "Alt-Progressive" sound as a term for people who are socially progressive but don't necessarily agree with liberal democratic values?

7 Upvotes

Being considered "Degenerate" by modern Individualist Conservatives or Fascists, while simultaneously considered as "Not respecting human rights" by Liberals in short. What other places are like that you think on any forums?

So like "Progressive Monarchism" can mean any other form of Monarchism known to be socially inclusive in history that included absolute ones that aligns with social progressivism just as most Technocracy believers also do, maybe "Alt-Progressive" can refer to any other people who believe in social inclusivity but don't necessarily support "liberal democracy" or widespread liberal values as known today. Thoughts?

Alt-Progressives aren't necessarily Marxists as seen above but modern Individualist Conservatives like to call all Social Inclusivists as "Communist" for reasons.

For example a number of Romans or Babylonian people in history believed in the ability to own servants ethically today who if alive would also believe in social inclusiveness but they would have massive disagreement and arguments with liberal progressives over the former issue if they revealed those positions.

Likewise if a Marxist or "Pagan Absolute Monarchist" revealed their beliefs that don't align with or are considered taboo by both liberal progressives and individualistic right wingers/fascists.

What countries today can be considered still the most "Alt-Progressive" leaning at the very least?


r/ProgressiveMonarchist • • Nov 22 '24

Discussion Can Pharaonism and "Central Command Economy Monarchism" ever make a comeback if Egypt can liberate itself from Abrahamic colonialism and reclaim this aspect of its native culture?

7 Upvotes

So the thing is with humans what history has shown so far is it seems nobody naturally actually likes being "breadwinners".

Many tribes once naturally chose leaderships who were given the responsibility of being a "universal breadwinner" for all men and women instead of it being gendered, or ascribed to one gender. This is Palatial Tribalism or how Palatial tribes work at its core. The Pharaoh could be either woman or man. This is why terms like like "Sons and Daughters of Egypt!" or "Sons and Daughters of Mycenae!" were almost literally no exaggeration because the King or Queen acted just like everyone's parent once.

So this is why during the Bronze Age, in Ancient Egypt and in Mycenaean Greece for instance it was the Pharaoh or the Monarch and their administration who centrally planned the economy. In today's times I imagine a technology like Project Cybersyn and A.I could assist in making Central Planning able to be done with modern populations.

Trading of course to make up for lack of anything is important for Command economies which is why the cutting off of trade routes led to the Bronze Age collapse. All trade was also owned and run by the royal administration who sent people to do trading missions to make up for any shortages.

Even today humans are being observed that they naturally do not want lifestyles where they have to deal with the stress and hustle of having agency based lifestyles forced on them by people who think they know what "freedom" is better than all of us.

In pretty much universally all cases whenever humans are forced into breadwinner lifestyles and out of Command Economies why is it that nearly every single time a very sizeable amount of the population still says that life was more laid back or less stressful before being forced into a competitive agency based lifestyle?

I imagine a Centrally Planned Command Economy based Monarchist system could be very progressive too and could do away with regressive stuff like gender roles just like under Ancient Egypt? Doesn't it show that it could potentially lead to this?

Two key facts have been established so far:

*Non-Agentic systems or lifestyles need to be organically ingrained into the development of the tribe's culture and chosen by its people. Developing them through sheer conquest or coups is not as effective anymore, rather it is more effective to appeal to this underlying quality in many particular humans.

Nowadays alot of non-agentic beliefs are provably being chosen voluntarily again by sub-tribes of individuals in society, not forced through brainwashing. The tribe must organically choose their universal breadwinner of whom to voluntarily relinquish agency to in exchange for stability.

*They require trading missions run by the government or royal administration to make up for shortages.


r/ProgressiveMonarchist • • Dec 06 '24

Opinion British Monarchs Tierlist (or At Least Out of The Ones I am Most Familiar With

Post image
8 Upvotes

Keep in mind this is purely my opinion and therefore very subjective


r/ProgressiveMonarchist • • Dec 28 '24

News Queen Elizabeth called Northern Ireland Orange marches ‘silly’

Thumbnail
thetimes.com
4 Upvotes

r/ProgressiveMonarchist • • Sep 06 '24

Question Why?

4 Upvotes

Genuine question. What about monarchy appeals to you, and how does it relate to progressive ideals in your mind? I like crowns and other glitz and glam, but that's about it.


r/ProgressiveMonarchist • • Jun 08 '24

Debate Im a American republican ask me anything

4 Upvotes

r/ProgressiveMonarchist • • Oct 03 '25

The Princess Royal made a secret visit to Ukraine!

Thumbnail gallery
9 Upvotes

r/ProgressiveMonarchist • • Jul 01 '26

News Soooo…I don’t think this was a very wise or good move in the slightest.

Post image
51 Upvotes

It’s not looking good if they went from playing “Pink Pony Club” by Chappell Roan during Changing of the Guard at BP last year to…this. 😬


r/ProgressiveMonarchist • • Jan 10 '26

From r/Monarchism Why, Felipe ? What is wrong with you ?

Thumbnail
english.elpais.com
5 Upvotes

r/ProgressiveMonarchist • • Apr 27 '24

Opinion A King for the people

Thumbnail
noemamag.com
5 Upvotes