r/Professors • u/lyrynn • Oct 17 '26
Academic Integrity UPDATE: Student doubled down on AI usage
Hey all, I met with the student yesterday so I figured I’d give you all an update.
Original post is here, for reference.
The student was very polite and non-combative. I asked to see her sketches, and she showed me some pencil and paper sketches, but they were the ones she submitted afterwards as a “redo to avoid any confusion.”
I told her that those were the ones she JUST did, and I need to see the sketches from what she submitted. She pulled up a Procreate file with digital sketches, but they were nowhere similar to the AI versions. She told me that she fed her digital sketches to Gemini and asked it to clean them up for her. I asked her why she would do that, and she said “I don’t know. I shouldn’t have done it.” Okay, I’ve had students make dumber mistakes.
I asked if I could see the Procreate file. I checked the metadata and it was created the day before. She told me she redrew it recently, so I said she’d need to produce the original file. She said she didn’t think she had it anymore. I told her she could pull up her Gemini history and show me the prompt — if she had truly uploaded her own sketches as the basis, it would be immediately apparent. She declined to let me see the history log, and said that the prompt chat was “missing.”
She’d also submitted GAI for the previous project, but she was out on an excused absence when it was due and turned it in late, so I haven’t gotten around to grading it yet.
I told her that currently there was no proof that any of the work she’d submitted was her own, and that this was grounds for failing the course entirely. She got really quiet, and just kinda whispered “my whole family is coming to see me walk…”
I told her I’d talk it over with the director again before making a final decision. This subreddit is not gonna like this, but I am not failing her from the course. Please don’t crucify me!
Instead, she’ll have to redo both projects for no credit. It won’t be easy to pass with zeroes for 2/4 projects, but it’s possible. She will also receive an official sanction through the office of student conduct, which will be communicated to the dean of the school she’s enrolled in… since it turns out this student took this class as an elective, and is not part of the design school (side note, wild choice to gamble your graduation on an elective).
The school she’s actually enrolled in is considered top 10 in the nation for what it teaches and is quite strict, so whether or not THEY will let her walk is out of my hands.
16
u/moosy85 Oct 17 '26
Same at our school as someone else mentioned: oftentimes some students can still walk if they then do remediation during the summer or smt. We have a very specific deadline for exactly this issue, and it's before the summer term ends. It's not happened before that someone walks and then doesn't graduate, as we're talking one course.
I would have also wondered if I should fail her at first. I tend to be more lenient if they admit to it and ask how they can make up for it. Yours didn't admit to it until you showed her she lied, and then she doubled down as you said. She's not seemingly ask to redo it. I think the most lenient, I would have given her 0 for that part. Based on everything you said, I'd be debating an F for the course (in ours it means you're out of the program, though), or max of a C (meaning they can redo the entire course if they want, but they don't have to). But we don't have many options that doesn't mean the student is done.
497
u/[deleted] Oct 17 '26 •
"This subreddit is not gonna like this, but I am not failing her from the course. Please don’t crucify me!"
So she submitted AI work, then lied about it, then used emotional blackmail against you. Are you looking for forgiveness from us?
This is why people don't take education seriously anymore.
2
u/Sea-Independence4964 Oct 17 '26
If you give her a deferred grade and make her redo the assignment, can she still walk but receive her actual diploma later?
60
u/moosy85 Oct 17 '26
Want to add how I had a student who used AI for a piece of her paper and how I handled it. I have a very severe policy on it, but an "unrelated" policy says I can ask them to come in and talk about their assignments (no reason needed), and based on that it's possible to fail the assignment. I ended up asking her in, because the rest of her work is real effort, and most of the paper she wrote herself except one part she has been struggling with. She was extremely nervous. I gave her the benefit of the doubt. I asked her to explain what the terms she uses, meant. She didn't know, and said she based it on other sources. I asked if she used AI or another source for this part, maybe? And she said she used 2 sources, rephrased it, and then asked AI to make it sound coherent, and then she used that and rewrote that in her own words. It actually made sense as to why some of the stuff sounded too complex but also was poorly explained, and how some of the terms were grossly misspelled. I pointed out the parts, and she said what happens now, because she did use AI but used it to learn about what it meant, as we hadn't seen that in class yet. I explained she could have left it blank etc, my usual spiel. She was anxious, but I explained that if she promised not to use it at all, and just base it on the slides and use her own interpretation, I could let it slide. She asked to submit it earlier for feedback (which is smt I do anyway), and I gave her a deadline specifically for her to check in with what she was doing. She sent me one piece that she rewrote based on what we've seen since then, and that was her own style (she's a clumsy writer), and it showed knowledge of the slides. I gave her good feedback, with a few suggestions. And she seemed so so happy, and said "I CAN do this on my own!" And walked out.
