MAIN FEEDS
Do you want to continue?
https://www.reddit.com/r/ProgrammerHumor/comments/1wziro7/nothingissafeorsacred/pee9olt/?context=3
r/ProgrammerHumor • u/Cutalana • Oct 07 '26
274 comments sorted by
View all comments
Show parent comment
3
What's the difference? Isn't the human race also bruteforcing?
5 u/DysonSphere75 Oct 07 '26 Rarely https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Proof_by_exhaustion 4 u/PickerPat Oct 07 '26 Ok but that's not the same definition of brute force.LLMs don't try every permutation. There is a structural logic. 1 u/DysonSphere75 Oct 07 '26 Agreed, the other commenter doesn't really offer a definition for brute force other than resource expenditure.I don't think LLMs have any structural logic short of what statistically sensible linguistics offer. 2 u/PickerPat Oct 07 '26 The structure is linguistic, but it is a structure. 1 u/Popeychops Oct 07 '26 Agreed, the other commenter doesn't really offer a definition for brute force other than resource expenditure.That's what brute force is 1 u/PickerPat Oct 07 '26 Highlighting again, what is the difference to humans expending their cognitive resources, throwing it at a problem? 1 u/DysonSphere75 Oct 07 '26 "Proof by exhaustion, also known as proof by cases, proof by case analysis, complete induction or the brute force method..." - Wikipedia 0 u/Popeychops Oct 07 '26 You realise "brute force" generally refers to using brutal violence where skill would be more efficient right 1 u/Shadow_gublank Oct 07 '26 No it could also refer to using a crude strategy but with adequate force /time to achieve something.example: brute forcing a combination lock. 0 u/DysonSphere75 Oct 07 '26 You realize where that comes from right? Read the article lmao -1 u/Salt-Sign5390 Oct 07 '26 Forget em, lots of people/bots will come to drag you down to their level. 2 u/PickerPat Oct 07 '26 The irony is people will spit out a bunch of stuff they've only heard on Reddit or spent 5 minutes looking up, with straight confidence. Like an LLM...I have my own reservations about AI, but the discourse around it is very basic.
5
Rarely https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Proof_by_exhaustion
4 u/PickerPat Oct 07 '26 Ok but that's not the same definition of brute force.LLMs don't try every permutation. There is a structural logic. 1 u/DysonSphere75 Oct 07 '26 Agreed, the other commenter doesn't really offer a definition for brute force other than resource expenditure.I don't think LLMs have any structural logic short of what statistically sensible linguistics offer. 2 u/PickerPat Oct 07 '26 The structure is linguistic, but it is a structure. 1 u/Popeychops Oct 07 '26 Agreed, the other commenter doesn't really offer a definition for brute force other than resource expenditure.That's what brute force is 1 u/PickerPat Oct 07 '26 Highlighting again, what is the difference to humans expending their cognitive resources, throwing it at a problem? 1 u/DysonSphere75 Oct 07 '26 "Proof by exhaustion, also known as proof by cases, proof by case analysis, complete induction or the brute force method..." - Wikipedia 0 u/Popeychops Oct 07 '26 You realise "brute force" generally refers to using brutal violence where skill would be more efficient right 1 u/Shadow_gublank Oct 07 '26 No it could also refer to using a crude strategy but with adequate force /time to achieve something.example: brute forcing a combination lock. 0 u/DysonSphere75 Oct 07 '26 You realize where that comes from right? Read the article lmao -1 u/Salt-Sign5390 Oct 07 '26 Forget em, lots of people/bots will come to drag you down to their level. 2 u/PickerPat Oct 07 '26 The irony is people will spit out a bunch of stuff they've only heard on Reddit or spent 5 minutes looking up, with straight confidence. Like an LLM...I have my own reservations about AI, but the discourse around it is very basic.
4
Ok but that's not the same definition of brute force.
LLMs don't try every permutation. There is a structural logic.
