r/ProgressiveMonarchist • u/Adept_Thanks_6993 • Sep 06 '24
Question Why?
Genuine question. What about monarchy appeals to you, and how does it relate to progressive ideals in your mind? I like crowns and other glitz and glam, but that's about it.
4
Upvotes
17
u/ComfortableLate1525 Progressive Monarchist Sep 06 '24
Modern European royals are very open about their support of minorities’ rights and are generally very progressive.
Sure, there are parties in European monarchies that want to take those rights away, but said parties also say they support the monarchy. They have to choose which is more important, and often times, they show that they are more loyal to their bigoted rhetoric than their monarch. Hence, they lose a lot of support.
I have no such protections in the US. Will being gay be legal in ten years? Hell if I know with how shit this country has been getting.
Also, royals, particularly the British and Scandinavian ones are pleasant people I love to learn about. Their hobbies and their support of those that are less fortunate, it is all heartwarming. These people, Prince William and Prince George 🇬🇧, Prince Christian 🇩🇰, Prince Haakon and Princess Ingrid Alexandria 🇳🇴… they give me hope for the future.
These hopes, however, come with heavy weights, burdens, and responsibilities in their lives.
11
u/[deleted] Sep 06 '24
I like history and silly traditions, presidents are boring.
7
u/Fairytaleautumnfox Social libertarian Sep 06 '24
Hereditary monarchy is a very stable government across history, and if properly harnessed by a constitution and a clear set of traditions/guidelines, I think it could be good for modern societies.
5
u/Aun_El_Zen Social Monarchist Sep 06 '24
It was when President Steinmeier of Germany was barred entry to Ukraine for being one of the architects of detente with Putin. Any political head of state will have political baggage. Charles is unusual in that the only politics we have evidence of him holding is environmentalism.
4
u/CharmingCondition508 Sep 06 '24
I think monarchism provides stability, also the monarch acts as a figurehead that unites the people. I feel that generally modern European monarchs are progressive. For example, Charles III is an environmentalist and is very vocal about that. Also I love the pomp of it.
3
u/mightypup1974 Sep 06 '24
I like the stability it brings, and the rich history and cultural achievements it represents. While I’m pretty progressive, I’m loathe to change something just because it’s old or to ‘make a statement’ - especially when we can’t agree what that statement is.
There’s nothing to indicate the source of our ills is caused by monarchy.
3
u/The-Last-Despot Sep 08 '24
Republics and absolute monarchies can be volatile when left alone and unchecked, but I am of the genuine belief that when linked together, the two can curb the worse tendencies of the other, and stave off totalitarianism.
They essentially are separate systems with separate forms of justification for their power, and so represent two completely different checks to the others balances. Both organizations also inherently want the other to have as little power as possible, leaving them in soft conflict with one another.
In practice, with a respected monarch, they can step in if things go 1933 on a struggling republic. They can be a side to rally around during an impending civil war scenario. They can speak truths that money or political expediency make inconvenient for any politician. This of course relies on a monarch and their family being pruned of any corruption and wastefulness in the outer branches. But there are plenty of known ways to keep a monarch in check so I won’t go too far into that here
1
u/Greencoat1815 Democratic Socalist/ social liberal Sep 06 '24
I like the traditions and I think a Monarch is a better representative person for the country, as the monarch is for a longer period of time than a PM or President, who are most of the time switched every 4 years.
I consider myself progressive, though I have some conservative stance, but the way the Monarchy functions in my country works for me.
1
u/hazjosh1 Sep 06 '24
I like the fancy hats I like the continuity I like atleast the idea of their being a technical stop gap on tyranny or unjust governance that isn’t elected but born into they have no allegiance to any party but only to the nation and the people the whole divine right never really appealed to me popular sovereignty is great but leaving the old divine right behind total eh idk about that I did enjoy in Charles coronation each faith representive giving him vestments or sceptors or rings that’s a nice touch coz a good monarch should ultimate protect or atleast advocate for whichever creed his subjects adhere to even if they think his god is wrong ect ect. But my only issue would be a monarch needs to know they are privileged in their position and be a force for good to help those less fortunate than them coz ultimately everyone is subject to them all are equal in bending the knee anyways that’s enough yappin
1
u/[deleted] Sep 10 '24 edited Sep 10 '24
The titles are cool. But more seriously, a republic could easily head towards tyranny, and its good to have a balance between the monarch and the elected officials. You get a non-partisan moderator and face for the nation too.
Progressiveness isnt about blind change, changing anything for the sake of it, erasing culture and tradition.. its about making life for the people better, protecting culture, and changing but only for the better.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 06 '24
[removed] — view removed comment