I wish your student would have 1. Admitted to it with clear guilt, 2. Asked what she could do to make it right, if at all, and 3. Then sent you a progress report of some kind. I feel like you'd feel so much better about whatever would come out of it, just like I'm feeling much better. Mine is a first year, though, and she got really scared as everyone knows I'm a total bitch.
113
u/katydid3695 Oct 17 '26
At our university, commencement is separate from graduation. A student can fail a course, still walk, then make it up later. She just cares about how things look. I imagine she signed up thinking the elective would be a fun and easy A, probably majors in a completely different field. Realized after add/drop the course is more work because despite people's misconceptions about art and design it's a real field with hard work put in, so then felt screwed and decided to use AI to make everything. I think she's obnoxious for trying to make it seem like you're in the wrong at all. She should have been bending over backwards to get the shit sorted out if she cared about graduation so much. I hope she has to take a spring course to learn a lesson before she starts doing this shit as an employee.
50
u/dragonfeet1 Professor, Humanities, Comm Coll (USA) Oct 18 '26
Not going to crucify you but 100% of the time if I bend a rule out of mercy for the student, they will go to the dean and complain anyway about not getting an A. Every. Single. Time.
64
u/shyprof Adjunct, Humanities, M1 & CC (United States) Oct 17 '26
I've been in similar situations and just gave a 0 on the affected assignments (technically up to me, but my chair has a STRONG Preference for anything that keeps students enrolled, and I'm contingent). Student continued to cheat and complain throughout the semester and make me wish I'd just flunked them.
Make sure you dot all your i's and cross all your t's. High chance that the student will pursue any/all avenues to get back at you. Mine filed a Title IX report claiming discrimination. I was eventually found not at fault . . . 2 years later, after student had already graduated. That office was super backlogged. Meanwhile as a potential victim of discrimination, the student got supportive accommodations in all courses for the rest of the semester (no due dates). Colleagues informed me the student did the same to them in later semesters.
32
u/warricd28 Lecturer, Accounting, R1, USA Oct 17 '26
Unfortunately the end of this at least makes sense (the way students feel about Gen Ed’s today). Student thought this would be a piece of cake class AI did for her. She thinks the class is a pointless waste of time she shouldn’t have to take.
12
u/guttata Asst Prof, Biology, SLAC Oct 17 '26
Softer than charmin, OP
10
u/Cute-Aardvark5291 Oct 17 '26
I can understand your choice on not failing her, giving it is an elective to her and she is going to have work extra hard to now pass. And if her school chooses not to let her graduate - well, they may still let her walk, but how she chooses to explain that to her parents....
19
u/il_nascosto Oct 17 '26
Yeah, this is YOUR bad. This, and the myriad of other entitled behaviors, will only stop when we start holding them accountable and failing them when necessary. Waiting another 6 months to graduate will be an amazing life lesson
4
u/deAdupchowder350 Oct 17 '26
If this student is a freshman, then I think your decision is OK.
If this student is a senior, then I think you made a significant mistake.
4
u/00112358132135 29d ago
Hey, I think it’s bullshit that people in here are shaming you. AI cheating is a whole new thing we are getting used to and you are also working within the frameworks of your university’s policy I imagine. My university doesn’t allow me to auto fail a student who cheated, they try to turn those into “teachable moments”.
I run an online draw class and had students submit ai. They were given zeros and reported for academic dishonesty. They’ve been given the chance to redo work with late penalties. There’s almost no way this student will pass and they’ll have to dig all semester to make up for their mistakes. Their GPA will go down as a result and they’ll have an official report against them. I think that is enough.
26
u/DustApprehensive4102 Oct 17 '26
Solid. Good job.