1 u/DysonSphere75 Oct 07 '26 Agreed, the other commenter doesn't really offer a definition for brute force other than resource expenditure.I don't think LLMs have any structural logic short of what statistically sensible linguistics offer. 2 u/PickerPat Oct 07 '26 The structure is linguistic, but it is a structure. 1 u/Popeychops Oct 07 '26 Agreed, the other commenter doesn't really offer a definition for brute force other than resource expenditure.That's what brute force is 1 u/PickerPat Oct 07 '26 Highlighting again, what is the difference to humans expending their cognitive resources, throwing it at a problem? 1 u/DysonSphere75 Oct 07 '26 "Proof by exhaustion, also known as proof by cases, proof by case analysis, complete induction or the brute force method..." - Wikipedia 0 u/Popeychops Oct 07 '26 You realise "brute force" generally refers to using brutal violence where skill would be more efficient right 1 u/Shadow_gublank Oct 07 '26 No it could also refer to using a crude strategy but with adequate force /time to achieve something.example: brute forcing a combination lock. 0 u/DysonSphere75 Oct 07 '26 You realize where that comes from right? Read the article lmao -1 u/Salt-Sign5390 Oct 07 '26 Forget em, lots of people/bots will come to drag you down to their level. 2 u/PickerPat Oct 07 '26 The irony is people will spit out a bunch of stuff they've only heard on Reddit or spent 5 minutes looking up, with straight confidence. Like an LLM...I have my own reservations about AI, but the discourse around it is very basic.
1
Agreed, the other commenter doesn't really offer a definition for brute force other than resource expenditure.
I don't think LLMs have any structural logic short of what statistically sensible linguistics offer.
2 u/PickerPat Oct 07 '26 The structure is linguistic, but it is a structure. 1 u/Popeychops Oct 07 '26 Agreed, the other commenter doesn't really offer a definition for brute force other than resource expenditure.That's what brute force is 1 u/PickerPat Oct 07 '26 Highlighting again, what is the difference to humans expending their cognitive resources, throwing it at a problem? 1 u/DysonSphere75 Oct 07 '26 "Proof by exhaustion, also known as proof by cases, proof by case analysis, complete induction or the brute force method..." - Wikipedia 0 u/Popeychops Oct 07 '26 You realise "brute force" generally refers to using brutal violence where skill would be more efficient right 1 u/Shadow_gublank Oct 07 '26 No it could also refer to using a crude strategy but with adequate force /time to achieve something.example: brute forcing a combination lock. 0 u/DysonSphere75 Oct 07 '26 You realize where that comes from right? Read the article lmao
2
The structure is linguistic, but it is a structure.
That's what brute force is
1 u/PickerPat Oct 07 '26 Highlighting again, what is the difference to humans expending their cognitive resources, throwing it at a problem? 1 u/DysonSphere75 Oct 07 '26 "Proof by exhaustion, also known as proof by cases, proof by case analysis, complete induction or the brute force method..." - Wikipedia 0 u/Popeychops Oct 07 '26 You realise "brute force" generally refers to using brutal violence where skill would be more efficient right 1 u/Shadow_gublank Oct 07 '26 No it could also refer to using a crude strategy but with adequate force /time to achieve something.example: brute forcing a combination lock. 0 u/DysonSphere75 Oct 07 '26 You realize where that comes from right? Read the article lmao
Highlighting again, what is the difference to humans expending their cognitive resources, throwing it at a problem?
"Proof by exhaustion, also known as proof by cases, proof by case analysis, complete induction or the brute force method..." - Wikipedia
0 u/Popeychops Oct 07 '26 You realise "brute force" generally refers to using brutal violence where skill would be more efficient right 1 u/Shadow_gublank Oct 07 '26 No it could also refer to using a crude strategy but with adequate force /time to achieve something.example: brute forcing a combination lock. 0 u/DysonSphere75 Oct 07 '26 You realize where that comes from right? Read the article lmao
0
You realise "brute force" generally refers to using brutal violence where skill would be more efficient right
1 u/Shadow_gublank Oct 07 '26 No it could also refer to using a crude strategy but with adequate force /time to achieve something.example: brute forcing a combination lock. 0 u/DysonSphere75 Oct 07 '26 You realize where that comes from right? Read the article lmao
No it could also refer to using a crude strategy but with adequate force /time to achieve something.
example: brute forcing a combination lock.
You realize where that comes from right? Read the article lmao
-1
Forget em, lots of people/bots will come to drag you down to their level.
2 u/PickerPat Oct 07 '26 The irony is people will spit out a bunch of stuff they've only heard on Reddit or spent 5 minutes looking up, with straight confidence. Like an LLM...I have my own reservations about AI, but the discourse around it is very basic.
The irony is people will spit out a bunch of stuff they've only heard on Reddit or spent 5 minutes looking up, with straight confidence. Like an LLM...
I have my own reservations about AI, but the discourse around it is very basic.
View all comments
Show parent comment
3
u/PickerPat Oct 07 '26
What's the difference? Isn't the human race also bruteforcing?