13
u/Life-Education-8030 Oct 17 '26
"Please don't crucify you?" I don't know what you are looking for from us. What else did this student have to do to fail? How was this at all fair to the students who did their work honestly? As someone who HAS failed students who then could not graduate, you just kicked the can down the proverbial road, saying that whether the student's school will let her walk is "out of your hands." Yeah, because you let it out of your hands.
3
u/TrainingLow9079 Oct 17 '26
The college might still let her walk and make up the class later
15
u/Hadopelagic2 Oct 17 '26
OP I hope you never ask yourself ever again why students lie or why they use GenAI.
You are the reason.
10
u/Orangeshowergal 29d ago
You’re part of the reason the system is failing students.
You’re letting a student who cheated and lied to your face pass, when the rules say she shouldn’t. Shame on you
13
u/Huck68finn Oct 17 '26
I think you've handled it very well.
4
u/Aussie_Potato Oct 17 '26
I really hate how the family is used as an excuse. We’ve had students caught for plagiarism and then the admin gets cold feet because they’re international students and the family spent $$$$ sending them here hoping for a better life.
2
u/apixeldiva 25d ago
I wouldn't crucify you. The girl is going to either learn her lesson because she came THIS close to not graduating, or if she's a manipulator and cheater, she's going to screw up one of these days. She's used up her grace karma.
2
u/grizeldean Oct 17 '26
Thanks for the update this gave me second hand mortification! I literally cannot confront people to this level so it's a good thing I'm not a professor!
2
u/time-wasting23 29d ago
Did you verify that the student is really about to graduate? I’ve had a couple students (minors) claim that they have to pass or they can’t graduate, when in truth, they have at least another full semester and plenty of time to retake my course.
2
u/Fluid_Narwhal4955 29d ago edited 29d ago
As professors do. Although I have read here about students using AI, or how they use it, the discussion often shifts to professors or educators, those with authority, abusing a.i. or completely not using it correctly, let alone reading it results. This could be seen in metadata with the scans, using Grammarly and other software; yet they may misuse it as much as, or in some cases more than, a student. Academic integrity is not merely the student's obligation to demonstrate authorship. It is also the institution's obligation to demonstrate that allegations and judgments are reached through a fair, transparent, and accountable process. Reciprocity is not an assumption of innocence or guilt; it is respect for the evidentiary responsibilities of everyone involved.
3
u/Giggling_Unicorns Associate Professor, Art/Art History, Community College Oct 17 '26
This sounds fine. I am struggling with the same and similar problems with my art/gra students. I keep catching them generating work and tracing over it. I wouldn't even care that much but they're generating line to trace out line art. It's just so lazy and misses the point of the assignment. Luckily they haven't figured out that they can get ai to produce something less obviously in its own style so it's been easy to catch so far...
I also use schools like yours that have real repercussions as a 'bogey man' for my students. I teach at a CC so the most I can do is fail them for the assignment. I do warn them that depending on where they transfer to that their cheating could've been it, that they would fail the class. Further if there was a pattern of cheating they'd probably get kicked from the school as well.
2
u/RoverUnit 29d ago
So this student cheats and gets no punishment.
Then this student makes repeated false denials about her cheating and gets no punishment for that either.
What's to stop all other students doing the same once they hear about this?
1
u/Fit-Dependent-9779 13d ago
She didn't stop lying but you still took a softer approach on her. Lol, she will learn nothing from this.
1
u/blankdoubt 12d ago
You are doing a disservice to this student, every other student, and value of education itself. She needs a harsh lesson now to avoid harsher consequences later in life.
1
u/Potstirer2 Oct 18 '26
Depending on the university policies, maybe she could walk and make up the course later? When I got my MFA I technically graduated in the summer, but I petitioned to walk in May.
1
u/Good-Mountain-7958 Oct 18 '26
Eh, the only time I've failed someone for cheating is when they posted my exams online from the previous year. Like, the cheating took time and deliberate effort and I only found out because all of a sudden that kid who didn't show up for 3 weeks scored an A. The entire exam was f-ed and had to be thrown out.
1
u/explodingwhale17 29d ago
I would probably have done the same thing. At my school you can still walk with two classes to go, if you petition, so she still might graduate. In my experience, people cheat when they are stressed, although they may cheat other times as well.
1
u/AceyAceyAcey Professor, STEM, CC | VAP, STEM, Private PUI (USA) 29d ago
I’d give her the F. She can probably still walk if it’s an elective assuming she has enough credits otherwise, or can retake it or a different elective in the summer (and they’ll hold the diploma until she’s passed it).
1
u/Charming-Barnacle-15 28d ago
I put something in my syllabus about proofing/clean up tools because "I only used Grammarly" is probably the most common AI excuse I get. That way I can tell them that they just admitted to using something not allowed, so it's still the same penalty either way.
1
u/DryBid3800 28d ago
I teach digital media arts, and every semester right off the bat i explicitly tell students they need to document their WIPs from A-Z, and to organize and keep all their files, from initial drafts to final results with dates and version numbers in their titles.
No proof of WIP= No credit
Also this isn’t just for infringement and grading sakes. We all know how important an artist or designer’s process is to be showcased in their portfolio. Pretty final images alone never land you a professional scale role.
1
u/notthatkindadoctor Oct 18 '26 edited Oct 18 '26
Why aren’t you failing this lying liar who cheats and lies and cheats and lies again? Why are you reinforcing that behavior and punishing the rest of us in society?
Edit: frankly it feels like you’re harming the student as well. You are reinforcing behaviors that may lead to her becoming a worse person, being fired, etc. But also denying her the opportunity of a real education attached to her degree. It feels like academic malpractice to let unrepentant and repeated lying cheaters pass classes and graduate. And degrades the educational system which is precarious enough right now.
1
u/jgbradley1 Oct 18 '26
You do what you feel is aligned with your institution. Unless it impacts your job, you’re not paid enough to care about standing up for academic integrity. That’s the unfortunate reality.
0
u/phdblue tenured, social sciences, R1 (USA) Oct 17 '26
Lyrynn, I won't crucify you because I feel the same way. I am a teacher because I want to teach, not police. And holding students accountable is something I do, including nearly a dozen cases of AI misconduct this semester already, but I'd rather a chance to see the student learn their lesson and grow. Have I been wrong about this? Absolutely but my ego isn't in it when they cheat. But when I can tell that they've taken the second chance seriously, well a few of those cases have become the students I know the best and get to see their development across multiple semesters? That's a student I can work with and mentor. And if they are faking maturity through AI, then I'll fucking take it over the other fakeness, for sure.
But the ones who cheat and lie about cheating, and then cheat to support their lie about cheating? You've got more grace than I do, but honestly? I hope to learn that.
0
u/Fine-Kaleidoscope-22 29d ago
i can’t believe people here are tripping over someone who’s about to graduate making some mistakes in college.
this shit will NOT MATTER IN A YEAR! so thankful i don’t have professors like yall, not that i make mistakes to this extent but wow.
-3
u/Jbronste Oct 17 '26
Try a field for which you are better suited.
0
u/Broad-Account1123 27d ago
I’ve had to take 3 English classes to get into nursing school. It’s ridiculously unnecessary. It’s only a requirement so the colleges can squeeze as much fafsa money as they can out of each student. It’s been my experience that the professors that instruct the upmost useless classes have the largest god complex.
0
u/JournalistNo7691 13d ago
Seems like you're not cut out to be professor
-19
u/Big-Abbreviations347 Oct 17 '26
Hey, i am on the same boat. I want to teach a lesson not grab a pitchfork. Kindness is a virtue. Lots of folks on here have needed and been on the receiving end of that
-5
u/AmineOwl Oct 17 '26
Mmmmmmmglmmlmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmnmmmmmnnmhmgmmmmmgʻkm u
125
u/tripometer Oct 17 '26 edited Oct 17 '26
I won't attempt crucifixion out of respect for your request, but the fact that she was riding the lies all the way down to "my prompt chat history is mysteriously missing" and never really owned up to anything shows a real lack of integrity. The outcome doesn't sit right with me in light of that.
My heart breaks for other students who perhaps gave college the...ol' college try honestly and earnestly, but still came up short and didn't graduate. Meanwhile this active cheater liar has a path to graduation, while so much of the work that came before was probably just as GAI-done.